More Than Points? Promotional Lessons From Australian Success Stories

Here’s a task. Think of the two most famous Australian loyalty programs.
We’d be surprised if you didn’t have either FlyBuys or Woolworths Rewards in mind. But are these schemes generating real loyalty?
Aldi recently lashed out at the points programs of Coles and Woolies in an advertising campaign that verbalised the sentiment, “Don’t get sucked in by pointless points. Switch to Aldi and save money instead.” The campaign makes a good point (sorry): supermarkets need more than a points programs to generate and maintain customer loyalty and to beat their competitors.
What is increasingly obvious is that consumers find it hard to conceptualise points and what they can give them. Which is why more and more loyalty programs are turning to prize and cash-based promotions to supplement their existing programs.
Australia’s leading rewards provider, Rewards Come True, knows the power of cash rewards. In her speech at the recent B&T Awards, CEO and founder of Rewards Come True Pat Dalton retold the company’s history, telling the audience that when her company brought Eftpos gift cards to Australia as cash rewards back in 2004, they saw their clients’ campaign results double.

Pat Dalton, CEO and founder of Rewards Come True, delivers her address at the B&T Awards 2018
Their work has taken players like ASUS, AMP, and Shell towards new approaches to incentive and rewards programs. And it looks like supermarkets, too, are moving away from purely points-based loyalty programs.
While it looks like a bloody battle between the two major supermarkets in Australia, there is something remarkably wholesome being used as a weapon: Coles Little Shop – collectable miniatures of Australia’s favourite brands, from Vegemite to Colgate and now, Coles Brand Pavlova.
Yes, it’s back for Christmas – get back in those ‘Swap and Sell’ Facebook groups.
Find a lucky “red hand” (like those that appeared in the “Down, down, prices are down!” ads) and you received a $100 cash prize to be spent on your ensuing Coles shop.
These little loyalty supplements and the potential for cash prizes provide notches in the habit-building process; people went out of their way to shop at Coles, spend that $30 required to get their toy, and it was reflected in their sales figures.
Woolworths even called Coles out as responsible for its less-than-spectacular performance in the same quarter – that and the plastic bag ban.
Whether this is a sustainable move for the company is left up to question. There is always going to have to be that next great promotion.
But at least now Coles know – it’s that joyous pursuit of a tangible or financial reward that drives sales and loyalty.
Some of us may have been surprised by how much we wanted to engage with campaigns like Little Shop, but Dalton isn’t.
“Taking a look at our unique customer spend data, we easily understand that the surprise and delight element these campaigns play with has a broad demographic appeal,” she says.
But the success of Coles’ future campaigns, Dalton adds, is contingent on what it learns from its successes – what and how it learns from the data its users present.
However, Dalton says what make Rewards Come True different is that a promotion never stands alone.
“We see every consumer contact as an opportunity to understand them better – to understand customers even better than they understand themselves,” she says.
“Promotions are a unique opportunity to grow that data pool, improve its quality and to build loyalty in the process.”
So, why doesn’t every brand jump on the promotions train? Well, because they can be complicated. They require distribution, promotional insurance, managing stakeholders and claims.”
Dalton explains how partnership with Rewards Come True has removed these struggles for its clients, dubbing it “the engine room” behind over 2000 leading brands.
To fulfil the thousands of campaigns they run each year, Rewards Come True runs its own mail house and draws on decades of customer experience. Its teams are busily working nigh on 365 days a year so that clients don’t have to be.
When it boils down to it, promotions – both those run by companies like Rewards Come True and supermarkets like Coles – work. And they work because they’re novel; they give us the illusion of a free gift, and they give us a little ray of sunshine in our days.
They send customers back in store (or online) time and time again. Really, what more could a marketer want for Christmas?
Please login with linkedin to comment
Customer Loyalty Loyalty Programs promotional lessons Rewards Come TrueLatest News

Former Webjet Marketing Manager Hayley Rathbone Joins Taguchi
Taguchi is a digital marketing platform. B&T apologises for mistaking it with the Tamagotchi in our earlier reporting.

Nine, John Hewson Settle Defamation Suit On Eve Of Trial
Nine and John Hewson have settled their defamation suit. Yet further proof of the assuaging nature of a large cheque.

Chartered Accountants Celebrates Accountants As ‘Difference Makers’ In Global Campaign Via JOY
Accountants say no need to constantly avoid us at parties in new advertising campaign via independent agency JOY.

Aussie Apples Unveil New Brand Platform Via TBWA Sydney And Atomic 212°
"An apple a day keeps the doctor away!" Well, that definitely wouldn't be the case if an apple tree fell on you.

Freeview Australia Brings Together Free-TV Broadcasters On Integrated HbbTV Service
Freeview Australia attempts to de-murk the rather murky world of television measurement with latest industry tool.

ATTENTION: Nominations Open For B&T’s Inaugural CMO Power List!
B&T's CMO power list is sure to be an industry hot potato! As in controversial, not likely to cause burns & blistering.

adidas Releases Special 4/20 Shoe With A South Park Twist
These adidas/South Park hybrids are set be a hit in trainer-obsessed adland. Although we can't see Sir Martin in a pair.

“Put Vera Back On!” Viewers Fume Over ‘Too Much’ Prince Philip Coverage
Costa Georgiadis assumes the title of the world's most famous Greek following the passing of Uncle Phil on Friday.

Brian White Scholarship Opens For Aspiring Radio News Broadcasters
This scholarship is aimed at aspiring radio news broadcasters, plus you don't need be an opinionated arsehole to enter.

This Is Flow Adds Global Business 1800-GOT-JUNK?
1800-GOT-JUNK may sound like a gay erotic film, however, as you'll learn here it's actually a rubbish removal business.

Five By Five Produces Animation Series For Gigabyte
Arguably animated ads are just another reason not to spend three years in an expensive acting course.

Heinz Launches Limited Edition ‘Footy Ketchup’ Bottles For AFL Fans
Nothing says 'footy' quite like a pie and sauce, does it? That and screaming vile obscenities at your television set.

Network 10 Conducting Company-Wide Culture Review
Network 10 conducting a company-wide culture review. 'Trial By Kyle' repeatedly coming up in a lot of people's answers.

Study: Australians Spend 17 Years In A Lifetime On Phones
Study finds Aussies are spending 17 years on their phones. Double that if you've ever tried phoning a bank's helpline.

The Rise Of The Content Creator & Why Every Brand Needs One
Columnist argues every brand needs to tell a great story. Ideally, not the time it rained on your holiday to The Goldie.

Sunday TV Wrap: Schapelle Gives Dancing With The Stars Its Best Launch Since 2015
Thankfully Schapelle wisely avoided any Cypress Hill or Miley Cyrus for her dancing debut on Seven last night.

How Gen Z Is Tackling Issues Of Diversity With UNiDAYS’ Viviane Paxinos
Here UNiDAYS' Viviane Paxinos talks Gen Z and diversity. A predilection for lower case i's isn't touched on.

How To Balance Fact-Based Decision Making With Trusting Your Intuition
Kay Bretz (main photo), author of Turning Right: Inspire the Magic, is a facilitator of transformation, executive coach, inspirational speaker and ultra-marathon runner in his spare time. In this guest spot, he dissects the merits of the “fact VS gut” instinct debate… Throughout my life I learned that being rationale was paramount. My parents taught […]

WPP AUNZ Reaffirms Guidance Ahead Of Proposed Acquisition By WPP PLC
This peek into WPP AUNZ's numbers is like a trip to H&R Block minus the plastic fern and the musty, damp smell.

WA Marketing Association Launches Under The Brand “We Are WAMA”
The WA Marketing Association will champion WA’s local marketing community.

diptyque And Like Fire Launch ‘A Scent In Song’ Campaign for New Perfume, Orphéon
Admittedly, B&T's trying a bit of cool namedropping in this headline, but not before Googling who they were first.

Enriching Customer Engagement Through AI And Analytics
Does your customer engagement need a bit of a pep & a spring clean? Read on with this Chux-esque read.

Verizon Fios Teases Gamers With ‘Unbreakable’ Gaming Controller Via McCann New York
Top news today if you're always smashing your gaming controller. Or, there's deep breathing exercises & scented candles.

YoPRO Recruits Ash Barty And Host Of Sporting Talent For Olympic Campaign Via Emotive
The gun has fired on the first of the Olympics ads! Expect a bit of national patriotism mixed in with some yogurt here.

Nike Settles Lil Nas X ‘Satan Shoes’ Lawsuit
Satan now reportedly doing rather nicely out of his Nike & Little Lucifer endorsements and trip to Georgia theme song.

Thursday TV Wrap: AFL Punts Seven To An Easy Win
The couch was the place to be for footy fans last night. B&T has no idea what calligraphy or découpage fans were up to.

Hackers Attempt To Sell The Data Of 500M LinkedIn Users
Hackers offering steak knives plus Kerri-Anne Kennerley's memoirs in desperate attempt to shift stolen LinkedIn data.

WARC Study: Highly Awarded Creative Ideas Are Significantly More Effective
Study finds winning industry awards isn't just great for an impressive email signature, they can actually sell shit too.

Poet Amanda Gorman, 23, Stars In Powerful US Vogue Cover
Poet Amanda Gorman stuns in latest Vogue cover and not a brown cardigan or matching corduroy as far as the eye can see.

Val Morgan: Easter Brings Biggest Cinema Audiences Since Pandemic Began
Easter certainly proved 'bums on seats' for the nation's cinemas; ironically, less so for the nation's churches.