Atomic 212º’s James Dixon: Is Advertising’s Greatest Debate Dead In The Water?
In this guest post, Atomic 212º’s chief digital officer James Dixon (main photo) argues adland’s fearsome “data VS creativity” debate isn’t really much of a debate at all…
It may have been months ago now, but Advertising Week APAC 2019 put the spotlight on plenty of issues that are keeping the media and marketing industry awake at night. One of the big ones is the ongoing debate between data and creativity. The problem is this debate is certainly nothing new, so why does it continue – and more importantly, why does there have to be a debate at all?
It may seem utopian, but I’d argue that a simple problem of definition has resulted in our industry becoming bogged down in a debate that shouldn’t really exist. Nothing more than a subtle reshaping of how we define both the scope and functionality of data and creativity in our industry will help brands stay competitive in a shifting market and drive truly great work.
Let’s begin by properly illustrating the problem.
For too long the definition of “data” within most agencies has focused heavily on what is generally deemed to directly oppose creativity – think tech stack metrics, digital retargeting and all the buzzwords people love to (justifiably) challenge the true value of at conferences like AdWeek. It’s understandable why investment in these shiny new toys is perceived to be at the detriment of good creative, if only because they’re so expensive and eat into the budget allocated for said good creative.
Facebook CMO Antonio Lucio outlines the problem well. “The one [issue] everyone will talk about is AI, predictive tech, martech… And we should all have it and understand when it works and when it doesn’t. All that type of stuff is great, but what it doesn’t say, is that it can’t help when you’re trying to build a strong emotional response or rebuild trust with your consumer base. We’re talking hopes, fears, expectations – that level of balance between the rational quantitative brain that we need to have to compete. At the end of the day connecting in an environment where there’s noise is done by superior storytelling. We’ve gone from art to 100% science and we’re missing the ball.”
The always entertaining Mark Ritson puts it more succinctly by paraphrasing the late, great British advertising executive David Abbott: “Shit that arrives at the speed of light is still shit.”
Both are certainly correct in their thinking. The problem, which then gives way to debate, arises when this particular definition of “data”, or more specifically data-driven tech, is treated as a key to superseding creative-led campaigns. To prove this is happening, Ritson indicated that Effie award winners from 2011 to 2015 saw a shift that spoke more about the media and the data involved in delivering the creative work than the creative itself.
While it’s understandable that the cost of data-driven technology comes with the necessity to reconfigure marketing investment, it doesn’t mean these products – or at least having a full suite of them – are a must for every single campaign. And it certainly doesn’t mean advertisers should be prioritising having a full suite of data-driven tech for a perceived competitive advantage at the expense of good creative.
In fact, there are very, very few parties asserting that data-driven technology and no, or cut-price, creative is the key to an effective campaign. So is this really a debate, or a group of well-informed conference speakers simply illustrating a point of contention in our industry. It’s a point we’ve heard for years now and it’s a point we continue to hear, so perhaps it’s time to approach things a little differently.
This debate, such as it is, ignores the fact that when used correctly, data can feed and enhance creativity. Again, this is nothing new, but it’s a point that seems to be continually glossed over.
Never forget, data is just past information, and that information is used to model future behaviour. Creativity is a force used to influence future behaviour. The two go hand in hand – a good campaign needs both in tandem.
When I say data here I mean data in its purest form, not the tech that uses it but the real ones and zeros. A proper understanding of which of those ones and zeros are most relevant to driving your campaign and informing how to frame your creative, amplified by only the data-driven tech that makes best use of those ones and zeros, will deliver truly smarter, faster and more accountable results for clients.
The issue is our industry is often skipping over the real data – the numbers themselves – and is instead running straight toward spending a bomb on the tech that mines and leverages as many numbers as possible in the hope of a result.
There’s more. Ritson says his study on the effectiveness of Effie winners discovered that data does indeed make you more effective, but you can overdo it. That is, it’s more crucial to use refined data sets that address a diagnosed problem, than to simply use as many numbers as possible.
Low levels of research (one to two studies) achieved an effectiveness score of 0.39 versus higher levels at 0.38. Ritson says: “This illustrates the key lesson of brand management. The system has always been the same. When done properly, there are three phases: diagnosis where you don’t do anything, step back, stop the clock and assess the problem; strategy, which means answering who am I targeting, what’s my overall position and what are my objectives; and finally tactics. All too often in Australia we so no real reason or logic, just a bunch of shiny, jangly tactics and that’s where we go wrong.”
By redefining data as a simple and carefully sourced tool to aid in Ritson’s process – used to support your diagnosis – and creativity as a driver of your campaign’s objectives, we’re well on track to a more streamlined approach that utilises data and creativity to drive results for the client.
Of course, there is still room for data-driven technology in the tactics phase, but this very much comes at the end of the process and involves careful selection of the most useful tools for your specific campaign. Never forget that Nielsen’s research on the drivers of effectiveness attribute 33% to targeting, reach and context combined – while creativity on its own accounts for 47%. Marketers need to spend their money accordingly.
Latest News
Bud Communications Expands APAC Footprint With Australian Office Launch
Bud Communications has expanded into the Australian market to bolster its regional capabilities for APAC’s most ambitious challenger and disruptor brands. The Southeast Asia-born PR and Content agency now brings agile and creative communications to disruptive brands expanding in Australia. Lead image: left to right, Richie Kenzie, Australia lead, Bud Communications, Oliver Budgen, founder and […]
Coles Group Ranks Number One In Disability Access & Inclusion
Australia’s peak body for workplace inclusivity has recognised Coles Group for its continued commitment to closing the disability inclusion gap, ranking it number one out of 40 organisations in the Access and Inclusion Index 2023. Lead image: team members Holly Picknall and Rachael Anastas. The Australian Disability Network announced the winners at the Disability Confidence […]
Is Alone Australia Coming For MAFS & Survivor?
Alone Australia has cemented its place as one of the standout TV hits of 2024, with a Total TV reach for the series to date of more than 3 million Australians. Alone Australia continues to deliver for SBS, with growing SBS On Demand viewing leading to episodes 1 and 2 of the series, surpassing 1 […]
AFR Pulls Plug On Newspapers In WA After Printing Costs Soar
Nine said it has been forced to stop distributing hard copies of its business masthead after the Seven West Media-owned printing press Colourpress terminated its contract, and would double the cost of printing. Colourpress is the only printing press in the golden state. The Australian Financial Review (AFR) will now be available to Western Australians […]
Spotify Delivers A “Masterclass” In Curating User Experiences For Listeners & Artists
Few players in the music game perform at Spotify’s level. At a media masterclass event last week, the music platform broke down all the ways it is changing the game, from curated listening experiences to unprecedented opportunities for artists to connect with fans. Spotify is constantly evolving, finding new ways to support artists and listeners. […]
REA Group Delivers Booming Q3 Performance
REA Group has announced its results for the nine months ended 31 March 2024 as reported by News Corporation. The News Corp report includes US GAAP financial information for REA Group and its subsidiaries (the Group) for the nine months ended 31 March 2024. Group financial highlights from core operations for the nine months ended […]
iProspect Reveals 2024 Level Up Committee Cohort
iProspect, a dentsu company, has revealed the 2024 cohort of its Level Up Committee, a shadow executive leadership team. The Level Up Committee, following a successful inaugural year, is an internal program designed to give iProspect team members access to leadership opportunities and was born out of the agency’s employee value proposition “where the ambitious […]
Surge In Kayo Subscriptions Helps Offset Foxtel Broadcast Declines
Kayo has been a shining light for Foxtel Group’s subscription video services in their latest quarterly report. The group – which includes Foxtel’s subscription broadcast service and streamers Kayo, BINGE and Foxtel Now – reported Q3 revenue of $455 million in the quarter, down by $22 million, or 5 per cent, compared with the prior […]
DEPT Doubles Down On Creativity With New APAC Executive Creative Director
Global digital agency DEPT is expanding its creative leadership in APAC with the appointment of Brad Stevens as the Executive Creative Director for the region. In this newly created role, Stevens will spearhead creative endeavours across the APAC region, driving pioneering work, and fostering a culture of excellence for clients such as Grill’d, eBay and […]
JCDecaux Unveils Giant Melbourne Wrap Around OOH Site
JCDecaux has unveiled its latest innovation, JCDecaux ICON. This unique wrap-around site is one of the largest Digital Large Format screens in the Southern Hemisphere, promising to captivate audiences and offering exceptional brand exposure in the heart of Melbourne’s bustling St Kilda Junction. Steve O’Connor, Chief Executive Officer, JCDecaux Australia and New Zealand, said: “JCDecaux […]
Brazilian Ad Agency Africa Creative Releases Powerful Gay Conversion Therapy Film
Following its premiere at the Cortina Film Club, the short movie is being made available on TikTok and Instagram to drive greater awareness of persistent anti-LGBTQIAPN+ policies and practices “The Cure” brings critical attention to the contemporary cruelties associated with homophobia with a searing story that takes aim at a history of harmful attitudes and […]
Spotlight On Sponsors: PGA Championship Becomes First Men’s Major To Sign Sports Betting Partner
The PGA of America has signed a landmark deal with ESPN Bet, becomming the first men’s golf major to sign a sports betting partnership. Meanwhile, St Kilda has locked down its defence in a new deal with NordVPN. Welcome back to B&T’s Spotlight on Sponsors series, where we break down all the major sponsorship news from inside […]
Mackenzie Arnold & Tony Gustavsson To Take Part In Inspiring Conversation At Vivid Sydney
CommBank Matildas’ Mackenzie Arnold and head coach Tony Gustavsson will join this year’s Vivid Sydney taking part in an inspiring Vivid Ideas conversation at Sydney Town Hall on Monday, 10 June. Champions of Change: Mackenzie Arnold and Tony Gustavsson will explore the dynamic between coach and athlete, offering an in-depth look at the pressures and […]
Smart Speakers Stung By Ad Fraud Costing Brands $1M Per Month, Says DoubleVerify
Be wary of a Nigerian sounding bloke that claims he is Kochie and pimping crypto on a smart speaker near you.
Contiki Challenges Influencers To ‘Switch On Social Travel’ In New Campaign Via We Are Social
Contiki wants influencers to give up irritating selfies on holiday by funding them to create irritating selfies. Genius.
“We Are In Our Epic Era”: Natalie Harvey On The Big Changes Coming As Mamamia Celebrates 10 Years Of Podcasting
Natalie Harvey has taken on the Mamamia CEO's chair that B&T hopes sports a mashed pumpkin vomit stain.
TV Ratings (08/05/2024) : Team USA Become First Female Team To Win LEGO Masters Australia
It's not been a great day for Australia - out early in Eurovision, crushed by the Yanks in Lego Masters.
GroupM Hires Former Amazon Ads Global Head Of Services
GroupM poaches Amazon's Mark Lomas to lead its retail media business. Says he has no opinion on Jeff Bezos' new yacht.
It’s All About The Indies! Introducing The Best Of The Best Indie Executive Creative Leaders 🎉
Indie agencies are thriving & it's mostly thanks to these industry leaders. And their delegating to the lackeys.
Introducing BrandComms.AI, Forethought Revolutionises How Brands Do Effective Creative
Marketing & strategy agency Forethought unveils new AI offering. Yet can't explain the plot to any of the Matrix films.
Independent Media Agencies Of Australia (IMAA) Announces Record 44 New Group Deals For 2024
The Independent Media Agencies rolls out even more support for its members. Alas, no signs of any discounted arancini.
After Google Search Spike, Reddit Shares Jump 14% In First Quarterly Results Since IPO
It looks like being a top time to be investing in the tech space. Defence industries & missile makers also doing well.
Gippsland Dairy Celebrates The Deliciousness Of Patience With ‘Slow Good’ Platform Via Special
Yoghurt's a lot like online dating, red wine & running marathons - you think it's good for you, but it probably isn't.
Let Them Eat Cake: Cashed-Up Professionals Are Back In CBDs And Airports And They Want Their Audis
Latest study finds the ABs are returning to offices & reveals how brands can cash in. Just not the work from home brands.
Mariah Carey Lends Her Inimitable Voice to ‘Portrait of a Portrait’, Audible’s Latest ‘Words + Music’ Installment
Think Mariah's only good for annoying the shit out of colleagues at Christmas? Think again with this new Audible work.
AiMCO Announces New Member Webinar To Deep-dive Into The Intricacies Of Influencer Agreements
Work with influencers? This webinar's a must. And, thankfully, sporting immaculately white teeth isn't a prerequisite.
TikTok’s Head Of People AUNZ Laura Chuck Leaves After Nearly 4 Years
As much as B&T wanted to use "chucks it in" in this headline, we didn't want the Chinese government coming after us.
News Corp Australia Gets Ready For D_Coded 2024
News' D_Coded event returns for 2024. And that can't be said about Alan Jones, the Masked Singer or plant-based meat.
Ideally Continues high growth trajectory, appoints senior marketing lead
Maura Halpin brings impressive resume to her new role at Ideally. Although her bronze in Year 12 swimming has vanished.
Feel-Good Gin! The Oasis Committee And Spirit of Little Things Collab On Charity Gin
Want to help disadvantaged youth all while drunkenly phoning an ex at 3am? Have we found the gin for you!
TV Ratings (06/05/2024): Emotional Lego Masters Goodbye Does The Numbers For Nine
And we thought Lego could only make you cry when you accidentally stood on a piece.
Lisa Wilkinson AM To Join Cannes In Cairns As Keynote Speaker
Multi-Award Winning Journalist and TV Host Lisa Wilkinson AM to speak at Cannes in Cains, sponsored by Pinterest.
Mamamia Names Natalie Harvey As New CEO
Mamamia has today announces the appointment of Natalie Harvey as Chief Executive Officer.
‘The Media Has A Way To Go On Diversity’ – Diversity Council Leader Lisa Annese On Industry Diversity And Why Sunita Gloster Is An Important Addition To Their Board
Few are more qualified than a Gruen regular to knock adland and the media into shape on diversity.
Mike Shows Up At A Wake And Still Hasn’t Seen That Show, In Latest Instalment Of ‘I Saw It On Binge’, Via Thinkerbell
Why is it we pay for 19 SVOD accounts namely due to FOMO but then rarely bother to watch the shows anyway?
Flexiroam Partners With Specialist Agencies To Launch “Ready For Anything” Global Campaign
Do you return from overseas with Bali belly, a possible STI & a huge phone bill? FlexiRoam may help with the last one.