Social Media Is Dead. Long Live Community!

In this opinion piece, Venessa Paech (pictured below), co-founder of the community management conference Swarm, argues social media isn’t the saviour we’d all once hoped and why it’s now all about the community…
Early champions of social media find ourselves in a tricky spot. As long time advocates of the positive power of social technology, we reflexively spring to defence when someone scapegoats’ social media for the woes of the world.
But the truth is, social media is doing damage, and it’s not solving the problems we hoped it might. Facebook may wind up being the biggest mistake we ever made. So it’s time to get real.
Social media for businesses is still typically used as a broadcast tool. There’s a reason they’re called channels. Even if those businesses are generating plentiful comments and a whopping number of shares… it’s still a media model, using connected audiences to scale. That’s fine. But it’s not a community model, nor is it the best way to affect behaviour. It’s old media in new clothes. Turns out we’re even more resistant to change than we thought. When you apply a media model to relationships, you reduce relationships and engagement to binaries, which creates serious challenges.
We’ve seen the race to the bottom play out, and it’s not pretty. Newer social media managers are particularly vulnerable to demands from organisations asking them to transgress boundaries to get a reaction – any reaction. Stoke a generational debate, play the race card, hot or not. They’re tabloid tactics that have been with us over a century, but they’re no more about meaningful engagement than than they ever were.
Organic reach is virtually zero, sending businesses scrambling to hit targets, throwing money at the problem, meanwhile brand social media managers spend their days gaming algorithms and nursing anxiety about being replaced by bots who could probably work that algorithm just as effectively.
Algorithms that make our lives easier somewhat less conveniently polarise and radicalise. We hand our power to platforms we don’t own whose mechanics are shaped out-of-sight and for profit. The noise gets louder, and we wonder why ‘authenticity’ doesn’t cut it anymore.
But engagement isn’t a straight line or a Like button. Communities are a type of social structure that accommodate the nuances of engagement over time, and don’t reduce people to a click, download or site visit. Instead of arguing in meetings about the dollar value of a Like or tweet, we can proactively create the behaviours and outcomes we’d like to see more of using community approaches. (Outcomes we know how to attribute and value, such as answering questions from other community members, creating original content, or offering considered feedback).
Communities are easily confused with social media. But when it comes to filter-bubbles, there’s no contest. Communities can actively reduce polarisation. The Wikipedia community has been studied at length for its success in promoting less segregated conversations. Communities proactively create culture, and culture ‘sells’ more powerfully than any product offering. Do you have the tools to steer culture on your social channels?
Communities aren’t immune to idiots, but they’re more resilient than social media to disruptors on a mission to derail or attack. Trolls who take on established communities face an army of pushback, not an isolated individual relying on a report button (unlikely to ever reach a fellow human being with context and understanding of that community).
Community managers are engagement professionals who design for the gamut of that engagement over time, as the context demands. They engineer for shared value and desired behaviours, while building for trust and safety. They architect for community knowledge as an asset. Communities can be built within a social network like Facebook, however they butt up against the purpose of that platform (to capture and monetise data). Communities of purpose are flocking to alternatives to build communities on their own terms (and escape the unchecked Ids native to social streams). We crave depth and dimension. The open web seems poised for a comeback.
There are some truly impressive examples of advertising in social media. As a marketing channel, it’s a creative gift. It remains the single most effective transmitter of content at speed across geographies. But for organisations interested in more than a digital age telegraph, the struggle is real. It’s time to revisit the value of OG social – community.
Latest News

Triple J’s Hottest 100: Only A Few Hundred Votes Separate First And Second Place!
Hottest 100 top songs of the year are neck and neck. B&T editor still working out who G Flip and Mallrat are.

Some Funny Bugger Has Stolen Pauline Hanson’s Website And Redirected It To The Refugee Council
It's a safe bet to assume "I don't like it" was uttered a few times up in Queensland this morning.

LinkedIn Launches Jobs Bootcamp To Make “2021 The Year Of Your Career”
B&T's hoping Uber Eats or Diageo will be the next company to launch an all-day Bootcamp.

WhatsApp Takes Out Full-Page Newspaper Ad To Address Privacy Concerns
After spending the last decade sending newspapers broke, Zuckerberg finally decides to throw them a bone with these ads.

Hailey Bieber, Kendall Jenner & Precious Lee Front Latest Versace Campaign
B&T's editor is more of a Lowes than Versace man, but he has been known to sport a colourful kaftan from time to time.

Greg ‘Blewey’ Blewett To Join Bernie And Jars For The Drive Home On Adelaide’s 104.7 Triple M
Adelaide's prodigal son is returning to the airwaves. Greg Blewett that is, not Guy Sebastian.

Lotame Extends New Cookieless ID Solution With Magnite, Sovrn, Eyeota And Advance Local Integrations
Dissapointingly, Lotame not rolling up sleeves and baking double choc cookies, as featured image would suggest.

Landor Australia Rebrands Women’s Tennis Association
Women's Tennis Association undergoes first rebrand in a decade, and not one tennis racket was thrown in a tantrum.

Collingwood Women’s Football Team Partners With AIA Australia
Collingwood women’s football team partners With AIA Australia. B&T hears it was a beautiful ceremony.

“Focus On Paying For Original Content”: Treasurer Slams Google’s Move To Block News Stories
Not one but two stories about Aussie politicians today. No, you're not reading The Guardian.

Integral Ad Science Acquires Amino Payments
Amino Payments joins the IAS family. Hopefully they don't get the middle child treatment.

Volkswagen Unveils Electric SUV, The ID.4, In Stunning Spot ‘The Wheel’ Via Johannes Leonardo
Zoetropes, a praxinoscope, early projectors, and a phenakistoscope have all been used to channel what is considered a monumental moment for carmaker Volkswagen in a new short by Johannes Leonardo. Directed by Sam Brown, the 90-second film ‘The Wheel’ uses some of the oldest devices of motion in film—the Zoetrope (praxinoscope, early projectors, and phenakistoscope)—as […]

ENGINE Group Australia Launches Media Agency
B&T will be extremely disappointed if the agency isn't asking its clients to "Rev the ENGINE" with this move.

DoubleVerify Earns MRC Accreditation For CTV Measurement
DoubleVerify earns this new accreditation which sadly does not come with a gold star or a giant sticker.

Rob Reilly Appointed As WPP Global Chief Creative Officer
Rob Reilly wins the race of WPP global CCO. Although not without a slight Achilles tendon tear, B&T understands.

R/GA Lands Uber Global Social Account As Agency Of Record
R/GA team excited about instantly scoring a 5 star Uber rating following this global win.

Four Celebrities Required Medical Attention Following Crazy Challenge On 10’s I’m A Celeb
I'm A Celeb contestants required medical attention following ice challenge. The water kind, not the hard drug kind.

M&C Saatchi Sport And Entertainment Nabs Richie Butterworth As Head Of Sponsorship
Butterworth begins new role with M&C Saatchi, where brick walls are soon to be painted minimalist white.

“Intentional And By Design”: How Val Morgan Digital Is Positioning Itself As An Advertiser’s Playground
Val Morgan is cementing itself as an advertiser's playground just minus the booze, cocaine and arancini balls.

TikTok Strengthens Protections For Under-18 Users
TikTok users over the age of 30 continue to be protected too, owing to the fact they don't really know how to use it.

Rebel Kitchen Calls Trump An Ass In Hidden Message On Outdoor Ads
As far as names Donald Trump has been called in recent days, 'ass' certainly ranks at the lower end.

Google Australia Set To Bury News Articles For Some Ahead Of News Media Bargaining Code
Google set to start burying certain articles. We're unsure if they will be able to find a big enough shovel.

The Athlete’s Foot Launches 2021 Back To School Campaign
When it comes to the downsides of being a parent, buying $150 shoes that are outgrown within months is right up there.

Brad Pitt Fronts Miraval Rosé’s First-Ever Ad Campaign With A Repurposed Image
If ever there was someone with no need for retouching it would have to be Brad Pitt.

Dentsu’s iProspect To Absorb Vizeum Globally
Dentsu continues to streamline operations with this move. It was either this merger or the coffee machine, staff told.

Nine & Stan Eye Off NBL Rights
On an unrelated note, Hugh Marks spotted practising his alley-oops and free throws at the North Sydney basketball courts.

Creepy Or Convenient?
If B&T's editor could think of a three-word headline for every story he'd be retired by now.

Cannes Confirms Plans To Go Ahead In 2021
Want to sip rosé on the French Riviera while keeping a respectable 1.5m distance from adland's best? Good news today.

OMA Appoints Ipsos To Rebuild MOVE For The Digital Age
Upset at B&T's lately acronym-lite newsletter? This article makes up for it in spades.

Is Moving The Australian F1 Grand Prix to November The Best News The Event (And Its Sponsors) Has Ever Had?
Is the F1 move the best thing to happen to the events industry EVER? It's either that or the invention of the slider.