2DayFM: ACMA least of SCA's worries as lawyers say DJs may have broken laws
Southern Cross Austereo and its station 2Day FM may have committed a criminal offence by recording nurse Jacintha Saldanha without her consent and broadcasting the prank, media lawyers said.
Justine Munsie of law firm Addisons told B&T that the DJs behind the prank, Mel Greig and Michael Christian, may have breached the NSW Surveillance Devices Act and NSW Listening Devices Act.
“There seem to be two issues one is the potential breach of the NSW Surveillance Devices Act which makes it illegal to record telephone conversations without consent,” Munsie said.
“The criminal offence is whether they should have been recording a telephone conversation with a person without their consent in the first place.
“It’s an issue that if the other person is overseas it is not all in Australia but the relevant recording is being done in NSW so that could be problematic.”
This comes after Rhys Holleran, SCA’s chief executive, said the company was “confident” it had not done anything illegal and London’s Metropolitan police contacted NSW Police yesterday.
The issue under debate is the prank phone call 2DayFM’s DJs made to the King Edward VII hospital in London last week in which they impersonated the Queen and tricked a nurse into sharing details about the Duchess of Cambridge’s health.
Saldanha, who transferred the call through to the hospital ward, later apparently committed suicide.
Asked whether she thought it was likely criminal proceedings would be brought against the station or the DJs, Munsie said it was a “possibility” as media organizations have been prosecuted for similar acts in the past.
But she said the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) would take in to account the fact that SCA sought legal advice before broadcasting the pre-recorded call.
“Because the DPP would be thinking ‘well what is the point in securing the conviction if on sentencing no judge in the world is going to punish these people if they got legal advice and acted in according with that legal advice.
“The criminal justice system only has so many resources but it is a possibility.”
The second issue at play, according to Munsie, is whether the station breached the Australian Communications and Media Authority’s (ACMA) Commercial Radio Codes of Practice.
The sticking point for Munsie and Hamish Fraser, a partner at Truman Hoyle Lawyers, is the media authority’s sixth code of practice.
Code 6.1 states: “A licensee must not broadcast the words of an identifiable person unless:
a) That person has been informed in advance or a reasonable person would be aware that the words may be broadcast; or
b) In the case of the words which have been recorded without the knowledge of the person, that person has subsequently, but prior to the broadcast, expressed consent to the broadcast of the words.”
Holleran, SCA’s CEO, reportedly said the station attempted to contact London’s King Edward VII Hospital which was treating the pregnant Duchess of Cambridge multiple times before broadcast.
Munsie highlighted the Code’s use of the word “identifiable” as “tricky” as at the time of original broadcast Saldanha may not have been able to be identified but was later identified through the subsequent coverage.
“I could see the ACMA saying ‘well you didn’t give her name, however, you did broadcast the fact that she was a nurse on duty at the Prince Edwards VII Hospital and you broadcast her voice’.
“Now those two facts made her identifiable at least to people who knew her and they might even say it was reasonably foreseeable in the age of the internet that this would be further circulated.”
However, Fraser told B&T that it is not automatically a breach of the code just because the station failed to comply.
There are four exclusions in 7.1 which mean it wouldn’t be a breach if SCA had either reasonable grounds to believe it wouldn’t be a breach, it was a reasonable mistake, reliance on information supplied by other people and an act or default of another person.
“6.1B appears to have been breached but you have to read that in conjunction with 7.1 which says that a failure to comply with the code…is not a breach if it is due to, in this case, either reasonable grounds to believe it didn’t breach or a reasonable mistake,” Fraser said.
Either way, Fraser believes an investigation is “almost inevitable” given the furor surrounding the case.
“It will trigger an investigation by the ACMA. If the investigation finds there has been a breach then there will be consequences.”
A likely consequence could be the imposition of another licence condition. Earlier this year, SCA was slapped with a second licence condition following shock jock Kyle Sandilands’ on-air outburst about a female journalist.
“They are not going to lose their licence immediately over it but there are a whole lot of things that could be put in place as result,” Munsie added.
Meanwhile, ACMA is reportedly considering circumventing its complaints procedure, which allows broadcasters to respond to complaints first, and instead kick off its own investigation into the issue.
For more on this story see:
-2DayFM: Scandal could make media more conservative.
-2DayFM: PR experts urge SCA to bring presenters out of hiding.
Please login with linkedin to comment
Latest News
History Has Arrived: It’s The Cairns Crocodiles Inaugural Shortlist
Pen the acceptance speech and ready your best thongs and muumuu, because the Cairns Crocodiles shortlist has arrived.
Fast And Furious: Top Gear Australia Launch Thrilled Motorheads, Car Entusiasts And Guests
B&T is still no closer to knowing who the new Stig is, except that she is a woman and a ridiculously fast.
TV Ratings (02/05/2024): Seven’s The 1% Club Wins The Night
The 1% club did not live up to its name when it comes to TV ratings last night.
TRA Welcomes Raft Of New Hires; Bolstering Expertise Across Markets
Insights and research agency TRA announces slew of new hires. Still no news on the return of marble wash denim, however.
CX Lavender Hires Boston Consulting Group’s Kim Verbrugghe as Chief Strategy Officer
CX Lavender announces new strategy hire and channels 'acoustic folk act at local RSL' for the publicity pic.
Opinion: Community standards, will they be the death of us?
This columnist is talking community standards. Sadly not those people who put dogs in trolleys in supermarkets.
Tegel gets heads bobbing with new free-range chicken platform
Sure, there's a lot of moral considerations when buying a chook. Yet, not as baffling as buying eggs or canned tuna.
Study: 66% of Aussie men believe masculinity is under attack
Two-thirds of Aussie blokes say masculinity's under attack. That said, sales of Solo lemon drink appear robust.
‘Equal Writes’: Canyon reveals new campaign and refreshed brand for women and non-binary writers
As this brand redesign again proves, nothing beats black on white. Well, white on black in this instance.
Icon Agency bolsters consumer and integrated offer with major hires
Icon Agency unveils new recruits. As press photo confirms office moustache competition now a lay-down misère.
Clemenger launches agricultural graduate program
Has Farmer Wants A Wife triggered an interest in dagging & hay balers? This grads program may resonate.
Levi’s Appoint UM As Global Media Agency For $217m Account
Levi's are the jeans for rockstars, models & the cool kids. Although that's not stopped dads from ruining their image.
QMS Nabs Sean Rigby From oOh!media
Things set to get spicy at the next Outdoor Media Association dinner and dance as a rival gets poached.
Bumble Reveals New Brand Identity To Usher In New Era Of Dating
It's ironic that all the dating apps market themselves as having no weirdos, freaks or mummy's boys like their rivals.
Stay In The House From Up! Airbnb Introduces Icons
Airbnb is now letting people stay in "iconic" places that sadly doesn't include the house from Silence Of The Lambs.
Changing The Conversation: The Role Of Media In Ending Violence Against Women
Governments are finally waking up to the DV crisis. Here, B&T chats with Jasmin Bedir on the role media can play.
“If You Want To Listen To Something Else, Go For It”: Fifi Box On Blocking Out The Noise & Focussing On What Works
No one is at the coal face of Melbourne radio like Fifi Box. Here, she chats with B&T without coughing up a lung.
Spotlight On Sponsors: Ferrari Signs Landmark New Title Sponsor
B&T continuing our series on sports sponsorships. And, yet again, there's little good news for the ten pin bowlers.
Choose A Path Less Trodden This Cannes In Cairns
Not since Wonka opened the factory has there been such a hot ticket in town. Here's how to make the most of Cairns.
Cannes In Cairns MC Keeva Stratton Shares Her Top Session Picks
Quip boss calls out her highlights of the Cannes agenda. We're assuming B&T staff b-boy demonstration was an oversight.
Here Are The Agencies That Made AFR’s Best Places To Work List And What The Industry Can Learn From Them
Did your office not make the list? Make sure your boss shouts at least two schooners at office drinks come Friday.
Get Ready, B&T’s Best Of The Best Is Back With The Top Holding Company Executive Leaders – Creative!
Want to know who the Grandest of the Grand Poobahs in the industry are? Look no further than this exhaustive list.
How A Glittering Campaign Helped The Australian Museum Sell 400,000 Tickets
B&T thoroughly enjoyed the Ramses exhibition at The Australian Museum, despite thinking we were going to the Archibald.
TV Ratings (30/04/2024): A “Shoey” Straight From A Fish’s Mouth Launches The Cheap Seats Into 2024
Last night's TV saw horny farmers beat Lego nerds, who beat fame-obsessed home cooks, who beat a chap with a large fish.
Spotlight Extends Partnership With Starlight Children’s Foundation
B&T always happy to promote the excellent work of the Starlight Foundation. Less so the Starfish Fanciers Foundation.
Amazon’s Advertising Quarterly Revenue Soars To $11.8bn
There are so many Amazon couriers visiting B&T headquarters at the moment our office dog doesn't know who to maul first.
VML Wellington Welcomes Jacob McGregor As Pou Ārahi Māori
McGregor set to lead cultural competency and safety at VML Wellington in important new gig.
“They Grow Up So Fast”: Simon Fowler On Five Years Of ABEL
Abel's CEO talks lessons learned from the agency's first five years. Including staff nicking all the Nespresso capsules.
Kyle & Jackie O Urge Melbourne To Pick A Side
Who can stop Kyle & Jackie O's indelible march into Melbourne radio? Is Peter 'Moony' Moon waiting by the phone?
Future & Taika Waititi Feature In Striking New Global Belvedere Campaign
Not only does drinking vodka make you cool like these dudes, it also has great weight loss properties for the bone idle.
The Fall Of Bonza: A Case Study In How To, And Not To, React In A Crisis
Does the collapse of yet another budget airline hark back to a gentler time of 17 hours spent on a Greyhound bus?
Opinion: Agencies, Be Unique – Stop Using The Word “Unique!”
Trinity P3's Ellie Angell says agencies are overusing the word unique. You could add omnichannel & holisitic to that.
Ex Marketing & Advertising Exec Releases Melanoma Memoir
Ex-adlander Anne Gately has penned a tome to skin cancer. Which is a handy reminder to check your moles, people.
Mamamia Appoint Danni Wright As New Head Of Strategy
Danni Wright takes up Mamamia's strategy reins with a feng shui expert called over positioning of office chaise lounge.
From The Bureau: Championing Competency & Cross-Industry Collaboration
The IAB's Jonas Jaanimagi calls for more specialisation in adtech. Meaning you'll understand it less than you already do.
Rumble Nabs Renee Park From Cutting Edge
Rumble has recruited Renee Park as one of its new sound designers. And it's only right to make some noise about it.