ACCC Hands Down Scathing Facebook-Google Report
Australia will have a new media regulatory framework by the end of 2019, after the government released the highly-anticipated Digital Platforms Inquiry by the ACCC this morning.
Treasurer Josh Frydenberg fronted the media alongside communications minister Paul Fletcher (pictured) to unveil the 600-page report, which sets out 23 recommendations to respond to the “substantial market power” that digital platforms like Facebook and Google now hold in Australia.
While accepting “the ACCC’s overriding conclusion that there is a need for reform”, Frydenberg did not announce any new policies that will shape the new framework, rather he announced a 12-week consultation process for interested stakeholders to provide feedback, before the government’s response is finalised by the end of the year.
The government said Facebook and Google need to be “held to account” for their market dominance.
“While the ACCC recognises the significant benefits provided by digital platforms, there are potentially adverse consequences of their growth that need to be considered,” says the commission in the report.
The report focusses on the way digital platforms impact consumers, media content creators and advertisers.
It also analyses the cyclical nature of Facebook and Google’s business models, asserting “the breadth and depth of the ongoing data collection reinforces their market power”.
The ACCC rules both Facebook and Google have “substantial market power” in the markets they operate in, which is “unlikely to erode in the short to medium term”.
In terms of display advertising, Facebook and Instagram now have a combined share of 51 per cent in Australia, which the ACCC says provides the social media giant with “substantial bargaining power in its dealings with news media businesses”.
And while Australian law does not prohibit a firm from possessing substantial power, the ACCC suggests “a firm with substantial market power could damage this competitive process by preventing or deterring rivals, including potential rivals, from competing on their merits”.
It is widely suggested Facebook’s dominance has been in part assisted by its acquisition of Instagram.
As part of its recommendations, the ACCC suggests Australia makes changes to merger law and requires advance notice of acquisitions.
Lack of transparency for advertisers, review into ad tech sector looms
The report highlights the need for change around online advertising, particularly in regard to how Google and Facebook operate their respective ad businesses.
“It is unclear how Google and Facebook rank and display advertisements and the extent to which each platform self preferences their own platforms or businesses in which they have interests,” said the ACCC.
“A lack of transparency makes it difficult for advertisers to understand the factors that influence the display of their advertising to consumers and, in particular, to identify whether Google or Facebook are favouring their own business interests at the expense of rival advertisers and consumers.
“While the ACCC appreciates the significance of minimising the opportunity for businesses to ‘game’ the key algorithms, it is not clear that the appropriate balance has been struck between avoiding this risk and ensuring advertisers are appropriately informed of the outcomes.”
The lack of transparency also gives Facebook and Google the opportunity to “self-preference” and conduct other anti-competitive conduct, pointing to recent revelations of Google abusing its dominance in Europe.
Advertisers are unable to determine whether they are in fact receiving value for money when they purchase digital services due to the “complexity and opacity” of the ad tech supply chain.
As a result, the ACCC has recommended an inquiry into the supply of ad tech services and advertising agencies.
What it means for journalism
The report looked at how the reduction in advertising revenue over the last 20 years, primarily due to the rise of online advertising, may impact different types of journalism that may be at risk of under-provision in Australia.
Data collected by the ACCC shows that between 2008 and 2018, 106 local and regional newspaper titles closed across Australia, representing a net 15 per cent decrease in the number of these publications. The research indicates a significant fall in the number of articles published covering local government, local court, health and science issues during the past 15 years. The decline in provision of each of these categories of journalism coincides with reductions in Australian metropolitan journalists and reductions in print/online media revenue.
The role of public broadcasters was also looked at in the report. In recognition of the role performed by the ABC and SBS in addressing the public good nature of journalism and consequent risk of under provision of public interest journalism, the ACCC recommended that stable and adequate funding be provided to the ABC and SBS. The report found public broadcasters are not currently resourced to fully compensate for the decline in local reporting previously produced by traditional commercial publishers.
The ACCC also looked at the risk of consumers being exposed to deliberately misleading and harmful news when using digital platforms. The report recommended digital platforms establish an industry code to govern the handling of complaints about disinformation. This would relate to news and journalism where content has the potential to cause serious public detriment. This proposal seeks to improve transparency and help consumers by publicising and enforcing the procedures and responses that digital platforms must apply when dealing with these complaints.
The industry responds
DIGI – the industry association that advocates for Facebook, Google, Twitter and Verizon in Australia – urged the government to take a considered approach to the findings.
“We urge the Australian Government to assess the ACCC’s recommendations against an innovation test, closely examining how they will impact Australia’s digital industry at large and Australia’s global standing as a place to invest in technology,” said DIGI managing director Sunita Bose.
“The terms of reference of the Inquiry were to look at the impact of digital platforms on competition in the media and advertising services market, with the incredibly important goal of protecting the future of journalism.
“We’re closely reviewing these recommendations to ensure they don’t bring unintended consequences to all digital businesses and the choice of digital products available to Australian consumers.
“A thriving technology sector means having large and small, local and global companies all alongside each other, creating an ecosystem where the calibre of employees, business opportunities and the choice of digital services available to Australians all increase.”
A Google spokesperson said: “The Final Report examines important topics in relation to Australia’s changing media and advertising industry and we have engaged closely with the ACCC throughout the process. We will continue to engage with the Government on the recommendations put forward in this report.”
Facebook Australia and New Zealand managing director Will Easton said: “Over the past 18 months, we’ve worked with the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission as they’ve reviewed the future of sustainable journalism and digital advertising in Australia.
“It is important to get the rules for digital news distribution right, as they could impact the 16 million Australians who use our services to connect, share, and build community, as well as the hundreds of thousands of small businesses that use our free tools to grow, thrive, and create jobs.
“We are fully committed to engaging in the consultation process around this report, while continuing to deliver the benefits of technology to the millions of Australians who use our services.”
Please login with linkedin to comment
digital platforms inquiry Facebook framework Google governmentLatest News
‘The Penny Has Dropped…So We’ve Supercharged How Brands Plan, Book And Measure In One Place’ – News Corp’s Lou Barrett On D_Coded
As a cookie depreciation tsunami slowly approaches, News Corp is sharpening its audience intelligence platform, Intent Connect, with AI tech that enables advanced data collaboration capabilities through planning, booking and measurement. Managing director of client partnerships Lou Barrett tells B&T it’s about future-proofing clients’s digital marketing plans. At last year’s annual D_Coded event, News Corp […]
Advertisers Wasting 42% Of Digital Ad Spend – Next&Co report
With the cost of living crisis biting I think we can all agree that waste is rarely a positive thing...
Introducing New Podcast ‘MID’: Holly Wainwright Rebrands The Mid-Life Experience For Australian Women
The joys of midlife are celebrated in this new podcast. And play it loud if the old eardrums are starting to creak.
TV Ratings (13/05/2024): The Summit Brings In The Eyeballs For Nine
The Summit does the business on its return for Nine. Meanwhile, press photo confirms the importance of headwear.
Snap’s ANZ Agency Lead Ellie Rogers Steps Down Amid Restructure
Ellie Rogers says family was a big part in her next career move. Not so B&T, who only comes to work to avoid ours.
Breast Cancer Foundation NZ’s Awareness Drive ‘The Signs Are Everywhere’ Is B&T’s Campaign Of The Month for April 2024
B&T's ad of the month is both a worthy cause & worthy winner. Even if KFC's Zinger box can feel slightly hard done by.
iSelect Launches New Brand Campaign ‘Save More’ Via Howatson+Company
If there's an agency that's "so hot right now" it's Howatson+Co. And, yes, B&T's unnecessarily bigged-up this new work.
In The Making Expands Into Melbourne
Brisbane PR agency unveils its Melbourne plans. Still adjusting from the pineapple print to the mandatory all black.
It’s Off The Crisper Sale! Introducing KFC’s New Original Crispy Burger Series
This article contains the location to obtain free KFC burgers. Why not send the workie for real world office experience.
Spotlight On Sponsors: Rugby Australia Sign First Dedicated Female Retailer
Don't know your Storms from your Wallaroos? At least you'll be sports sponsor aware with B&T's ongoing series.
Mars Agency Rebrands As Mars United Commerce
Tired of fielding prank calls about nougat & caramel, Mars Agency rebrands to the more long-winded Mars United Commerce.
Azerion Expands Platform With Interactive Video Products
Did your last inter-team marketing brainstorm see 'interactive video' come up more often than not? Read on quickly here.
Inside NGEN: Seven’s Rachael Everett On What We Can Learn From Sport
Were you the wheezy kid that always wagged PE at school? Even more reason not to avoid this lessons-in-sport piece.
Cairns Crocodiles The Work: Changing the World Campaign Presented By Pinterest
Casual dress & motley beards aside, did you join adland to try and change the world? Get tips from those who did here.
Nine And Magnite Strengthen Partnership To Boost 9Now
Nine calls in Magnite to sort out its BVOD programmatic ads. Not before having to switch the plugs from a Type C to a I.
Cricket Australia Appoints Special As Creative Agency For Men & Women’s International Series
Special wins Cricket Australia's creative. Here's hoping they don't get Thomas Keneally to do a poem of 'C'mon Aussie'.
‘Do I want Kids?’ – Laura Henshaw Asks Just That In Latest Podcast
Whether you have kids or not, just know that if you do, it's no lie that they poo, vomit & keep you awake all night.
R/GA Australia Appoints Marie Conley As Executive Strategy Director
Marie Conley returns from the UK after 12 years to take up new role at R/GA. Immediately flabbergasted by house prices.
Zenith Australia Hires Penny Shell As Strategy And Product Lead
Unfortunately B&T refrained from using "the Penny has dropped at Zenith" in this headline. We apologise in advance.
‘It Takes a Village’: New Industry Support Group For Working Parents Launches
Here's a top industry initiative to help adland families. Sadly, no tips on mummy using the F-word after losing a pitch.
Belinda Rowe Unpacks The Forces Of Discrimination That Lead To A Lack Of Diversity In Leadership Roles
With an enviable resume in tow, Belinda Rowe reveals why our boardrooms aren't as eclectic as they really should be.
Marketing From The Cockpit: How Creativity Transformed AB InBev From A Brand Buyer Into A Brand-Building Powerhouse
Do you find American beers watery, insipid & bland? This conference would have been the perfect platform to heckle at.
Cebu Pacific Launches Campaign To Showcase The Philippines As Major Destination For Aussies
In case you needed another reason to visit the Philippines.
Elon Musk’s X Corp Defeats eSafety In Federal Court
Is it just B&T or is Elon Musk slowly morphing into Darth Vader minus the chokehold?
TV Ratings (12/05/2024): Framer Brings Home The Bacon
Lovelorn famers continuing to do good TV numbers. As desperate roof tilers & abattoir employees say "what about us?"
Starcom Pips PHD & Kaimera To Win Gold At Nine’s Agency Games – Check Out All Of The Photos And Coverage Of The Event
Starcom proves the top agency at Nine's Agency Games. Thankfully, no one has asked for urine testing either.
Zitcha Solves In-store Retail Media Measurement With Game Changing Venvee Partnership
Does your in-store retail media measurement resemble a kitchen draw with the screwdrivers & plastic bags? Help is here.
Menulog Delivers More Beef Than Drake and Kendrick Combined, Via Thinkerbell
This "more beef" ad could have also used William & Harry, Oasis, and Bruce Lehrmann & just about everybody.
Komo Tech Announces Landmark Partnership With Fanatics Events To Revolutionise Live Event Experiences
This partnership promises to "revolutionise live event experiences". Hopefully it doesn't alert any sniffer dogs too.
SCA “Disappointed” After ARN and Anchorage Capital Withdraw Takeover Bid
ARN's bid for SCA trips up at the final hurdle. It's also unclear if other states will have to suffer Kyle Sandilands.
About Bloody Time – News.com.au Campaign Secures Win For Endometriosis Sufferers
News.com.au puts aside its passion for 'China set to invade' & overcharging Sydney cafe articles to do some real good.
Fast 10: B&T Talks Brand Rituals, Keeping It Fresh And DE&I With Affinity Media’s Angela Smith
B&T's probing Fast 10 is so quick it's liable for double demerit points on public holidays.
FriendlyJordies Journalist Calls The Police After Allegedly Being Informed Of Gangland Threats By ABC Reporter
What's better than a Walkley Award for journalism? Getting a hit put out on you by a Sydney underworld drug gang.
Two Iconic Brands Seal The Deal With Exclusive Strategic Partnership
Wonderfully, a horse turned up for this press photo. Better again, everyone went home with some manure for their roses.
JCDecaux Wins Tender To Retain Sydney Airport
Shopping at airports has always been a paradox. On one hand there's the duty-free, on the other there's $24 schooners.
QMS Adds Hills Shire To Sydney Network
Forget the hills being alive with the sound of music, as Sydney's Hills district comes alive with new outdoor.