The Unconscious Bias In Facebook’s Moderation Problem
Following the recent leak of Facebook’s moderation practices, online community expert, Venessa Paech (pictured below), covers the myriad challenges for the platform, and where to next for Facebook and its users in this guest post for B&T…
Facebook’s moderation practices are in the news yet again, as more detail of their playbook was leaked to the public (aka, their users) recently. They highlight alarming inconsistencies and a disdain for duty of care. But they also illuminate the bias at the heart of the problem.
Technology isn’t neutral. Like any other tool, it’s imbued with the assumptions, expectations, politics and predilections of those who create it. It’s shaped by the experience and perspectives those doing the tooling have lived up to that moment. We’re getting better at recognising and responsibly managing unconscious bias in our businesses and organisations. But we’re pretty ordinary at calling it out when it comes to social networks that feature prominently in our daily lives.
The standard push-back to more responsible content and user regulation on Facebook is concern over censorship (driven primarily by a nativist US perspective). This is, of course, a straw man argument. Facebook policies and positions already ‘censor’. Terms of service prohibit certain behaviours and activities. This is the beginning of curating a culture – at the margins.
When Facebook moderators remove a personal picture of a mother breastfeeding, but not a graphic rape or death threat, they’re making choices and creating cultural norms. These interventions are based on an explicit world view and legal lens particular to a small portion of actual users. They don’t consider community context and they ignore the fact they’re already a form of ‘censorship’.
When someone is intimidated or threatened out of participation, censorship is in effect. Women and other institutionalised marginalised groups are routinely drummed out of the virtual room by armies of trolls, men’s rights activists or the loudest hater in the room at any given moment. For some it’s a matter of life and death, where speaking up or speaking out provokes the ultimate attempt to silence – doxing (posting personally identifiable details like address or phone number, with the invitation to harass or stalk that person).
Facebook reporting tools, though better than they once were, still suffer from an either/or, square peg/round-hole problem, with inadequate categories to accommodate the thrilling range of abuse directed at women on the platform. And of course there are the all-too-common cases of people in crisis, (again, usually women), seeking the connectivity and support of their personal social network, but needing to cloak their identity and online activity from abusive parties.
Facebook will tell you repeatedly that they are committed to improving their content reporting capabilities, making it ‘easier’ and ‘faster’ to raise alarm. But reports are still in relation to Facebook’s ‘standards’, and it’s there that unconscious bias needs tackling first. By prioritising profit over harm minimisation, by intentionally refusing to use available technology to quarantine graphic content, and by ignoring their wider unconscious bias, Facebook is complicit.
Twitter founder Evan Williams recently issued a sincere mea culpa for what he now understands as Twitter’s role in mobilising toxic behaviour. I like and admire Evan, but was surprised at the naiveté of his comment: “I thought once everyone could speak freely and exchange information and ideas, the world was automatically going to be a better place. I was wrong about that.” I’m pretty sure most women (and other institutionally marginalised voices) would have had a safe bet what was in store; and some suggestions about better tools to help manage it.
Facebook has taken positive steps to scrutinise and address employer-side unconscious bias. But this doesn’t yet filter through to the platform itself. A diversity of perspectives in the room allows Facebook to more accurately map risk scenarios and desired user journeys. How many women or people of colour were involved when their now infamous moderation playbook was created? How many did they run it by to see if it tracked with lived experience? Were there anthropologists and ethnographers working alongside the lawyers? Diversity makes better products. It also makes safer, more equitable ones. Lessons from community management and the world of social science teach us that when people feel they can disclose without threat, they’re more likely to (ironically, revealing the kind of intimate data Facebook transforms into product, currency and share price).
Social and community professionals manage millions of groups across their platform, not to mention the ‘accidental’ community managers who voluntarily administrate local groups and communities of interest. One way to help scale the mountain of moderation is to engage these people in the creation of tools to manage and create a group culture that reflects their values and their needs. There are signs Facebook is starting to address this, with a ‘Communities Summit’ in Chicago connecting group admins with Facebook staff (including Zuckerberg himself). However, there is a rigorous application process and, for now at least, it’s only open to U.S admins. We watch with interest to see if the conversation is about ‘getting more out of Facebook’, or listening to community management needs with an intent to act.
Imagine where we might be if this decade-old business had engaged community experts and others outside its filter bubble to begin with? Imagine what a commitment to transparency could accomplish on all sides?
Venessa Paech is the Co-Founder of Swarm, Australia’s premier community management conference. Tickets now on sale at www.swarmconference.com.au
Latest News
TV Ratings 29/4/24: Farmer Wants A Wife And Lego Masters Lock Horns In Overnight’s Battle
Who won the battle of the big guns - Lego or Farmer Wants A Wife? One thing's for sure, it wasn't Great Train Journeys.
Nielsen Data Reveals Brands Spending Big To Attract Aussie Tourists
Nielsen Ad Intel data has revealed that the travel and tourism industry spent more than $153 million on advertising in Australia in Q1, 2024 – an increase of 8 per cent from the previous quarter, with TripADeal the biggest spender, followed by Virgin Australia, then the Flight Centre-owned Ignite Travel. As many Australians return from […]
IAS Awarded New Responsible AI Certification From Trustarc
Integral Ad Science tossing up over the mahogany or teak frame after being awarded TRUSTe Responsible AI Certification.
AWARD Calls For Hall Of Fame Nominations
B&T's noms for AWARD Hall of Famer includes Louis The Fly, Chums' talking Scottie dog & Mumbrella's coke dealer.
Havas Red Wins PagerDuty PR Account
Havas Red wins PagerDuty's PR. And judging by B&T having to Google PagerDuty, it could probably do with some help.
ACA Poised To Release Results Of 2023 Create Space Census
The Advertising Council unveils date for its census results. Hey, why not coincide it with an office lamington drive?
Why Fear Is Essential To Fernando Machado’s Creativity
If there's anyone B&T loves to chat to, it's fabled marketer Fernando Machado. Although the 5am time difference sucks.
Superdry Drafts AFL’s Patrick Lipinski For New Campaign
B&T fast regretting that poncho we just bought, as it appears the puffer jacket returns as winter's hottest trend.
Elon Musk vs eSafety: Legal Experts Warn That ‘Rogue Operators’ Like X Are Unlikely To Win Federal Court Battle
If this legal stoush boils down to who can afford the better lawyers, B&T's backing Mr Musk every single time.
Amy Poehler Presents First Look At Inside Out 2 At Vivid Sydney 2024
Vivid isn't about freezing your arse off while looking at lights on a wall, as you'll learn with this Amy Poehler news.
Mutinex Launches DataOS Improving Data Warehousing & Quality For MMM Marketers
Work in marketing? Does your data warehousing resemble a teenager's bedroom? Here's a Marie Kondo-approved read.
IMAA Celebrates Three Years Of Group Trade Credit Insurance Deal
Are you a struggling indie? Thinking of firebombing the building for the insurance money? IMAA has you covered here.
Adam Sandler Seemingly ‘Slams’ Ukraine In Pro-Kremlin Campaign
Host of A-list celebs caught slamming Ukraine's president. Thankfully it does have the Milli Vanillis about it.
New Marketing & Comms Agency For Defence & Aerospace Industry Takes Flight
As painful as this is to say, judging by current world events, the bomb & tank industries must be in rude health.
Opinion: Do Punters Want To Wear Your Brand?
This columnist asks do punters want to wear your brand? B&T'd say yes if you were Nike, no if you were Anusol.
WiredCo Builds Portfolio With Appointment To G.J. Gardner Creative Account
WiredCo 'cements' its relationship with home builder G.J. Gardner. Did you see what B&T cheekily did there?
Keep Left Reveals ‘Strategically Assembled’ Strategy Team
PR agency announces serious upgrade to its strategy offerings. Thankfully stops short of calling them Delta Force.
Initiative’s Michael Chong: What Do Mountaineering, Media & Marketing Have In Common?
Yes, B&T's running an inspiring mountaineering story. And this from people who won't come to work if the lift's broken.
CMOs To Watch: DrinkWise’s Part Time Builder, Part Time Marketer, Nathan Kent
Despite his love of DIY, B&T can't see Drinkwise's Nathan Kent in any "you can get it" VB ads anytime soon.
Mari Kauppinen Pops Up As MD Of ITA Group ANZ
Mari Kauppinen set to bring some zing, some song and some va-va-voom to her new role at ITA Group.
“It Is Getting Better But At A Glacial Speed”: PR Guns On Shaping A More Diverse Media Industry
B&T has a love-hate relationship with PRs. Love if they take us for a boozy lunch. Hate when you send releases as PDFs.
GoTransit Media Group Unveils The Power Of Regional Transit Advertising
Need reminding lots of people live outside the Surry Hills enclave? It's the regionals &, yes, they have almond milk.
Slew Of Promotions For Special Senior Creative Leadership Team
Special announces a slew of promotions in its creative team. And, no, they didn't order Uber Eats to celebrate.
Kantar: AVOD Subscribers Double In 12 Months
Study finds Aussies happy to watch ads on their streaming services. Or, are they just putting the kettle on more often?
Val Morgan Digital Exceeds All Campaign Uplift Benchmarks Via A 12-Month Brand Metrics Study
Val Morgan announces it has exceeded all its campaign benchmarks. Still can't get under an hour for the City To Surf.
Australian Retirement Trust launches monster of a campaign, by M&C Saatchi and Bohemia
Get offered a seat on the bus today? Knees creak like an old pirate's galleon? This retirement ad may be of interest.
Print Audits To Discontinue As Audited Media Association Of Australia Pivots To Support Influencer Marketing
Is it just B&T or are audits in the media industry suddenly becoming murkier than Roxy's husband's tax returns?
News Corp Australia Launches 2024 National Education Advocacy Initiative With Expanded Program
News Corp set to shine a light on the nation's schools in new series, giving illegal bikie gangs a well-earned rest.
Decoding The Consumer Maze: Urban List Report Reveals How Modern Shoppers Spiral From Discovery To Purchase
Latest report unravels a shopper's journey from the joy of discovery through to a nasty letter from a debt collector.
Cosmo Returns To Australia!
Ever get the feeling we've weirdly warped back to 1988 at the moment? Confirm it with the relaunch of Cosmo in print.
People & Culture Consultancy Human Kind Collective Launches To Plug HR Gap For Media Agencies
Does the very mention of HR have you struggling to remember last year's Christmas party? Get the sweats with this news.
‘We Want To Be A Growth Partner, Not Just A Media Buyer Or Someone That Makes Ads’ – Bohemia Boss On Agency’s Ambition
B&T's chatting with Bohemia boss Paul ‘Hutch’ Hutchison. Although we do think 'the dagger' a far superior nickname.
Initiative’s Geoff Clarke: ‘Youth Hits Targets With Enthusiasm, Experience Hits The Targets You Can’t See’
Initiative’s CCO Geoff Clarke on the value of experience in agencies. Not to mention quoting lines from Pulp Fiction.
The Iconic Teams Up With 5 Aussie Athletes For Latest Campaign
Fashion label brings in the athletes for new campaign, many of whom appear to have prepped with re-runs of Zoolander.
Seven West Media Secures New Director Of News & Current Affairs
After a tumultuous few weeks, Seven unveils director of news & current affairs. And B&T never uses tumultuous lightly.
Seven Network Expands NSW Sales Team With Two New Group Business Directors
Seven ramps up its NSW sales team. Both of whom are well versed in pronouncing Manu Feildel's croque-monsieur.