PwC Should Face Consequences For Brazen Breach Of Trust
Who better to comment on PwC’s current woes than Mark Forbes (lead image), a director at Icon Reputation. In this guest post, Forbes gives his expert tips on dealing with any reputational crisis…
Let’s call it. PwC, personnel directly implicated in misusing confidential government tax plans and those involved in its cover-up, should be banned from working with any government for at least seven years.
The brazen breach of trust, ethics and potentially law involved in advising Canberra on how to crack down on tax fraud by multinationals, then using that information to market avoiding the crackdown on those same companies, is breath taking. Worse still is how PwC, from the top down, blocked and obfuscated to hide its transgressions.
Why a seven-year ban? In 2016, the firm had its first opportunity to come clean when the taxation office asked what staff and clients were told. PwC avoided accountability for at least seven years. Its corporate penalty should continue at least that long.
In a reputational crisis, the response can have more impact than the initial incident, and PwC broke every reputational rule. In our crisis ebook, I spell out the four R’s of crisis: recognise, respond, regret and remediate. The second-largest professional services network in the world failed on all counts.
The scandal dates back to 2014, when a taxation partner at PwC, Peter Collins, signed a confidentiality agreement in order to advise Treasury on measures to crack down on multinationals circumventing Australian taxes.
On May 11, 2015, Treasurer Joe Hockey announced the new legislation to tackle tax avoidance, naming 30 global companies that paid no tax in Australia as targets of what was dubbed the ‘Google tax’. “This is about the integrity of the Australian tax system,” he said.
Within minutes, PwC’s tax partners began emailing and calling customers with plans to circumvent the tax. Collins had shared details with colleagues – an internal email from Collins, recently uncovered, described it as a both controversial and“treasure trove”.
In 2016, the ATO, alarmed at proliferating schemes to avoid its new taxes, began requesting information from its consultants, including emails sent between advisers within their firms and to their external clients.
In 2017, the tax office ramped up inquiries into the big four consulting firms, PwC, KPMG, EY and Deloitte, who were peddling schemes to avoid the tax on multinationals, demanding documents and emails. Only PwC refused.
Tax Commissioner Chris Jordan told a Senate Estimates hearing last week, “it appeared our investigation was being frustrated through false legal professional privilege claims…Despite our best efforts, due to the obstacles placed in our path, it took a long time to obtain the information requested (from PwC).”
What it did learn raised significant concerns about schemes being marketed by PwC, and Collins’s inside knowledge. “As the confidentiality breach was not a tax offence, we were unable to investigate the matter further,” Jordan said.
The case was handed to the Federal Police, who were also stymied in obtaining information, and in July 2020, the ATO informed the Tax Practitioners Board. Last December, the board announced that it had deregistered Collins as a tax agent for two years and ordered PwC to run conflicts of interest training.
When the Australian Financial Review pressed PwC for details, it downplayed the issue, denying its leadership was aware of what happened. But a couple of determined Senators were more than curious, and when the Practitioners Board’s CEO appeared before Senate Estimates in February, he revealed that between 20 and 30 PwC partners and staff had been involved in sharing the confidential information.
PwC CEO, Tom Seymour, who had headed the firm’s tax practice during these years, claimed it was a “perception issue”, and there had been “no finding” that 30 staff were involved in sharing the information.
Unfortunately for PwC, Labor Senator Deborah O’Neill lodged a Question on Notice asking the Board to table the report of its investigation, as well as all PwC emails. Its investigation report was suppressed, but 144 pages of heavily redacted emails painted a devastating picture of how deeply involved many PwC partners were in sharing the confidential information from Treasury and Taxation.
Seymour confirmed he was a recipient of the damning emails and stepped down. PwC subsequently announced that nine senior partners were “sent on leave” and chairs of the governance board and its risk committee were stepping down.
The new acting CEO, Kristin Stubbins, then issued an apology in an open letter, another example of what she concedes was the firm’s “too little, too late approach”. She apologised for “betraying the trust” of the public and vowed to “ring-fence” its Federal Government work.
Labour senator Deborah O’Neill called the apology “too late and not complete” and demanded the firm “name the names” – the list of 53 names in the cache of redacted emails”. Many question how PwC can continue to receive any government work. This week PwC handed over names – the four partners nominated are no longer at the firm.
Police have launched a new investigation and there could be a wider parliamentary inquiry. Legal sources suggested the case could even be one of the first referrals to the new National Anti-Corruption Commission, when it commences on 1 July.
A cloud hangs over PwC’s future government work, with the Finance Department ordering officials to consider confidentiality breaches when evaluating bids. The fallout won’t be contained to the public sector; our biggest superannuation fund, AustralianSuper, which paid PwC $2.3 million last year, has paused any new contracts due to the scandal.
The essence of crisis management is simple: do the right thing – something lacking at PwC’s every turn. Potential conflicts and confidentiality should have been front of mind for a company attempting to work both sides of the fence, designing tougher tax laws to stamp out avoidance while marketing tax minimisation to corporates.
For PwC, any concept of Chinese walls was quickly breached by a funnel of confidential information. Its leadership either approved or turned a wilful blind eye.
Too right it’s been ‘too little, too late’. From the start, PwC has missed every opportunity to come clean and remediate. Back in April 2015, as the breach was beginning, Seymour and Collins appeared together before a Senate tax avoidance inquiry, when Seymour stated no one at PwC was breaching tax laws. “I think we have a great contribution to making Australia’s tax laws work better,” he said.
It is difficult to see a clear path for PwC’s reputational recovery, possibly dismissal of implicated staff and a split up of the firm – separating government advisory from corporate services – but the delay in coming clean and making good means the reputational stain, to some degree, will remain indelible.
Latest News
Slew Of Senior Hires At Sparro by Brainlabs & Jack Nimble
Independent digital marketing agency, Sparro by Brainlabs, and creative production agency, Jack Nimble, have announced four new senior hires across the agency group. The appointments follow several significant recent new business wins and product launches. Lead image: Kiki Jones, Morgen Mathews, Lauren Nixon-Smith, Michael Sparkes Kiki Jones joins Jack Nimble as group account director following […]
Initiative’s Fein, Geer, Colter To Depart For Accenture Song
It's great news for Accenture Song, very bad news for the Initiative company card with this triple leaving do.
Pizza Hut Fined $2.5m For Spamming Customers
To be honest, if you're going to spam customers, cheap pizza deals is probably on the low side of the dodgy scale.
Jetstar & Qantas Perception Ratings Soar After Bonza Cancelled Flights, YouGov Finds
This poll is further proof nothing builds a positive brand image like your competitor monumentally f@cking up.
Pedigree Launches AI-Powered Ad Initiative To Give All Dogs A Home, Via Colenso BBDO & Nexus Studios
B&T encourages this dog adoption initiative. And that's despite us barely being able to look after our own selves.
Apparent Launches “All Heart, No hassle” Integrated Campaign For Flight Centre’s Corporate Traveller
Apparent charged with Flight Centre's Corporate Traveller creative. Has avoided any gags about stolen hotel bathrobes.
South African Tourism CMO: ‘We Want Consumers To Experience SA Through The Eyes Of A Child’
B&T chats with South African tourism's Aussie CMO. Admittedly, we had to quickly rectify our Barossa Valley questions.
Market Research Firm TRA Names KFC’s “Look On the Fried Side Of Life” As Australia’s Favourite Ad
A poll of everyday Aussies has revealed our favourite ads. And it'll make difficult reading for the Harvey Norman team.
‘A Big, Big Step In The Right Direction’: Media Buyers React To News Corp’s D_Coded
There was a universal thumbs up for News' D_Coded event. Although there were calls for glitter bombs at the finale.
CommBank Announced As Presenting Partner Of Vogue Codes 2024
Vogue Codes is a top initiative encouraging women into STEM-based careers. All while wearing Jimmy Choos, apparently.
Brad Garbutt Joins OMA As Marketing Lead
Seasoned adlander Garbutt joins the outdoor association. Says he's got the DOOH down pat, but working on the PDOOH.
TV Ratings 15/5/24: Gruen Pulls A Crowd For Aunty As It Enters 16th Season
Although B&T typically shuns predictions, we're expecting big numbers for Peter Dutton's Budget reply speech tonight.
D_Coded panel: ‘If You Are A Marketer Handling Data And Haven’t Spoken To Legal, You’re In Trouble’
This fiery panel was a highlight of Tuesday's D_Coded event. Not that it spilled out into the carpark.
SBS Audio Campaign Tells The Stories Of New Australians, With Multilingual Content Offerings To Assist Migrants
SBS Audio has launched a new marketing campaign for its ‘Australia Explained’ service which supports new migrants to successfully navigate life in Australia and achieve a greater sense of belonging and social cohesion. SBS’s flagship service for new migrants, Australia explained, has launched a multi-platform marketing campaign that reaches into the heart of the migrant […]
Tracker App Launches, Promising Consumers A Read On Brand’s & Products Sustainability Chops
Shoppers can now get access to sustainability information at their fingertips through Tracker, a first-of-its-kind mobile app. The Tracker app centralises sustainability data into a single, easy-to-understand format, helping shoppers make informed choices about the brands and products they support. Shoppers can simply scan the barcode of their favourite supermarket, chemist or department store item […]
Channel Factory Expands Team Across Australia & New Zealand By 20%
Social media agency Channel Factory announces a significant lift in staff numbers. Doesn't thank Tuesday's Budget.
Jaywing Extends Strategy Team Appointing Fran Martin As Senior Brand Strategist
As is often said, you can never have too much strategy. Same can't be said of programmatic & AI.
Tourism Tasmania Taps Broadsheet For Latest “Off Season” Campaign Iteration
Do you like to drape yourself in sheepskin, flannelette & weird, wooly hats? Tasmania in winter is for you.
Netball WA Appoints 303 MullenLowe As Brand Strategy partner
Netball WA appoints 303 MullenLowe for its brand strategy. Any mention of Gina also now strictly forbidden.
RyvalMedia Flies Off With RedBalloon Media Account
Got family or friends working at RyvalMedia? Say ta-tah to shit birthday presents as agency pricks RedBalloon's media.
“First We Get Plastered Then We Fill Your Holes” – Tradies Face Ad Standards Ire
As juvenile as this plasterer's tagline is, it does sound like the plot to most adult films.
ANZ, Lyre’s, Uber, Adam Ballesty & An Australian Of The Year – More Big Names Join Cannes in Cairns, Presented by Pinterest!
Judging by this cavalcade of A-listers set to star in Cairns, a selfie stick is now mandatory for all attendees.
Grab A Sneak Peek At Pinterest’s Special Guests This Cannes in Cairns!
It's another teaser to the awesome talent you can expect in Cairns. Oddly, no sign of the B&T staff barbershop quartet.
M&C Saatchi Sport & Entertainment’s Steve Martin & Jamie Wynne-Morgan Sign Off From Agency They Set Up
Will Steve and Jamie ape Maurice and Charles with their new agency name? Stay tuned to B&T to find out.
Netflix Has Google & Amazon In Crosshairs With Ad Server Launch
Is your dream weekend Uber Eats & a Netflix binge? More toilet breaks are on the way, as streamer amps up ad offerings.
Boom, Boom, Boom! Get Ready For the Boomtown Bus Whisking You To Cannes in Cairns, Presented By Pinterest In Style!
Worried your hibiscus print kaftan might overshadow things in Cairns? Fear not, as you can see this bus from space.
On The Menu Joins Forces With TBWA\Melbourne To Melt Freezer Shame
This campaign "fights misconceptions about frozen food". Ice-cream, pies, Sara Lee! What misconceptions, B&T asks?
IMAA Announces Digi-Byte Event Featuring Industry’s Top Talent Plus “Immersive” Gaming Competition
The indies fan group unveils plans for its newest event. Says anyone in a WPP running singlet will be refused entry.
Bowel Cancer Revealed As Australia’s Deadliest Creature In New Campaign, Via Ogilvy Health
Does your office have a secret & serial farter? Possibly lure them out with this important bowel cancer campaign.
Who’s In Charge? B&T Reveals The Best Of The Best Industry Association Chiefs!
B&T's acknowledging the 10 very best industry association bosses. Discover if your membership dues are worth it here.
TEDxSydney Splits Into Two; Check Its New Creative Program
TEDxSydney moves to Luna Park's Big Top in June. Get motivated & throw up on the Wild Mouse at the very same time.
TV Ratings 14/5/24: Punters More Interested In Farmer Wants A Wife Drama Than Jeremy Clarkson’s Agricultural Adventures
Think sheep husbandry programs are TV's missing link? You can't complain with Farmer Wants A Wife AND Clarkson's Farm.
Paper Moose and Innocean Australia launch Love Our Work Industry Charter
It's a top initiative fostering harmony in the creative space. Not to downplay the unbridled joy of destroying a rival.
IAB: Privacy Act Changes Might Lead To “Nonsensical Outcomes” For Digital Advertising As Industry Wrings Hands
B&T front row at the IAB's Data & Privacy Summit. So private, in fact, attendees were wearing fake moustaches.
Fortress Games Hits Play On Partnership With Havas Network’s Organic And One Green Bean
The games culture destination names local agency roster who'll hopefully explain what a games culture destination is.
Fabulate Launches New List Of Fastest Growing Aussie Creators, Including Leah Halton, Across Social Media
A list of who's hot in Australia's influencer/creator world's here. And it's bad news for foodies angling for a freebie.