Social Media Is A Hub For Progressive Ideas, So Why Aren’t Its Ads?
Our lives, and by extension, our access to new ideas, are inextricably intertwined with social media. And, as we all now know, social media and tech platforms rely on ads.
An interesting dilemma has thus appeared: we expect our social media to reflect our values because tech companies like Google, Twitter, YouTube and Facebook actively present themselves as benevolent. Because of this, we also expect our values to be reflected in the ads we are served on those platforms, too.
In September 2020, Facebook banned an ad by period underwear brand Modibodi, which used the colour red to represent period blood.
In February 2021: Facebook banned an ad called ‘The Boob Life’ by infant care brand Tommee Tippee. The ad, which focused on breastfeeding, showed nipples.
Back in February, B&T spoke with Tommee Tippe’s marketing manager Vaness Gonzalez, who said: “a Facebook representative told us that even though it may be an ad referencing breastfeeding, that they don’t allow nudity in any form and that the creative should be revisited so as not to cause negative interactions or experiences.”
“If you’re offended by a mother feeding their baby then just look away. Censoring [the ad] only serves to reinforce archaic attitudes towards mothers and women — advertisers have an opportunity to change that.”
A spokesperson for Tommee Tippee confirmed to B&T that this version of The Boob Life, which depicted nipples, was never approved by Facebook as an ad.
At the time, a Facebook spokesperon told the Daily Mail: “This campaign is important and we applaud the work Tommee Tippee is doing to support new mums in their breastfeeding journey. We allow all posts of breastfeeding on Facebook and Instagram, but we do not allow adverts showing visible nipples. Ads are governed by a stricter set of policies because they receive paid distribution to appear in people’s feeds, and that’s why these were removed.”
Fast-forward to October 2021. AWWA, a New Zealand-based period-care brand created a new campaign depicting two housemates on their periods.
In the minute-and-a-half long video, one housemate is seen with dried blood on their underwear. One is seen rinsing out their period underwear, as blood runs into the sink. Another shot shows one showering with a period.
To show these things is not sensationalist, it is realistic. Perhaps it would shock someone who has never seen a period before, but to pretend that bodily functions don’t happen: that periods don’t involve blood, or that breastfeeding doesn’t involve nipples, is to censor the bodies that perform those functions.
But the question appears to be, how visible should these bodily functions be in ads?
In October 2021, Facebook banned AWWA’s period ad. Like the cases of Tommee Tippee and Modibodi, it cited a breach of community standards.
Both Facebook and AWWA have confirmed that the full, uncensored video is allowed on the brand’s social media, both its Facebook and Instagram pages. But, as a paid-for-ad, it violated the platform’s Community Guidelines, colloquially referred to as the ‘shock and scare’ policy.
Facebook is upfront about the fact that it has strict commercial guidelines. Antonia Sanda, head of communications for Facebook ANZ said to B&T in a statement: “Encouraging open discussion about the issues that women face is important to me personally and to our values at Facebook.”
“We know these issues are complicated, and our team has been working closely with AWWA to advise how to run this campaign on our platforms. The AWWA campaign video is running in full on the AWWA Facebook and IG page. A cut down version of the video is also running as paid content on our platform.”
Speaking to B&T, though, AWWA’s co-founder Michele Wilson confirmed that the post hadn’t been removed from the brand’s Instagram and Facebook pages. But, she pointed out, because it has been banned as an ad, the video will only be seen by people who already followed the brand.
She also denied Facebook’s assertions that they had approved a cut-down version of the ad. The ad she believes Facebook is referring to is one the company made as a “pisstake”, where AWWA covered up the imagery of blood with comments from their followers praising the ad’s depiction of periods.
“Everywhere where the blood was shown, we put over a quote from one of our customers that have said how beautiful the ad is,” Wilson explained.
“That’s been approved, and I can only assume that that’s the cut-down version that Facebook says they’ve approved, but the ad actually makes no sense for anyone that watches it.”
Both Facebook and AWWA confirm that they have discussed the ad.
“I actually had a Zoom meeting with two people, quite high up representatives at Facebook,” Wilson said.
Wilson continued: “[they] said that although they agree with us and they think it should be shown, they think it’s really important, they personally think it should be shown, the internal policies team said no, it’s not gonna happen.”
“They said that the only way it can be shown is if we remove blood from the pad and blood from the back of the underwear.”
“We said, ‘we can’t do that, that’s the point of the ad – to show the blood’.”
And here lies the real dispute. That the content is important, or well-shot, or powerful is not the issue. The issue is whether it is acceptable as an ad.
An earlier version of this article was titled: Why is Facebook so determined to pretend that people don’t have bodily functions?
Perhaps instead, it should say: Bodily functions, particularly those of people with uteruses, have been hidden and used as a tool of ostracism for years. What role should a powerful media platform like Facebook advertising play in changing ideas?
Last year, when Modibodi’s ad was banned for using red liquid to represent blood – a decision Facebook later reversed – Modibodi CEO and founder Kristy Chong said, “our aim for this film was to open people’s minds by taking the stigma out of what is a perfectly natural bodily function for women. It was not made to be deliberately sensational or provocative, but to show the very real and natural side of periods.”
“We’ve used red to represent blood from day one and ‘The New Way to Period’ shows the real side of menstruation and that there are better options available than eco-damaging disposable pads, liners and tampons.”
The responses from Facebook in each of these scandals has been conciliatory. Members from the Facebook team have spoken to the press about personally loving the ad, or acknowledging its importance, while ultimately coming back to the same point: that they violate Community Guidelines.
Before Facebook accepted Modibodi’s ad, Naomi Shepherd, Facebook’s director for ANZ said: “I love the video that Modibodi has created to normalise periods, encourage discussion, and promote their underwear range. The full 60 second video is available to view on their Facebook page and Instagram account.”
“Our Community Standards outline what is and isn’t allowed on our free services, however, when it comes to ads on Facebook we have a higher set of standards for what content can be included in an ad.”
Facebook’s community guidelines say: “ads must not promote shocking, sensational, gory or excessively violent content that may shock or scare viewers.”
Here lies the crux of the dispute, where Facebook and the brands whose ads have been banned disagree – whether a period or a nipple is shocking, sensational, or confronting when it is promoted on people’s feeds.
For Facebook, there is an important difference between what is allowed on a platform and what is allowed in an ad. It points out that the user, by and large, chooses to see what is on their News Feed. Users have far less control over what ads are fed to them.
Really, though, there is a more central dichotomy at play.
It may be true that an ad depicting period blood could shock, upset, or offend someone it was served to. However, it is undoubtedly also true that one of the only ways to normalise things like periods, or breastfeeding, is to show them. That means showing them to everyone, not just to the people they affect.
Periods, and the blood that comes with them, will continue to be seen as shameful when advertising platforms prioritise the hypothetical user who could be offended, over the hypothetical user who could be empowered by a video like AWWA’s randomly appearing as an ad on their feed.
Facebook’s adult content rules are strict. They define adult content as including “nudity, depictions of people in explicit or suggestive positions, or activities that are overly suggestive or sexually provocative.”
“Sexually suggestive content includes nudity or implied nudity, excessive visible skin or cleavage and images focused on body parts like abs, buttocks or chests, even if “not explicitly sexual in nature”.
Each brand argues that its content, while maybe breaking from the norm of advertising, should not be defined as explicit, adult, or offensive.
“Period care brands have shied away from the truth of menstruation,” said Wilson. “And the giants like Facebook have been kind of part of that as well.”
“All of the research that we can find that we know how important it is that advertising does show girls and children the picture of a real period,” she continued.
“The reality is the emotions, the difficulties. Showing our period product in the way that it’s intended to be used, I think, is really important here.”
She cited traditional, prevalent period marketing strategies, like kittens playing with tampons, the infamous blue liquid, and the boyfriend covered in pads, pretending to be a robot.
“Half of the population almost, of the world, have their period and there’s no wonder we have period poverty and we have shame. Because when someone gets their period [it’s] like shock horror, what is this thing that’s happening? I thought I was supposed to be dancing around with my girlfriends.”
As consumers, our expectations of ads – particularly those marketing ‘taboo’ products – have changed. And, ultimately, social media creates our norms. Of course people want more from it.
Back in April this year, Facebook’s Q1 figures showed a total revenue of US$26.17 billion, a 48 per cent increase from the year before. At the time, Facebook explained that massive number in as due to the money it makes in ads. Ad prices on the platform have increased 30 per cent year-on-year.
Advertising is unquestionably reliant on social media. And social media – all of it, not just Facebook – has relied on a veneer of social progress and democratised ideas to become the cultural force it is today.
What we are seeing in examples like AWWA’s is that the genuinely revolutionary potential of social media to counter decades-entrenched ideas about periods ( and by extension, certain bodies) does not translate into what it allows as ads.
And, when that is the case, there is a limit to how truly progressive social media is.
What is worse? Showing an ad of dried blood to someone who may be offended, or refusing to promote an ad that is truthful and unprecedented?
That decision, ultimately, can only be made by Facebook (which has, this week, renamed as Meta). For the moment, they appear to be sticking to the former.
What this all comes back to is the fixed idea that, in Wilson’s words, a period is “secret, shameful, and should be kept under wraps.”
“But there’s nothing shocking about it, and as long as we continue this idea that it’s shocking and disturbing, the more we’re going to keep having problems with our women, with people with periods, with non-binary people with periods, with trans people with periods.”
“It’s something that needs to be spoken about openly.”
Latest News
TV Ratings (06/05/2024): Emotional Lego Masters Goodbye Does The Numbers For Nine
And we thought Lego could only make you cry when you accidentally stood on a piece.
Lisa Wilkinson AM To Join Cannes In Cairns As Keynote Speaker
Multi-Award Winning Journalist and TV Host Lisa Wilkinson AM to speak at Cannes in Cains, sponsored by Pinterest.
Mamamia Names Natalie Harvey As New CEO
Mamamia has today announces the appointment of Natalie Harvey as Chief Executive Officer.
‘The Media Has A Way To Go On Diversity’ – Diversity Council Leader Lisa Annese On Industry Diversity And Why Sunita Gloster Is An Important Addition To Their Board
Few are more qualified than a Gruen regular to knock adland and the media into shape on diversity.
Mike Shows Up At A Wake And Still Hasn’t Seen That Show, In Latest Instalment Of ‘I Saw It On Binge’, Via Thinkerbell
Why is it we pay for 19 SVOD accounts namely due to FOMO but then rarely bother to watch the shows anyway?
Flexiroam Partners With Specialist Agencies To Launch “Ready For Anything” Global Campaign
Do you return from overseas with Bali belly, a possible STI & a huge phone bill? FlexiRoam may help with the last one.
Samsung Unveils Power Of AI To ‘Upscale Every Moment’ With Neo QLED 8K
Got mates who brag about their 83-inch, 10K resolution, OLED screen TV? You're just as bored & baffled as all of us.
Media-Wize Wins AUSCERT PR Account
Media-Wize calls itself "a media training and technology and cyber security PR agency". Think nerds with better hair.
Snapchat Taps Gelato Messina In New Brand Campaign
B&T needs little tempting to scoff more Gelato Messina. Apart from having to go up a size.
Travel Insurer Trippi Draws Ire From The Brazilian Embassy Over Cheeky Brazilian Ad
There's a very fine line between "playful" and "utterly offensive". These ads are almost a dictionary definition of it.
Racing NSW Hits Tabcorp With Legal Action Over $6 Million Revenue Loss
Here's some horse racing news that thankfully doesn't require a silly hat or passing out in a nearby rose bush.
AI Tools Such As ChatGPT Leading To ‘Content Overwhelm’ Among Marketers
Study says tech leading to an avalanche of content for marketers. Not to mention having to read the instruction manuals.
Stake Appoints 72andSunny As It’s Creative Partner
72andSunny nabs Stake's creative. And by that we mean the investment platform, not the nemesis of all vampires.
61% Of Aussies Want Corporate Australia To Stay Away From Social & Political Issues Leo Burnett Study Finds
Do you love a study that appears to fly in the face of every study before it? Be mesmerised by these results from Leos.
Brendon Cook, OAM, Inducted into the OMA Hall of Fame
Other than Australia's typically pleasant weather, no one's done more for outdoor than the former oOH! boss.
New Campaign Highlighting Renewable Gas As A Crucial Component Of Energy Transition
It's hard not to make a renewable gas ad sound like a tedious Year 9 science lesson. So well done to the agency here.
Love Media Welcomes Alana Dowling As New Client Director
Seasoned media pro Alana Dowling joins the Love Media team. Clearly replacing someone who didn't love it
B&T 30 Under 30 – Where Are They Now? Until Recently, Prison!
A prestigious 30 Under 30 gong can get you headhunted, promoted or, in this instance, a two-year stint in the slammer.
“We Will Never Tell A Journalist What To Write” – Nine’s Aimie Rigas On How Data Is Shaping News
Data becoming the journalist's tool for more engaged content. Still not beating dodgy MAFS contestants or a Kardashian.
Beware The Bad Guy. Billie Eilish Fans Brace Themselves For Scammers
Thought getting Tay Tay tickets was an unimaginable nightmare? Read on as Billie Eilish promoters say hold my beer.
Twilio Names Chris Koehler As CMO
Chris Koehler named as Twilio's CMO. Which may prove a prickly tongue twister after a lengthy open bar tab.
ARN Announces Ad Sales Partnership With The Athletic
Can we slow the rotation of the sun? Because that's the only way we'll fit all these new podcasts into one day.
Burger Wars Continue As Hungry Jack’s Brings Back The Big Jack & Mega Jack
Hungry Jack's' Big Mac ripoff set to return after recent legal win. Still no one racing to clone the Filet-O-Fish.
Diverse Voices, Sustainable Choices: Natalie Dean-Weymark On Why Sustainability Is A Non-Negotiable
Here, Compass Studios' Natalie Dean-Weymark talks diversity in media. It's the human equivalent of the Family Assorted.
New Partnership Between The Sweetshop And The Gardening.Club
Thought you'd be getting tips on aphids & fungus gnats from this Gardening. Club news? Prove yourself totally wrong here.
‘A Very Rare Breed Of Creative’ – Clemenger BBDO hires Chief Creative Officer
B&T's chatting with Clems boss Dani Bassil on Adrián Flores CCO appointment. We never got to Italian or Thai herbs.
Concrete Playground Debuts Innovative Urban Exploration Platform With Lexus As Launch Partner
Concrete Playground announced the launch of its redesigned website in partnership with Lexus. This partnership introduces a new era of urban discovery, enabling a deeper, more intuitive engagement with cities through a state-of-the-art digital platform. Revolutionised Digital Experience Concrete Playground’s website has undergone a significant transformation, designed to enhance the way users interact with their […]
Mindshare And The Brand Agency Take Top April’s New Business Rankings
Which agencies soared like an eagle for the month of April? As in stellar performance, not Eddie the hapless ski jumper.
Suntory BOSS Coffee Fuels Ambition With New Campaign From It’s Friday
Does your workplace have a strict, policed illegal drug policy? Then Suntory BOSS Coffee will have to do.
Resolution Digital Wins MyPlates Media Account
The best thing about personalised number plates is it makes spotting wankers on the road far easier. And drug kingpins.
Debunking The “Three Year Lie”: A New Approach To Retail Digital Strategy
This columnist says it's wrong to claim digital always has a three-year pay off. Has no opinion on the seven-year itch.
TV Ratings (06/05/2024): The Farmer Is Back And He Wants A Wife
It was a good night for lovers of farming and love.
The Growth Distillery Unveils The New Rules Of Influence
The New Rules Of Influence has arrived. And there appears to be no "difficult second album" syndrome here.
Whittaker’s Launch New Brand Platform, ‘Hello Chocolate Lovers’ Via Bastion Shine
New Zealand chocolate brand continues its insidious march into the Aussie market. Much like New Zealanders themselves.
Tyro Shows They Are ‘Into Business Big Time’ With New Brand Campaign Via Howatson+Company
Think finance isn't funny? Think again with this fun work. Yes, it still applies to funeral homes & Clive Palmer ads.
IAB Study Finds 66% Of Advertisers Have Five Or Less Years Experience With Affiliate & Partnership Marketing
Study finds advertisers & agencies not overly experienced with affiliate marketing. The opposite to networking drinks.