Existential Threats: The Advertising Industry Has Lost All Its Credibility

Existential Threats: The Advertising Industry Has Lost All Its Credibility
SHARE
THIS



In part two of a four-part series (see part one here) aimed at threats and opportunities for agencies, regular B&T columnist, Robert Strohfeldt from Strohfeldt Consulting argues that the industry has lost its once treasured trust and credibility, and it’s time to get it back.

This is the second of four articles looking at existential threats to advertising agencies, which the key threats Identity, Credibility, Competition and Remuneration. Though addressed separately, the four are all intertwined.

The first article was on Identity – agencies moving away from their core purpose of Persuasion. A perfect example of credibility, or lack of, was an article in response which stated: “How Innovation Prize Shows Agencies How to be More Than Just Agencies”.

Read the article and the so called innovation is in fact a community service campaign aimed at getting young men to check themselves for signs of testicular cancer. Excuse me? Strip away the bullshit wording and what we have is an advertising campaign.

They used porn stars and supposedly interrupted “programming”, but it was still what agencies have been doing since they first started around 150 years ago. It is innovative, but innovation is not a new phenomenon that was only thought of in the digital era.

“To step outside the existing parameters of Above and Below the Line advertising and explore new solutions, alternatives, the innovative, the lateral. The possibilities are endless with our pool of beyond creative resources as diverse as playwrights, academics, musicians, journalists, performers and psychiatrists. Our role can include correlating these possibilities and creating a total concept from above, below and beyond.”.

The above is a quote from the Bond Strohfeldt credentials document in 1990. We didn’t have an Innovation Lab, rather innovative thinking was a culture we created throughout the agency, from receptionist to CEO. We performed many jobs and projects that were outside of what would have been called “traditional advertising”, but they were all to do with Persuasion.

The technology has changed, but the philosophy and approach should not.

The “magic” of advertising and creativity started slipping before the digital era commenced. But this has accelerated with what can best be described as scandals, as they became better known as in the past couple of years. A consequence is that advertising has slipped down the totem pole of importance and relevance to the CEO and board.

If a company puts in a new Gloggity Glog machine worth $20 million, the directors all line up for their photos to be taken with said machine. But if the CEO asks for an additional $20 million in advertising, he will probably be looking for a new job – advertising is now, more often than not, seen as an expense rather than an investment. (Unlike that bloody new Gloggity Glog machine).

2016 has been a watershed year for the industry. Though many people have spoken and written about various credibility issues, Professor Mark Ritson was the first to tie the major problems and issues together in his series of lectures to the AANA earlier this year. Encouragingly, there has been a noticeable shift in attitude and action by many agencies to tackle these problems.

A quick summary of what Ritson described as “the greatest scandal/s in the history of marketing (and advertising)”, and marketing because client actions were primary causal factors in their making.

Social Media – Groan, not that old chestnut. But with around two-thirds of CMOs unsure of their ROI from social, and around the same percentage saying they are going to increase their social budgets, something somewhere is amiss.

It seems that no matter how much evidence is put forward that social media, whilst having a role to play, is way over-represented in the money and resources put into it, it is ignored. (The main industry publications have also played their part who, according to Ritson, have devoted around 48 per cent of their editorial coverage in the past 12 months to social media).

Yet, two separate large sample quantitative studies have come up with the same result – two-thirds of Australians do not follow any brands on social media. There is a large and increasing choice of mediums/conduits to the consumer. But the effectiveness of each is determined by more than just the number of people who use it, which is a primary rationale for social. The landline at its peak, had billions of users, yet after 100+ years all it has given us is telemarketing.

Digital Marketing/Advertising/Media – All through the nineties, convergence was the buzzword. But the proliferation of media options has resulted in divergence. Consumers slip seamlessly between online (digital) and traditional media (which is digital). Yet our industry has created a divide between the two.

Online Versus Traditional Media – Google and Facebook have done a tremendous job of denigrating traditional media, whilst simultaneously talking up their own efficacy. Again, the industry media have lent a helping hand. Not only has social received far more coverage than its impact deserves, the vast majority of articles about traditional media are negative – last century, no longer effective and so on.

The days of three commercial networks and channels are over. But mainstream still draws numbers online options can only dream about. And the increase in the number of digital channels has resulted in more precise targeting, with reduced overlap. Search is highly effective, no argument. But display?

These criticisms are of course generalisations, with many agencies and individuals utilising the advantages presented by new media and technology and developing integrated communications that positively impact consumers at every touch point. Customer experience, for example, is a specialty that agencies should and do now specialise in.

In retail, brand image is determined by POS experience. Highly effective initiatives which result in increased sales traffic can result in brand image degradation if that experience is bad.

Banks provide a case study in what not to do. Like lemmings, the majors have been following each other in telling customers they put them first – they are not about money, they are about people. Then The Reserve Bank cuts cash rate interest and all of this is passed on to the customers they care about.

Within 24 hours, tens of millions of dollars in communications has not only been rendered useless, it has worked against them – a classic example of shooting yourself in the foot, or the head. I am sure many in the industry could see the dangers in these “people first, money second” campaigns. But we longer have the direct access to the top level decision makers. We are left to deal with mid-level executives.

The late Neil Lawrence was one of the last of the era whose standing and influence was such that he worked and reported directly to those at the top. His effectiveness was not diluted by having to report to a chain to the real decision makers. And in doing so he gave great credibility to our industry and demonstrated what we can achieve for clients (be they private, public or politicians).

Today, CEOs are more likely to be surrounded by accountants, lawyers and investment bankers. (Who have now become competitors).

We need to win back the broad trust and credibility that advertising/communications once had. They were the days when CEOs and boards recognised that we made the money, the rest basically counted it.

Next – Competition.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Western Australia Gets Its First Influencer Marketing Agency
  • Marketing

Western Australia Gets Its First Influencer Marketing Agency

Western Australia’s first dedicated social influencer marketing agency will launch next week to service the state’s new and rapidly growing digital industry. The Influencer Agency – TIA – brings strategy, accountability and measurement to influencer marketing for WA brands using WA influencers. TIA will also assist influencers wanting to grow their brand by developing new […]

One-on-one With Marie Claire Editor Nicky Briger
  • Media

One-on-one With Marie Claire Editor Nicky Briger

Following the launch of the revamped marieclaire.com.au, editor Nicky Briger spoke to Magazine Networks about all it can offer readers. In September, Pacific Magazines unveiled an all-new digital experience for Marie Claire. Led by design thinking, the new look marieclaire.com.au was crafted to provide a better reader experience across all devices. It’s a testament to […]

Women’s Health Unveils Its New Premium Digital Experience
  • Media

Women’s Health Unveils Its New Premium Digital Experience

Pac Mags’ Women’s Health has unveiled an all-new premium digital experience. With a faster, cleaner, more intuitive and visually consistent brand experience across all devices, the new look is designed to optimise the user’s journey with less clutter, discoverable content and seamless integration for commercial partners. Will Everitt, head of product and technology said: “The digital evolution of […]

Digital Agency Inlight Secures Two Key Client Wins
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Digital Agency Inlight Secures Two Key Client Wins

Independent agency Inlight has announced it has won the digital account for Benetas, a not-for-profit aged care provider in Victoria. Following a competitive pitch process, Inlight was chosen to handle Benetas’ new website design, build and ongoing optimisation. Richard Barker, marketing manager at Benetas, said: “We wanted an agency that could be our true digital […]

AMI Awards 2017 Winners Revealed!
  • Marketing

AMI Awards 2017 Winners Revealed!

With almost 30 awards handed out, B&T predicts plenty of numb bottoms at last night's AMI Awards in Melbourne.

Clems Sydney CEO Andy Pontin Quits
  • Advertising

Clems Sydney CEO Andy Pontin Quits

Sure, B&T flashed the news of Andy Pontin quitting this morning. White lies aside, he's actually still got six months.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Adobe MAXes Most Creatives In A Room Record
  • Advertising
  • Media

Adobe MAXes Most Creatives In A Room Record

B&T's journo is reporting live from the annual Adobe Summit in Vegas. Although, "reporting" is somewhat of a stretch.

Opinion

by David Hovenden

David Hovenden
Digital Women’s Network & The Australian College Of Marketing Unveil Latest Short Courses
  • Marketing

Digital Women’s Network & The Australian College Of Marketing Unveil Latest Short Courses

The Australian College of Marketing is collaborating with the Digital Women’s Network to bring new short courses aimed to provide the latest skills across all aspects of the Digital landscape, kicking off in Melbourne and Sydney in 2018. Course content will focus around various topics related to the digital marketing landscape. All courses will run […]

Man working at office desk, looking at computer and scratching head
  • Technology

Where Are Digital & Tech Skills & Salaries Headed?

The rapid pace of technological change in the digital sector is seeing demand for those with the right skill sets outstrip availability, both locally and globally. The individuals who have kept their skills up to date are being well-rewarded financially. Now, Digital + Technology Collective’s expanded annual Skills and Salary Survey will put some numbers and context […]

Disney & ESPN Unify Sales & Partnerships Teams
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Disney & ESPN Unify Sales & Partnerships Teams

Disney and ESPN have formed an even closer bond, announcing a new alignment of the two properties through their media sales and partnerships teams. Instead of entering through three doors, Disney ESPN Media Sales & Partnerships will give media buyers and marketers a refined, singular point of entry for Disney, ESPN Digital and Maker. Nik […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Sydney Start-up Muzaara Partners With Commission Factory To Turbocharge Digital Ad Spends
  • Advertising
  • Marketing

Sydney Start-up Muzaara Partners With Commission Factory To Turbocharge Digital Ad Spends

Sydney-based adtech start-up Muzaara has announced a new strategic partnership with performance marketing platform Commission Factory. Together, Muzaara and Commision Factory are providing SMEs with a secret weapon to skyrocket their online brand visibility and effectively manage and maximise their online advertising campaigns. This partnership will allow both online marketing companies and their impressive roster […]

Kellogg’s Creates AR Halloween Trick Or Treat Experience Via Shazam & Orchard
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Kellogg’s Creates AR Halloween Trick Or Treat Experience Via Shazam & Orchard

Breakfast cereal manufacturer Kellogg’s has joined forces with Shazam and digital agency Orchard to deliver a first-of-its-kind augmented reality (AR) Halloween Trick or Treat experience for families. The campaign, which leverages Shazam’s visual recognition platform and recently-launched AR platform, sees Kellogg’s pilot the replacement of physical gifts in cereal packs with a digital experience that […]

Kraft Heinz Appoints Cummins&Partners As New Creative Agency
  • Advertising

Kraft Heinz Appoints Cummins&Partners As New Creative Agency

Kraft Heinz today confirmed the appointment of Cummins&Partners as its new Creative agency after an extensive pitch process. They will be responsible for brand strategy and integrated creative across the expanding Kraft Heinz portfolio including Kraft, Heinz and Golden Circle. A Kraft Heinz spokesperson said: “After an exhaustive search involving a competitive pitch, we have made […]

Patrick Delany (CEO, Fox Sports), Hugh Marks (CEO, Nine Entertainment Co), Miranda Devine (Columnist, News Corp), Michael Miller (Executive Chairman, News Corp Australasia), Grant Blackley (CEO & Managing Director, Southern Cross Austereo) at Radio Alive 2017
  • Media

Media Bosses Weigh In On Ten-CBS Deal

Do you enjoy articles featuring industry big-wigs? Well, it doesn't come much bigger and wiggier than this, we say.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Kantar TNS’ Ali Dexter Joins T Garage As Director Of Insights & Strategy
  • Marketing

Kantar TNS’ Ali Dexter Joins T Garage As Director Of Insights & Strategy

Melbourne-based market research consulting agency T Garage has announced the appointment of Ali Dexter as its director of insights and strategy. Dexter joins T Garage from Kantar TNS, where she was the director of its Qualitative division. Prior to that, Dexter held a number of senior roles at Kantar TNS in the US and Vietnam.  “After […]

XXXX on Tuesday, March 21, 2017, in Las Vegas. (Jeff Bottari/AP Images for Adobe)
  • Advertising

Adobe Releases Advertising Cloud App

Not one, but two Adobe announcements. The tech elves have been busy this week, not that we're inferring Adobe is Santa.