Why A Slow Comment Is As Bad As “No Comment” In A PR Crisis

Why A Slow Comment Is As Bad As “No Comment” In A PR Crisis
SHARE
THIS



In this guest post, PR crisis management expert Gerry McCusker (pictured below) explains why a slow comment in a crisis is becoming the next worst thing to making no comment.

Gerry McCusker

Recently, the AFL was heavily criticised for failing to issue a prompt condemnatory statement when one of its executives was cited for coward-punching (blindsiding) an opponent in an amateur football game. Despite following what they termed ‘due process’, the AFL leadership was lambasted for following a form of issues management broadly perceived as ‘wait and see’.

Having analysed and researched PR disasters for over a dozen years, I know that the W&S phenomenon comes from an era – a media age – when brands had the relative time luxury to formulate their response to an issue or crisis. That time, literally, has disappeared. In our crisis simulations with clients, we’re working to an issue acknowledgement time of seven minutes! Social media can drive the crisis narrative.

Customers, clients, the public and – more critically – the media, make their minds up about any incident, story, occurrence in the blink of an eye. More tellingly, they’re savvy enough to know when something is plainly wrong and should be called out as such. Yet many brands will dally and dither while deliberating if their ‘issue’ really is a ‘crisis’.

But given that media monitoring systems like Meltwater can pretty accurately indicate the strength of stakeholder sentiment on any given topic, what’s the issue with prompt engagement? What’s not to like about statements crafted to resonate with the citizenry?

In fact, when big data is turned into issues management ‘intel’, your brand can stay almost totally attuned to – and possibly move in step with – influencer and public opinion. As Carlos Castillo infers, there’s just no need to look unaware or unprepared.

I’ve consulted in incident situation rooms where ‘W&S’ execs prefer to see how bad or tortuous a situation will become before deciding if – or how – to engage with the crisis narrative. I’d prefer to help shape the story, rather than just be a victim of it.

I reiterate to clients, if you’re not IN(forming) the crisis narrative, you can’t influence it.

In (round) football-speak, it’s like giving Chelsea three goals of a start in the first 45, and hoping to draw level in the second half; realistically, that’s unlikely to happen.

I get Schadenfraude giggles when I see people put their hands up to cover their faces or camera lenses when pursued by news crews. They sometimes mumble, “No comment”, which is semiologically signalling, “Yep, I’m guilty”.

Given the acceleration of fact-free, agenda-driven, opinion-forming, pronouncement-making, speculation-indulging social and news media – and the influential SEO narrative that accompanies it – slow comment in a crisis is becoming the next worst thing to no comment. It can leave you out of the crisis conversation.

Latest News

A young boy nerd shouts at the top of his voice to his co-worker through a megaphone trying to talk some sense into him. The young nerds are dressed in bowties and glasses. Retro styling.
  • Opinion

Smart Speakers: The Voice Of A Generation

In this opinion piece, Growth Tank management consultant David Willey looks into research on the usage of voice assistants and access to smart speakers for Generation Z, Millennials and Generation X in Australia. We hear a lot about how Millennials, and now Generation Z, are changing the game on marketing by adopting the latest technology, including digital voice […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Host/Havas Bags Work For Oroton
  • Advertising

Host/Havas Bags Work For Oroton

Host/Havas staff forced to takes lessons on accessorising after snaring Oroton's creative account.

Glenn McGrath & Mike Hussey Join Macquarie Media’s Cricket Commentary Team
  • Media

Glenn McGrath & Mike Hussey Join Macquarie Media’s Cricket Commentary Team

Macquarie Media has announced that two of Australia’s cricketing greats, Glenn McGrath and Mike Hussey, are the latest additions to its cricket commentary line-up. McGrath (pictured above, right) and Hussey (pictured above, left) will join Darren Lehmann and Ian Chappell in the Macquarie Macquarie Sports Radio commentary box this summer, as part of the company’s new six-year […]

SBS Chooses Fairfax’s Andrew Mudgway To Lead Its Commercial Strategy
  • Advertising
  • Media

SBS Chooses Fairfax’s Andrew Mudgway To Lead Its Commercial Strategy

Special Broadcasting Service (SBS) has announced the appointment of Andrew Mudgway as its national sales manager for TV and digital. Mudgway joins SBS from Fairfax Media, where he was responsible for the publisher’s national digital and print sales team. He brings more than 25 years’ experience to SBS, having also held positions at IPG Mediabrands, […]