Woolies Warned Masters Venture Would Be A Disaster As Far Back As 2009

Woolies Warned Masters Venture Would Be A Disaster As Far Back As 2009
SHARE
THIS



Woolworths finally closed its disastrous Masters hardware venture on Monday after bleeding cash since it opened in 2011.

The end means some 63 stores nationwide will close and some 7000 employees could lose their jobs if a suitable buyer is not found.

However, documents uncovered in recent days say the idea of another hardware chain competing in the already crowded $18.5 billion a year hardware market was a bad idea from the beginning.

In 2009 investment banking firm Merrill Lynch ran the ruler over the prospective business and quickly warned shareholders the idea was one big dog – some two years before the first store even opened.

The analysis at the time reported: “We believe that Woolworths entering the hardware market will dilute returns on investment for its shareholders and will not provide the company with the growth platform that clearly its management team so strongly craves.”

It estimated each store would cost Woolies $25 million to build and return only $20 million in sales (although the time period was not disclosed.) On this evidence alone Merrill Lynch concluded, “Woolworths return on investment in entering the hardware market it likely to be poor – in our view, it is going to destroy shareholder value.”

The bank agreed that Woolies’ grocery and liquor businesses were “outstanding” but “we are concerned that the company is starting to show less discipline in some financial decisions and we see a move (to launch Masters) as an example”.

However, Merrill Lynch appears ecstatic about Woolies’ management’s decision to close the struggling business last Monday. It described its chairman Gordon Cairns as a “man of action” and called the chain’s closure a “momentous day” for shareholders.

Cairns has said in the media that having ditched hardware the grocer would go back to battling its old food foes Coles and ALDI, with another round of price-cutting expected.

So what exactly killed of the Masters chain? All the reports are that it struggled to attract a following from the beginning and its range and pricing was poor in what is a highly competitive market. On top of the might of Bunnings, the Australian hardware market has a host of players including Mitre 10, Home Timber & Hardware, on top of a raft of independents.

Masters’ biggest problem was that it was in a fight with arguably Australia’s most popular retailer – the Bunnings chain.

Simon Downes from retail rating firm Canstar believed Masters had an image problem from the very beginning which arguably stemmed from an association with Woolworths who have a reputation for being expensive

“There are few retailers in the country that can challenge the popularity of Bunnings,” Downes told News.com.au

“It seems to be an accumulation of different complaints, although in terms of overall satisfaction it actually does fairly well for value — better than Mitre 10, better than Home Timber & Hardware.

“It just can’t shake off its image problem, which [could be] the Woolworths factor,” he said.

Downes added that all the research was that Masters’ customers were largely happy with their shopping experience, the problem was that most of their customers were shopping at rival Bunnings.

“The problem is not enough of them went there. That’s what killed it — they didn’t get people through the door,” he said.

Latest News

Clemenger BBDO’s ‘Exceptions To The Rule’ Recruitment Program Now Open
  • Advertising

Clemenger BBDO’s ‘Exceptions To The Rule’ Recruitment Program Now Open

The annual search for Australia’s best and brightest talent has launched today through Clemenger BBDO’s ‘Exceptions to the Rule’ program, with applications open for placements across Clemenger BBDO Melbourne and Sydney. ‘Exceptions to the Rule’ is a commitment to the agency’s belief that the future leaders of the creative industry aren’t solely coming through traditional […]

The Six Types Of Meetings People Despise
  • Media

The Six Types Of Meetings People Despise

Donna McGeorge (pictured below) is a speaker, author and mentor who helps people make their work work. She is also author of The 25-Minute Meeting: Half the Time, Double the Impact. In this guest post, McGeorge says most of us despise the office meeting and here’s the six worst types… I once heard a very senior leader […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Mango Melbourne Announces Three New PR & Event Hires
  • Marketing

Mango Melbourne Announces Three New PR & Event Hires

Mango Melbourne, part of the DDB Group, has welcomed three new team members following recent business growth. Carol Laws (right in photo), Janette Henstridge (left) and Maddie Poulson (middle) bring with them experience across PR and events, in sectors including consumer, retail, telecommunications and fashion. An account director with previous roles at Kate & Co […]

Why Curiosity Matters In Leadership
  • Opinion

Why Curiosity Matters In Leadership

Corrine Armour (pictured below) is a leadership expert who helps leaders and organisations develop fearless leadership and deliver transformational results. Armour is also the author of Leaders Who Ask: Building Fearless Cultures by telling less and asking more. In this guest post, she asks are you a genuinely curious leader or just a judgemental one? Curiosity creates […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Businesswoman hand connecting jigsaw puzzle, Business solutions, success and strategy concept
  • Media

Tealium Partners With The Lumery

Tealium, the leader in real-time customer data orchestration solutions, and The Lumery, a full-service customer experience agency, have partnered to bring to life the vision of a full MarTech ecosystem for Vocus Communications. Vocus recognised a huge opportunity for growth through the digitisation of their consumer brands. As such, Vocus has begun the process of […]

McCann Names New MD For Melbourne
  • Advertising

McCann Names New MD For Melbourne

McCann's new Melbourne MD is promising sweeping changes. Well, at the very least delicate carpet shampoo changes.