“Would Obama Be President?”: Industry Leaders Debate Whether Advertising Leads Culture
Powered by Nine’s fortnight of panels and events ended last night with a highly engaging debate on the motion: does advertising lead culture?
While the audience ultimately voted against the proposition – agreeing that advertising is instead led by culture – there were extremely compelling arguments on both sides.
In the affirmative were Rachael Fraser, Head of Strategy at M&C Saatchi, Roshni Hegerman, Executive Strategy Director at McCann Worldgroup, and Toby Boon, Director Strategy, Insight and Effectiveness at Powered (pictured right with Liana DuBois, director of Powered).
Arguing the negative was Andrew Wynne, Principal at JOY, Michele O’Neill, Director of Powered Enterprise, and Camille Gray, Strategist at Rufus, Powered by Initiative (and shortlisted B&T 30 Under 30 award nominee!).
Opening the debate was Rachel Fraser, who questioned where our society would be without the power of advertising.
She began with an image of an advertising-free world: “would Obama ever have become president? Would women still be stuck in the kitchen? Would I have a mum-bob, a side-part, or be aware that my skinny jeans should be replaced by straight ones if I have any chance of not being ‘cheugy’?”
Much of the debate focused on definitions: what is advertising, what is culture and, perhaps most importantly, what does it mean to lead?
The affirmative’s argument largely rested on the idea of leading culture as shaping it. They claimed that “culture is the ship, advertising is the captain”.
All three speakers used the example of smoking – the advertising industry popularised smoking, but is also the reason for its demise in popularity.
However, as pointed out by the negative team’s third speaker Camille Gray, advertising alone was not responsible for the decline in smoking – it was also because the government massively increased the price of tobacco.
“The government actually interviewed and spoke with a massive range of cultures about their relationship with smoking. They used cultural insights to create those ads – the culture lead the ad,” she argued.
For the negative team, advertising does not lead or create culture, rather it amplifies and reflects specific elements of existing culture. In some cases, it does bring niche elements of culture into the mainstream, but it doesn’t truly create.
Andrew Wynne, the negative team’s first speaker, accused the opposition of “[overclaiming] the role of advertising, and [underclaiming] the work of everything else in the world.”
This was emphasised by their second speaker Michelle O’Neil who argued that advertisers sell, rather than lead. The things that actually lead culture are education, war, and design.
While the affirmative team referenced the significance of advertising in our society – with second speaker Roshni Haberman pointing to the ubiquity of slogans like “not happy, Jan” or iconic figures like Rhonda and Ketut – ultimately, the audience was not swayed.
The winning argument of the negative team was perhaps best captured by Camille Gray in her closing remarks, when she made the case that: “A doctor brings a stethoscope to work. What does an advertiser bring? They bring a mirror.”
Please login with linkedin to comment
The Big Ideas StoreLatest News
History Has Arrived: It’s The Cairns Crocodiles Inaugural Shortlist
Pen the acceptance speech and ready your best thongs and muumuu, because the Cairns Crocodiles shortlist has arrived.
Taylor Swift’s Music Re-Enters TikTok As Universal Pens Landmark Deal
Universal Music Group (UMG) have secured the future of Taylor Swift-backed TikTok videos by signing a new multi-dimensional licensing agreement. the deal will deliver significant industry-leading benefits for UMG’s global family of artists, songwriters and labels and will return their music to TikTok’s billion-plus global community. The news comes after UMG failed to reach a deal with […]
HAVAS Red launches inaugural Influencer White Paper
HAVAS Red (formerly Red HAVAS), the global merged media micronetwork today released its inaugural The State of the Influencer in 2024: A Client’s Perspective whitepaper. To understand how influencer marketing is evolving, HAVAS Red surveyed clients across ten markets – Australia, Ireland, Germany, Italy, Japan, The Philippines, Singapore, UAE, the U.S., and the U.K. These […]
Two Sides Global Campaign Reports Increasing Greenwashing As Organisations Focus On Sustainability
Two Sides has challenged over 2,650 organisations found to be communicating greenwashing messages to their customers. Over 1,180 organisations have, so far, removed misleading anti-paper statements. Economic pressures remain the driver for much of greenwashing, and many organisations that have relied on paper to communicate with their customers are increasingly transitioning their customers from traditional […]
Aruga Launches New HQ & Changed Ownership Structure
Aruga has unveiled its new Brisbane headquarters, senior leadership team and a changed ownership structure. Lead Image: L-R – CFO Richelle Power, Co-Founder Donna Kramer, Group Account Director Natalie Ogbourne, Agency Director Tracy Llewelyn, Co-Founder Adam Brunes. The Brisbane-based independent was founded in 2017 by PR wunderkinds Donna Kramer and Adam Brunes in partnership with […]
Delicious & American Express Partner To Launch Month Out 2024 In Syndey
delicious. and American Express have come together for the fifth consecutive year for American Express delicious. Month Out 2024, returning May 1–31. The month-long event returns to Sydney, Adelaide, Melbourne and Brisbane, with dining offers, exclusive experiences and one-off events designed to encourage everyone to get out and enjoy the rich dining culture of their […]
Aussie Ad Market Continues Decline In March
Marketers across most categories are spending less on advertising this year than they did a year ago, which places Australia at odds with spend patterns in the US and Canada, according to Guideline SMI figures. Cinema and out of home are the only media channels that did not contract in March as ad spend continues […]
VMA Focuses On Skills And Training For Members
The Visual Media Association (VMA) concluded its eight-week P.o.P (Power of Print) webinar series this week with a talk from David Barron, executive manager of Stakeholder Relations, Manufacturing Industry Skills Alliance (MISA) on the work MISA does to support skills and training in our industry. The webinar highlighted industry’s needs for improving apprenticeship completion rates, […]
Nearly 90% Of Consumers Want Transparency About AI Images, Finds Getty Images Report
Getty Images yesterday held a Webinar to announce the release of its “Building Trust in the Age of AI” report. The study aims to empower marketers and communications professionals by providing data-driven insights into the integration of AI-generated content within marketing and communications strategies. Supported by the company’s cutting-edge visual and creative intelligence platform, VisualGPS, […]
The National Breast Cancer Foundation Partners With VML To Boost Funds
Today the National Breast Cancer Foundation (NBCF) and VML announce their partnership in Australia. Together they will create a future-focussed, connected marketing and customer experience strategy that will propel the not-for-profit’s ability to raise funds and continue to invest in world-class research towards their vision of Zero Deaths from breast cancer. The team will develop […]
Perry ‘Pez’ Lazaris Named New National Hit Network Announcer
The Hit Network has announced Perry ‘Pez’ Lazaris will be taking over the Hit Network’s regional Afternoon shift from Monday, 6 May. Pez knows a thing or two about radio with a career spanning over 15 years, working in Townsville, Adelaide, Western Australia and most recently, Newcastle. Now, Pez will take over the national regional […]
Before Adland: Garry Dawson’s Journey From Teacher To Marketer
Many know Garry Dawson as the prolific marketing manager behind the Hopeful Monsters team, but the story many don’t know is how a chance encounter at a local cafe just three years ago changed the trajectory of his entire life. Having worked as a teacher for six years at this point, Dawson was preparing a […]
Scott Cam Urges Tradies To Prioritise Sun Protection
New research from SafetyCulture has shed some light on the number of Aussies working outside without proper sun protection. The survey of more than 1,000 Aussie outdoor workers, which included the likes of tradies, landscapers, and road workers, revealed that almost all (93 per cent) are concerned about the long-term effects of working in the sun. […]
PubMatic Study: Advertising On Retail Media Is 50% More Effective Than Social Media
PubMatic has released a new study examining the influence of digital media on shopper behaviour at the top and bottom of the funnel. The research found that retail websites are approximately 50 per cent more effective at driving a response from shoppers than social media. Commissioned by Inside Retail and conducted by PubMatic, 500 Australian […]
From MOWING to life GROWING: Jim Penman launches ‘Life Coaching’ services
Jim Penman, founder of the Jim’s Group, has officially launched Jim’s Life Coaching and intends to help millions of Australians live their best life. “Life coaching is a powerful and effective way to achieve success in business and personal life. It helps people to set their own goals, and then work out how to get there. It has […]
Budweiser Brazil Turns Songs That Name Drop The Iconic Brand Into Spotify Ads
Budweiser has created a new way of advertising on Spotify to ensure that ads don’t ruin the vibe of your favourite playlists. UninterruptAds: a pioneering initiative, converts songs that mention the brand’s name into targeted ads within the platform in Brazil. When the Brazilian team identified that their name is present in more than 500 tracks […]
Effie Worldwide Strengthens Board With 6 New Members
Effie Worldwide, has announced six new members to their Worldwide Board of Directors, alongside three new co-chairs of the Future Council; a powerful injection of fresh talent as the organization evolves across all its programs to expand its mission to champion marketing effectiveness. The Effie Board contributes to the non-profit’s mission to champion effectiveness through […]
Special Enlist A Penguin Named Nigel In Latest Energy Campaign For Contact
After introducing “Flatties” a couple of weeks ago, Contact and Special have now enlisted the help of rule-stickler penguin Nigel to motivate all Kiwis to reduce their energy consumption during peak hours. Contact is investing heavily in creating more renewable energy sources to lead the way in decarbonising New Zealand, but to make an even […]
Anya Taylor-Joy, Chris Hemsworth & George Miller Ignite Sydney For Epic Mad Max Launch
The global promotional tour for Universal’s Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga, the much-anticipated return to the iconic dystopian world Academy Award-winning mastermind George Miller created 45 years ago, kicked off in epic fashion in Sydney yesterday. Anya Taylor-Joy returned to Australia, joining Chris Hemsworth, George Miller and producer Doug Mitchell at a fiery media call […]
IAS Launches First-To-Market Integration With Roblox To Provide 3D Immersive Measurement
Integral Ad Science, a global media measurement and optimization platform, today announced a market integration with Roblox, a global immersive platform for connection and communication. Available for advertising campaigns on Roblox later this year, IAS’s Viewability and Invalid Traffic (IVT) Measurement products will provide advertisers increased transparency into the quality of their Immersive Ads within […]
Fast And Furious: Top Gear Australia Launch Thrilled Motorheads, Car Entusiasts And Guests
B&T is still no closer to knowing who the new Stig is, except that she is a woman and a ridiculously fast.
TV Ratings (02/05/2024): Seven’s The 1% Club Wins The Night
The 1% club did not live up to its name when it comes to TV ratings last night.
TRA Welcomes Raft Of New Hires; Bolstering Expertise Across Markets
Insights and research agency TRA announces slew of new hires. Still no news on the return of marble wash denim, however.
CX Lavender Hires Boston Consulting Group’s Kim Verbrugghe as Chief Strategy Officer
CX Lavender announces new strategy hire and channels 'acoustic folk act at local RSL' for the publicity pic.
Opinion: Community standards, will they be the death of us?
This columnist is talking community standards. Sadly not those people who put dogs in trolleys in supermarkets.
Tegel gets heads bobbing with new free-range chicken platform
Sure, there's a lot of moral considerations when buying a chook. Yet, not as baffling as buying eggs or canned tuna.
Study: 66% of Aussie men believe masculinity is under attack
Two-thirds of Aussie blokes say masculinity's under attack. That said, sales of Solo lemon drink appear robust.
‘Equal Writes’: Canyon reveals new campaign and refreshed brand for women and non-binary writers
As this brand redesign again proves, nothing beats black on white. Well, white on black in this instance.
Icon Agency bolsters consumer and integrated offer with major hires
Icon Agency unveils new recruits. As press photo confirms office moustache competition now a lay-down misère.
Clemenger launches agricultural graduate program
Has Farmer Wants A Wife triggered an interest in dagging & hay balers? This grads program may resonate.
Levi’s Appoint UM As Global Media Agency For $217m Account
Levi's are the jeans for rockstars, models & the cool kids. Although that's not stopped dads from ruining their image.
QMS Nabs Sean Rigby From oOh!media
Things set to get spicy at the next Outdoor Media Association dinner and dance as a rival gets poached.
Bumble Reveals New Brand Identity To Usher In New Era Of Dating
It's ironic that all the dating apps market themselves as having no weirdos, freaks or mummy's boys like their rivals.
Stay In The House From Up! Airbnb Introduces Icons
Airbnb is now letting people stay in "iconic" places that sadly doesn't include the house from Silence Of The Lambs.
Changing The Conversation: The Role Of Media In Ending Violence Against Women
Governments are finally waking up to the DV crisis. Here, B&T chats with Jasmin Bedir on the role media can play.
“If You Want To Listen To Something Else, Go For It”: Fifi Box On Blocking Out The Noise & Focussing On What Works
No one is at the coal face of Melbourne radio like Fifi Box. Here, she chats with B&T without coughing up a lung.