Metric Madness: “How Likely Are You To Recommend Me?”

Metric Madness: “How Likely Are You To Recommend Me?”
SHARE
THIS



Marketers love a good metric system, but the numbers we’re so keen on crunching aren’t always the main objective, says Honorary Adjunct Professor, Macquarie Graduate School of Management, Stephen Holden.

Marketers are mad about metrics! By that, I mean both manic-mad and misguided-mad.

The manic side is clear in the availability of marketing metrics beyond measure: Net Promoter Score, brand valuation, brand equity, purchase intention, ServQual, social media “likes”, CTRs (click-through rate), etc.

The misguided side is that we have become like a child fascinated by a tape measure or a digital scale. A little girl pulls out the tape measure and delights as the tape automatically retracts. A little boy puts his hand on the kitchen scales, the digital display lights up, a number appears.

We get a number, but what does it mean? Who knows! But everyone is measuring it, so we do it too.

As a consumer, I’m baraged by requests to complete little surveys for my bank, my mobile provider, my internet-provider, the airlines I fly, etc. And so many of them end with what we all know is the Net Promoter Score:

“How likely is it that you would recommend [brand] to a friend or colleague?: 0=not at all likely, 10=extremely likely.”

But what does this mean? I suspect that many think that a high recommender score means high satisfaction and/or high future purchase intention – and a low recommender score the converse. But even just a little thought highlights that ain’t so.

What mobile network would I recommend? In accord with MBA-speak, the answer is “it depends!” If you want coverage in rural areas, go with Telstra – and no, that is not my network provider!

What internet provider would I recommend? Not mine because they suck. However, they have rather neatly promised me the world wide web, tied me into a 24-month contract and then delivered crap service. But how good are the alternatives? Not much better – as reflected perhaps in the low NPS norm for internet service which is three!

Purchase intention, satisfaction, and recommendation measure three different things. I might recommend a wedding dress designer, but I have no intention of using them again!  I loved going to Tahiti, I might even recommend it if I thought it suited the person I am talking to, but I’m never going back: “been there, done that.”

I am dissatisfied with my bank, but I have no intention of changing: it’s just too hard. I might even recommend them as being the best of a bunch of bastard bankers.

And I have no intention of talking about, let alone recommending, my favourite guilty pleasures (my favourite treat at the local bakery which is in limited supply), my dirty little secrets (the toilet paper I use), things so trivial or personal, I simply don’t know the brand and/or would never would discuss with others (butter, toothpaste).

Another meaningless measure is the widely touted brand value. What can this measure mean when multiple agencies come up with different scores?

Marketing Week columnist and academic, Mark Ritson has eloquently railed on this nonsense in print and in a public debate with the companies which hawk this BS.

Just because I can measure something does not mean it is useful. I could measure the average height and weight, of the marketing department, but what does it mean? If you’re measuring marketing muscle, you need measures to match.

Make the measure to fit the effect, not the other way round.

 

Please login with linkedin to comment

stephen holden

Latest News

Medallia Appoints Heather Paterson As ANZ Country Manager
  • Advertising

Medallia Appoints Heather Paterson As ANZ Country Manager

Medallia has appointed Heather Paterson as its new ANZ country manager to drive further growth across Australia and New Zealand. With a strong sales performance and leadership background, Paterson joins Medallia as ANZ country manager following more than seven years with leading SaaS financial technology provider, Intralinks, where she was most recently director for Asia […]

Spikes Asia Brings Spikes Awards Forward To February 2021
  • Media

Spikes Asia Brings Spikes Awards Forward To February 2021

Spikes Asia today announces that the 2021 awards will take place in February, bringing them forward to the first quarter of the year. Judging for the Spikes Asia Awards, the region’s most prestigious creative branded communications accolade, as well as the Tangrams Awards and Young Spikes competitions will all take place in February 2021. In […]

Finalists In Round One Of 2020 Australian Effie Awards Announced
  • Advertising

Finalists In Round One Of 2020 Australian Effie Awards Announced

Following a rigorous round of online judging by 133 industry experts, The Communications Council today announced that 88 finalists from 24 agencies on behalf of 36 clients have made it into Round Two of the Australian Effie Awards. Finalists will now compete for Effies, Australia’s only awards based on proven advertising effectiveness – across 26 […]

IAS And Channel Factory ‘Channel Science’
  • Technology

IAS And Channel Factory ‘Channel Science’

Integral Ad Science (IAS) today announced the launch of “Channel Science”, an industry-leading partnership between Channel Factory and IAS. The Channel Science solution helps advertisers to leverage both companies’ technologies through a single product to ensure their YouTube campaigns are brand-safe, brand-suitable, and performance-optimized.  More than ever before, advertisers are searching for ways to streamline their media buying and improve […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
WPP AUNZ Launches Secrets & Lies Podcast Series
  • Advertising

WPP AUNZ Launches Secrets & Lies Podcast Series

WPP AUNZ has launched its inaugural podcast series, led by WPP AUNZ Chief Strategy Officer, Rose Herceg (pictured).  The podcast series will focus on the company’s recent thought leadership study: Secrets & Lies Chapter 4, Humanity & the Machine. Aired over the next few weeks, each discussion will take a deep dive into exploring the role […]

Playing
  • Technology

Google Presses Play On Programmatic Audio

If CV-19's given us anything, it's more podcasts than you could listen to in 1000 lifetimes. Monetise yours with this.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Melbourne, Australia - July 26, 2018: Homeless man sits in front of Westpac bank in Melbourne Australia
  • Technology

Westpac Group Partners With Verizon Media DSP For Omnichannel Solution

Westpac Group today announced it has partnered with Verizon Media’s Omnichannel DSP across its entire brand portfolio including Westpac Bank, St George Bank, Bank of Melbourne and Bank of South Australia. The new partnership gives Westpac Group access to Verizon Media’s end-to-end strategic marketing and planning capabilities including: first-party data based audience insights; full-service omnichannel […]

Adobe Analytics Adds Mobile App
  • Technology

Adobe Analytics Adds Mobile App

If there's anything to be said about the Adobe company, it doesn't sit on it laurels. Discover its latest gizmo here.

Nova Cuts 70 Employees Amid Pandemic
  • Media

Nova Cuts 70 Employees Amid Pandemic

All B&T will say here is, whoever decided having Szechuan bat for dinner was a good idea has a LOT to answer for.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Major Stars Including Kerri-Anne Kennerley & Tim Bailey To Go As 10 Announces Major Restructure
  • Media

Major Stars Including Kerri-Anne Kennerley & Tim Bailey To Go As 10 Announces Major Restructure

Network 10 is set to undergo a massive restructure, leaving a number of high-profile journalists out of a job, including Kerri-Anne Kennerley, Natarsha Belling and Tim Bailey, B&T understands. As first reported on The Sydney Morning Herald, the restructure was announced to staff on Tuesday. As part of the restructuring, the presentation of the weekday […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
How To Get Out Of A Cashflow Crisis
  • Opinion

How To Get Out Of A Cashflow Crisis

Here's top tips on getting out of a cashflow crisis that don't include robbing the kids' moneyboxes or a 7-Eleven store.