So You Stole Dallas Buyers Club…

So You Stole Dallas Buyers Club…

With yesterday’s court case in Sydney forcing internet service providers to divulge the names of customers who allegedly downloaded the film Dallas Buyers Club without paying for it, there’s undoubtedly some nervous local film fans sweating the decision today.

Not only have fines as high as $US7000 been bandied about for people who pinched the Academy Award-winning flick, it needs to be asked what does the ruling mean for the rest of us who may have accidentally forgotten to pay for that film, TV show or game we sourced via the internet?

And if you’re an iiNet, Internode, Dodo or Adam internet customer will you have to spend the next six months hiding in a cupboard and being scared of the postman delivering you a monster fine?

In yesterday’s case the judge ruled that iiNet had to reveal the details of customers – some 4700 of them – who allegedly downloaded the film. This information can now be given to the film’s producers, a company called Voltage Pictures in the US.

According to Erin Turner from the consumer advocacy group Choice, Voltage Pictures have a history of this sort of activity in other countries – US, the UK and Denmark to name a few. They use the courts to divulge the details of people who’ve downloaded its films and then send them a big nasty fine in the mail. A practise known as speculative invoicing.

According to Nic Healey, a Sydney-based senior editor with tech news site CNET, the best thing to come from yesterday’s decision was that any letters or fines the film’s producers propose to send out to people it suspects of downloading the film would have to go through the Australian courts first.

“The good news out of all this is that the 4762 IP addresses that Dallas Buyers Club now has access to, what the court has done has insist that any letters that are going to individuals or families or whoever they are going to be checked by the court first. The big concern is that Dallas Buyers Club might indulge in speculative invoicing where they send a letter that sort of says ‘pay us five grand and we won’t take you to court’.

“But the Australian court is insisting that there is genuine contact and not a speculative one. The problem here is that nobody knows what will happen when this letter arrives because we’ve never been in this situation before in Australia,” he said.

So you’re an iiNet customer and you nicked the film, what’s next?

Choice’s Erin Turner’s advice is certainly not to panic. “The case isn’t settled yet and iiNet still has 28 days to challenge the ruling. What is likely to happen is that the people behind The Dallas Buyers Club will get the details of the alleged downloaders. But the problem here is just because your name’s on the account it doesn’t mean you’re the one that actually downloaded the film. How do you find the person if it happened in a share house, for example?

“What will happen? I don’t think anybody really knows. It’s uncharted territory in Australia where a rights holder has taken action against someone who has pirated a TV show or movie. I think the problem here is that the copyright act in Australia leaves consumers with little protection. It was written in the 60s and has only recently acknowledged that people tape movies from TV on their VCRs.”

Turner says if you do receive any correspondence it’s best to get legal advice and her organisation, Choice, can certainly lend a hand.

“This company has a real dodgy history of doing this, of sending out speculative invoices. These letters are legal extortion and thankfully the judge (on the Australian case) is aware of this and does not want to see that happen here. They want to stamp out speculative invoicing; this idea of demanding money before proving guilt.

“The laws in this country are all wrong if someone illegally downloads a $15 movie and then is liable for thousands of dollars in fines for doing so,” she said.

Arguably, the bigger worry is yesterday’s ruling sets some sort of legal precedent and any person that’s ever poached something online could be held to a similar accountability and equally hefty fines.

Nic Healey agreed: “I think it will make people very, very nervous. How will it pan out? I don’t think anybody knows for sure because we don’t know what will happen once these letters arrive. Yes, this is a big case and it’s giving these people access to peoples’ data. From here we just don’t know what the next steps will be and it will be every interesting how this all plays out.”

Adding further spice to the debate, Turner cites a Choice study from 2014 that found a third of Australians had pirated something online.

“Why do people do it? It’s usually because of cost and timeliness,” she said. “We know that 55 per cent of Australians actually look to buy what they want first – be that in a store or online – and when they can’t find it then they turn to piracy. It doesn’t excuse it but it does explain it.”




Latest News

Australia’s Automotive Industry Shifts Gears With CTV
  • Partner Content

Australia’s Automotive Industry Shifts Gears With CTV

Australia’s automotive market broke all-time records for new vehicle sales in 2023. Over 1.2 million cars were sold, with Toyota, Ford and Mazda alone making up around 30 per cent of those sales. During the same period, car manufacturers accelerated their advertising spend investing $661 million on advertising – over $60 million more than 2022, […]

Partner Content

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Australia’s C7EVEN Communications Launches Services In Japan With New Tokyo Office
  • Advertising

Australia’s C7EVEN Communications Launches Services In Japan With New Tokyo Office

Australian marketing and communications agency, C7EVEN Communications has officially launched its overseas offering, with a new office recently opened in Tokyo’s Toranomon Hills district in Japan. Lead Image: Adam Arndell and Jonathan Mueller  Specialising in regional, rural marketing and communications, with a strong existing client base in food, fibre and agriculture, C7EVEN’s new Japan office […]

Daniel Goldstein Promoted To Head Of PR At Example
  • Advertising

Daniel Goldstein Promoted To Head Of PR At Example

Earned-led culture agency Example has announced the promotion of Daniel Goldstein to head of PR. Goldstein’s journey within Example has been marked by exceptional dedication and stellar accomplishments during his tenure spanning over four and a half years. Since joining the agency as an account manager in 2019, he has demonstrated unparalleled prowess in spearheading […]

marie claire & Volvo Partner For The Planet: Nominees For The Inaugural marie claire Sustainability Awards Announced
  • Marketing

marie claire & Volvo Partner For The Planet: Nominees For The Inaugural marie claire Sustainability Awards Announced

Are Media, Australia’s leading omnichannel content company for women, is proud to announce the inaugural Marie Claire Sustainability Awards in partnership with Volvo Car Australia. The marie claire Sustainability Awards will champion businesses and products that are implementing genuine change and building a better tomorrow. Finalists were selected across eight categories by four judges: marie […]

Sefiani Unveils A Wave Of Promotions & Appointments
  • Advertising

Sefiani Unveils A Wave Of Promotions & Appointments

Sefiani has strengthened its digital offering with a new senior appointment and bolstered its corporate and crisis management team with two new hires and two senior promotions. Katrina Calvi has been appointed social and digital content account director to lead the agency’s rapidly growing digital marketing offering, working closely with Clarity Global’s digital teams in […]

Yahoo Launches Identity Solutions For CTV
  • Technology

Yahoo Launches Identity Solutions For CTV

Yahoo Advertising has launched Yahoo Identity Solutions for Connected TV (CTV) environments including Paramount. Yahoo Identity Solutions on CTV will give advertisers enhanced targeting and measurement for the ID-constrained world, backed by global partnerships with Paramount, Tubi, NBCUniversal and FreeWheel “As CTV investments increase, identity signals are declining, impacting targeting and performance across channels, including […]

Infosum Launches Data Clean Room Solution With Samsung Ads Australia
  • Technology

Infosum Launches Data Clean Room Solution With Samsung Ads Australia

Samsung Ads has launched a data clean room solution powered by InfoSum. The relationship enables Samsung Ads’ clients to maximise the performance of their data-driven advertising strategies within InfoSum’s privacy-focused environment. As privacy regulations evolve, organisations across the region are prioritising their first-party data programs – making data clean rooms an increasingly important piece of […]

Fast 10: Bread Agency’s Amaury Treguer Its “Unrivalled” Social Commerce Focus
  • Advertising

Fast 10: Bread Agency’s Amaury Treguer Its “Unrivalled” Social Commerce Focus

Founded in August 2022, Amaury Treguer and the team at Bread Agency have certainly caught B&T’s eye recently. In January, it picked up the global social media account for Modibodi and last month, it launched an unusual billboard-first recruitment campaign. Greg ‘Sparrow’ Graham caught up with the agency’s co-founder Amaury Treguer to get the low […]

CRA Siren Award To Be Presented At B&T Awards 2024!
  • Media

CRA Siren Award To Be Presented At B&T Awards 2024!

After 20 years, Commercial Radio and Audio (CRA) will be revamping its Siren Award, with the trophy being handed out at this year’s B&T Awards! The Siren Award will be presented as the Best Use of Radio/Audio at this year’s B&T Awards, and marks a new approach for B&T and CRA aimed at reflecting excellence […]

Special Launches Second Iteration Of Virgin’s “Bring On Wonderful” Brand Platform
  • Campaigns

Special Launches Second Iteration Of Virgin’s “Bring On Wonderful” Brand Platform

The second installation of Virgin’s “Bring On Wonderful” brand platform, created by Special, has been revealed featuring the airline’s team members. The campaign was inspired by Virgin Australia team members demonstrating the ways they go above and beyond to bring joy to the flying experience. Like a viral video of a Perth baggage handler who […]

OMA & RSL Join Forces For ANZAC Day
  • Advertising

OMA & RSL Join Forces For ANZAC Day

The Outdoor Media Association (OMA) and RSL have once again joined forces in the spirit of mateship, partnering for the fifth consecutive year to encourage Australians to commemorate ANZAC Day. Lead image L-R: Geoff Noonan, QMS Queensland State Sales Manager; Jimmy Sullivan, Assistant Minister for Justice and Veterans’ Affairs; Elizabeth McIntyre, Outdoor Media Association CEO; Major […]

JOLT Appoints Former Vicinity Centres Alicia Proebstl As Group Sales Manager
  • Advertising

JOLT Appoints Former Vicinity Centres Alicia Proebstl As Group Sales Manager

JOLT has announced the appointment of Alicia Proebstl as its new group sales manager in Melbourne, driving out-of-home and digital advertising solutions for its growing Victorian and South Australian client base. In the role, Proebstl will be responsible for managing end-to-end media sales across JOLT’s Melbourne client base, while also growing market share and revenue. […]

NAB’s New Brand Campaign Flexes To Target Gen Z Via TBWA\Melbourne & Mindshare
  • Campaigns

NAB’s New Brand Campaign Flexes To Target Gen Z Via TBWA\Melbourne & Mindshare

NAB, together with TBWA\Melbourne and Mindshare, has unveiled the next iteration of the recently launched ‘Wrangle Your Money’ campaign. The new work is specifically tailored for Gen Z and is in response to young Australians feeling the ongoing cost-of-living crisis the hardest. Recent findings from ASIC reveal that 82% of Gen Z, in contrast to […]

“Intrinsically I’ve Always Had Giving At My Heart”: UNICEF’s Zunilka Whitnall On Making A Positive Social Impact
  • B&T Exclusive

“Intrinsically I’ve Always Had Giving At My Heart”: UNICEF’s Zunilka Whitnall On Making A Positive Social Impact

Zunilka Whitnall is a force to be reckoned with. The daughter of immigrant parents who desires to leave a legacy for her own children, Whitnall is passionate about evoking positive social change, not just financial. As the innovation, new products, and senior partnership specialist lead at UNICEF Australia, Zunilka cuts through the noise to achieve […]

AI-Powered ROI: The Retail Marketing Revolution
  • Partner Content

AI-Powered ROI: The Retail Marketing Revolution

In this op-ed, Jonathan Reeve, vice president of APAC for Eagle Eye, unpacks the power of AI for ROI in retail marketing. With AI, we’re on the verge of achieving retail marketing’s holy grail: true one-to-one personalisation. This is crucial because recognising the individuality of each shopper and delivering a custom retail experience that reflects […]

Partner Content

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine