Blood money or right move? PR experts debate 2Day FM's donation pledge

Blood money or right move? PR experts debate 2Day FM's donation pledge
SHARE
THIS



Public relations experts have cautiously commended Southern Cross Austereo’s decision to indirectly donate funds to the family of Jacintha Saldanha, but believe the move is too little too late.

The radio network at the centre of the royal prank call scandal today announced it would return all advertising to embattled station, 2Day FM, tomorrow after a five day self-imposed suspension.

It also pledged to donate all of 2Day FM’s advertising profits from Thursday until the end of the year to a charity which will help the family of nurse Saldanha (pictured) – a guaranteed minimum of $500,000.

Simon Lloyd, head of consulting at AccessPR,  told B&T while payment would not bring absolution, it was a step in the right direction.

“Saying you’re going to donate money should never be regarded as an easy way to fix a crisis like this. Nevertheless I think it is a very good move by Austereo.

“From a PR standpoint I don’t have any issue with them resuming advertising. It would have been smarter if they’d decided to donate a bit faster but it’s always easy to be wise after the event.”

“Because this is so unprecedented it’s impossible for anybody to say what is absolutely right or absolutely not right from a crisis management point of view. If I was to give them a score of how they were managing it so far it would be a B+.”

But Kat Thomas, MD of PR agency One Green Bean was more skeptical about the network’s cash promise, suggesting the move may be interpreted by the public as ‘blood money’ – unofficial compensation for loss of life.

“It’s a very tricky to decide whether this is right or wrong because in one regard it’s an acknowledgement and a willingness to put things right, but in another regard it’s could be seen as putting a dollar amount on someone’s life.

“There will be a bit of speculation around whether that was the right move and what the motivation is behind it,” she told B&T.

Putting aside ethical debates about the concept of monetary donation, both practitioners see flaws in the particulars of SCA’s offering.

Instead of pledging to donate advertisers’ dollars, Thomas believes the station should have committed its own, existing cash.

“They were very transparent about the fact that the money they will be using is advertiser dollars. There could be some speculation around whether that is the right move – whether they should be using advertiser dollars vs their own dollars to make good for the situation that their organisation has caused,” she said.

And what of SCA’s proposed timeline? The network has pledged it will donate advertising profits from tomorrow until the end of the year, which, in reality, is only 18 days away.

“To say until the end of the year when it’s so close to the end of the year is questionable. I would have thought it would be smart to put a longer time line on it because it’s not very long, even though they say they are going to guarantee $500,000.”

So what else needs to be done to save the station’s reputation?

Lloyd believes the network still needs to come clean about the processes which led to the phone call being broadcast.

While Southern Cross Austereo claims to have unsuccessfully called the King Edward Hospital VII five times for permission to play the call on-air , the hospital claims it has no record of any attempted calls.

“Honesty and transparency are really the critical elements in any corporate crisis and the biggest mistake they’ve made is failing to be completely honest, or apparently honest about the process involved.

“The fact that they have been less than forthcoming about the actual process of approval begs the question ‘what is going to happen if and when ACMA steps in?’ because that will reveal the truth.

“They have not yet admitted that the process was completely flawed and I think that is their most serious mistake,” he said.

Ultimately the station needs to be clear and proactive about formalising safeguards and initiatives which prevent such a debacle from taking place in the future, says Thomas.

“They’ve tackled it a little bit late and a little bit clumsily but they are handling it now,” she said.

“The key thing is that they need to flag what they’ve learnt out of this and what procedures and protocols they’ve put in place to make sure that they never land in a situation like this again.”

Please login with linkedin to comment

Latest News

Myer Goes “Naughty Or Nice” In Christmas Spot Via Clems Melbourne
  • Campaigns

Myer Goes “Naughty Or Nice” In Christmas Spot Via Clems Melbourne

Myer has announced the arrival of Naughty or Nice Baubles for sale at Myer stores around Australia. The baubles, developed by Clemenger BBDO Melbourne, are the centerpiece of this year’s Myer Christmas campaign. A Naughty or Nice bauble apparently lets you and your family know whether you’re on Santa’s naughty or nice list. Using a little […]

Columbus Appoints Reprise Digital’s Rich Conway As Group Client Partner
  • Technology

Columbus Appoints Reprise Digital’s Rich Conway As Group Client Partner

Data-driven marketing agency, Columbus, A Merkle Company has appointed Rich Conway as Group Client Partner in NSW. Conway will lead a large-scale team and head up Columbus’ integrated solutions across Virgin Australia and a number of key Australian brands. With more than seven years of industry experience, Conway joins Columbus from Reprise Digital where he […]

The Brand Agency Brings Science To Behaviour Change
  • Media

The Brand Agency Brings Science To Behaviour Change

The Brand Agency has welcomed behavioural psychologist Dr Mark Hurlstone to its strategy and behaviour change team. Dr Hurlstone is head of The University of Western Australia’s Behavioural Economics Laboratory in the School of Psychological Science. Dr Hurlstone’s appointment is in direct response to the lack of true behavioural psychologists in the communications industry. His expertise will […]

Buyer journey flat isometric vector. A man to make a purchase is moving by the specified route with following steps - awareness, consideration, reviews, choice, purchase.
  • Advertising

Study: Australian Consumers Say Marketers Are Doing Customer Experience Wrong

Despite increasing investment from brands in marketing technology, nearly half of Australian consumers say brands aren’t meeting their expectations when it comes to the customer experience (CX). On top of this, even fewer remember the last time a brand exceeded expectations, according to results of a global survey commissioned by Acquia. Today’s consumers have more […]

Busiest robot in the office with a heavy workload on all of his six hands.
  • Partner Content
  • Technology

Seven Tips To Stop Robots From Taking Your Job

The Fourth Industrial Revolution is upon us, and it has many people freaking out about their career future. Jobs are increasingly being automated via technology such as artificial intelligence (AI), the Internet of Things and cloud computing. In fact, recent research by McKinsey suggests about 60 per cent of occupations could see at least a […]

Partner Content

by Hays

Comms Council & Pluto Media Form AWARD School Indigenous Scholarships Program
  • Advertising

Comms Council & Pluto Media Form AWARD School Indigenous Scholarships Program

In a bid to encourage more indigenous people into the advertising and media industries, Pluto Media has teamed up with The Communications Council of Australia to form a brand new AWARD School Indigenous Scholarships program. This includes acceptance into the AWARD School Application workshop and then, if selected, entry into the AWARD School course itself. Pluto Media’s […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
News Unveils Delicious.Com.Au Refresh, Plus The Launch Of Delicious.Travel
  • Media

News Unveils Delicious.Com.Au Refresh, Plus The Launch Of Delicious.Travel

News Corp Australia’s premium food and lifestyle media brand delicious. has unveiled its new website delicious.com.au and launched the brand’s travel content destination delicious. Travel at an event at Icebergs Dining Room and Bar in Sydney. News Corp Australia’s director of lifestyle Fiona Nilsson and delicious. editor-in-chief Kerrie McCallum were joined by newly appointed delicious.Travel editor-at-large George Calombaris and […]

Taylors Wines Urges Vino Drinkers To Chill Their Reds Again This Summer
  • Campaigns

Taylors Wines Urges Vino Drinkers To Chill Their Reds Again This Summer

Taylors Wines is again challenging wine conventions in a new campaign that inspires wine drinkers to chill their red wines this summer. It’s widely believed that red wine should be served at room temperature. But among those in the know, popping a red in the fridge for 30 minutes before serving can make all the […]

How To Be An Introvert AND Run A Successful Client-Facing Agency
  • Opinion

How To Be An Introvert AND Run A Successful Client-Facing Agency

Emma Bannister (pictured below) is the CEO of Presentation Studio and author of the book Visual Thinking: How to transform the way you think, communicate and influence with presentations. In this guest post, Bannister – a self-confessed introvert – reveals her tips on overcoming her people fear and becoming a success… I have a classic kitchen bench, start-up […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Holden Unveils Latest Acadia 4WD In New Campaign Via AJF Partnership
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

Holden Unveils Latest Acadia 4WD In New Campaign Via AJF Partnership

Holden’s brand rejuvenation from Aussie local to full-import takes another step with the launch of the Holden Acadia advertising campaign: Holden Acadia. Arrive.  The campaign, developed by AJF Partnership, suggests Acadia drivers that they “Don’t just turn up. Arrive.” Holden marketing director Kristian Aquilina said the Holden Acadia – as well as the Equinox also launched this year – […]