The Rise Of Programmatic (And The Rise Of The Problems)

The Rise Of Programmatic (And The Rise Of The Problems)
SHARE
THIS



In this guest post, Edge’s digital manager, Inez Zimakowski (pictured below), admits programmatic’s not without its teething problems, but it will ultimately prove the best option for brands and their agencies…

Online advertising has come a long way since the first banner ad went live in 1994. Click through rates are down, costs are rising, and it’s getting harder and harder to get cut through in an increasingly competitive environment.

Screen Shot 2018-03-22 at 9.44.21 am

But it’s not all doom and gloom – a whole new suite of platforms, ad formats and targeting options are available to us now that the marketers of the ’90s didn’t have. I don’t know about you, but I’m pretty glad I’ve never had to hard code a banner into a website and manually swap them out every day.

Screen Shot 2018-03-22 at 9.47.39 am

I’m also very happy that banners no longer look like this. Allegedly, this banner had a 44 per cent CTR. Unimaginable these days, especially for something like this, #clickbait. Why the multi-coloured text and arrow, Modem Media?

Still, despite its heinousness, that banner ad sparked an advertising revolution, and it has spawned ad networks, Adwords, ad exchanges, DSPs, SSPs, and a bunch of other acronyms.

In all of this, programmatic advertising was born. From ads going direct from brand or agency to publisher, we suddenly had the middlemen, the DSPs from the buyer side, the SSPs from the publisher side, and the ad exchange in the middle. Meant to make life easier for both publishers and buyers alike, the lack of transparency around costs, bids and who was actually seeing the ads left buyers and publishers in the dark about what was going on. The good thing was that we also had an automated way of buying massive amounts of inventory, and optimising the buying and bidding process.

Programmatic has been the subject of much scrutiny, particularly in the last 18 months, with fraud and transparency becoming increasingly bigger problems.

When we buy ads, we all want them to be seen by a real person, otherwise what’s the point? But questions around bots have been thrown around a lot lately in the programmatic space, with an estimated 52 per cent of total web traffic in 2016 being from bad bots. The World Federation of Advertisers is also predicting that by 2025, ad fraud will be costing advertisers an insane $US50 billion globally.

Now fifty billion is a lot of money to be spending on non-existent users, and advertisers have called on the industry to clean up the mess before it gets to that point. Even now, there are billions being spent on bot traffic on dodgy websites, with the IAB and EY declaring that in the US, ad fraud costs the advertising industry $US8.2 billion annually.

So, what can we do about it, and who should be responsible?

On one hand, there are those saying that the advertiser should bear responsibility; after all, it’s their money. That’s a bit of risky logic if you ask me, because it means the advertiser has to wait until after the fraudulent activity happens and has been paid for, and then what? It’s also going to start a chargeback process nightmare that no one wants.

On the other hand, it should be the ad networks’ problem, given they are the middleman supposedly vetting publishers in their portfolio. Here we meet another issue in the industry, transparency. Should ad networks be providing more detail about their portfolio and telling advertisers who is delivering fraudulent traffic? More importantly, should they then allow advertisers to block these sites from their whitelists? We think so.

Looking at transparency as another issue, and one of the biggest questions from buyers has been ‘how much of my ad dollar is actually going to the publisher?’. If everyone is now getting a slice of the pie, who’s losing out, and should you switch providers if they’re taking a huge cut? The lack of transparency in the buying chain has been a roadblock for many brands, and lifting the veil of secrecy will go a long way towards alleviating the trust issue.

Then we’ve got the much-touted ‘ads.txt’ file, or Authorised Digital Sellers for the uninitiated. The short, simple piece of code was developed by IAB to help increase transparency in the advertising industry by allowing publishers and distributors to publicly declare who is authorised to sell their inventory. What happens if your seller is selling you inventory but isn’t on that sites list? Well, your seller might be a little dodgy as they’re selling something they technically don’t have the right to sell.

Want to check if the inventory you’ve bought is legit? Just go to the publisher site in question, and add /ads.txt to the end of the URL. If they have the tag implemented you’ll be able to see if your seller is listed there!

What does it look like? Here’s the HuffPost one!

Screen Shot 2018-03-22 at 9.50.03 am

Pretty, right? But at least we can clearly see who can buy directly with HuffPost, and who has the authorisation to resell their inventory.

To sum up, yes programmatic has its issues, as does every other advertising channel when it comes to wastage and accuracy (hi TV, how’s that measurement and conversion piece going?). The industry is going through a clean up, publishers are taking note and the ads.txt file is slowly being added across more sites. So, to anyone who represents a brand that might be reading this, don’t freak out, change is coming. To any publishers, please add the ads.txt file to your site. And to my fellow media buyers, let’s call on ad networks, and our DSPs to give us more information upfront. #teameffort

Please login with linkedin to comment

Edge Inez Zimakowski Programmatic

Latest News

The Turning Tide Against Surveillance Capitalism
  • Opinion

The Turning Tide Against Surveillance Capitalism

In this guest post, CTO of Wiise, Hamish Browne (pictured below), says tech’s new focus on privacy will lead to new rules and new ways of doing business for marketers… With the delicate balance between customer data and privacy in the spotlight like never before, the potential emergence of new standards and business models, is […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Kim Kardashian Spruiks Cryptocurrency In Instagram Ad
  • Media
  • Technology

Kim Kardashian Spruiks Cryptocurrency In Instagram Ad

Businesswoman, reality TV star, and social media personality Kim Kardashian has posted an ad for mysterious cryptocurrency Ethereum MAX [EMAX]. In a post on her Instagram story – where she has 228 million followers – Kardashian wrote: “Are you guys into crypto????” “This is not financial advice but sharing what my friends just told me […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Great Southern Bank Rebrands With ‘Happily Clever After’ Via Indie Agency Richard Rose
  • Campaigns

Great Southern Bank Rebrands With ‘Happily Clever After’ Via Indie Agency Richard Rose

Great Southern Bank has launched a brand campaign this week, ‘Happily Clever After’, coinciding with its name change from Credit Union Australia, bringing to life its purpose of helping all Australians own their own home. The journey to changing from Credit Union to Great Southern Bank began back in 2020. When Australia’s largest customer-owned bank, […]

Nine Promotes Jo Clasby To Commercial Director, Publishing
  • Marketing

Nine Promotes Jo Clasby To Commercial Director, Publishing

Nine has promoted Jo Clasby to the role of commercial director – publishing, where she will report to Nick Young. She was previously director of client partnerships – publishing. Her new role establishes her at the same level of seniority as Anthony Smyth, commercial director – radio. Smyth was promoted at the start of this […]

Mark Zuckerberg, chief executive officer of Facebook Inc., listens as Narendra Modi, India's prime minister, not pictured, speaks during a town hall meeting at Facebook headquarters in Menlo Park, California, U.S., on Sunday, Sept. 27, 2015. Prime Minister Modi plans on connecting 600,000 villages across India using fiber optic cable as part of his
  • Technology

“No F*cking Way!”: Pink Floyd Frontman Refused To Give Mark Zuckerberg Rights To Song

Roger Waters, co-founder of Pink Floyd, said he refused to give Mark Zuckerberg the rights to use hit song Another Brick in the Wall (Part Two). Waters was speaking at a pro-Julian Assange event when he said that he had been offered a “huge, huge amount of money” for the use of the 1979 hit […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Accor Celebrates Aussie & NZ Cities With New ‘Go ALL Out’ Campaign
  • Campaigns

Accor Celebrates Aussie & NZ Cities With New ‘Go ALL Out’ Campaign

Hospitality giant Accor is shining a light on the joy of cities through its newest campaign, ‘Go ALL Out’, which launches in Australia and New Zealand today. The gateway to the ‘Go ALL Out’ campaign is ALL – Accor Live Limitless, a lifestyle loyalty program that integrates rewards, services and experiences throughout the Accor portfolio […]

Marketing Firm Silverbean Set To Double Headcount To Support New Client Wins
  • Marketing

Marketing Firm Silverbean Set To Double Headcount To Support New Client Wins

Global affiliate and partner marketing firm Silverbean has secured new contracts with 13 major Australian brands and is now working to double the size of its Asia-Pacific team. Silverbean launched in Australia in 2019 and has seen steady growth through its work with retailers. Now, with 15 new brands joining the Silverbean portfolio, the agency […]

Xandr Launches New Guide Exploring The Future Of Identity
  • Advertising
  • Technology

Xandr Launches New Guide Exploring The Future Of Identity

Xandr, AT&T’s advanced advertising company, today released “Shaping the Future of Identity,” an industry guide exploring the approaches for buyers and sellers, as well as market participants, as they evaluate identity solutions in preparation for a future without third-party cookies.

GTI Appoints New GM Of Marketing & Strategy, Snares Fresh Client
  • Marketing

GTI Appoints New GM Of Marketing & Strategy, Snares Fresh Client

Tourism PR and marketing agency GTI has announced the appointment of longtime media executive Jenny Pham as its new general manager of marketing and strategy. Pham (pictured above) will lead the agency’s marketing division with responsibility for strategy, media and consumer marketing, while GTI founder and managing director Sarah Anderson remains as the day-to-day lead […]

Hospitality Networking Platform Clipboard Launches Equity Crowdfunding Campaign
  • Campaigns
  • Marketing

Hospitality Networking Platform Clipboard Launches Equity Crowdfunding Campaign

Clipboard, a free professional networking platform for the hospitality industry, has announced it will seek to raise its next round of funding via equity crowdfunding platform Birchal. This will power its vision to transform the way the fragmented hospitality industry connects, shares experiences, markets and recruits. With a growing member database of over 24,000 hospitality […]