Is Google Pulling Out Of Australia? There’s A Lot At Stake Amid The Threats & Bluffs!

Google’s feud with the Australian government has not only dominated news headlines for the past few weeks but overseas observers are keenly watching on to see who’ll blink first.
In one corner, treasurer Josh Frydenberg is pushing his News Media Bargaining Code that would see Google pay for using locally produced news content and see the tech giant invoiced upwards of $1 billion a year.
On the other side, the tech behemoth is threatening to shutter its local operations and take its reported $53 billion worth of value to the local economy with it.
Google’s fear, arguably, is that if it happens here it can happen anywhere and follows news from mid-January that its Silicon Valley chiefs had agreed to pay major French publishers for linking to their content.
Over the weekend, Canadian authorities labelled Australia’s plan the “perfect solution” to its very own Google woes. So, it’s clear the dominoes are starting to line up.
So will Google make good on its threats and pack its bags and head to Sydney airport? And if it were to, where would that leave agencies and their clients?
One keen industry observer of the ongoing – and it’s been ongoing – ding-dong is Nick Beck (main photo), CEO of Sydney-based digital performance marketing agency Tug.
For Beck, one of the more unusual aspects of the government’s decision to take on a company said to be worth an estimated $US280 billion, that operates in 200 countries, is the enormous benefit it brings to SMEs in Australia.
“The risk to Australia here is pissing off all the small businesses [if Google were to leave] and I think ScoMo would be aware of that. Small businesses do very well out of the tech giants – Google and Facebook – in terms of their advertising,” Beck told B&T.
“The argument you hear from the likes of News Corp and the government is that Google has been destroying regional newspapers through local advertising. But actually that’s not entirely true. And by that, I mean that the Google/Facebook advertising model is just better for smaller business – more targeted and more efficient. Australia would be doing small businesses a disservice to get rid of Google, in my opinion,” he added.
“Josh Frydenberg’s argument is that these tech giants are making money off the back of great journalism – and there’s a global argument for that. And it kinda feels that the writing is on the wall for that, that Google will have to pay something. The question is how much and what for?” he said.
Where the debate gets murkier, Beck adds, is that Murdoch’s News Corp has railed against the tech giants’ power for some time and the government pressing its News Media Bargaining Code could be seen by many as a way of getting more favourable coverage in News Corp-owned media.
It’s often argued that Google killed off regional newspapers in Australia; however, the real irony here, according to Beck, is that one of the probable culprits in Australia was the News-owned Realestate.com.au and the Nine-owned Domain, which eroded regional property advertising revenues.
“That said, the last thing Google wants is a western democracy shutting it down, telling the world that they can function without Google,” Beck added.
“And all this brings Microsoft’s Bing into the picture, the 11th most popular website in the world.
“Tug has done tests with Bing in the Australian market and it’s results are on par with Google in the major client verticals, however Bing’s local business offering is not as sophisticated as Google’s. Yahoo (remember Yahoo?) still has an offering in Japan and could potentially make inroads in Australia if Google disappeared.
“The third option is that Apple could come in and go, ‘I’ll take advantage of this.’ The rumours are that Apple’s starting a search engine and if Google pulled out Apple could do a deal with the Australian government and walk straight in.
“And this is why I think Google is bluffing over its threats to exit Australia,” Beck added. “Sure, we’re a small market for them but the risk for Google is that other markets – say Europe or Canada – if they saw that Australia could function fine without Google then that would be a huge concern for them.”
Another problem for the Australian market is that Google has about 95 per cent of all search functionality here, making them virtually a monopoly. “And I don’t think anyone thinks that less competition is a good thing,” Beck added. “Even in the US, Bing has about 20 per cent [of the search market].
“Again for agencies and their clients it’s obviously better to have more tools to be able to market, that there’s not one person you have to rely on,” he said.
Another issue for Google if it were to exit our shores is that it uses Australia as a test market, Beck revealed.
“Australia is a bit of a sandbox for Google, it can test new betas in an English-speaking country which mirrors American user habits.
“They know that Australians search and act and think in a very similar way to Americans and that means Australia – and this is good news for agencies and clients – is more advanced than a lot of other countries when it comes to digital innovation,” he said.
As the war of words drags on, ultimately what does Beck think will happen?
“I think Google leaving Australia is the worst outcome for everybody concerned. I see this ultimately being negotiated.
“The Australian government is saying ‘You must pay for everything’ and Google is saying if that happens, we’ll pull out. There has to be some sort of agreement made. This needs to be much more than the federal government kowtowing to the wishes of Nine and News. But Google will have to come to the party, too,” he said.
Latest News

Creating Efficiencies in the Age of Consumer Privacy
In this opinion piece, Jess Miles, Country Manager ANZ of Integral Ad Science, reflects on the questions surrounding consumer data. The ability to collect consumer data online has revolutionised digital advertising by enabling customised targeting strategies and data collection. This reliance on data has been the cornerstone of many audience targeted strategies enabling marketers to […]

Jye Smith Named President Of Vibewire Board
After ten years of board leadership of the young entrepreneurial collective Vibewire, Founder & Co-CEO of Disruptors Co. Gavin Heaton is passing the torch to fellow strategy and creative leader Jye Smith, Founder and Director of branding and design studio DOUBLESTAR CO, who will now take over as Board President.

The Peers Project And Alibaba Group Launch Entrepreneur Podcast Series, ‘The Build Up’
There are now so many podcasts in the world that it would take the average person 98.9 years to find an interesting one.

AnalogFolk Promotes Two Senior Staff
AnalogFolk has promoted two senior staff, but not promoted enough to secure a spot in the downstairs carpark.

“Destroying The World!”: Confusion Reigns As Mr Potato Head Goes Gender Neutral
Mr Potato Head goes gender neutral. Barbie apparently happy she's no longer the most marginalised one in the toy aisle.

New Mercedes G-Class Campaign From Akkurat Studios Makes A “Pointe”
B&T arrived to work this morning in a chauffeured Mercedes-Benz. Well "chauffeur/government bus driver", same thing.

Kia Selects Cartelux To Spearhead Dealer Ad Technology
It's not one but four motoring articles today, dear readers. Call it coincidence as B&T really knows nothing about cars.

‘Woka-Cola’: Trump Supporters Boycott Coca-Cola Over Anti-Racism Seminar
Trump supporters are calling for a Coke ban in the US. However, it remains doubtful if that will grow their teeth back.

Dear God! Triple J Books Return Of OG Wiggles For Like A Version
It's all hot potato and big red cars in the B&T office this morning. Scottish staffer reconsiders visa application.

Thursday TV Wrap: MAFS Hands Nine The Win On A Quiet Night
Last night's TV numbers again appeared to confirm that after 15 years still nobody's watching Bondi Rescue.

Twenty-Seven Year Old Australian Margaret Zhang Appointed Editor Of Vogue China
Who doesn't love to see Aussies doing well on the world stage! Okay, maybe not Schapelle Corby or Mel Gibson.

VOZ Insights: “Television Is Now An Everywhere, Multi-Device Medium”
Only Jesus' second coming and the next Guns N Roses album officially taking longer than the arrival of VOZ.

Australian CDP Lexer Raises $33.5M In Funding
Lexer, the Customer Data Platform for brands and retailers, today announced it has raised AU$33.5 million in Series B funding, bringing its total funding to AU$43 million. The round was led by Blackbird Ventures and King River Capital, with Series A investor January Capital also participating. Blackbird’s Rick Baker will join the Lexer board. The […]

CHE Proximity Unveils Latest Work For eBay
These new eBay ads have an eerie sense of déjà vu. Worse, a not overly funny déjà vu either.

Thrive PR + Communications Makes Multiple Hires Across Sydney & Melbourne
Thrive PR has announced a string of new hires, none of whom chain smokes or swigs from a Stoli bottle.

Peroni’s Zero Alcohol Beer Partners With Aston Martin, Ahead Of Its Formula One Return
Problem with zero alcohol beers is it's all the urine but without the embarrassing one-night stands of full-strength.

Pepsi Brings Messi, Pogba And Sancho To Life In Bubbly New Campaign
B&T's shamelessly namedropping in this headline. Unless you've no idea who they are, then just move to the next article.

Chief Of Cherokee Nation Calls For Jeep To Retire Vehicle Name: “It’s Time”
Do you own a Jeep Cherokee? Well, watch it instantly devalue by a good 10 grand by simply reading this.

Women’s Lifestyle Media Company The Grace Tales Acquired By AllBright
Local women's lifestyle media company receives what all publishers are looking for - a large cheque in an acquisition.

Martech Myths: Why Most Organisations Waste Ninety-Five Per Cent Of Their Software Capabilities
This expert columnist is debunking martech myths. Including the one about Salesforce making you pregnant.

Net Profit Up 60% For Southern Cross Austereo On The Back Of Leaner Operating Model
Southern Cross Austereo's profits up 60%! Which certainly made interviewing Grant Blackley today a lot less awkward.

Cummins&Partners Welcomes PR Agency Romano Beck, Bringing Creative, Media and PR Under One Roof
Cummins&Partners has welcomed Romano Beck, who may sound like a swarthy Italian actor but is actually a PR agency.

CarsGuide Partners With Mitsubishi, Wavemaker To Create Virtual Road Trips
CarsGuide, Mitsubishi and Wavemaker create virtual road trips that includes virtual car sickness.

Petition To Ban Same-Sex Kiss In Cadbury Crème Egg Ad Garners 56,000 Signatures
Cadbury Crème Eggs join Durex condoms & Frankie Goes To Hollywood on list of things Christians find hard to swallow.

Future of TV Advertising Conference: Times Are Tough, But We’re All In This Together
B&T's reporting live from today's Future Of TV event. Not before mistakenly going to the dental hygienist conference.

TV Will Not Only Build Your Brand, It Will Get Your Cash Registers Ringing
There can be no denying TV's power as an advertising medium. Putting aside Holey Moley and Plate Of Origin, that is.

TikTok Continues To Fight COVID Misinformation
Current COVID misinformation includes the vaccine can make you pregnant while developing a Lionel Richie addiction.

Wednesday TV Wrap: 10’s The Cube Debuts To 567,000, Gives MAFS A Little Hickey
B&T's delivering all of last night's TV numbers, dipped in chocolate, rolled in coconut, with a tasty jam-filled centre.

As Bruce Springsteen Is Cleared Of Drunk Driving Charge, Jeep Resumes Use Of Super Bowl Ad
With the Springsteen saga dealt with, Jeep now turns its focus to Michelle Bridges as its next brand ambassador.

WPP AUNZ’s Unveils 32.6% Profit Drop For 2020, Revenues down 14.1%
WPP AUNZ's results out today made for some pretty sobering reading. That's why B&T read them with a couple of daiquiris.