Australia Vs Facebook: Regulating The Market Of Attention

Facebook has blocked the sharing of all news content in Australia, not far behind Google’s threat of exit just last month. But what’s prompting these nuclear options?
By Mariam Nadeem, Gabby Bush, Dr Dana McKay and Professor Jeannie Marie Paterson, University of Melbourne

Treasurer Josh Frydenberg says Facebook’s news ban has shown the immense power of the “digital giants”. Picture: Getty Images
On the surface, it appears to be all about news content. But make no mistake, underlying these disputes is a battle about advertising revenue, the collection and use of consumer data and more broadly the ‘attention economy’ on which these platforms’ business model is based.
Last year, a Digital Platforms Inquiry conducted by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) signalled the beginnings of a regulatory implosion on tech giants and their immense market power.
Balking at proposed legislation that would force Google and Facebook to remit part of their advertising revenue to news publishers, the companies have since scrambled to oppose the bill.
Tempers cooled as Google met with Australian officials and began to strike deals with major media players. But Facebook’s latest move is a clear shot over the bow of Australia’s news media code.
And this is only the beginning.
The Federal government has just completed a far-reaching review of privacy protection in Australia that may see new control given to consumers over the use of their personal data for purposes such as personalised advertising – which sits at the heart of the Google/Facebook income stream.
There is also the potential for substantive, fairness-based controls on how data may be handled – for example, protecting those who don’t know or can’t act to protect their own welfare when it comes to trading personal information.
And there is more.

Australians are being blocked from accessing news in their Facebook feeds. Picture: Supplied
The ACCC is following up with scrutiny over the dominance of the digital platforms in advertising – so called ‘ad-tech’ – with a new interim report on advertising technologies which effectively operate by monetising our attention.
Digital advertising platforms function much like shopping malls. Accessible for free to ordinary ‘shoppers’, they instead sell the opportunity to capture consumer attention through what is called ‘ad inventory’.
The ACCC’s chief concern is over the way in which Google and Facebook exercise virtual monopolies over the digital advertising delivered straight to our Facebook feeds and Google searches.
What underlies this monopoly is the massive data-collection infrastructure companies like Google and Facebook control.
The majority of this data is derived from the myriad free-to-consumer services provided by Facebook and Google, and the collection of trackers on third party websites. If users aren’t paying for a service, there is every likelihood that they, or rather their collected ‘data points’, are the product that’s earning revenue for the platform.
The ACCC’s report points to “a real lack of competition, choice and transparency” in the digital advertising industry.
So, what does this all actually mean for consumers?

The Federal government has just completed a far-reaching review of privacy protection in Australia. Picture: Getty Images
The ACCC argues that increased costs for advertisers are passed onto consumers. It includes in its options for reform boosting data portability and interoperability while also breaking up large data sets held by any incumbent.
Add this to the other proposed reforms and there is a real and world-leading challenge to the way in which Facebook and Google make advertising revenue.
It’s important to understand that the advertising enabled by the combined force of large volumes of consumer data, tracking technologies and machine learning based predictive analytics are changing the nature of online shopping and the ways in which advertising can be personalised to individual consumers.
And this ability to target, nudge and influence consumers is what results in Facebook and Google’s huge ad revenue, and the increasing ubiquity of surveillance ‘adtech’.
Research led by Professor Shanton Chang and Dr Suelette Dreyfus, with Dr Dana McKay, reveals how significantly this market violates user expectations, and the harms that are produced by these violations.
The research explores surveillance technologies that track consumers and how data obtained from them is used to personalise digital advertisements.
One example is the digital advertising boards seen in shopping malls, cinemas, and train stations.

The ability to target, nudge and influence consumers is what results in Facebook and Google’s huge ad revenue. Picture: Getty Images
These ‘smart kiosks’ are embedded with cameras that monitor people’s emotional response to advertisements via facial recognition technology. The information can provide detailed insight on consumer attitudes, but to what end?
Data obtained from similar IoT (Internet of Things) devices contributes to practices such as differential pricing – where users are charged different prices relating to things like their economic status, gender, or even race.
iPhone users, for example, have been charged more on travel and booking websites, as they are stereotyped as wealthier than their android-using counterparts. Similarly, certain consumers are ‘steered’ by algorithms towards specific products while online shopping.
These practices entrench inequalities when consumers are unaware of their existence, or of the criteria that underlies them. They can also function as virtual red-liners, denying equal service and opportunity.
Facebook was recently under fire for not advertising higher quality housing to people from certain income levels and ethnic backgrounds even where the advertisers specifically asked them not to discriminate.
While users no doubt understand that social media posts reflect the users experiences and bias, the influence of targeted advertising and skewed online shopping experiences are much more subtle.
When it comes to search engines, users truly (and misleadingly) believe they are encountering neutral, credible information.

Users can truly (and misleadingly) believe they are encountering neutral, credible information. Picture: Shutterstock
Regulators in Europe have called for a ban on surveillance based targeted advertising altogether. The ACCC proposes a shift towards ‘contextual advertising’, which targets ads based on the relevant context in which they are shown (keywords, dates) instead of user attributes.
Australia is also potentially on the verge of sweeping new data rights protections, on par with what is already in place in the EU through its General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
Privacy and fundamental rights can only be preserved when consumers have meaningful control over how their data is used and there are substantive limits on the kinds of uses that are acceptable.
Our policy report advocates combining approaches from privacy and consumer law, as well as a robust understanding of the technology underlying personalised advertising.
Its recommendations include:
- stronger privacy protections and data rights
- protection against predatory advertising
- greater transparency in the display and ranking of online products
- accessible data dispute resolution (including through a data ombudsman)
- innovative use of technology to better inform and protect consumers
- more research on consumers/expectations about what is fair and appropriate in online personalised advertising.

Australia is also potentially on the verge of sweeping new data rights protections similar to the EU. Picture: Getty Images
Ultimately, the bundle of proposed reforms being put forward by the ACCC means major changes to not just the ways in which news is promoted online in Australia but, importantly, the way ad revenue is earned and distributed via consumer data.
This is at the heart of the Facebook model. More disruption is likely here in Australia, and potentially worldwide, until we find a resolution.
This article was written by University of Melbourne’s Dr Dana McKay, Gabby Bush, Mariam Nadeem and Professor Jeannie Marie Paterson, and first published on Pursuit. Read the original article.
Latest News

Emotional Storytelling Is A Rarity, IAG CMO Brent Smart Tells Future Of TV Advertising
In an interview with Mindshare’s Katie Rigg-Smith, recently returned Australian CMO Brent Smart said advertising lacks enough emotional storytelling, and that marketers lack the support of their organisations to brand build in the long term. Smart is the chief marketing officer at Insurance Australia Group, a position he moved to after returning to Australia from […]

Imagining Life After Cookies With LiveRamp’s Deb O’Sullivan
We've busted out the crystal ball to take a look into the future. Apparently the Lotto numbers are 10, 4, 29, 3, 43, 26.

Making Steps Towards Transparency: AANA/MMI Reveal Ad Tech Shortfalls
Missed this report because you were up late watching MAFS last night? Relish in this special edition cheat sheet.

Vogue Australia Launches ‘Baby Steps’ Podcast, With Jesinta Franklin And Remy Rippon
Vogue ditching the Prada pumps and the Hermés Birkin bags for shitty nappies and vomit in new baby podcast.

Stan To Reveal Cast Of Ru Paul’s Drag Race Down Under At 2021 Mardi Gras
Stan to reveal local cast of Ru Paul's Drag Race. B&T can't confirm if Fatty, Blocker & The Big Man are in the running.

Research Commissioned By Pantene Finds Only Six Per Cent Of LGBTQI+ People In Australia Play Team Sports
Study finds LGBTQI+ community eschewing team sports. Apparently it has nothing to do with the half-time oranges either.

Monday TV Wrap: True Crime A Winner For Nine
True crime helped Nine to a comfortable win last night. That said, fake marriages also helped.

CHE Proximity Snares Ogilvy’s Gavin McLeod For Chief Creative Officer Role
Gavin McLeod brushing up on the collected works of Edward de Bono before joining CHEP as its new chief creative officer.

Cancer Council NSW Appoints Archibald Williams For CX Strategy
If there's one brand we'd all like to see suffer a sharp decline in customers it's definitely the Cancer Council.

Common Ventures Unveils First Work For Bank Australia
Why not take advantage of historically low interest rates and saddle yourself with enough debt for seven lifetimes.

Are They Listening? Why Targeted Ads Work So Well
Here's an expert piece on targeted ads. And though not explicitly inferred, it sounds like the end of skywriting to us.

Are Media Partners With Australian Geographic & Woolies For Retail Promotion
B&T is an avid reader of Australian Geographic. Well, if truth be told we hide our copy of New Idea in the middle.

JCDecaux Launches OPTIX To Improve The Effectiveness Of Outdoor Creative
When passed out drunk on a big night, B&T staff choose and recommend JCDecaux's assuaging array of street furniture.

Meet Charlie Blacker: Van-Based Photographer And Shutterstock Artist
B&T'd love to be a van-based photographer, sadly we're claustrophobic, suffer car sickness & are bad backseat drivers.

Jim Beam Debuts Global Marketing Campaign ‘Always Welcome’ In Australia, Via adam&eveNYC
Jim Beam debuts global marketing campaign 'always welcome'. B&T assumes that's not referring to the hangovers.

The Hallway Snares CHEP’s Iain MacMillan As Its Melbourne Creative Director
Can't keep up with all the ECD movements at the moment? Well, let B&T add to your boggled mind with this.

“Neo-Nazi Attack!” Channel Nine Security Guard Caught In Terrifying Fight With White Supremacist
Much like quinoa, Bundy & Coke and MAFs brides, where there's white supremacists you'll invariably find trouble.

Study Finds Motive Trumps Incentive Advertising In Persuading Consumers
Do you make ads? Then you need to read this. Even better it never refers to the marketing funnel or the omnichannel.

Initiative Perth Announces New Hires, Including Steve Hare And Briana Wells
Here's confirmation that B&T doesn't ignore our Perth readers. However, we'll continue to ignore our Tasmanian readers.

Is Your Customer Lost? Why Gaps In Your Customer Journey Could Be Costing You More Than You Think
This deep dive exposé asks "is your customer lost"? Or, are they merely taking the scenic route via your competitors.

Industry Vets Andy DiLallo & Steve Jackson Launch Creative Agency Milk & Honey United
Adland vets Andy DiLallo & Steve Jackson are launching their own agency B&T believes they'll rue not calling Lalloson.

ING Launches New Brand Direction, Do Your Thing, Via Ogilvy
Surely a better tagline for ING would be "we were one of the few banks not named in the Banking Royal Commission".

SMI Data: January Ad Spends Sink As COVID & The Delayed Oz Open Bites
Did the January numbers have your head of accounts slugging from a concealed silver flask? Data says you weren't alone.

Slingshot Wins Masterpet And Endeavour Consumer Health Accounts
Media strategy specialist Slingshot has won the strategy, planning and buying account for Masterpet, and Endeavour Consumer Health. Masterpet owns pet care brands Black Hawk, VitaPet and Aristopet, while Endeavour Consumer Health includes brands like Red Seal, Pharmacy Choice and Faulding. Slingshot CIO and Partner Simon Corbett (pictured) said that winning the two businesses was […]

New Campaign Highlights That 70% Of Australians Say They Want To Die At Home
Leading South Australian ageing care provider ECH (Enabling Confidence at Home) is shining a light on the need for Australians to talk openly about death with their family members and loved ones to ensure any specific wishes or choices can be fulfilled. Australia faces a significant societal challenge as death continues to be a subject […]

Introducing The Zavy Social Scoreboard
Introducing The Zavy Social Scoreboard You might have noticed a colourful scoreboard sitting on the B&T homepage this month. Well, allow us to formally introduce ourselves – and it. We’re Zavy. And we believe in the promise of social media: brand building by two-way engagement and rich communication. What does this have to do […]

Global Virtual Communications Consultancy fluid Expands Reach In Australia
Virtual consultancy fluid expands its reach into Australia with Brian Shrowder joining global collective of senior communications consultants

WE Communications Australia Announce New Leadership Roles
WE Communications announces new leadership roles & then communicate it superbly via this expertly penned press release.

Nimble Moves Away From The Bunny Suit In New Work Via Cyclone Creative Agency And Monster & Bear
Payday lenders are the modern equivalent of hocking a car stereo at Cash Converters.

Val Morgan Digital And TheFork Launch Thrillist Serves
Here's some foodie news for the gourmands out there. But that's not to suggest anyone can't sink their teeth into it.