Monday Bloodbath Follows Black Friday For Dick Smith

Monday Bloodbath Follows Black Friday For Dick Smith
SHARE
THIS



Black Friday is infamous among Americans and the world as one crazy whirlwind of a day for consumers. BrandData CEO Georgie Summerhayes told B&T how brands can shine through the chaos:

Last Friday was Black Friday in the US, the post-Thanksgiving Day sale when Americans buy consumer electronics.

It’s also an entertaining event for those of us who enjoy watching the wrestling at Walmart. This year’s lowest-of-the-low award goes to the woman who was filmed snatching a veggie steamer out of a child’s hands – the YouTube video has more than 7 million views right now.

This, right after the day people are supposed to be thankful for what they have.

Originally an American invention, Black Friday is gaining traction in the UK and now Australia too; Aussies spent an estimated $73 million in Black Friday sales last week – up 166% from 2014.

But the spending spike couldn’t help Dick Smith, whose share price crashed almost 70% on Monday after it announced a $60 million earnings impairment against hard-to-sell inventory.

So where have the ‘Techxperts’ gone wrong? Is it a product issue, a service issue, or a marketing issue?

Well, according to social analytics firm BrandData’s tracking, the fault doesn’t lie with their online marketing.

Georgie Summerhayes

Georgie Summerhayes

Dick Smith is ranked third of all electrical retailers, behind only Harvey Norman and The Good Guys, with an engagement rate of 0.76%. This isn’t crash-hot, but the category as a whole averages only 0.3%.

Hardly surprising. The electrical retailers are serving the public an uninspiring diet of non-stop promotions, competitions to win products, and sales announcements. There is absolutely nothing about their brand proposition or offering — only price cuts.

This doesn’t bode well for the future. If price is their only differentiator, they will surely lose in the battle against the online retailers.

Once upon a time, Dick Smith did have an edge — after-sales service and tech expertise — when you could “Talk to the Techxperts.” But those days are gone.

“The staff know very little if anything about the products they’re selling,” commented ‘Barters’ on News.com.au.

So there’s a service problem. And probably, a product problem too.

“Dick Smith is the Aldi of home electronics,” runs another comment on the same website. “They sell crappy no name TVs, or brand name TVs you can get cheaper elsewhere.”

Still, Dick Smith’s issues could prove to be a good thing for customers, since they’ve announced a 70% off clearance sale this Saturday to clear excess inventory.

We might even get a few funny YouTube videos out of it.

 

Please login with linkedin to comment

Designworks holysmoke! keeping up with the joneses

Latest News

UK Mobile Game Advert Accused Of Condoning Violence Against Women Banned
  • Media

UK Mobile Game Advert Accused Of Condoning Violence Against Women Banned

A now banned ad for mobile game Gold and Goblins features a man readying to strike an unsuspecting woman over the head with a chair. The advert which appeared in the games ‘Hooked Inc: Fishing Games’ and ‘Quizzland’  has been accused of “trivializing and condoning” domestic violence. The Gold and Goblins ad began with a […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Numbers Are Important But Relationships Are Imperative
  • Opinion

Numbers Are Important But Relationships Are Imperative

Hamish Thomson, author of It’s Not Always Right to be Right, is a former regional president and global brand head for Mars Incorporated (UK, Australia, Chicago), a senior sales and marketing lead for Reebok International (England and the Netherlands) and an account exec in the London advertising scene. In this guest post, Thomson says you […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
A Creative’s Top Tips On How To Be A Better Client
  • Opinion

A Creative’s Top Tips On How To Be A Better Client

In this guest post, Tim Dyroff (main photo), creative director at Resolution Design, talks what things should a prospective client consider when building relationships with their creative partners… Within the post-production industry you can be sure you will encounter the good, the bad, and the ugly with any given client. From feedback to briefing, issues […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
The Gerety Awards Announce All-Star Jury For 2022
  • Media

The Gerety Awards Announce All-Star Jury For 2022

The Gerety Awards have announced an all-star jury lineup for 2022, including Australia’s own Tara Ford. The annual awards are the only creative prize to reward the best in advertising from the female vision. The jury for 2022 includes some of the most respected leaders from the advertising and marketing world. Representing Australia on the […]

GAY TIMES And Grey London Launch New Campaign To Support Trans Rights
  • Campaigns

GAY TIMES And Grey London Launch New Campaign To Support Trans Rights

GAY TIMES and Grey London have launched Amplifund campaign, ‘Incomplete Without the T’ at GAY TIMES Honours in response to increased transphobia and hate in the global media. This year has become the deadliest on record for trans people, with the community increasingly facing transphobia and hate from both the media and right-wing groups. Controversial […]

Podium Announces Australia’s ‘Most Loved Local Businesses’
  • Campaigns

Podium Announces Australia’s ‘Most Loved Local Businesses’

Local businesses communication and payments platform, Podium, and Council of Small Businesses Organisations of Australia (COSBOA) has today announced the winners of Australia’s Most Loved Local Businesses, which includes a specialised biking store and a stigma-busting dental practice. The campaign aimed to shine the spotlight on a handful of vibrant, dynamic and innovative Australian businesses following an […]

Decoding Creativity And Effectiveness
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns
  • Media

Decoding Creativity And Effectiveness

Spikes Asia talks with chief creative officer at Performance Art, Ian Mackenzie (main photo), about his Spike award winning campaign, ‘Publicly Traded’… When creativity is effective and effective work is creative, it has even greater power to positively impact people, brands and the world. Spikes Asia brings weekly insights from award winning creators of inspiring […]

UnLtd Announces Open Applications For 2022 ‘Ambassador For Good’ Program
  • Media

UnLtd Announces Open Applications For 2022 ‘Ambassador For Good’ Program

UnLtd and Yahoo’s inaugural Ambassador for Good program has come to a close for 2021, with the call for applications being sent out for next year. From over 80 applicants, 16 individuals from across the industry were selected into the launch initiative to use their skills and networks for good. Over the past year, the […]