Revealed: The Aussie Retailers Most At Threat From Amazon (& Why It’s About The ‘Human Connection’)
Amazon has arrived in Australia and already has nervous retailers reaching for the anxiety pills.
However, a new study by researcher Roy Morgan has revealed which retailers are most at threat when the online shopping behemoth finally gets up and running.
According to the study, Amazon does well in countries that already have a rich history of online shopping – and that would be Australia.
It also does well against retailers whose existing shoppers shop in-store and online.
Coincidentally, only about four per cent of Australians do their grocery shopping online, which could explain why Amazon has no plans to launch its Amazon Fresh or Amazon Prime offerings in Australia just yet. And is certainly good news for the likes of Coles and Woolies.
According to Roy Morgan, Australians will most likely buy electronics or appliances from Amazon, which is bad news for the likes of JB H-Fi or The Good Guys.
The study also found that 30 per cent of David Jones’ customers had visited Amazon’s website. The list below shows the percentage of Australian retail customers that also shop online at Amazon.
David Jones 30 per cent
Zara 28.2 per cent
Dymocks 27.2 per cent
Officeworks 25.2 per cent
Toys R Us 24.5 per cent
Ikea 24.5 per cent
Spotlight 24.4 per cent
JB Hi-Fi 23.9 per cent
The Good Guys 23.2 per cent
Myer 22.4 per cent
Priceline 21.7 per cent
Cotton On 21.5 per cent
Harvey Norman 21.5 per cent
Target 21.2 per cent
Bunnings 20.7 per cent
According to Roy Morgan: “Both JB Hi-Fi and Harvey Norman have publicly predicted that they will be able to compete with Amazon on price, but given their high-margin business model this looks like being an unrealistic stretch.
“The inconvenient truth is that Amazon does not rely on gross profit margin for success. Its success is driven by volume – and it has that in spades. That’s what led founder Jeff Bezos to famously declare, ‘Your margin is my opportunity.’
“Last year Amazon’s gross profit margin – in basic terms, the mark-up on products they sell – was a miniscule 6.8 per cent. And still JB Hi-Fi with a gross margin of 21.9 per cent and Harvey Norman with 31.4 per cent believe they can compete on price.”
The study added: “Australian retailers also have high operating costs. Woolworths and Coles, for example, spend more than 24 per cent of sales revenue on leases, wages, marketing, etc. Operating costs for department stores are much higher, typically reaching 40 per cent. JB Hi-Fi is the exception in the Australian retail scene with costs at a low 16.3 per cent of sales revenue.”
However, Roy Morgan does conclude that Aussie retailers that play on the human side of their business will better compete with Amazon. For example, grocery stores that play on their locality in the neighbourhood. Those who try and take Amazon on in price are the ones that are doomed.
The study concluded: “The local, very human connection with supermarkets and their low levels of online shopping largely quarantines incumbent supermarket brands from Amazon.
“This also signposts a solution to other retail sectors – do not try to compete on price. You cannot win. Instead, compete on everything that has a human and local connection. Amazon cannot compete with that.
“Let’s turn our backs on artificial intelligence (AI). That’s Amazon’s universe. Instead, let’s focus on human intelligence (HI). Make that the universe you own,” it noted.
Latest News
Think You Can Do A Better Vaccine Ad Than The Government? Introducing B&T’s Good AZ Gold Ad Industry Challenge
Think you can make a better ad than the current crop of vax ads? Well, you're probably right & now here's your chance.
UK Ad Men Win Gender Discrimination Case: Only For Female Director To Face Sexism
UK-based senior creatives Chase Bayfield and Dave Jenner have this week won their lawsuit against their former employer WPP-owned J. Walter Thompson for gender discrimination. Alarmingly, however, the underpinning issue of gender and inherent sexism in the industry, continue to be reflected in the responses to this case. This week, Bayfield and Jenner won their […]
Semi Permanent Sydney Announces New Dates For 2021 Festival
In light of the prolonged lockdown occurring throughout New South Wales, Semi Permanent Sydney has announced new dates for this year’s festival. It will now take place between 17-19 November 2021 at Carriageworks. “Our mission, always, is to craft the best and most valuable experience for both our speakers and audience, and to ensure the […]
B&T’s Tokyo Wrap: Your Daily Dose of Blunders, Accidents and Romance!
The Olympics' creed is "faster, hgher, stronger - together". B&T's Olympic wrap is "blunders, mishaps & humiliation".
New Tourism Campaign Encourages Queenslanders To Enjoy ‘Days Like This’
Latest Queensland tourism ad features Van Morrison's classic 'Days Like This', amid reports Powderfinger a bit miffed.
New Study Reveals The Specific Things Aussies Love About Big And Small Businesses’ eCommerce Offerings
New study reveals what Aussies love about ecommerce. Not having to put up with painful sales assistants not among them.
Australian Academic Joins Facebook’s Global Women’s Advisory Panel To Help Empower Women Online
Here's another Aussie proving herself on the world stage and not a gaudy yellow and green tracksuit to be seen!
ACCC Continues Ban On Infant Formula Advertising, But Cites New Fears Surrounding Toddler Formula
ACCC confirms ban on infant formula advertising. Continues its ambivalence to awful Harvey Norman ads with Gerry Harvey.
Cats & Dogs Star In Impossibly Cute Campaign For Apple’s Latest “Shot On iPhone” Series
This campaign will melt the heart. Equally, a deep-fried parmigiana for lunch has similar heart-melting properties.
Ubiquity Lab Beefs Up Agency Team, Makes Two New Hires
Despite clearly not wanting a joint press photo, Ubiquity's new starters report they're still very close.
TBWA\Melbourne Banks NAB’s Creative Away From Rival Clems
NAB shifts its creative from Clems to TBWA. Insists it has no plans to stop being wonderfully evil, however.
Sorrell’s S4 Bolsters Data Capabilities With Acquisition Of Australian Salesforce Specialist Destined
S4 nabs another Aussie agency, and all while Sir Martin was watching 'Neighbours' in his pajamas & smoking jacket.
Acast Adds New Brand Suitability Controls For Advertisers Via Comscore
Acast, the independent power source of podcasting has teamed up with Comscore to provide brand suitability controls for brands advertising through the Acast Marketplace. This new innovation is part of a global partnership with Comscore, and will be available to all advertisers working with Acast Australia and New Zealand. The brand suitability solutions offered by […]
Monday TV Wrap: Olympics Continues To Score Over A Million (Even On A Weekday Arvo)
Olympic TV numbers continue to soar & we haven't even got to the archery, pistol shoot & always tedious 20km race walk.
Innocean Says The Future Wants Its Car Back With The All-New Hyundai Tucson
Has the time come to replace the "Holden" in "football, meat pies, kangaroos & Holden cars" with "Hyundai cars"?
V Energy Brings Back The Bugs In Fresh New Campaign Via Clemenger BBDO Sydney
The breakfast beverage of choice for teenage boys, gamers and IT professionals - V Energy Drink - unveils new work.
Hamish Blake And Andy Lee Renew SCA Partnership
Hoping for some new, fresh young blood on Aussie radio? Feel like you've heard it all before with this latest news.
RMIT Students Discover The Importance Of Teaching To Learn
Here's a top guest post from an student of advertising. You can almost smell the two-minute noodles reading it.
HootSuit Appoints Maggie Lower As Chief Marketing Officer
Social media management solutions company Hootsuit, has announced that Maggie Lower has joined the company as chief marketing officer. Lower will own the brand’s overall global strategy, demand generation, communications, and events. Prior to joining Hootsuite, Lower was the global chief marketing officer at Cision, the first chief marketing officer at TrueBlue, and has held […]
MyDeal Appoints Ryvalmedia As Agency Partner
MyDeal adds Ryvalmedia to client roster with the added bonus of a further 10% off teeth whitening kits for agency staff.
PHD Acquires Gold Mental Health First Aid Skilled Workplace Recognition
Well done to PHD on this top mental health initiative. But apparently the wall plaque is proving stressful to mount.
Aidan Corrigan Joins Medium Rare As Head Of Video
Aidan Corrigan joins Medium Rare as head of video. Ranks 'Inglourious Basterds' top of his favourite Tarantino films.
MediaCom’s Susie Si Shifts Over To Wavemaker As New Vodafone Lead
There can be no doubting the owner of anything labelled "SS' in the Wavemaker fridge after Susie Si joins the team.
Trade Indy Opens Sydney Office With Appointment Of NSW Commercial Director Ben Mulcahy
Headquartered in Melbourne, Trade Indy is expanding off the back of strong client retention and consistent growth through existing and new business. Founded in Melbourne in 2014, the team have since expanded the business through team members in Singapore, Indonesia, Tasmania and Queensland, and are pleased to announce the full-time employment of NSW commercial director […]
Outbrain Goes Public, Making Nasdaq Debut
Outbrain Inc. has announced the pricing of its initial public offering of 8,000,000 shares of common stock at a price to the public of US$20.00 per share. The gross proceeds to Outbrain from the offering, before deducting the underwriting discounts and commissions and offering expenses, are expected to be approximately $160 million. The shares began […]
HubSpot To Support The GO Foundation As Part Of World Certification Week
HubSpot, the customer relationship management (CRM) platform for scaling companies, has announced that as part of its World Certification Week, it is supporting the GO Foundation with its mission to empower young Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people through education. As part of the support, HubSpot will donate $5 for every HubSpot Academy certification awarded […]
Foxtel Appoints Conor Woods To Head Of Pay Per View
Foxtel appoints Conor Woods to head its pay per view. Soon to be inundated with free subs requests at dinner parties.
IntelligenceBank Secures $50M Investment From Five Elms Capital
IntelligenceBank has today announced a strategic growth investment from Five Elms Capital. The $US37 million ($50 million) investment comes as brands and enterprises have realised that outdated technologies, disjointed data sources, and manual processes make it challenging to efficiently manage essential marketing workflows and ensure compliance across the organization. IntelligenceBank digitally transforms manual processes and […]
SCA Announces Ten New Dab Music Stations Via LiSTNR
Southern Cross Austero (SCA) announced today 10 all-new DAB+ music stations on LiSTNr. The introduction of the 10 new Dab stations takes the number of music stations to 25 and reinforces its commitment to growing exclusive music programs and content. The 10 new stations have been created to cater to a variety of moods and […]
SBS Launches Live Interpreting Of Daily NSW COVID-19 Conferences In Vietnamese And Arabic
SBS has launched live interpreting of the daily NSW Government COVID-19 press conference in languages other than English, to provide communities with access to the latest information and critical health messages. The national-first initiative provides real-time interpreting of the press conferences in Arabic and Vietnamese, streamed live every day on the SBS Arabic24 and SBS Vietnamese Facebook pages, SBS […]
