Playing nice

Playing nice
SHARE
THIS



It’s a fairly common situation: two competing agencies working for the same client. What happens? They stab each other in the back – subtly sabotaging each other’s work, criticising each other’s work to the client, talking up their own capabilities in contrast.

Meanwhile, the agency teams suffer an unpleasantly hostile working relationship, the client pays for resource dedicated to skirmishing that could have been directed into servicing their needs, and everyone’s joy is sapped by the depressing experience of producing adequate but uninspiring work that could have been great.

All the agencies had to do was work together and everyone would have benefited – including the client, whose budget for both agencies may well have expanded as a result of the cooperative effort.

So why didn’t they?

Incentivising nastiness

At the heart of the problem is the simple fact that, individually, we are paid to make money for our agency, not to help our clients.

Don’t get me wrong – in the long run, helping our clients is the best way to make money for our agency, but often an individual’s performance is measured against short-term targets rather than long-term gains.

This translates into account managers being pressured from above to grow their accounts by undermining the accounts of competing suppliers. And even if there’s no pressure to go on the offence, there’s the fear of being on the defense – losing business to the aggressive tactics of the competition.

When faced with this situation, however the other agency behaves, the outcome will be better for you if you play nasty. They play nice? You screw them. They play nasty? You keep from being screwed. It’s a no-brainer.

The thing is, they’re faced with the exact same situation. And it’s a no-brainer for them too.

So if you both act rationally for short-term benefits, you’ll both play nasty. And if you both play nasty, you’ll both get a fairly undesirable outcome. But if you both just played nice, you’d both get a fairly desirable outcome.

In game theory, this scenario is called the Prisoner’s Dilemma, and its solution hinges on a simple fact: we don’t face these situations just once, but rather face them over and over again.

Finding a solution

Looking for the best strategy for repeated instances of the Prisoner’s Dilemma, a political scientist named Robert Axelrod organised a tournament in which different strategies could be competed against each other.

In a study of the other most successful strategies in the tournament, Axelrod found five recurring traits. Successful strategies…

· …are never the first to play nasty.

· …counter-attack when the competition plays nasty.

· …return to playing nice if the competition stops playing nasty.

· …often trial a return to playing nice to give the competition a chance to do the same.

· …don’t seek to reap more benefit than the competition.

So, what does that mean for you?

Benefiting in the real world

Take a little advice from mathematics in your relationships with other agencies…

1. Treat other agencies the way you’d like to be treated. Don’t look for opportunities to undermine other agencies. Hell, if you think they did a good job, tell them and the client that you think so.

2. But don’t be a doormat. If you learn that another supplier has started trying to push you out of business you already handle, you push right back.

3. Favour reconciliation. If things are hostile, be eager to end hostilities. They might not expect that, so there’s a good chance you’ll have to let them know. Have a coffee or a beer, tell them the situation’s bad for everyone and work together on ending it.

4. Let your agency’s work do the talking. Most important point of all. Another agency can only really push you out of business if you don’t deliver good work (you don’t deserve the client) or your client can’t recognise good work (the client doesn’t deserve you). Either way, a team that prioritises quality over politics will win the long game.

Remember, qualities like humility, respect, friendliness, forgiveness and integrity aren’t for suckers – they’re good for business.

You can’t argue with that: it’s maths.

Ryan Sproull is a digital strategist at Zuni. 

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Women In Print Starts New Chapter & Finds New Home
  • Media

Women In Print Starts New Chapter & Finds New Home

Women in Print has re-launched itself this week to take on the year, and future ahead. A refreshed brand, website, calendar and team are leading the way with Women in Print also announcing a new partnership with The Real Media Collective. A new look, new management and new focus – Community, Knowledge, Network and Support […]

Emotive Partners With YouTube And The United Nations
  • Media

Emotive Partners With YouTube And The United Nations

Creative agency, Emotive, and Good Oil Films, is partnering with YouTube and the United Nations to raise awareness around the importance of quality education, which forms part of the UN’s Global Goals for sustainable development.

ScoMo Rules Out TikTok Ban
  • Technology

ScoMo Rules Out TikTok Ban

ScoMo rules out TikTok ban, as Albo releases his latest unicorn, fairy dance video complete with cascading rainbows.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Outdoor Industry Unites For Global #OurSecondChance Campaign
  • Campaigns
  • Media

Outdoor Industry Unites For Global #OurSecondChance Campaign

The global Out of Home (OOH) industry has today launched a campaign #OurSecondChance. The campaign asks simple questions about how we can make the most of the positive opportunities that have arisen out of the pandemic. Broadcast on OOH signs around the globe #OurSecondChance is collaboration between World Out of Home Organisation (WOO) and the […]

batyr & UM Take ‘Run For The Herd’ Virtual
  • Campaigns

batyr & UM Take ‘Run For The Herd’ Virtual

With the COVID-19 crisis affecting all crowd-based activities, youth mental-health charity batyr has devised the first-ever Run for the Herd Virtual Festival partnering with media business UM to bring the virtual event to life.  With the City2Surf event in Sydney, normally a big fund-raising opportunity for batyr, postponed this year, batyr has created a virtual event and with the support of UM are encouraging […]

QMS Sport Rebrands As Media Tech
  • Media

QMS Sport Rebrands As Media Tech

Following QMS’ acquisition of TLA Worldwide (Aust) last year, QMS Sport has today announced it will transition to the TLA brand and formally become a business unit of TLA. ‘Media Tech’ is officially the new name for what was formally known as QMS Sport, and will operate alongside TLA’s existing business units that span the […]