A hotbed of hate or forum for debate?
Advertising by its nature divides opinion and stirs debate. Because of this, the people who create it must expect a certain amount of criticism of their work. In the best cases comment threads on industry websites can become a forum for robust, open and honest discussion.
At their worst they can descend into petty and unjustified personal abuse and a forum to settle vendettas and embarrass a rival. This is what M&C Saatchi regional creative director Tom McFarlane describes as a “hotbed of hate”.
“The industry blogs are eating, and destroying, our young,” he says. “The blogs should be a showcase for young talent – somewhere they can receive encouragement, or informed opinion on how to improve their work. I have seen young copywriters and art directors devastated by the vitriol directed at their work – often their very first TV or major print campaign.”
Founder of recruitment firm Hourigan International, Anthony Hourigan says the culture around the comments is giving Australia a bad reputation in the rest of the world. “I think it’s a blight on the Australian advertising industry, and the comments are absolutely gutless. It reflects very poorly on our industry globally,” he says. “It’s a unique issue to our industry, and I think we have an awful reputation abroad for not supporting each other and the work out of this market.”
The debate around anonymous commenting is not new. Despite this Communications Council CEO Margaret Zabel says it is still something which is bubbling away in the background” and is regularly mentioned to her by agency heads.
Campaign Brief was the first ‘blog site’ to launch in 2006, allowing people to have their say anonymously. Initially unmoderated, it unsurprisingly led to a steady stream of personal, and often borderline libelous commentary.
In 2008 Mumbrella was born, and founder Tim Burrowes admits he was “surprised” by the culture which sprung up around commenting on the site, quickly moving to pre-moderation, filtering the most dangerous remarks. AdNews and B&T soon followed suit, and suddenly the advertising industry had multiple channels to air their thoughts and frustrations.
Comments taken from the threads of various industry sites.
In 2008, the suicide of a creative in Chicago was attributed to vitriol sprayed at him on a US industry site with unmoderated comments. This led to consternation amongst many creatives, and in 2011 the Communications Council tried to organise a round-table event for editors from the various trade press to discuss the issue, but it was called off at the last minute and never made it back onto the agenda.
According to Burrowes, the move by all the sites to pre-moderation has led to a dampening down of the vitriol, with the truly personal attacks and most libelous comments never published.
Despite this he admits: “Every single time we post about a creative agency’s work, it brings out the worst behaviour. Unfortunately that behaviour has become normalised within the agencies. It might be those behaviours formed very early on, but we see different levels in creative than in other parts of the industry.”
Campaign Brief founder Michael Lynch says the vast majority of negative comments are about the campaigns themselves, rather than the people who created them.
“Although they take it personally, they’re normally about it being a really crap ad,” he says. “It’s more often than not about the work. I think people are honest if ads are good or bad. It’s the bad agencies that are scared, that’s the real truth.”
Both admit there is a problem with some agencies taking to comment threads to slag off rivals, especially if there has been a contentious pitch, although there is also the phenomenon of “astroturfing”, with agencies posting positive comments en-masse to make their work look better.
Burrowes adds it can be a challenge knowing when to moderate commentary, especially when a slew of personal comments come through from different people about the same person: “You wonder whether you’re stopping people from having a fair say at some points”.
But, both Hourigan and McFarlane say the tone of some commentary makes the industry look unprofessional, both to clients and to the international community. “How does their (clients’) agency look when they go to the industry blogs and see their new campaign trashed?” adds McFarlane.
“They’ll feel embarrassed, and then they’ll blame their agency. The knock-on effect is less trust next time they are presented with a less-than-orthodox creative approach.”
Hourigan says while other countries do have sites allowing anonymous commenting, which attract derogatory comments, “it doesn’t seem to have the impact and power”, with many of the international talent he has recruited telling him they are “shocked” by the culture on the sites.
Both say the culture is stifling creativity within the industry, with would-be innovators increasingly playing safe, for fear of a backlash. Hourigan adds: “Creatives should feel free and be supported by their own. Where is the nurturing support? If people put their names to opinion, it would stop so much of the negativity, and force bullies to stop hiding behind the internet.”
But the right for anonymous commentary is defended by both Burrowes and Lynch, who say it allows readers to have the safety to express their honest opinions, while sign-up processes are inevitably laborious, and time-consuming, and ultimately put people off contributing.
Lynch adds: “It doesn’t work. Everyone’s shit scared, no matter who they are they don’t even want to be seen as liking something because other people will come after them. They’d rather stay anonymous, even if it’s a good piece.”
Burrowes also points to those who are able to contribute because of their anonymity adding real value to debates and clearing up misconceptions, where they would otherwise be forced to stay silent.
But McFarlane is quick to dismiss the notion of anonymity facilitating free speech and honest debate. “Frankly how can it be honest discussion if you don’t know who you are talking to?” he says.
“Would anybody watch a Geoffrey Robertson hypothetical if all the panelists were masked? Would David Stratton movie reviews have any more clout if he were anonymous? It’s absolute heresy to use the word ‘honest’ in the context of anonymous blogging.”
The Communications Council is working to quell the deluge of commentary by speaking not only to publishers, but also asking agencies to integrate their new social media guidelines into their HR policies, giving staff a stricter code of conduct.
“People on both sides need to take responsibility, and everyone needs to do more. There is still a long way to go before people in our industry feel comfortable expressing their opinion freely,” Zabel concludes.
This article first appeared in the February 15 edition of B&T Magazine.
Please feel free to leave your thoughts on this topic, either named or anonymously, below.
Please login with linkedin to comment
Latest News
Kantar: AVOD Subscribers Double In 12 Months
Study finds Aussies happy to watch ads on their streaming services. Or, are they just putting the kettle on more often?
Val Morgan Digital Exceeds All Campaign Uplift Benchmarks Via A 12-Month Brand Metrics Study
Val Morgan announces it has exceeded all its campaign benchmarks. Still can't get under an hour for the City To Surf.
Australian Retirement Trust launches monster of a campaign, by M&C Saatchi and Bohemia
Get offered a seat on the bus today? Knees creak like an old pirate's galleon? This retirement ad may be of interest.
Print Audits To Discontinue As Audited Media Association Of Australia Pivots To Support Influencer Marketing
Is it just B&T or are audits in the media industry suddenly becoming murkier than Roxy's husband's tax returns?
News Corp Australia Launches 2024 National Education Advocacy Initiative With Expanded Program
News Corp set to shine a light on the nation's schools in new series, giving illegal bikie gangs a well-earned rest.
Decoding The Consumer Maze: Urban List Report Reveals How Modern Shoppers Spiral From Discovery To Purchase
Latest report unravels a shopper's journey from the joy of discovery through to a nasty letter from a debt collector.
Cosmo Returns To Australia!
Ever get the feeling we've weirdly warped back to 1988 at the moment? Confirm it with the relaunch of Cosmo in print.
People & Culture Consultancy Human Kind Collective Launches To Plug HR Gap For Media Agencies
Does the very mention of HR have you struggling to remember last year's Christmas party? Get the sweats with this news.
‘We Want To Be A Growth Partner, Not Just A Media Buyer Or Someone That Makes Ads’ – Bohemia Boss On Agency’s Ambition
B&T's chatting with Bohemia boss Paul ‘Hutch’ Hutchison. Although we do think 'the dagger' a far superior nickname.
Initiative’s Geoff Clarke: ‘Youth Hits Targets With Enthusiasm, Experience Hits The Targets You Can’t See’
Initiative’s CCO Geoff Clarke on the value of experience in agencies. Not to mention quoting lines from Pulp Fiction.
The Iconic Teams Up With 5 Aussie Athletes For Latest Campaign
Fashion label brings in the athletes for new campaign, many of whom appear to have prepped with re-runs of Zoolander.
Seven West Media Secures New Director Of News & Current Affairs
After a tumultuous few weeks, Seven unveils director of news & current affairs. And B&T never uses tumultuous lightly.
Seven Network Expands NSW Sales Team With Two New Group Business Directors
Seven ramps up its NSW sales team. Both of whom are well versed in pronouncing Manu Feildel's croque-monsieur.
New PR Subscription Changing The Game For Aussie Start Ups
Need better PR? You can now buy it via a monthly subscription. Price does not include a fascinator or Moet piccolos.
Paul Kent At Centre Of Fresh Scandal After Alleged Street Brawl
Do you long for the fights, gouges & testicle grabs of footy's glory years? So too, it appears, does Paul Kent.
DiDi Taps Disney’s Tim Farmer For Head Of Brand Marketing Role
Disney's Tim Farmer shifts over to rideshare company DiDi. Taking with him his Donald Duck coffee mug & mouse ears.
As Sure As Night Becomes Day, The End Of Third-Party Cookies Has Been Delayed
The question remains: what will we see first? The end of cookies, alien invasion or Jesus's second coming?
Fast 10: Scoundrel’s Tim Bullock Explains What Shane Warne & Salt-N-Pepa Have In Common
It's a Fast 10 with Scoundrel's Tim Bullock. Make it sound even faster by sucking on helium while reading it.
Outbrain Snatches Chris Oxley From Foxtel Media
Foxtel's Chris Oxley shifts over to Outbrain, but not before having his press photo taken in the wilds of the Daintree.
oOh!media & POLY Partner With Greening Australia For OOH Awareness Campaign
Like to quell the road rage with super cute pics of fluffy marsupials? This outdoor's just the ticket.
Are Media Cares For The Carers In Its Latest Social Change Campaign
Are Media calls on the government to add super payments to carers' payments. Remains silent on AUKUS, however.
In A Fragmented World, Engagement Is King
Today, B&T TV's talking fragmentation & engagement. But not in a down-on-one-knee sense of the word.
Kyle Sandilands On Advertising: “We Want Return Business. It’s No Good Just Taking Someone’s Money”
Kyle & Jackie O finally arrive on Melbourne radio. As yet, no sign of the monotonous and bitter AFL-NRL debate.
Sydney Comedy Festival: Taking The City & Social Media By Storm
Sydney Comedy Festival 2024 is live and ready to rumble, showing the best of international and homegrown talent at a host of venues around town. As usual, it’s hot on the heels of its big sister, the giant that is the Melbourne International Comedy Festival, picking up some acts as they continue on their own […]
Global Marketers Descend For AANA’s RESET For Growth
The Australian Association of National Advertisers (AANA) has announced the final epic lineup of local and global marketing powerhouses for RESET for Growth 2024. Lead image: Josh Faulks, chief executive officer, AANA Back in 2000, a woman with no business experience opened her first juice bar in Adelaide. The idea was brilliantly simple: make healthy […]
Is Meta’s New AI Chatbot Too Left-Wing?
Meta's chatbot accused of being left-wing after being caught wearing a Che Guevara T-shirt & listening to Billy Bragg.
TV Ratings (23/04/2024): Why Did No One Tell Angela That Farmer Wants A Wife Is Set On A Farm?
As wonderful as this headline is, let's face it, we all know an 'Angela', don't we?
PubMatic Unveils New AI Partnership To Turn Social Posts Into Ads For Any Digital Channel
Here's some nifty tech for turning social posts into ads. Assuming said posts aren't one-star character assassinations.
Intuit Mailchimp Makes A Splash With Its First Australian Brand Campaign
Ever laugh along at a gag you didn't get so as not to appear dumb? Get ready for more feigning with this new work.
GumGum’s Rob Hall: Advertisers Can No Longer “Rely On Binary Descriptions” Of Consumers
If anyone's got their finger on adtech's pulse, it's Rob Hall. He also avoids using the good paper in the office printer
Mastercard Nabs Florencia Aimo From Marriott International
Marriott International's Florencia Aimo jumps from the hotel business to the exploitative credit card one.
Bastion Agency Appoints Cheuk Chiang As New ANZ CEO
Cheuk Chiang takes the reins over at Bastion Agency. But not the rains down in Africa.
Spotlight On Sponsors: Major Sponsorship Wins After A Disappointing Week In Sport
B&T continuing our deep dive into local sport sponsorships & that's despite not a single offer of a free ticket as yet.
Macca’s Marketing Director, Samantha McLeod On Big Mac Chant: “What Was Once Old Is Now Cool Again”
Macca's using the power of nostalgia in latest Big Mac campaign. Well, only for those who've ever eaten one sober.
World Premiere Of Midnight Oil: The Hardest Line To Open Sydney Film Festival 2024
Oil's biopic to open Sydney Film Festival. Here's hoping Molly Meldrum will take his pants down at the premiere.
Entries Are Now Open For The 2024 Brandies, IntelligenceBank’s Annual Brand Marketing Awards
The Brandies are, of course, a prestigious marketing gong and not the mystery tipple favoured by nannas everywhere.