Blood money or right move? PR experts debate 2Day FM's donation pledge

Blood money or right move? PR experts debate 2Day FM's donation pledge
SHARE
THIS



Public relations experts have cautiously commended Southern Cross Austereo’s decision to indirectly donate funds to the family of Jacintha Saldanha, but believe the move is too little too late.

The radio network at the centre of the royal prank call scandal today announced it would return all advertising to embattled station, 2Day FM, tomorrow after a five day self-imposed suspension.

It also pledged to donate all of 2Day FM’s advertising profits from Thursday until the end of the year to a charity which will help the family of nurse Saldanha (pictured) – a guaranteed minimum of $500,000.

Simon Lloyd, head of consulting at AccessPR,  told B&T while payment would not bring absolution, it was a step in the right direction.

“Saying you’re going to donate money should never be regarded as an easy way to fix a crisis like this. Nevertheless I think it is a very good move by Austereo.

“From a PR standpoint I don’t have any issue with them resuming advertising. It would have been smarter if they’d decided to donate a bit faster but it’s always easy to be wise after the event.”

“Because this is so unprecedented it’s impossible for anybody to say what is absolutely right or absolutely not right from a crisis management point of view. If I was to give them a score of how they were managing it so far it would be a B+.”

But Kat Thomas, MD of PR agency One Green Bean was more skeptical about the network’s cash promise, suggesting the move may be interpreted by the public as ‘blood money’ – unofficial compensation for loss of life.

“It’s a very tricky to decide whether this is right or wrong because in one regard it’s an acknowledgement and a willingness to put things right, but in another regard it’s could be seen as putting a dollar amount on someone’s life.

“There will be a bit of speculation around whether that was the right move and what the motivation is behind it,” she told B&T.

Putting aside ethical debates about the concept of monetary donation, both practitioners see flaws in the particulars of SCA’s offering.

Instead of pledging to donate advertisers’ dollars, Thomas believes the station should have committed its own, existing cash.

“They were very transparent about the fact that the money they will be using is advertiser dollars. There could be some speculation around whether that is the right move – whether they should be using advertiser dollars vs their own dollars to make good for the situation that their organisation has caused,” she said.

And what of SCA’s proposed timeline? The network has pledged it will donate advertising profits from tomorrow until the end of the year, which, in reality, is only 18 days away.

“To say until the end of the year when it’s so close to the end of the year is questionable. I would have thought it would be smart to put a longer time line on it because it’s not very long, even though they say they are going to guarantee $500,000.”

So what else needs to be done to save the station’s reputation?

Lloyd believes the network still needs to come clean about the processes which led to the phone call being broadcast.

While Southern Cross Austereo claims to have unsuccessfully called the King Edward Hospital VII five times for permission to play the call on-air , the hospital claims it has no record of any attempted calls.

“Honesty and transparency are really the critical elements in any corporate crisis and the biggest mistake they’ve made is failing to be completely honest, or apparently honest about the process involved.

“The fact that they have been less than forthcoming about the actual process of approval begs the question ‘what is going to happen if and when ACMA steps in?’ because that will reveal the truth.

“They have not yet admitted that the process was completely flawed and I think that is their most serious mistake,” he said.

Ultimately the station needs to be clear and proactive about formalising safeguards and initiatives which prevent such a debacle from taking place in the future, says Thomas.

“They’ve tackled it a little bit late and a little bit clumsily but they are handling it now,” she said.

“The key thing is that they need to flag what they’ve learnt out of this and what procedures and protocols they’ve put in place to make sure that they never land in a situation like this again.”

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

First Lady Michelle Obama and President Barack Obama Dance Together at the Presidents Ball
  • Media

Netflix Secures Producer Deal With The Obamas

It seems former US president Barack Obama and former First Lady Michelle Obama aren’t quite done with the international spotlight just yet. The Obamas have officially signed a multiyear deal with Netflix, which will see the power couple producing films and series with the streaming giant. According to Netflix, “The Obamas will produce a diverse […]

How To Spot A Trend Versus A Fad
  • Opinion

How To Spot A Trend Versus A Fad

Nils Vesk (pictured below) is an innovation architect who’s delivered programs for some of the most prestigious organisations in the world, including Microsoft, IBM, Commonwealth Bank and Nestle. In this guest post for B&T, he shows you how to spot a lasting trend that’s not merely just another passing fad…   The importance behind learning […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Study: Almost Half Of Aussies Browse Mobile Retail Sites For “Retailtainment”
  • Marketing
  • Technology

Study: Almost Half Of Aussies Browse Mobile Retail Sites For “Retailtainment”

A new study today has revealed that although mobile commerce may have begun as a convenient way to shop on-the-go, it has quickly developed into an entertainment experience for many Aussies. The PayPal mCommerce Index Trends Report 2018 (which you can read in full here) found that two thirds (67 per cent) of Aussie smartphone owners browse shopping sites just […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Why Engagement Is The New Rule Of Content
  • Opinion

Why Engagement Is The New Rule Of Content

In this guest post, King Kong’s head of growth, Sabri Suby (pictured below), takes a look at recent changes to Google’s rankings and how it will affect content makers and the measure of any content’s success… Changes to Google’s ranking algorithm mean that time on a page is valued higher than the number of clicks. With these new rules […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Fairfax Media Recruits 20 Trainee Journalists Across All Its Titles
  • Media

Fairfax Media Recruits 20 Trainee Journalists Across All Its Titles

Fairfax Media has today announced the recruitment of 20 trainee journalists to join the newsrooms of The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age, The Canberra Times, The Australian Financial Review, Brisbane Times and WAtoday. This represents one of Metro’s largest trainee intakes in years and underlines the commitment of the mastheads to fostering a new generation […]

Sydney Australia - November 7, 2011. An extreme close up of an American express card issued by the Australian bank Westpac.
  • Media

AMEX Launches Global Media Review

Are there not enough hours in the day? Are you cheek-by-jowl with your co-workers? Well, hopefully you won't win this.

Sydney Water & Republic of Everyone Create Vinyl Records Made Of Recycled Marine Plastic
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing

Sydney Water & Republic of Everyone Create Vinyl Records Made Of Recycled Marine Plastic

Sydney Water has pioneered a way to create records from marine plastics and, in doing so, encourage more people to join the movement of local clean-up groups rolling up their sleeves every weekend to clean plastics, litter and other pollutants from the city’s beaches and waterways. Plastics are collected by volunteers, then cut in pieces […]

Credit Card Compare Names Its First Head Of Marketing
  • Marketing

Credit Card Compare Names Its First Head Of Marketing

Aussie credit card comparison site Credit Card Compare has announced the appointment of Caroline Raffan as its inaugural head of marketing. Raffan (pictured above) has over 10 years’ experience in brand strategy, campaign development, digital marketing, events, public relations, content creation, market research, advertising, stakeholder management, social media marketing, and project management. She joins Credit […]

Why Programmatic Needs To Become A Branding Machine
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Opinion
  • Technology

Why Programmatic Needs To Become A Branding Machine

In this opinion piece, Phil Murrell (pictured below), country manager for Australia and New Zealand at Sizmek, argues that programmatic ad spend needs to move up the branding funnel. When I started in digital advertising way back in 2004, we got our media insertion orders via the fax machine. We relied on that machine to […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
An Apology To Salmat’s Karen Lewis
  • Media

An Apology To Salmat’s Karen Lewis

Whoops! B&T's stuffed up and this certainly comes with our sincerest apologies for any offence caused.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Adland Execs To Be Locked Up
  • Media

Adland Execs To Be Locked Up

Continuing adland's fascination with prison when it comes to charitable causes comes this latest trip to the slammer.

Australian Directors’ Guild Announces Mentorship Winners
  • Campaigns
  • Media

Australian Directors’ Guild Announces Mentorship Winners

Now in its second year, the Australian Directors’ Guild’s (ADG) Commercial & Content Directing Mentorship program announced its next round of eight mentoree recipients. The winners were announced at a special event held last night at FINCH, Sydney and attended by members of the screen and advertising industries. Acclaimed director, and ADG President, Samantha Lang, […]

Diversity Case Study Series: OMD
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Diversity Case Study Series: OMD

One need only look at the Cadbury Favourites chocolate selection to know it has nought to do with industry diversity.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Eyeota Deep Dives Into Australian Automotive Purchase Behaviour
  • Media

Eyeota Deep Dives Into Australian Automotive Purchase Behaviour

Eyeota, the global leader in audience data, has today released its latest results on automotive purchase intentions in Australia. The results provide a deep dive into what motivates the buyer and segments those into six different personas.

APN Outdoor Joins The AANA
  • Marketing
  • Media

APN Outdoor Joins The AANA

AANA's annual Christmas dinner and dance got a teensy bit more crowded following this announcement this morning.

QMS Introduces ‘The Lonsdale’ To Melbourne
  • Advertising
  • Media

QMS Introduces ‘The Lonsdale’ To Melbourne

Digital outdoor media company QMS Media has turned on a new premium landmark digital billboard situated in the heart of Melbourne’s CBD. Delivering a commanding presence at the major intersection of Lonsdale and Russell Streets, ‘The Lonsdale’ offers extended dwell times to both vehicle and pedestrian traffic, impacting more than 2.2 million contacts per month. […]

Portrait of a woman looking through out the blinds. Office worker looking through window blinds
  • Opinion

The Lurking Brand Threats Facing CMOs

Treading on gardening rakes and possible alien abduction notable omissions from this CMO threats piece.

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Women In Media Profile: Susannah George
  • Media

Women In Media Profile: Susannah George

B&T is delighted to profile Urbanlist supremo Susannah George who, we understand, is not related to George Brandis.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Ikon Lands Avis Budget Group Account
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

Ikon Lands Avis Budget Group Account

B&T chooses and recommends Avis and John Karandonis shoes. Hang on, that was the end of Sale Of The Century.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine