Can Coles & Woolies Convince Consumers That They’re On Their Side?
Who’d run a grocery store in Australia? Currently, Woolworths and Coles are facing not one, not two, but five separate inquiries into their pricing practices at both state and federal levels and from the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC).
From a consumer’s perspective, the math seems simple. In 2022, Coles and Woolies controlled nearly two-thirds of Australia’s grocery market with ALDI a distant third with a nine per cent share. This kind of power makes Coles and Woolies unavoidable for consumers but it also makes them seem irrepressible in their quests for profits — while that may not actually be the case at all. Of course, both retailers protest that they are not in the business of squeezing Australians until the pips squeak.
Andrew Hicks, Woolworths’ longstanding chief marketing officer, told B&T that “It’s become ‘we can help you spend less at Woolworths’. It’s about saying to the customers we care about and actively want to help you.
“The customer notices what you do, not what you say. It’s about actions — big and small — and small actions matter,” he added.
Amanda McVay, the relatively new CMO of Coles, meanwhile told B&T that she was determined to help “Australians eat and live better” and was focused on “delivering for communities.”
In their submissions to the Senate Select Committee on Supermarket Prices, however, both firms stressed that it was down to the complexity of the food market in Australia. Around 70 per cent of Australian livestock is exported, rather than sent to Aussie retailers, for example, and the global interconnectedness of foodstuffs has led to wholesale price rises and, simply, the weather. In effect, both brands seemed to suggest that they were doing everything they could to make lives better for Australians despite the hands tied behind their back. They were also quick to highlight that they recorded significantly lower profit margins than other retailers.
“The price of fruit and vegetables in Australia is primarily driven by supply and demand,” said Woolies in its submission.
“For example, in 2022, prices went up when heavy rain and low sunlight associated with La Niña reduced the available volume of fruit and vegetables on the market. Better growing conditions in 2023 improved availability, and fruit and vegetable prices have been in deflation since the middle of 2023.”
The grocer added that it sourced around 96 per cent of its fresh fruit and veg from Australian growers and that “almost all” of its submit pricing quotes every week.
Coles, meanwhile, took a stab at the highly politicised price of red meat. It said that the overwhelming majority of its red meat came directly from farmers at prices agreed with them.
“These contracts provide security of demand for our suppliers and security of supply for Coles and our customers. While livestock prices fluctuate, there are many other operational costs that impact the price consumers pay. Those costs, including transport, processing, packaging, labour and operating costs such as for refrigeration and energy, have gone up and remain high,” it said.
But does any of this matter to consumers? And, perhaps more importantly, does any of it pass the pub test? Nitika Garg, professor of marketing at UNSW, said that it all depends on just how deep the varying inquiries delve into the matters — or whether the legislators use them as a chance for some political grandstanding.
“Is [the inquiry] going to give some conclusions on the issues or will the government implement some changes that would overhaul the industry?” she told B&T.
“If they are found guilty of price gouging, I think it is more of a regulatory issue that has allowed this to happen. It would then fall on the government to correct the supply chain issues along the way.
“I don’t think people understand the complete details of how the market works. If you tell them there has been a drought and this has impacted our supply chains for bananas in Queensland and the price goes up, they’ll broadly understand why this has happened. But most people do not have the time or expertise or are willing to understand the market. So, even if the inquiry finds that they couldn’t have done anything more or much different, people aren’t going to change their perception.”
However, she also pointed to the price of milk. Coles, for instance, introduced a $1 litre of milk in 2011, which now sells for between $1.50-$1.60 per litre. In June 2022, the price jumped by 25 cents. The retailer said that the price increases were “due to ongoing cost increases in the supply chain.”
“The prices went up drastically because of the crisis. This was a big shock to consumers but even after the crisis was resolved, the prices did not come down. They were like ‘Oh well, consumers are used to paying more now. So why should we bring the prices down?'”
Woolworths is due to release its half-year results for its 2024 Financial Year next Wednesday. Coles is set to release its results for the same period on 27 February. There is no reason to expect that the retailers will not announce huge profits — despite their protestations that their profit margins sit at only 2.6 per cent, compared to Wesfarmers 6.5 per cent, JB HiFi’s 5.3 per cent and Harvey Norman’s 13.8 per cent.
High-ranking execs are due to appear in front of the respective inquiries soon. Woolies’ CEO Brad Banducci will be speaking to the Senate Inquiry, as well.
There is one beneficiary to this whole episode, though — ALDI.
“It’s a tough environment at the moment, and what happens in times like this is that consumers are willing to try an alternative, which is where we come in,” ALDI CMO Jenny Melhuish told B&T.
“This is our chance to change perceptions, win them over, show them that shopping with ALDI is not a compromise, and although we offer the lowest prices, it is not at the expense of quality. We do not have all the frills, and for good reasons, which we are proud of.”
Is there any way around this? Garg believes that the best defence for Woolies and Coles’ brand reputation would be a good offence.
“I would have emphasised communications ahead of time. As soon as the prices were going or people were beginning to hurt, I would have ramped up the communication to help mitigate some of the backlash,” she said.
Latest News
South African Tourism CMO: ‘We Want Consumers To Experience SA Through The Eyes Of A Child’
Thembisile Sehloho was appointed as the new chief marketing officer (CMO) in early April, so she’s literally had her feet under the desk for just longer than a month. Lead image L-R: Thembisile Sehloho, CMO, South African Tourism At Africa’s Travel Indaba, B&T editor-in-chief David Hovenden sat down with for her only Australian interview and […]
Market Research Firm TRA Names KFC’s “Look On the Fried Side Of Life” As Australia’s Favourite Ad
KFC’s “Look On The Fried Side Of Life” has been named Australia’s favourite ad according to a survey from TRA. KFC’s spot was joined by Telstra’s ‘This is Footy Country’ and ALDI’s ‘Good different’ taking second and third spot respectively. In New Zealand, ASB’s ‘Ben & Amy’ took out the number one spot for the […]
‘A Big, Big Step In The Right Direction’: Media Buyers React To News Corp’s D_Coded
Media agency leaders, buyers and planners have welcomed News Corp’s focus on data security and how brands can navigate its ecosystem with confidence in a cookieless world. Senior media buyers have given News Corp’s D-Coded presentation a tick of approval and feel more confident the business will support marketers from signal loss and the deprecation […]
CommBank Announced As Presenting Partner Of Vogue Codes 2024
Vogue Australia announced Commonwealth Bank has signed on as presenting partner of Vogue Codes 2024 to support the STEM-focused event series. The supporting partner line-up includes Audi Australia, Billy Blue College of Design at Torrens University and Net-A-Porter, along with event partner Dress for Success. Vogue Codes, established by Vogue Australia in 2016 to advocate […]
Brad Garbutt Joins OMA As Marketing Lead
The Outdoor Media Association (OMA) has appointed Brad Garbutt as marketing lead. Lead image: Brad Garbutt, marketing lead, OMA. Brad joins OMA following marketing roles at Dell, Apple, Network 10, and News Ltd. The outdoor industry body said his commitment to a collaborative approach and industry experience made him a natural fit for OMA’s dynamic […]
TV Ratings 15/5/24: Gruen Pulls A Crowd For Aunty As It Enters 16th Season
Gruen returned on the ABC for its 16th season last night and drew a sizeable crowd as the panellists discussed Hubbl and KIA’s B&T Campaign of the Month-winning spot for its upcoming Tasman ute. Host Wil Anderson was joined by Todd Sampson, Camey O’Keefe and Karen Ferry to discuss everything advertising, as well as a […]
D_Coded panel: ‘If You Are A Marketer Handling Data And Haven’t Spoken To Legal, You’re In Trouble’
At this week’s D_Coded event, News Corp’s product lead Pippa Leary hosted a panel (pictured above) at News Corp’s D_Coded event featuring LiveRamp senior VP, go-to-market Daniella Harkins, OMG Australia chief investment officer Kristiaan Kroon, Journey Beyond group manager of digital and loyalty Wade Stokes and AdFixus head of sales Roland Irwin. When asked about […]
SBS Audio Campaign Tells The Stories Of New Australians, With Multilingual Content Offerings To Assist Migrants
SBS Audio has launched a new marketing campaign for its ‘Australia Explained’ service which supports new migrants to successfully navigate life in Australia and achieve a greater sense of belonging and social cohesion. SBS’s flagship service for new migrants, Australia explained, has launched a multi-platform marketing campaign that reaches into the heart of the migrant […]
Tracker App Launches, Promising Consumers A Read On Brand’s & Products Sustainability Chops
Shoppers can now get access to sustainability information at their fingertips through Tracker, a first-of-its-kind mobile app. The Tracker app centralises sustainability data into a single, easy-to-understand format, helping shoppers make informed choices about the brands and products they support. Shoppers can simply scan the barcode of their favourite supermarket, chemist or department store item […]
Channel Factory Expands Team Across Australia & New Zealand By 20%
Channel Factory has expanded its team by 20 per cent in Australia and New Zealand with the hire of a new sales director and five account managers. Lead image: Channel Factory new hires. New hires include account managers Renee Fox and Anna Soucek in Melbourne; Emma Sepokas, Liana Mann and Lachlan Granville in Sydney; and […]
Jaywing Extends Strategy Team Appointing Fran Martin As Senior Brand Strategist
Jaywing has appointed Fran Martin as senior brand strategist, a newly created role to plan and craft a wide range of solutions for Jaywing’s performance and creative clients. Lead image: Fran Martin, senior brand strategist, Jaywing. Martin joins Jaywing Australia’s growing strategy offering and will work cross-functionally with the agency’s client service, creative and paid […]
Tourism Tasmania Taps Broadsheet For Latest “Off Season” Campaign Iteration
Tourism Tasmania has once again tapped Broadsheet for its “Off Season” campaign marking the third consecutive year of the collaboration to drive visitation to Tasmania during the winter. This year, Broadsheet and Tourism Tasmania have gone bigger than ever and, for the first time, have turned the Tasmania content vertical on the site ‘dark’. In this […]
Netball WA Appoints 303 MullenLowe As Brand Strategy partner
Netball WA has appointed 303 MullenLowe to develop an organisation-wide brand definition and related value propositions for the sporting body. Once complete, the strategy will shape the future direction of all brand expression and stakeholder communications. It is the first time the agency has partnered with Netball WA, as it looks to implement a consistent […]
RyvalMedia Flies Off With RedBalloon Media Account
Australia-based experience marketplace RedBalloon has appointed RyvalMedia to helm its media duties. Lead image: Bianca Falloon, Sydney general manager, RyvalMedia. After working with RedBaloon on its Christmas and Mother’s Day campaigns, RyvalMedia took home the full media strategy, planning and buying remit. “The future of our partnership with Ryvalmedia is bright as we continue to […]
“First We Get Plastered Then We Fill Your Holes” – Tradies Face Ad Standards Ire
Ad standards has banned an ad for a plastering firm, branding it “violent” and featuring “sexual innuendo”. Bergmann Plastering’s vehicle advertisement shows its logo and the slogan “First we get plastered then we fill your holes.” Ad Standards’ community panel considered that the slogan was seen to be degrading to women. Based on a 17 […]
ANZ, Lyre’s, Uber, Adam Ballesty & An Australian Of The Year – More Big Names Join Cannes in Cairns, Presented by Pinterest!
With less than a month to go, there are just a few final moving parts to the epic Cannes in Cairns, Presented by Pinterest agenda. Lead image: Adam Ballesty, CMO, GM, Growth Consultant. In case you missed it, we revealed that multi-award-winning journalist and TV host Lisa Wilkinson AM is set to join the incredible […]
Grab A Sneak Peek At Pinterest’s Special Guests This Cannes in Cairns!
With just mere weeks to go until Cannes in Cairns, Presented by Pinterest, kicks off, we’ve got the official sneak peek of its mainstage special guests. That’s right, the global visual discovery platform powerhouse is back with two epic keynote sessions. Grab your Cannes in Cairns tickets now, before it’s too late! “The quality of […]
M&C Saatchi Sport & Entertainment’s Steve Martin And Jamie Wynne-Morgan Sign Off From Agency They Set Up
Two of the industry’s top sports marketing leaders have officially left the agency they helped set up 20 years ago after a period of gardening leave and will launch a new venture soon. Lead image: Steve Martin and Jamie Wynne-Morgan will be launching a new venture in the coming months. Former M&C Saatchi Sport & […]
Netflix Has Google & Amazon In Crosshairs With Ad Server Launch
Netflix has announced that it will be launching its own ad server and bringing its adtech in-house at its Upfronts presentation overnight. The burgeoning ad-supported streamer plans to have its own in-house adtech platform up and running by the end of next year. “Bringing our ad tech in-house will allow us to power the ads […]
Boom, Boom, Boom! Get Ready For the Boomtown Bus Whisking You To Cannes in Cairns, Presented By Pinterest In Style!
Hot on the wheels of rolling out an epic agenda, Cannes in Cairns, Presented by Pinterest, is the gift that keeps giving. Not only will record-level attendees be privy to world-class content across three tracks and a bevy of Cairns Extra dinners and VIP networking events but the fun is set to continue with The […]
On The Menu Joins Forces With TBWA\Melbourne To Melt Freezer Shame
This campaign "fights misconceptions about frozen food". Ice-cream, pies, Sara Lee! What misconceptions, B&T asks?
IMAA Announces Digi-Byte Event Featuring Industry’s Top Talent Plus “Immersive” Gaming Competition
The indies fan group unveils plans for its newest event. Says anyone in a WPP running singlet will be refused entry.
Bowel Cancer Revealed As Australia’s Deadliest Creature In New Campaign, Via Ogilvy Health
Does your office have a secret & serial farter? Possibly lure them out with this important bowel cancer campaign.
Who’s In Charge? B&T Reveals The Best Of The Best Industry Association Chiefs!
B&T's acknowledging the 10 very best industry association bosses. Discover if your membership dues are worth it here.
TEDxSydney Splits Into Two; Check Its New Creative Program
TEDxSydney moves to Luna Park's Big Top in June. Get motivated & throw up on the Wild Mouse at the very same time.
TV Ratings 14/5/24: Punters More Interested In Farmer Wants A Wife Drama Than Jeremy Clarkson’s Agricultural Adventures
Think sheep husbandry programs are TV's missing link? You can't complain with Farmer Wants A Wife AND Clarkson's Farm.
Paper Moose and Innocean Australia launch Love Our Work Industry Charter
It's a top initiative fostering harmony in the creative space. Not to downplay the unbridled joy of destroying a rival.
IAB: Privacy Act Changes Might Lead To “Nonsensical Outcomes” For Digital Advertising As Industry Wrings Hands
B&T front row at the IAB's Data & Privacy Summit. So private, in fact, attendees were wearing fake moustaches.
Fortress Games Hits Play On Partnership With Havas Network’s Organic And One Green Bean
The games culture destination names local agency roster who'll hopefully explain what a games culture destination is.
Fabulate Launches New List Of Fastest Growing Aussie Creators, Including Leah Halton, Across Social Media
A list of who's hot in Australia's influencer/creator world's here. And it's bad news for foodies angling for a freebie.
Find Your Work-Life Balance: ‘Airbnb’ Your Next Job With ViewJobs
Farmer Wants A Wife piqued your interest in all things regional? See who's hiring with this regional job initiative.
Madeleine Hawcroft Joins Deadset Studios As Executive Producer
Madeleine Hawcroft has joined the Deadset Studios team. Confirms she is of no relation to Russel.
Zimmermann Opens An Immersive Brand Space At Iconic Paris Department Store Le Bon Marché With Amplify Paris
Zimmermann continues to pioneer Aussie fashion on the global stage. Not forgetting Tradies underpants in that comment.
Red Rooster And Four‘N Twenty Team Up To Rev Up “Aussie-ness” Ahead Of Footy Final Season
Australia's greatest culinary gifts to the world join as one. B&T unsure of the whereabouts of the lamington.
‘The Emperor’s New Clothes Are Going To Be Stripped Off’: News Corp’s Pippa Leary & Panel Of Industry Leaders Urge Advertisers To ‘Wake Up’
B&T goes one-on-one with News' MD of client product, Pippa Leary. Sadly, we got KO-d in the third.
News Corp Rolls Out Shoppable And Targeted In Time View Ad Formats
Accidentally doze off during the juicy bits at yesterday's D_Coded? No one will be any the wiser with these cheat tips.