What The Landmark ‘House Rules’ Case Means For The Future Of Reality TV
Last week, Seven was found liable to pay worker’s compensation to former House Rules contestant Nicole Prince.
Prince, who was a contestant on the show in 2017, took the network to court over claims she suffered psychological trauma as a result of being on the reality show.
After multiple claims were denied, Prince eventually succeeded after arbitrator Cameron Burge rejected Seven’s argument that no service was provided by her and her partner on the show, which the network said meant she wasn’t liable for worker’s compensation.
He said: “The respondent derived benefit from the applicant giving her time and engaging in the home renovations for the television show.
“Without the contestants, the production would not take place.”
Burge ruled Seven’s relationship with Prince was “appropriately categorised as that of employee and employer”.
The landmark ruling has sent ripples throughout the TV industry as a case like this has never been won before, and it now sets a precedent for similar claims to be brought forward.
Reality TV contestants – are they all employees?
Faculty of law professor at the University of Technology Sydney, Joellen Riley Munton, told B&T she wasn’t surprised Prince was awarded worker’s compensation based on the fact she presented a very convincing argument based on the definition of an employee under Australian law.
She said an employer and employee relationship is based on two things: remuneration and the level of control.
“In Australia, the definition of Australian law focuses on looking at all the aspects of the relationship, but particularly the level of control the person who engaged the other person has over [their actions],” said Munton.
She said in the House Rules case, it was easy to demonstrate Prince was performing work considering she and her partner were renovating a house.
“With that kind of a reality show where someone’s taken out of their normal life and put into a new job for a period of time, it’s easy to establish that you have a working for remuneration relationship.”
Munton also said there was clear evidence that showed the producers of House Rules had significant control over Prince, which she said was a “crucial” aspect in the case.
“Any reality show that actually takes somebody completely out of their other life, and puts them in a situation where they’re being told what to do, that’s control and that’s an employee and employer relationship,” said Munton.
Arguably, most of the reality TV shows across Seven, Nine and 10 take contestants out of their everyday life and exert a substantial level of control over their actions on the shows.
Signing a contract isn’t the end of the story
What was also interesting in the case was the fact Prince’s contract with Seven explicitly claimed there was no employment relationship.
The contract read: “You acknowledge that your participation in the program is not employment, does not create an employer/employee relationship between Seven and you and is not subject to any award or collective bargaining or workplace agreement and does not entitle you to any wages, salary, corporate benefits, superannuation, workers compensation benefits or any other compensation.”
In this US, the courts will look at a contract and accept it on face value. However, in UK and Australian law, signing a contract is “not the end of the story”, according to Munton.
She said: “It would be too easy for employers to simply get everyone to sign a contract saying, ‘I’m not your employee’.
Munton said in Australian law, it’s more important how the relationship actually plays out in real life, rather than what’s stipulated on a piece of paper.
“You can’t contract out of things like worker’s compensation, minimum wages, entitlements, holidays breaks and so, in Australia.”
New house rules: will there be a tidal wave of similar claims brought forward?
The House Rules case was not only monumental in and of itself, but it also sets the foundation for similar cases to come out of the woodwork.
And, while Munton believes we will be seeing more cases and claims similar to Prince’s, she doesn’t believe they will necessarily succeed.
“There are two elements here you have to demonstrate. One, that your particular kind of contract makes you an employee. You also have to demonstrate that you’ve had significant illness as a result of being on the show. It’s got to be more than just, ‘I’m really pissed off’. I’m really pissed off doesn’t cut it.
“This particular candidate [Prince] was able to demonstrate she had medical treatment and that she wasn’t able to get other work as a result of her time on House Rules.”
Munton believes, however, based on Prince’s success, there will be more law firms willing to take on similar cases. In the past, Munton said winning such a case would be too remote a chance for most lawyers to take on. That’s no longer the case.
“Lawyers might now say, ‘Oh, actually, that’s quite a strong precedent’,” said Munton.
She also believes that as soon as lawyers start taking on worker’s compensation claims similar to Prince’s, they may very well start to investigate other avenues at the same time, such as defamation.
“One of the things that the US has been successful in is tort cases based on intentional infliction of emotional distress,” said Munton. “That’s a very unusual claim in Australia to succeed, but if you think you’re going succeed on the work compensation side anyway, [lawyers] might also test the waters for those kinds of claims.”
“Because this particular case has been so widely publicised, and a lot of people seem to have come out of the woodworks claiming that they’ve suffered similarly, you might get enough law firms with an interest in testing the margins.
“Once you take a client on, you look at all the circumstances and all the potential claims that you might make for that person. So it’s very possible we will see more of these cases.”
Former reality TV stars air their grievances
Following on from Prince’s worker’s compensation success, it isn’t unreasonable for the networks to be concerned over the potential for further claims.
Just last Friday, multiple disgruntled former reality TV contestants spoke on the Kyle & Jackie O Show and aired their anger at producers on some of Australia’s most popular shows over their “manipulative” behaviour.
Several reality stars claimed on-air they were forced to say things they didn’t mean and were often “stitched up” in the final edit.
Nine’s Married At First Sight contestant Davina Rankin who was on the show in 2018 and has aired her frustrations about her time on the show multiple times said she was “coached” into giving the producers what they wanted.
She said the show’s producers encouraged her affair with Dean Wells and told them it would be a “recoupling” because they were both unhappy in their original pairings.
Until the show actually aired, Rankin and Wells had no idea they’d been edited to “look horrible”.
She said: “There were billboards of me in my wedding dress up in Brisbane [with the words] ‘Australia’s most hated woman'”.
Former 2017 House Rules contestant Bec Herning also spoke to Kyle and Jackie O about her reality TV experience, claiming the way she was portrayed on the show was “disgusting” and accused the producers of fabricating her storyline.
She said: “They keep you up 24 hours a day, put you in positions and force you to say everything.”
10’s Bachelor in Paradise contestant Bill Goldsmith also called in to share his experience of being painted as a TV “villain”.
Goldsmith said: “You have to take responsibility for the things you say, but they are very sneaky in the way that they edit it, the way they manipulate you into doing things.”
The future of reality TV – should the networks be worried?
Safe to say, Prince’s landmark ruling will no doubt have far-reaching implications for the future of reality TV.
While it can be argued some of the former reality TV contestants are simply trying to have another five minutes of fame, there are indeed others who have actually suffered health issues as a result of their time on reality television.
While Munton couldn’t answer whether TV networks should be worried, she did say she believes contracts moving forward will be tightened.
“One thing I think they’ll try and do is tighten up the contracts. They might try and minimise the level of actual control. ”
What does this mean for reality TV and the future of entertainment? Bigger budgets set aside for worker’s compensation claims? Less producer control? A little less entertainment? We’ll soon see.
Seven, Nine and 10 declined B&T‘s request for comment.
Latest News
Twilio Names Chris Koehler As CMO
Twilio, the customer engagement platform that drives real-time, personalised experiences for today’s leading brands, today announced that Chris Koehler has been appointed CMO. Koehler brings more than 25 years of expertise in customer engagement and marketing technology, and a proven track record of driving growth and innovation at industry-leading companies. As CMO, Koehler will report […]
ARN Announces Ad Sales Partnership With The Athletic
ARN’S iHeart has announced an ad sales partnership in Australia with The Athletic, one of the world’s largest digital sports publishers. The alliance aims to radically expand the Australian sports podcast landscape, offering significant access and opportunities for advertisers to engage a previously untapped audience at scale. The Athletic is renowned for its compelling storytelling […]
Burger Wars Continue As Hungry Jack’s Brings Back The Big Jack & Mega Jack
The moment Australia has been waiting for is here – The controversial Big Jack is back! With a much-anticipated return, Hungry Jack’s is gunning to set the nation’s taste buds alight as the iconic Big Jack and Mega Jack return to menus nationwide, for a limited time only. The burger wars reignite as The Big […]
Diverse Voices, Sustainable Choices: Natalie Dean-Weymark On Why Sustainability Is A Non-Negotiable
With sustainability a growing concern in all facets of life, there is an increasing need for diverse attitudes and minds within the media industry, driving the cause for positive change. As a B-Corp-certified PR and digital marketing agency, Compass Studio understands this need. The agency supports ethical, environmentally friendly, impact-led brands, utilising strategic storytelling to […]
New Partnership Between The Sweetshop And The Gardening.Club
The Sweetshop is set to unveil a partnership that marks a new chapter as they join forces with futurist Tomas Roope and renowned AI artist Jacqui Kenny. The partnership is named ‘The Gardening.Club’, drawing upon the fact that Tomas has used the “gardening” metaphor for years to explain how A.I. is radically changing the creative […]
‘A Very Rare Breed Of Creative’ – Clemenger BBDO hires Chief Creative Officer
B&T's chatting with Clems boss Dani Bassil on Adrián Flores CCO appointment. We never got to Italian or Thai herbs.
Concrete Playground Debuts Innovative Urban Exploration Platform With Lexus As Launch Partner
Concrete Playground announced the launch of its redesigned website in partnership with Lexus. This partnership introduces a new era of urban discovery, enabling a deeper, more intuitive engagement with cities through a state-of-the-art digital platform. Revolutionised Digital Experience Concrete Playground’s website has undergone a significant transformation, designed to enhance the way users interact with their […]
Mindshare And The Brand Agency Take Top April’s New Business Rankings
Which agencies soared like an eagle for the month of April? As in stellar performance, not Eddie the hapless ski jumper.
Suntory BOSS Coffee Fuels Ambition With New Campaign From It’s Friday
Does your workplace have a strict, policed illegal drug policy? Then Suntory BOSS Coffee will have to do.
Resolution Digital Wins MyPlates Media Account
The best thing about personalised number plates is it makes spotting wankers on the road far easier. And drug kingpins.
Debunking The “Three Year Lie”: A New Approach To Retail Digital Strategy
This columnist says it's wrong to claim digital always has a three-year pay off. Has no opinion on the seven-year itch.
TV Ratings (06/05/2024): The Farmer Is Back And He Wants A Wife
It was a good night for lovers of farming and love.
The Growth Distillery Unveils The New Rules Of Influence
The New Rules Of Influence has arrived. And there appears to be no "difficult second album" syndrome here.
Whittaker’s Launch New Brand Platform, ‘Hello Chocolate Lovers’ Via Bastion Shine
New Zealand chocolate brand continues its insidious march into the Aussie market. Much like New Zealanders themselves.
Tyro Shows They Are ‘Into Business Big Time’ With New Brand Campaign Via Howatson+Company
Think finance isn't funny? Think again with this fun work. Yes, it still applies to funeral homes & Clive Palmer ads.
IAB Study Finds 66% Of Advertisers Have Five Or Less Years Experience With Affiliate & Partnership Marketing
Study finds advertisers & agencies not overly experienced with affiliate marketing. The opposite to networking drinks.
Optus Names NBN boss Stephen Rue As New CEO
In what would've been a delicious irony, alas this Optus news didn't get leaked in a major security beach.
Indy Enigma Delivers Signage For NSW’S First Purpose-built Surf Park
Is the fear of shark attack holding you back from a professional surfing career? This new surf park could be the ticket.
Houston Ramps Up Creative Capability, Appoints Two Senior Creatives
Houston - we don't have a problem! Well, not anymore with the appointment of these other-worldly recruits.
JCDecaux Secures All Major Bus Advertising Contracts Across Sydney
Do you like your ads to arrive 25 minutes later than scheduled? JCDecaux now boasts Transport for NSW's bus ad contract.
CommBank Launches The Brighter Side TV On 10 And 10 Play
Commbank teams with 10 for a new financial literacy program. Pensioners and the unemployed are advised not to watch.
IMAA Announces Next Female Leaders Of Tomorrow Programme
Here's a top initiative by the IMAA that B&T's proud to get behind. Unlike the 20 hotdogs in 20 minutes challenge.
Fast 10: Avid Collective’s Luke Spano On Building Deeper Relationships With Local Publishers & Advertisers
Avid Collective's Luke Spano takes on B&T's fast 10 questions. Well, 11 if you include "did you have a nice weekend?"
QMS Boosts NSW Billboard Network With Australian Turf Club Agreement
The QMS team seemingly now the ones to ask for a hot tip at Rosehill after partnering with the Australian Turf Club.
VMO Signs Deal With Stockland Shopping Centres
Often visit Stockland malls only to forget the very reason you came in the first place? Let VMO give you a gentle prod.
Day Management Appoints Paramount’s Tim Wall As Head Of Talent And Publicity
Paramount's Tim Wall exits the TV business after 12 years. Confesses the Rove years were the most taxing.
Poppet’s Postive Party Celebrates First Birthday At New HQ
Think first birthdays and fairy bread and dirty nappies spring to mind. Not to say it didn't happen at this one either.
Enjoy A Hahn Solo… And May The Fourth Be With You
If anything, this campaign does beg the question - at what age does Star Wars cut off as a cultural phenomenon?
DMARGE Founder Unveils Creator-Led Social Media Agency Feedstar
New creator-led social media agency Feedstar to be aimed directly at Gen Zs. Well, they'd hardly want print, would they?
TV Ratings (02/05/2024): A total of 1,753,000 Aussies Witness Port Adelaide’s Defeat
Seven's AFL numbers almost double that of the NRL last night. The NRL still easily winning for ruptured ACLs.
Hotglue Cashes In With La Trobe Financial Digital Media Account
Hotglue staffers learning their cashflows from their collaterals today after nabbing La Trobe Financial's digital media.
M&C Saatchi’s Sydney Creative Lead Exits
B&T's stopping short of calling it a revolving door at M&C at the present, but there's definitely heat on the hinges.
Taylor Swift’s Music Re-Enters TikTok As Universal Pens Landmark Deal
Yes, B&T may have spent 152 hours failing to get Taylor Swift tickets, but, as you'll read here, it's all behind us now.
HAVAS Red launches inaugural Influencer White Paper
Havas Red has debuted its first influencer white paper. Unless you print it out in colour, of course.
Two Sides Global Campaign Reports Increasing Greenwashing As Organisations Focus On Sustainability
New report confirms greenwashing's on the rise. Apparently Mars' 'work, rest & play' claims also under investigation.
Aruga Launches New HQ & Changed Ownership Structure
PR agency Aruga proves Brisbane is 'so hot right now'. So hot in fact, Adelaide's had to go on anti-anxiety meds.