Five Reasons Why Your Ideas Are Completely Missing The Mark
Zoe Aitken is the head of consulting at leading behavioural science and innovation consultancy Inventium and has over 20 years’ experience helping organisations develop customer-centric growth strategies and innovation. In this guest post, Aitken offers her expert tips on turning dud ideas into golden bullets…
It’s easy to launch mediocre ideas. And it’s even easier to launch terrible ideas. Yet how does this happen? How do we get to the point where we launch ideas that completely miss the mark with our customers? Here are five reasons that help explain why we might persist with terrible ideas.
- The Pathos Problem
Originating from the Greek term ‘pathos’, which was coined by Aristotle as a means of emotional persuasion, the ‘Pathos Problem’ is when we shift into ‘accidental approval seeking’ and fishing for compliments around our idea.
Entrepreneur Rob Fitzpatrick, who wrote ‘The Mom Test’, coined this phrase. He states that the ‘Pathos Problem’ happens when we are passionate about our idea, and we start appealing to our audience’s emotions to convince them of its merits. Whether that be to our boss, our CEO, or our customers during a Focus Group. It is rarely intentional; however, it happens when we expose our ego, which leads people to want to protect us (and our fragile egos!) by saying nice things.
The Pathos Problem leads us to believe that the people around us think our idea is as worthwhile and valuable as we do. Which gives us the confidence to keep persisting.
- Confirmation Bias
A close cousin to the Pathos Problem is Confirmation Bias, which is the tendency to interpret new evidence as confirmation of our existing beliefs or theories. This happens a lot during the business case phase, when we collect lots of data and information to support our idea. And we can get very creative at this stage. We go digging into dark and obscure places to find any and all evidence to validate our idea and ensure it sees the light of day.
When we’re looking for data to validate our idea, we will find it. We will find a way to make our business case very compelling. And so, the business is impressed, and we persist with our idea.
- Sunk Cost Fallacy
The sunk-cost fallacy means that the more resources (i.e., time, people, and money) we invest in something, the more inclined we become to blindly persist with it, regardless of evidence to the contrary.
Many of our organisation’s processes often mandate a lofty business case that can take months to prepare. We can get involved in countless meetings to seek alignment and funding for our idea when we haven’t even determined if it’s something our customers want. All these hours build attachment to our idea and encourage us to buy into our own convictions and keep blindly persevering.
- Loss Aversion
The greater the love for our idea the more likely we are to fall victim to ‘loss aversion’. This is our natural tendency to avoid loss and failure because we experience the pain associated with loss, twice as intensely as the joy associated with a win. Therefore, we try to avoid it. We avoid failure and we avoid killing ideas even if we know we should. And so, we keep persisting with mediocre (or worse, bad) ideas to avoid the psychological pain of the loss.
- Flawed Reward Structures
Often organisations have reward structures based on specific deliverables, such as ‘launching Idea X’, ‘achieving X number of sales for Idea Y within 12 months’, or ‘executing the annual plan’. These types of execution-focused objectives promote the delivery of specific ideas or products to market, on time and within budget. Therefore, they leave little room or incentive for us to kill or pivot our ideas.
When this happens, we convince ourselves (and the business) of our idea’s merits because we must in order to achieve our objectives and be rewarded.
Being aware of these five perils can help us avoid them. To launch ideas that our customers love, we must not get attached to the solution. Businesses need processes and systems in place that support an evidence-led approach to experimenting with ideas. And importantly we need to stay open to pivoting and killing our ideas along the way.
Latest News
Canva Unveils Enterprise Era With Powerful New Workplace Products Debuted At Canva Create
At its first international Canva Create event in Los Angeles today, Canva, the world’s only all-in-one visual communication platform, accelerated its focus on the enterprise, debuting the platform’s biggest overhaul in a decade alongside a range of new workplace products and services poised to redefine the way millions of people work. Lead image: Canva Founders […]
Who are Australia’s top media suits? B&T’s Best Of The Best Media Agency Leaders – Holding Co
B&T wishes it could pick the order of the list by challenging entrants to a media agency version of It's A Knockout.
Worksafe Helps Young Workers Recognise When Things Feel A Bit ‘umm…’ Via Sickdogwolfman
New Worksafe campaign targets the 15-24s. It really needs to target drive-thru workers who always give you cold fries.
Olympians Front “Find Their Drive” Novated Lease Australia Campaign
Novated leasing is an excellent cost saving option... something professional athletes worry about daily, we're sure.
HoopsFest Basketball Extravaganza To Hit Western Australia
Hoopsfest promises the "ultimate fusion of basketball, music & culture". And lots of people acting like Americans.
Shooting For 2027: Why Woolies & Suncorp Are Investing BIG In Netball
As wonderful as it is to see the Matilda's achievements, it's arguably left netball with a pursed lip & furrowed brow.
TV Ratings (23/05/2024): AFL Takes Home Thursday Night Footy Crown!
We're a third of the way through the footy season & it's around about now you realise your team has zero chance in 2024.
Nine Appoints Jo Barton As Director Of Sales – Sydney
Nine promotes Jo Barton to Sydney director of sales. However, is prepared to travel as far as Wollongong.
Susie O’Neill Swaps The Pool Deck For DJ Decks For Nova
Nova threw quite the party in Brisbane last night. So far, no one sheepishly summoned to HR this morning.
“Decide What Success Looks Like For You; Don’t Let Anyone Else Decide For You”: Lorraine Woods On The Importance Of Charting Your Own Path
Atomic 212º's Lorraine Woods chats Women in Media & imparts top career advice. Stays mum on her favourite quiche type.
Vistar Media & ChinaDOOH Bring Programmatic DOOH To Mainland China
Vistar Media unveils its expansion into China. Thankfully no one has mentioned the new nuclear submarines as yet.
Australian Agency Signs APAC Deal With Data-Driven Platform To Remove Bias In The Sports & Entertainment Decision-Making Process
New platform set to "remove the bias" in sports & entertainment marketing. Just not in lawn bowls' bias.
Adland Leaders Launch Pembleton: A Clubhouse For Creative Ideas
Pembleton's a "clubhouse for creative ideas". Yet it could be a synth band from Düsseldorf judging by the press photo.
Dwyane Wade “Toasts” To The Finals In New 2024 NBA Finals Campaign
The NBA finals are upon us and it certainly doesn't muster the gravitas in Australia as its Super Bowl contemporary.
Year13 Launches Virtual Work Experience Program
Call B&T old fashioned, but virtual work experience? How do students clean the fridge and do the vacuuming?
Taskmaster’s Tom Cashman Reveals Why He Is More Relaxed This Season
B&T's chatting with Taskmaster's Tom Cashman who's under strict instructions not to be funnier than the host.
QMS Put Brands Up In Lights For Vivid Sydney 2024
That's right, Vivid is back. Want dinner a reservation in the city? Think again!
A Current Affair EP Fiona Dear Appointed Nine Director Of News & Current Affairs
Nine's new director of news & current affairs has strict instructions to keep badly behaved staff out of the headlines.
Cashrewards: A Decade Strong!
Cashrewards' CEO muses on the company's 10 year anniversary. Still refusing to answer questions about a possible party.
Gold Artifacts Give Clues To Apple Music’s 100 Best Albums
Nothing stirs debate quite like a ubiquitous 100 best albums list. Nor pits the Xs against the Ys.
Chook & HOYTS Celebrate Webby Honouree Recognition At The Australian Web Awards
Chook sounds like the bloke who brings the half-time oranges to the footy but, as you'll read here, it's far greater.
Salesforce’s Bobby Jania: AI Has Flipped Marketing Campaigns On Their Head
B&T on the ground at this year's Salesforce conference in Chicago. Also finding it nothing at all like the musical.
Network 10 Axes Gladiators
Alas, 10's Gladiators has gone as quickly as it came. Should make for a very wild garage sale, however.
Élysée Collective Sydney Team Expansion & Growing Roster Of Global Luxury Clients
The PR agency adds a number of luxury clients to its roster. More proof of what accents in your name can seriously do.
Hard-hitting Local And Global News Kept Australians Hooked Through April, Says Ipsos
Research finds Aussies "hooked" by hard hitting news in April. B&T currently revisiting our MAFS archives for evidence.
Weber Shandwick Australia Promotes Angela Malkin, Bolstering Leadership Team
There's so much movement at Weber Shandwick today, B&T suspects it triggered the earthquake in Goulburn today.
Scaleup Mediafund Third Funding Round Of $15m Completes First Two Deals
On occasions, B&T does serious business news like this. Which you should expect from an alleged business site.
Modern, Inclusive & Personal: Skincare Brand E45 Reveals New Brand Identity
Has your job given you sags, bags and wrinkles where you least need them? This moisturiser news may be of assistance.
Man Eating Avo With Spoon At AFL Kicks Off Thinkerbell & Hort Innovation Creative Partnership
Mums clearly failing to get kids to eat their veggies as Thinkerbell named creative agency for produce purveyor Hort.
All Opinions Matter: Clems Gives A Voice To Dying Patients
B&T warns this article deals with sombre issues such as the end of life. It's not for those looking for sombrero issues.
Watch Out Influencers, Podfluencers Are On The Rise: Spotify Unveils New Global Podcast Trends Tour
If COVID gave us anything it's a massive increase in podcasting & a renewed appreciation for lavatory rolls.
MG3 Hybrid Is Ready To Hit The Road With ELLE
Chinese motor marque MG teams with Are's flagship fashion brand Elle. Just don't expect sheepskin carseat covers.
CHEP Network Promotes Tash Johnson To National Head Of Integrated Production
Let Tash Johnson's promotion be proof of the value of talent & hard work. Although there's more humour in demotions.
“Connection” Study Reveals What Brands Can Learn From Changes In Human Connection
Aussie pollies might be readying to give social media a kicking, but this new study says we should save the brickbats.
CJ Media Serves Up Australian Open For South Korean Viewers
Deal will see South Koreans enjoying the Oz Open until 2027. Or not enjoying it given the lack of South Korean players.
TV Ratings (22/05/2024): MasterChef Constestants Channel Their Inner Uni Students With Microwave Challenge
The much-maligned microwave stars in MasterChef overnight. B&T hoping to see the return of the fondue set anytime soon.