Telstra Sinks As Court Rules In Favour Of Optus

Telstra Sinks As Court Rules In Favour Of Optus
SHARE
THIS



Telstra has lost its battle with Optus over a series of ads featuring a phonebox sinking into the sand during a court hearing.

The ads in question include a tagline stating, “Empires end. That’s what they do,” accompanied by an image of an orange and blue phone box.

According to Telstra, the ads, which were designed by Optus’ internal agency Yes Agency, indicate a “significant and permanent change in the relationship between the Telstra and Optus mobile networks”.

Telstra took Optus to court over its advertisement, showing a sinking phone box.

However, Judge John Robson has opposed Telstra’s claims, arguing the phone box ads do not mislead consumers and is instead “humorous”.

Robson added, “[The] distinctive shape, and blue-and-orange colour scheme” made it “easily recognisable as a Telstra phone box of the type that was once commonplace on Australian streets”.

Though, purposely omit the telco’s actual logo from the design.

“It would be fanciful to imagine that the humorous image of a Telstra phone box in a desert landscape would persuade a reasonable person that Telstra’s strong position in the market has been permanently destroyed,” he said.

The win for Optus follows the ongoing court proceedings between the two telcos, with both claiming its competitor’s advertising has been falsified.

Last week, Telstra was reprimanded by the Federal Court for its ‘Unlimited’ slogan.

Advertising across out-of-home and social media claimed the telco offered ‘Unlimited’ mobile plans, with ads stating, “One word from Australia’s best mobile network. Unlimited.”

Though, according to the Federal Court’s Justice Jacqueline Gleeson, the mobile plan “does not offer a mobile product or service that is unlimited”.

This decision followed Optus being forced to pull ads which used data from an international report.

Telstra claimed Optus’ advertisements were false and launched an application for an injunction preventing Optus from using the report’s findings for advertising purposes.

“The P3 report is not a sufficient basis to support the claims made by Optus and in fact ranked Telstra best for data performance,” a Telstra spokesman told The Australian.

Now, Justice Ross Robson has granted the application, meaning Optus will be forced to pull the advertising until the matter is taken to trial at Victoria’s Supreme Court next Tuesday.

“I am satisfied that there is a serious question to be tried in relation to the allegations of misleading or deceptive conduct on the part of Optus,” Robson said.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Optus telco Telstra

Latest News

Dan Gregory’s Five Tips For Effective Collaboration
  • Opinion

Dan Gregory’s Five Tips For Effective Collaboration

In this guest post, CEO of The Impossible Institute, Dan Gregory (main photo), says if you’re lost for inspiration then two heads – even 100 heads – are always better than one… The implementation of effective collaboration leading the generation of results has been well documented, but there is one example that comes to mind – this […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Poll Reveals What Journalists Fear the Most
  • Media

Poll Reveals What Journalists Fear the Most

A global poll of journalists from 52 countries has identified declining ad revenues as the profession’s number one concern. Staff cuts came second and the dreaded “fake news” came in at third. The poll was conducted by German press organisation Impressum and asked respondents the three questions below: In one word, what defines journalism in your […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Aussie Adland’s Brightest Come Together To Crystal-Ball Trends In Creative & Marketing
  • Advertising
  • Marketing

Aussie Adland’s Brightest Come Together To Crystal-Ball Trends In Creative & Marketing

A new Aussie study – based on the views of some of adland’s brightest – has concluded that data and technology is bringing agency creatives and marketers far closer together. The study, titled Joining The Dots: The Future Of Creativity, was conducted by PwC and Google and included the opinions of 15 industry thought leaders […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Aussie Study: Brands With An Excellent Reputation Can Charge Almost 10% More
  • Marketing

Aussie Study: Brands With An Excellent Reputation Can Charge Almost 10% More

Consumers are willing to pay more for products that not only have the features they want but also are delivered by businesses with a good reputation, a new Australian study has found. The study (which you can read in full here) was done by researchers at the University of Technology Sydney (UTS), puts a price on reputation […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
P2P Transport Limited Becomes Australia’s Largest Taxi Advertising Network
  • Media

P2P Transport Limited Becomes Australia’s Largest Taxi Advertising Network

The acquisition of Nonstop Media by ASX-listed P2P Transport Limited will create Australia’s largest taxi advertising network. Adflow, P2P Transport’s advertising division, will take control of all acquired media assets to complement its growing fleet of digital rooftop signage, vehicle wraps and in-vehicle entertainment products across Australia. The acquisition grows Adflow’s footprint substantially by adding […]

UNSW Partners With Adobe To Transform Its Digital Ecosystem
  • Marketing
  • Technology

UNSW Partners With Adobe To Transform Its Digital Ecosystem

Computer software giant Adobe has announced a partnership with UNSW Sydney that will see Adobe Experience Cloud implemented across the university’s global digital ecosystem. The partnership with Adobe is part of a five-year overhaul of UNSW’s digital ecosystem designed to boost its reputation as a top 50 global university through improved integrated marketing capabilities and […]