Woolies Warned Masters Venture Would Be A Disaster As Far Back As 2009

Woolies Warned Masters Venture Would Be A Disaster As Far Back As 2009
SHARE
THIS



Woolworths finally closed its disastrous Masters hardware venture on Monday after bleeding cash since it opened in 2011.

The end means some 63 stores nationwide will close and some 7000 employees could lose their jobs if a suitable buyer is not found.

However, documents uncovered in recent days say the idea of another hardware chain competing in the already crowded $18.5 billion a year hardware market was a bad idea from the beginning.

In 2009 investment banking firm Merrill Lynch ran the ruler over the prospective business and quickly warned shareholders the idea was one big dog – some two years before the first store even opened.

The analysis at the time reported: “We believe that Woolworths entering the hardware market will dilute returns on investment for its shareholders and will not provide the company with the growth platform that clearly its management team so strongly craves.”

It estimated each store would cost Woolies $25 million to build and return only $20 million in sales (although the time period was not disclosed.) On this evidence alone Merrill Lynch concluded, “Woolworths return on investment in entering the hardware market it likely to be poor – in our view, it is going to destroy shareholder value.”

The bank agreed that Woolies’ grocery and liquor businesses were “outstanding” but “we are concerned that the company is starting to show less discipline in some financial decisions and we see a move (to launch Masters) as an example”.

However, Merrill Lynch appears ecstatic about Woolies’ management’s decision to close the struggling business last Monday. It described its chairman Gordon Cairns as a “man of action” and called the chain’s closure a “momentous day” for shareholders.

Cairns has said in the media that having ditched hardware the grocer would go back to battling its old food foes Coles and ALDI, with another round of price-cutting expected.

So what exactly killed of the Masters chain? All the reports are that it struggled to attract a following from the beginning and its range and pricing was poor in what is a highly competitive market. On top of the might of Bunnings, the Australian hardware market has a host of players including Mitre 10, Home Timber & Hardware, on top of a raft of independents.

Masters’ biggest problem was that it was in a fight with arguably Australia’s most popular retailer – the Bunnings chain.

Simon Downes from retail rating firm Canstar believed Masters had an image problem from the very beginning which arguably stemmed from an association with Woolworths who have a reputation for being expensive

“There are few retailers in the country that can challenge the popularity of Bunnings,” Downes told News.com.au

“It seems to be an accumulation of different complaints, although in terms of overall satisfaction it actually does fairly well for value — better than Mitre 10, better than Home Timber & Hardware.

“It just can’t shake off its image problem, which [could be] the Woolworths factor,” he said.

Downes added that all the research was that Masters’ customers were largely happy with their shopping experience, the problem was that most of their customers were shopping at rival Bunnings.

“The problem is not enough of them went there. That’s what killed it — they didn’t get people through the door,” he said.

Latest News

Diversity Case Study Series: OMD
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Diversity Case Study Series: OMD

One need only look at the Cadbury Favourites chocolate selection to know it has nought to do with industry diversity.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Nielsen, Ispsos & The Readership Works Evolve emma Readership Data Offering
  • Media

Nielsen, Ispsos & The Readership Works Evolve emma Readership Data Offering

The Readership Works (TRW), Nielsen and Ipsos have announced a strategic collaboration with Australia’s news media industry to deliver a ‘single source of truth’ in measuring, understanding and reporting Australian consumers’ increasingly fragmented engagement with brands and content. This evolution sees Nielsen now leading the fusion process that brings together accredited readership data, emma (Enhanced […]

Ten Brings Ellen DeGeneres’ Game Show Down Under To Replace Family Feud
  • Media

Ten Brings Ellen DeGeneres’ Game Show Down Under To Replace Family Feud

Network Ten has announced it has commissioned a new family entertainment series which will premiere on Ten and the WIN Network later this year. Game of Games is based on the US show of the same name, which only launched in January this year. The US show is produced by Warner Horizon Unscripted & Alternative […]

m2m Drives Away With $51m Hyundai Media Account
  • Media

m2m Drives Away With $51m Hyundai Media Account

Media agency m2m has been awarded the Hyundai media planning and buying account. The agency, under Omnicom Media group, was up against incumbent Initiative and Havas, with Hyundai’s Innocean Australia handling the pitch process. Speaking to B&T, a Hyundai spokesperson said, “We’d like to thank Initiative for their sterling service over the last 10 years – […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Adland Execs To Be Locked Up
  • Media

Adland Execs To Be Locked Up

Continuing adland's fascination with prison when it comes to charitable causes comes this latest trip to the slammer.

Australian Directors’ Guild Announces Mentorship Winners
  • Campaigns
  • Media

Australian Directors’ Guild Announces Mentorship Winners

Now in its second year, the Australian Directors’ Guild’s (ADG) Commercial & Content Directing Mentorship program announced its next round of eight mentoree recipients. The winners were announced at a special event held last night at FINCH, Sydney and attended by members of the screen and advertising industries. Acclaimed director, and ADG President, Samantha Lang, […]

Eyeota Deep Dives Into Australian Automotive Purchase Behaviour
  • Media

Eyeota Deep Dives Into Australian Automotive Purchase Behaviour

Eyeota, the global leader in audience data, has today released its latest results on automotive purchase intentions in Australia. The results provide a deep dive into what motivates the buyer and segments those into six different personas.

APN Outdoor Joins The AANA
  • Marketing
  • Media

APN Outdoor Joins The AANA

AANA's annual Christmas dinner and dance got a teensy bit more crowded following this announcement this morning.

QMS Introduces ‘The Lonsdale’ To Melbourne
  • Advertising
  • Media

QMS Introduces ‘The Lonsdale’ To Melbourne

Digital outdoor media company QMS Media has turned on a new premium landmark digital billboard situated in the heart of Melbourne’s CBD. Delivering a commanding presence at the major intersection of Lonsdale and Russell Streets, ‘The Lonsdale’ offers extended dwell times to both vehicle and pedestrian traffic, impacting more than 2.2 million contacts per month. […]

Portrait of a woman looking through out the blinds. Office worker looking through window blinds
  • Opinion

The Lurking Brand Threats Facing CMOs

Treading on gardening rakes and possible alien abduction notable omissions from this CMO threats piece.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Women In Media Profile: Susannah George
  • Media

Women In Media Profile: Susannah George

B&T is delighted to profile Urbanlist supremo Susannah George who, we understand, is not related to George Brandis.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Ikon Lands Avis Budget Group Account
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Ikon Lands Avis Budget Group Account

B&T chooses and recommends Avis and John Karandonis shoes. Hang on, that was the end of Sale Of The Century.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Principals Appoints New Creative Director For Melbourne
  • Marketing

Principals Appoints New Creative Director For Melbourne

Branding design agency Principals has announced the appointment of Pip Ireland as its Melbourne creative director. Ireland, who has been freelancing with the agency for the past six months, has previously held roles at Designworks in New Zealand and Melbourne as well as Moon Communications in Sydney. Principals executive creative director Simon Wright said: “We’ve […]

Pureprofile Unveils Next-Level Audience Segmentation Offering With RDA Research
  • Media
  • Technology

Pureprofile Unveils Next-Level Audience Segmentation Offering With RDA Research

Global media and technology company Pureprofile has partnered with RDA Research to enable further audience segmentation across its audience profiles. RDA Research’s geoTribes is a unique classification system that rivals traditional geodemographic approaches by grouping consumers into fifteen ‘tribes’ based on their life stage and socio-economic status. Clients are then able to better understand consumer […]

WPP AUNZ Launches ‘The Bond & Associates’
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

WPP AUNZ Launches ‘The Bond & Associates’

Advertising conglomerate WPP AUNZ has launched an innovative new stakeholder and community engagement practice called The Bond & Associates. Led by newly-appointed national director and former Newgate Australia adviser Gail Morgan (pictured above), The Bond & Associates will provide a complete solution for both government and private sector clients involved in complex public projects and […]

MYOB Partners With Network Ten’s Shark Tank
  • Marketing
  • Media

MYOB Partners With Network Ten’s Shark Tank

Accounting software provider MYOB has announced it has signed as a major sponsor of Shark Tank on Network Ten, which returns to screens tonight. In its fourth season, Shark Tank continues its format of having budding business owners and entrepreneurs pitch their ideas to the ‘sharks’, who have invested $21 million of their own money […]

Aussies Back ABC Over Budget Cuts
  • Media

Aussies Back ABC Over Budget Cuts

A new poll has found a resounding 70% of Aussies oppose cuts to the ABC despite only 7% actually bothering to watch.

Meerkats Test-Drive Dream Safari Holiday In New Comparethemarket.com.au TVC
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Meerkats Test-Drive Dream Safari Holiday In New Comparethemarket.com.au TVC

Leading comparison service comparethemarket.com.au has launched its latest TVC nationwide to announce its dream Safari holiday competition. The TVC – ‘Safari’ – which sees the meerkats back in their ancestral home ‘selflessly’ test-driving the amazing Safari trip that is up for grabs for one lucky winner. Narrowly avoiding an elephant trampling their picnic, an inquisitive […]

Women In Media Profile: Lauren Nicole
  • Media

Women In Media Profile: Lauren Nicole

We'd like to say B&T provides a delightful high tea for all Women In Media interviewees, but it'd be a scandalous lie.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine