Cruelty To Animals Isn’t A Problem In ALDI Christmas Campaign: Ad Standards

Cruelty To Animals Isn’t A Problem In ALDI Christmas Campaign: Ad Standards
SHARE
THIS



ALDI’s Christmas campaign starring the caroling family ‘The Tinkletons’ has come under the watchful eye of the Advertising Standards Board (ASB).

The complaint focused on the 15 second TVC promoting ALDI’s Monsigny Premier Cru Champagne, when in the final few seconds of the advert a cork hits a magpie: “Its disgusting that it seems to say the cork killed the native bird”. 

The campaign, created by BMF, included a series of 30 second and 15 second TVCs, social content, print, radio, OOH and display advertising. Here’s part one and part two of the campaigns.

An ALDI representative gave two reasons why the complaint should be dismissed: “No reasonable viewer would understand the advertisement as portraying an intentional act of harm. On the contrary, it is clear from the context that the man popping the cork had no idea that the cork had hit a bird until the bird falls from sky.

“Secondly, no reasonable viewer would understand the advertisement as literally depicting a cork killing a bird, whether intentionally or otherwise. It is clear from the humorous context that “bird” that falls from the sky is a stuffed animal, and not an actual bird. ALDI can confirm that this was in fact the case.”

The ASB agreed with ALDI, noting the Board dismissed complaints back in 2014 about a Specsavers campaign which showed a man mistaking a seagull for a volleyball:

In the Specsavers ruling, the Board noted “the man does appear to hit the seagull hard but considered that most members of the community would recognise that it was a CGI creation and not a real bird. The focus on a man mistaking a bird for a ball is unlikely to be considered to condone or encourage violence against seagulls or any other animal by most members of the community and is a situation most likely to be considered unlikely and humorous”.

The Board took a similar tone with its ALDI ruling: “The Board noted the advertiser’s response that the bird is a stuffed animal and not an actual bird and considered that most reasonable members of the community would recognise that the bird is not real.

“The Board noted that the scene is accompanied by a warning and considered that there is no suggestion that the man intended to harm a bird with his actions. The Board considered that in the context of a warning in the advertisement about carefully opening a bottle, the suggestion of a cork accidentally hitting a (fake) bird does not depict, encourage or condone violence towards animals.”

Please login with linkedin to comment

INDEPTH Samsung Thinktank Social

Latest News

WPP Q3 Revenues Fall 7.6% YOY
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

WPP Q3 Revenues Fall 7.6% YOY

Work at WPP? Down to the last notch on your belt? Well, expect a little more tightening judging by these numbers.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Inner Health’s Iconic Blue Bugs Are Back In New Brand Platform Via VMLY&R
  • Media

Inner Health’s Iconic Blue Bugs Are Back In New Brand Platform Via VMLY&R

Inner Health has revolutionised its famous blue bugs as part of a new brand platform launching this week.  Developed by VMLY&R, the new platform ‘Listen to your Gut’ re-introduces the bugs in a whole new environment.  VMLY&R Client Service Director Jo Millington said the new platform aimed to reposition Inner Health as an overall health […]

MINT Expands Technology Portfolio With The Addition Of Audio Brand Bang & Olufsen
  • Media

MINT Expands Technology Portfolio With The Addition Of Audio Brand Bang & Olufsen

Insight-led communications consultancy, The Mint Partners has expanded its technology portfolio with the addition of luxury audio lifestyle brand Bang & Olufsen. Founded in 1925 in Struer, Denmark, Bang & Olufsen has pushed the boundaries of audio technology for almost a century. The company continues to be at the forefront of acoustic innovation with its […]

RAC Insurance Tells WA Locals “We See What You See” In New Spot Via Wunderman Thompson
  • Campaigns

RAC Insurance Tells WA Locals “We See What You See” In New Spot Via Wunderman Thompson

WA car and home insurer, RAC has launched a new campaign to show locals that they understand the priceless relationship members have with their belongings. Created by Wunderman Thompson Perth, the campaign titled ‘We See What You See’ uses computer generated imagery (CGI) to depict the unique relationship a family has with their insured items – […]

TPG Telecom Appoints Paper Moose As Creative Agency For New Brand Felix
  • Campaigns

TPG Telecom Appoints Paper Moose As Creative Agency For New Brand Felix

Paper Moose has created a campaign for the recently announced carbon-neutral telco brand, felix, due to go to market towards the end of the year. This is the first work from Paper Moose since winning a competitive pitch for the new TPG Telecom brand. The teaser campaign raises awareness of the nearly 1 million tonnes […]

  • Technology

Why Apple Is Building Up Its Search Engine

Forget the shiny gadgets & skivvies, evidence is mounting that Apple could possibly be the Fourth Order Of The Sith.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine