Quotas Should Be Used On The Hiring Panel, Not In The Agency

Quotas Should Be Used On The Hiring Panel, Not In The Agency
SHARE
THIS



It’s a debate rolling around the industry as to whether agencies should have quotas to fill to ensure diversity.

While some argue the concept of setting quotas shows measurability and is more likely to be accomplished, there’s the argument companies could start hiring to fill a quota, rather than who is best for the job.

“It can incent the wrong behaviours and choices,” Caroline Turner wrote for The Huffington Post. “It enables men to charge reverse discrimination. It can invite cynicism and backlash.”

When asking a table full of senior women at ad retargeting company AdRoll a yay or nay on quotas, Stacey Manes, vice president of human resources and recruiting, said it’s about having diversity on the hiring panel itself.

“A certain amount of a panel had to be a female. At the end of the day you pick the best candidate, but it ensured you had a more diverse panel of candidates.”

The move for AdRoll’s diverse recruitment panels was spearheaded by Michelle Filo, human resources director.

“In the Sydney office we’re very much looking at that diverse mix of recruitment interviewers,” she explained. “We have a large range of people from different disciplines that sit on the panel.

“It’s to ensure that whilst you can’t dictate how someone may operate, it’s about building an awareness around our bias. Once we’re aware of it we can make a more educated decision

“When we do interview, we ensure we have a variety of demographics that includes gender.”

In early 2015, creative Vicki Maguire at Grey Group in London, said she doesn’t mind quotas – but hates the thought agencies put in “orders” for people.

“‘Can we have two birds, a couple of ethnics; not Swedes, we’ve got them… Have you got any disabled?’” she quipped for British trade magazine Campaign Live.

Still, agencies should be looking at the remit and questioning their own diversity management.

“All clients should be asking questions when the same white besuited posh boys and professional northerners rock up to meeting after meeting talking about changing the cultural landscape,” added Maguire. “Come on. Anyone can see your agency is dying on its arse.

“If you can’t see that coming, you’re fucked.”

Latest News

A young boy nerd shouts at the top of his voice to his co-worker through a megaphone trying to talk some sense into him. The young nerds are dressed in bowties and glasses. Retro styling.
  • Opinion

Smart Speakers: The Voice Of A Generation

In this opinion piece, Growth Tank management consultant David Willey looks into research on the usage of voice assistants and access to smart speakers for Generation Z, Millennials and Generation X in Australia. We hear a lot about how Millennials, and now Generation Z, are changing the game on marketing by adopting the latest technology, including digital voice […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Host/Havas Bags Work For Oroton
  • Advertising

Host/Havas Bags Work For Oroton

Host/Havas staff forced to takes lessons on accessorising after snaring Oroton's creative account.

Glenn McGrath & Mike Hussey Join Macquarie Media’s Cricket Commentary Team
  • Media

Glenn McGrath & Mike Hussey Join Macquarie Media’s Cricket Commentary Team

Macquarie Media has announced that two of Australia’s cricketing greats, Glenn McGrath and Mike Hussey, are the latest additions to its cricket commentary line-up. McGrath (pictured above, right) and Hussey (pictured above, left) will join Darren Lehmann and Ian Chappell in the Macquarie Macquarie Sports Radio commentary box this summer, as part of the company’s new six-year […]

SBS Chooses Fairfax’s Andrew Mudgway To Lead Its Commercial Strategy
  • Advertising
  • Media

SBS Chooses Fairfax’s Andrew Mudgway To Lead Its Commercial Strategy

Special Broadcasting Service (SBS) has announced the appointment of Andrew Mudgway as its national sales manager for TV and digital. Mudgway joins SBS from Fairfax Media, where he was responsible for the publisher’s national digital and print sales team. He brings more than 25 years’ experience to SBS, having also held positions at IPG Mediabrands, […]