The Majority Of Claims On Cosmetic Ads Are Crap, Says New Research

Set of various cosmetics isolated on white background
SHARE
THIS



Many ads for cosmetic brands contain some form of statement on the ad, such as ‘scientifically proven’, ‘award-winning’ and ‘miracle’, however new research suggests 82 per cent of these claims are pure rubbish.

The study comes from the Journal of Global Fashion Marketing: Bridging Fashion and Marketing, entitled Deception in cosmetics advertising: Examining cosmetics advertising claims in fashion magazine ads. It was authored by Jie G. Fowler, Timothy H. Reisenwitz and Les Carlson.

The research looked at a total of 757 ads for cosmectic products in well-known global magazines such as marie claire, Vogue, Harper’s Bazaar and Elle.

It focused on six specific claims many of them make; superiority claims such as ‘award-winning product’, scientific claims ‘clinically proven’, stand-alone performance claim like ‘your skin feels softer’, endorsement claim such as ‘recommended by dermatologists’, environmental claim like ‘no animal testing’ and subjective claims ‘visibly clearer skin’.

Of the total 757 products looked at within the six categories, only 136 (18 per cent) of them were deemed acceptable.

Some 316 were considered too vague, 130 had omissions from the claims that would have made them testable for truthfulness, and 175 were just outrightly false.

The research however found that many consumers are already well aware of the potentially false claims on beauty product ads, which leads to consumers already feeling defensive about the glossy ads when they see them.

For advertisers, the authors suggested the need to tackle “distrustful consumers” in the marketplace. One way proposed was to use more of the endorsement claims which appeared to be the most positively associated claim on beauty products. For example, using claims such as ‘recommended by dermatologists’ – of course, provided that the product actually is recommended.

“Deception not only undermines the credibility of advertising as a whole by making consumers defensive, but also produces damaging effects for the advertisers who are directly responsible for making the claims,” the authors note in the conclusion.

“The study makes it clear that marketers have a powerful self-interest in upholding the truth in cosmetics advertising.”

Latest News

News.com.au Unveils New Homepage
  • Media

News.com.au Unveils New Homepage

Australia’s leading national news website news.com.au today unveiled a new homepage. As the gateway to Australia’s largest news website, the news.com.au homepage delivers 135 million page impressions per month. The redevelopment of the news.com.au homepage has been designed to evolve the brand into the next decade with plans to roll out continued updates across the […]

Study: Startup Mentality Defined By Culture More Than Age Or Size
  • Marketing
  • Media

Study: Startup Mentality Defined By Culture More Than Age Or Size

The lines between startups and corporates should no longer be defined by organisation size, but by the kind of culture they foster, a panel of top marketers have agreed. Some of Sydney’s top marketers – including Guzman y Gomez CMO Lara Thom, Outdoria CEO Nick Baker, Menulog’s head of marketing Tasman Page and Facebook ANZ’s […]

Cupcakes on a cake stand with sparklers
  • Media

The New Daily Turns Five

Online news site, The New Daily, the brainchild of industry super fund boss Garry Weaven and former Age and Herald Sun editor Bruce Guthrie, turns five this week. It boasts a monthly Google audience of more than two million and close to 500,000 daily subscribers. It’s impressive climb up the Nielsen news site rankings – from outside […]

Nielsen: Aussies Aged 50+ Spent Most Time Online With News
  • Media

Nielsen: Aussies Aged 50+ Spent Most Time Online With News

Nielsen Digital Content Ratings monthly-tagged data for October 2018 revealed that more than half (52 per cent) of the total time spent online consuming news-related content during October 2018 was by Australians aged 50 plus. Desktop was the device of choice for Australians accessing news stories online, contributing to close to half (49 per cent) […]

Haystac Shakes Up National Leadership Team
  • Media

Haystac Shakes Up National Leadership Team

Haystac, part of the BWM Dentsu Group, has announced three key changes to its national leadership team as the agency evolves to service the needs of major national and global brand clients. Haylie Marchant moves into a new national role, as head of strategy at Haystac. Formerly the general manager of Haystac Brisbane, Haylie will drive Haystac’s new […]

Virtue Announces New Key Hires, Campaigns And Partnerships In Australia
  • Marketing
  • Media

Virtue Announces New Key Hires, Campaigns And Partnerships In Australia

Creative agency VIRTUE has introduced a number of key hires, innovative campaigns and an expanding roster of clients within its newly established Sydney office. VIRTUE is the creative agency born from global youth media company VICE, and will service the whole of Asia-Pacific from three offices in Sydney, Singapore and Seoul. The agency aims to […]