Five seconds, is that enough for a brand to tell its story? While Todd Sampson says otherwise, Tyler Greer, head of strategy APAC, Exponential, believes it’s where the industry is heading.
I was recently watching Gruen and, like you, yelling at the TV that I know more than any of them and “where is my spot on the panel??”, when Mr. Sampson made a comment that made me pause. The discussion was around pre-rolls and whether delivering them in shorter bursts, given they often proceed short form content, might be wiser. Five seconds, for instance. Sampson suggested that five seconds was too short a format through which to deliver a brand story. This is a principle which needs exploring.
Pre-rolls are a strange beast in advertising – loathed by consumers, loved by media agencies, often misunderstood by creatives, worth a fortune to publishers, and arguably the driving financial force behind the fastest growing channel in the online world, video. Studies consistently suggest that pre-roll outperforms TV placement on a range of brand health metrics. This may or may not be true, but one thing is certain: they ain’t going anywhere. The question is whether or not the industry is using the space in the right way. It may be, in fact, that five seconds is actually the optimal way to go. The idea that TVCs can be shunted into the digital video space as a way to gain incremental reach presupposes that all screens operate the same way for consumers, and that reach trumps impact. Possibly right. But perhaps there are ways better suited to the boundaries of the medium.
Buying models often seek to address this. Cost per Completed View is a simple buying method, but it respects a format in which the user has the option of skipping, rendering the video of lesser value. User opt-in Cost per Engagement models also recognise that, the importance of charging only for those who elect to take a deeper brand journey.
Sampson’s idea that five seconds is too short a format through which to deliver a story is perplexing, particularly if this format is shown to carry less-annoyance, stronger impact, and offer a more efficient buying model for brands. Focusing on the limitations of the environment rather than the creative solution seems an unhelpful.
In fact, limitations are more often than not what fuels creativity – they foster a process that forces us to think our way through and problem solve. A canvas is static, so when the artist needs to convey movement he is forced to deploy technique and colour and brushstroke to achieve this. The limitations of the medium means he needs to find creative solutions. When it’s done well we call it genius. This applies to many of the great human achievements we admire; the ability to create something astonishing or functional with limited tools or parameters. We even have a saying for it: necessity is the mother of invention.
Outdoor advertising has known this for decades. Constricted to the short amount of time in which the freeway driver whizzes past and looks up, the medium found a way to deliver a brand message in a very short window. Boundaries are not always a barrier to creativity; rather a problem which must be solved using available techniques and tools. If five seconds is too short a format through which to tell a story, then change the story.
Edward de Bono, he of the ‘six thinking hats’ theory, speaks of being ‘blocked by openness’, a situation by which the easiest way forward robs us of experience and creative thinking. To illustrate this, he places a roadblock on the freeway you take to work every day, forcing you to take an alternative route. Along this route you see things you have never seen – houses, streets, shops – but also discover that the path is a more effective way to reach your destination. The openness of the freeway precluded this exploration in the first place.
Why does this matter? Because right now the industry is faced with an ever expanding array of formats through which to speak with audiences, and few adhere to traditional creative structures. Some are text based, some only image and some video, some aural and others interactive; in each case they differ and so too will the creative solutions brands must bring to them. The ability of a brand to connect with its audience will require each channel be taken on its merits and, if need be, the story telling method altered accordingly. This is the most critical challenge in media and advertising today.
This is no doubt a challenge, and if you’re reading on for an answer as to the best way forward here’s a spoiler alert: I don’t have one. Traditional advertising has sculpted our thinking around story-telling of 30 second TVCs supported by outdoor, magazine and radio. And it has also defined how we measure success and the attribution models we bring to these – reach, awareness, brand health, etc. All are up for re-evaluation because consumer touchpoints are so varied. It is the most interesting and exciting time in history to be working in media. So many channels, so many ways to tell brand stories, and so many ways for creative exploration.
Before the various comments question my right to discuss creative matters, consider that this comes first and foremost from a media consumer who is, like everyone else, inundated daily with a multitude of messages. Some work, most don’t, but the ones that have the best chance of achieving their goals are the ones whose creative approach is in harmony with the channel and format into which it is placed. It’s a rule that will never change but one to which we must all constantly adapt.
On the back of 12 months of sustained growth from a string of agency acquisitions and new business wins including Toyota, Maybelline New York and eBay, HERO has appointed industry luminary James Greet to the newly created role of Chief Operating Officer. HERO was launched by Ben Lilley in 2020 after a rapid succession of […]
Liz Cambage, Australian basketball star, has taken to social media to criticise a lack of racial diversity in recent Australian Olympic Committee photoshoots, indicating she may boycott the Tokyo games. Cambage is a member of the Australian Opals basketball team, and has played in a number of elite leagues including the WNBL, where she played […]
Massachusetts state attorney Maura Healey has sued Publicis Health, a subsidiary of Publicis Groupe SA, over allegations of deceptive marketing. Healey argued that Publicis Health used unfair, deceptive marketing tactics to sell a powerful, addictive prescription painkiller called OxyContin on behalf of Purdue Pharma. According to the suit, “dangerous opioid drugs continue to kill hundreds […]
B&T’s Research Agency Of The Year, strategic insights consultancy Nature, was a big winner at the Research Society Awards last night, taking home four prestigious honours. Nature won the Research Effectiveness Award for Technology and Innovation for its work for Don KRC; Managing Partner Chris Crook (main photo) was accepted into the Research Society’s Fellowship; […]
Australasia’s leading independent creative company, Special Group, has been named the world’s best Creative and Independent Agency of the Year by one of the world’s most prestigious advertising titles – the United Kingdom’s Campaign. Special Group – which has offices in Sydney, Melbourne, Auckland and Los Angeles – was named Global Agency of the Year […]
The winners of Fast Company’s 2021 World Changing Ideas Awards have just been announced, honoring the businesses, policies, projects, and concepts that are actively engaged and deeply committed to pursuing innovation when it comes to solving health and climate crises, social injustice, or economic inequality. Losing Lena by Clemenger BBDO Sydney was a finalist in […]
Adland's future was on display at yesterday's Young Lions. Sadly, the B&T's editor's plumbers crack was also on display.
A highlight of Australia’s creative calendar, The Design Conference celebrates its 10th conference with a cracking line-up of 20+ speakers when it returns to Brisbane Powerhouse from Wednesday 16 – Friday 18 June 2021. Over the last ten years, The Design Conference has evolved into one of the world’s premier professional development opportunities at the […]
Sydney-based design studio Universal Favourite launched a new branding for US beauty brand Youthforia, whose mission is to make makeup more playful. To appeal to a Gen Z market bored by the minimal aesthetic approach adopted by most beauty brands, Universal Favourite created a maximalist identity. The result is purposefully messy, uncurated, raw.
APRA AMCOS, a music rights management organisation for Australian and New Zealand songwriters and music publishers, has engaged Klarrio to help modernise its IT architecture and accelerate its digital transformation journey. Klarrio, a systems integrator specialising in real-time data streaming and customised IT architecture modernisation, is helping APRA AMCOS migrate from an on-premise, single-threaded processing […]