In this guest post, creative strategist Liz Penton discusses the pitfalls of this year’s Super Bowl advertising.
As the confetti settles on another Super Bowl, the advertising industry takes stock of the commercial triumphs and fumbles witnessed during one of the most-watched television events of the year. However, a surprising trend has emerged from the latest gridiron showdown: big ideas that fuel integrated campaigns are surprisingly scarce.
Recent analysis reveals that less than half of this year’s Super Bowl commercials were part of broader, connected campaigns. The ‘Big Idea’—the driving force behind a brand’s cohesive storytelling across multiple channels—seems to be side-lined in favour of standalone 30-second spots. This raises a critical question: can a Super Bowl ad maintain its impact beyond the initial buzz without the support of an integrated campaign?
The data paints a concerning picture for advertisers. System1 Group research, which evaluated 308 Super Bowl ads between 2020-2023, found that only 20 per cent of viewers who saw the ads were not able to remember the brand promoted. This finding highlights the potential limitations of a one-off commercial, regardless of its creativity or immediate appeal.
Furthermore, this year’s ad landscape shows a reliance on familiar tactics: a significant number of ads relied on humour, celebrity endorsements, and nostalgia to engage audiences. Although these elements can certainly enhance an ad’s memorability, they fall short of ensuring the kind of enduring brand association that an integrated campaign can achieve.
The decline in connected campaigns indicates that brands might be overlooking the chance to craft more persistent narratives. Given that a 30-second Super Bowl spot is valued at a staggering $7 million USD, a standalone TV commercial that goes viral for a brief period may not warrant such a hefty investment.
The current trend in Super Bowl advertising points to a strategic shift where the immediate payoff of a standalone spot seems to be favoured over the lasting advantages of an integrated campaign. Brands appear to be seeking quick wins rather than investing in the long game. However, as the effectiveness of these ads comes under closer examination, marketers may need to reassess the worth of the ‘Big Idea’ and the enduring impact of a campaign that continues to resonate well after the Super Bowl excitement has waned.
Reflecting on this year’s Super Bowl advertising initiatives, it’s evident that while humour, celebrity, and nostalgia can still captivate viewers, the lack of integrated campaigns could represent a significant missed opportunity for brands aiming to establish a lasting impression. In the competitive arena of advertising, the ‘Big Idea’ might indeed retain its status as the most valuable player.
