Three Things Every Marketer Needs To Know From Google’s ‘Messy Middle’ Research

In this guest post, founder of Hardhat agency Dan Monheit (pictured) offers his outtakes on the three things every marketer needs to know from Google’s ‘Messy Middle’ research…
People can say whatever they want to say. Brands can promise whatever they want to promise. But when it’s all said and done, behaviour is the only thing that’s real.
This belief is what’s driven me to spend more of the last decade thinking about, researching, experimenting, podcasting and presenting on human behaviour, than almost anything else. So when in April this year, Google invited me to help unpack their groundbreaking global research into how behavioural biases impact our purchase decisions, it was a pretty quick ‘yes’ from my end.
The large scale scientific study delved deep into the “messy middle” – that elongated phase between initial inspiration and eventual purchase. The research covered a two-year-long study of over 250,000 online shopping journeys and draws on decades of behavioural science research before that.
Three key insights for marketers
Historically, there’s been a lot of deeply academic research into the field of behavioural economics. What I loved was that this study specifically set out to see how we can apply these findings outside the lab, and turn them into real-time commercial, competitive advantages.
There was a lot to take in, but my three biggest takeaways were as follows:
1. You can’t win if you’re not there
While this might sound obvious, the Google data demonstrated the tremendous importance of presence alone – essentially, just turning up. Researchers asked ‘in market’ shoppers for their first and second favourite brand across dozens of categories. They then ran purchasing simulation, where these shoppers were asked to choose between the two.
Just having a choice between brands, saw more than 30% of shoppers deflect to their second favourite, which rationally, makes no sense at all. It’s like saying that your favourite ice-cream is chocolate, then being presented with chocolate and strawberry ice cream, and immediately choosing strawberry!
The power of presence alone was enough for a competing brand to take a third of the favoured brand’s sales, proving the potency of unconscious factors over rational reasoning when it comes to decision-making.
2. We’re all emos
Google’s research also revealed a new consumer purchasing model, known as ‘The Messy Middle’. While the traditional ‘purchasing funnel’ was represented by a linear path, in which consumers move from awareness, through interest, desire and action, the new model highlights the distinct modes of ‘exploration’ and evaluation’, in which shoppers add and remove options along the way.
Sometimes, shoppers get stuck in that infinite ‘exploration/evaluation’ loop, narrowing in on a decision, before zooming back out again with updated purchasing criteria or new priorities. It’s our job as marketers to nudge them out of this loop and towards a purchase, by triggering an emotion with something relevant and compelling. For example, showing shoppers that people like them have already bought the item, that there are only a few left in stock, or guaranteeing delivery by 9am the next day was often enough to disrupt the loop and make what is objectively the same product, suddenly more attractive.
3. Marketing as alchemy
Marketing has swung hard in the direction of data. Ask the algorithm and it will give you the answers! But research consistently demonstrated that consumers don’t act according to spreadsheets. Emotional triggers consistently and predictably drive more sales than rational arguments.
Most interestingly, the research showed the compounding effect of layering different behavioural biases on top of each other. In categories as diverse as skincare and health insurance, turning up, then activating a range of biases including the authority bias, social proof and the power of now, was enough to deflect almost 80% of preference away from a ‘preferred’ brand and towards a second choice. In fact, in many categories, triggering these biases was enough to deflect half of all preference towards a competing brand that was completely made up.
The magic here is being able to steal between 50% and 80% of a competitor’s sales with techniques that cost virtually nothing to activate. Whether it’s including reviews, highlighting faster shipping or informing people that there are limited items left in stock, activating biases is one of the quickest, easiest and cheapest ways to boost sales in a significant, meaningful way.
With so many of our purchases now moving online, brands have an unprecedented opportunity to experiment with behavioural economics and start enjoying the benefits it can bring in the short and long term.
Latest News

Hurry: Entries Close This Friday For Snapchat Young Lions!
Entries close this Friday for Snapchat Young Lions! No warning bells, no air horns, no firing of a small canon. Nothing.

Voting For B&T’s 30 Under 30 People’s Choice Awards Is Now Open!
Of all the awards B&T hands out, THIS is one of our favourites. That & our in-house 'staff f@ck-up of the month' trophy.

National Indigenous Television Appoints Jack Latimore Managing Editor Of NITV Digital
NITV has announced that Jack Latimore, acclaimed writer and journalist, and proud Birpai man with family ties to Thungutti and Gumbaynggirr/Bundjalung nations, has been appointed Managing Editor of their digital offering. Latimore has been acting in the position since last December. Before that, he was Digital Editor at NITV. His promotion sees his remit expand […]

5,000 Votes Later, These Are Your Top Five 30 Under 30 People’s Choice Awards Nominees
B&T's server barely coped with yesterday's announcement of People's Choice. Well, we doubt it was that cloud article.

Are Media Launches TRENDtalks, A Category Insight Series For Marketers
Magazine publisher Are Media continue to unveil a raft of initiatives that have little to do with publishing magazines.

Verizon Promotes Simon Wheeler to Senior Director Of Content
Verizon Media has promoted Simon Wheeler to senior director of content, following significant growth of Verizon Media’s Australian media brands. Under his new regional remit, Wheeler will lead editorial strategy in English-language regions, including Australia, India and South-East Asia. Editorial teams in India and across South East Asia will now report into Wheeler under the […]

Spirit Super Appoints Common Ventures As Creative Partner
Nothing says "I'll be working until I'm 107" quite like opening the latest super statement in the mail, does it.

Subaru Launches New Outback With Homage To The 80s In New Campaign Via The Works
This wonderful 80s-inspired car ad will arguably make no sense whatsoever to anyone aged 35 or under.

Destination NSW Launches New Media Centre
A message to Destination NSW - yep, you got us, we're not going anywhere else now, are we? Rack that travel cue, we say.

Howatson + White Snares Allianz’s Creative Away From TBWA As Its Foundation Client
Howatson + White hurriedly forced to switch their car's green slip insurer after snaring Allianz as inaugural client.

electriclimefilms Vows To ‘Shape An Inclusive Culture In Film And Media’
Since its inception in 2010 of bringing expressions of art to commercial films, electriclimefilms has been seeking and taking firm steps towards moulding an inclusive culture within the workplace and film industry. In a male-dominated industry, the film house prides themselves on a growing female presence across Dubai, Singapore and Sydney; seventy per cent of […]

Jon Foged Appointed To Kantar’s ANZ Leadership
Jon Foged promoted to MD of Kantar's ANZ insights division. Also exhausted by constantly adding "it's without the 'h'."

YouTubers Expose Royal Experts For Lying About Harry And Meghan’s Oprah Interview
Despite Oprah's probing interview, we're none the wiser to the family's hatred of Fergie or if the Queen ever farts.

The Royals Unveils ‘Perfect Match’ Campaign For Home Loan Lender Athena
All but given up on ever owning your own home thanks to insane property prices? Feel the rage with this comedy spot.

Special Group Adds Matt Bladin And Phoebe Sloane To Melbourne Creative Team
Special Group snare award-winning duo for Melbourne office. And by "award-winning" we mean not just third in backstroke.

CHEP & Aptamil Toddler Launch Campaign To Help Mums Return To Work
Nothing screams "I'm a new parent" quite like the bags under the eyes and the vomit down the back, does it!

“Women Belong In The Kitchen!” Burger King Flame Grilled For Tone Deaf Ad
B&T's labelling this article as crisis management, but it's really about laughing at people stuffing-up really badly.

Monday TV Wrap: Meghan And Harry’s Oprah Interview Resoundingly Wins The Night For 10
Oprah's Meghan and Harry tell-all proves a winner for 10, but not for New Idea's printers forced to work to 5am.

The Ads I Wish I’d Made: CCG’s Ant Melder – “Pot Noodle’s The Ring Transcended The Brand”
It's the latest in B&T's video series 'The Ads I Wish I'd Made'. And, yes, it excludes the pre-roll ads on the YouTube.

Those Stories About Your Brand’s ‘Social Impact’ Are A Waste Of Time – And Money
This expert argues brands blabbering on about their social impact is a waste of time & money. And you read it for free.

Sacked Channel Seven Presenter Simon Reeves Settles Court Battle With Network
Ryan Phelan, Andrew O'Keefe and now Simon Reeves! It's been a big year for ex-Seven employees' legal teams.

Data, Identity And The Art Of Keeping It Simple
Here's a piece titled "data, identity & the art of keeping it simple". And, to the author's credit, he's kept it simple.

Working Mums Are Always Asked, How Do You Manage Career And Family? Let’s Build A Society Where This Isn’t The Norm
This should've run yesterday for International Women's Day. But in B&T's defence, it was $10 schnitzels at our local.

Never Not Creative Launch Never Not International Women’s Day Campaign
A platform that shares talks addressing the challenges of women in society by women and male supporters in our industry, live, on-loop 24.7.365.

First-Party Data, Transparency And Aggregation: Tips On Surviving A Cookieless World
This headline does suggest you're in for a heavy techy read here. But fear not, even B&T understood a good 60 per cent.

UnLtd Big Clash Cricket Tournament Returns To Raise $160,000 For Children At Risk
UnLtd's industry cricket tournament raises $160,000 for kids, at the same time costing $7435 in smashed windscreens.

QUT And BCM Launch Campaign Celebrating Women In STEM
QUT’s long-term agency partner, BCM, has developed a thought provoking and impactful campaign for the university to coincide with 2021 International Women’s Day.

NRMA Insurance Unveil Next Instalment Of ‘Every Home Is Worth Protecting’ Campaign, Via The Monkeys
To demonstrate that every home is worth protecting, NRMA Insurance has released its latest campaign that sees the return of young boy Sammy as he continues his quest to look out for the homes of Australia’s iconic but vulnerable koalas. Created by The Monkeys, part of Accenture Interactive, the campaign centres on Sammy as he […]

Westpac Launches New Campaign To Highlight Life’s Eventful Moments, Via DDB
Westpac has launched its new brand campaign, created by DDB Sydney, highlighting life’s eventful moments where all the surprise, excitement, vulnerability, and challenges can lie; in moments both big and small. Westpac Group Head of Brand, Advertising and Media, Jenny Melhuish said, “our new work builds on our ‘help’ series, which focused on those really […]

GHO Strengthens Equity Team With Hamish Stewart Promoted To Creative Partner
GHO has appointed Hamish Stewart as an equity partner in the business. Hamish joins GHO’s four existing partners to round out the diversity of experience offered by the agency across research, strategy, design, digital and creative marketing.