Q&A with Doug Gimesy on ‘Gruen Planet chided over ad ethics’

Q&A with Doug Gimesy on ‘Gruen Planet chided over ad ethics’
SHARE
THIS



Following the big response to Doug Gimesy's opinion piece on ad ethics, B&T caught up with him to further flesh out the issue.

Q. What did you make of the response to your article?

I think it's great that a lot of people have engaged with this issue, and looking at all the comments, some great points have been raised. For example, the view that it can be just as important to consider the outcomes of an action, as well as the motives behind it, is absolutely valid. 

Q. Some have said that you are just splitting hairs and being semantic. Do you disagree?

No, not at all, however I do find it ironic that when a large strategic component of any good advertising is based on understanding the meaning and impact of communication – whether it be via words, sounds or visuals – that I was criticised for what semantics is all about – the meaning of language. If the meaning of words was not important, would we really need highly skilled copywriters?

Q. Isn't there a thin line between coercion, manipulation, persuasion and education?

I understand how some people might think that, for what may be manipulation to one person, may simply be persuasion to another. And what may be persuasion to one person, may have no influence whatsoever on another. However, I think it's important to understand that coercion, manipulation, persuasion and education are very different approaches used to influence others, and each is embedded with a different intent and application. Notwithstanding this, there are two things that connect them all, and that's their ability to influence, and the degree of respect, or disrespect, that they show towards their target market.

Q. So how do you see them as different?

For me, coercion is when a situation is created that forces someone to behave or not behave in a certain manner. Emotional blackmail is a great example. Promoting a product as the 'in thing' can set up the threat of being excluded from a social group if you don't own it, and so can drive someone to purchase it when they normally wouldn't. This is more often seen with younger people where peer group pressure is stronger.

Psychological manipulation is, as I mentioned in my opinion piece, when someone tries to influence another, with the aim of changing their perception or behaviour through underhanded, deceptive, or even abusive tactics.  Persuasion on the other hand is when someone tries to influence another through reason and argument, and this is often done via the removal of bias, and then providing them with balanced options. Education is simply providing someone unbiased and balanced data.

Now certainly all four approaches may have the same outcome, and these can be positive or negative, however I think that the motives behind whatever strategy or approach is used, is just as important as the outcomes produced.

Q: Any last words?

Ethics are always important, and as highlighted in one comments made to my piece, unfortunately we often see these lacking in those organisations, industries or institutions that have significant influence on our society. When done effectively, Marketing and advertising is no exception due to its vast reach and its ability to influence others.

For an industry whose reputation often suffers, I think it’s great to have a laugh at ourselves, and programs like Gruen Planet certainly offers this. I just think when we start making generalisations about what we are and what we do, we need to be very careful about the words used and the meanings attached to these, especially when it comes to our ethics.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

HEADS UP: Entries For B&T’s Best Of The Best Awards Close This Week!
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media
  • Technology

HEADS UP: Entries For B&T’s Best Of The Best Awards Close This Week!

Okay, people. It’s time to take us seriously when we say that entries for B&T’s Best of the Best awards close this Friday! The day we’ve been warning you about for weeks is here, and it’s time to get your act together. Head on over HERE and start your submission. On-time entries for Best of the Best will be […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Witchery Partners With GlamCorner To Boost Subscription Shopping
  • Media

Witchery Partners With GlamCorner To Boost Subscription Shopping

Australian fashion brand Witchery has partnered with B Corp GlamCorner as part of GlamCorner’s subscription box offering as the demand for everyday essentials soars. This partnership marks another milestone for the Australian fashion industry towards becoming more circular and introducing more paths to reduce textile waste. Customers nationally will be able to rent more of […]

Curry Club For COVID-19 Relief, Powered By UnLtd, Challenges AdLand To Raise $100,000
  • Marketing
  • Media

Curry Club For COVID-19 Relief, Powered By UnLtd, Challenges AdLand To Raise $100,000

The media, marketing and creative industries are being encouraged to host their own ‘Curry Club for COVID’ before 30th June to help meet the ambitious $100k target set by its organisers. Curry Club for COVID, which was conceived by long-time adtech executive Peter Bray, sales director at Impact, and is powered by industry social purpose organisation […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
UnLtd’s ‘Goals for Good’ Soccer Tournament Celebrates 10 Years
  • Media

UnLtd’s ‘Goals for Good’ Soccer Tournament Celebrates 10 Years

The UnLtd Cup is returning for its tenth consecutive year, marking a decade of soccer shenanigans that’s raised nearly $500,000 for children’s mental health charity, KidsXpress. On July 22-23rd, 28 teams from across the industry will battle it out on the soccer field in the two-day tournament at Sydney University Sports and Fitness Centre, Darlington. […]

Mobile Pnone Shopping Online With A Debit Card
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Ultra Commerce Acquires Vesta eCommerce

Australian-bred company Ultra Commerce has acquired New Zealand-based company Vesta eCommerce, a global software business providing leading product data management solutions. The recent acquisition is a significant move for the business, which is Australian born, owned, and headquartered, but has built out a global presence as it pursues rapid growth in the eCommerce market. Connecting […]

Crater Teams Up With Director Luna Laure For ‘Harry’s Story’, Canteen’s Newest Campaign
  • Campaigns

Crater Teams Up With Director Luna Laure For ‘Harry’s Story’, Canteen’s Newest Campaign

Canteen’s latest campaign features the combined talents of Director Luna Laure and creative agency Crater. The campaign strives to raise awareness for young people affected by cancer. The awareness campaign centres around Harry Barentson, who at 12 years of age found out his pregnant mum had cancer. The campaign aims to bring awareness to Canteen’s […]

AFL Legend Kevin Sheedy Narrates ‘A Love Letter To Victoria’ Via Enthral Partners
  • Campaigns

AFL Legend Kevin Sheedy Narrates ‘A Love Letter To Victoria’ Via Enthral Partners

In partnership with storytelling agency Enthral, AFL star Kevin Sheedy has voiced a video ‘Love Letter to Victoria’ using visuals to showcase the state’s natural beauty and culture. Victoria has been hit with the worst of the coronavirus pandemic compared with any other Aussie state experiencing four lockdowns. Sheedy has partnered with Ethral to share […]

Telstra’s Belong Appoints Howatson + White For Strategy & Creative, Retains OMD For Media
  • Advertising

Telstra’s Belong Appoints Howatson + White For Strategy & Creative, Retains OMD For Media

Telstra’s lower-cost telco, Belong, has awarded its strategy and creative account to Howatson + White, and has reappointed OMD to its media buying account, after a competitive pitch process. Howatson + White will handle strategy, planning, creative and CRM, while former agency Clemenger will continue to have a relationship with Belong, managing PR and retail activation. […]

Coke Releases New Campaign, ‘Turn Up Your Break’, Via Ogilvy
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Coke Releases New Campaign, ‘Turn Up Your Break’, Via Ogilvy

Coca-Cola Australia has rolled out its new campaign ‘Turn Up Your Break’. The campaign will be led by a TVC that encourages people to truly pause with a Coke on their break so they can walk away feeling refreshed and uplifted. The TVC features two busy chefs stepping outside for a break, the bustling kitchen […]