Why Instagram’s Algorithmic Feed Will Suck
Instagram recently announced it would make changes to its algorithm to show users posts they “care about most” first (although have since backtracked until further notice). In this opinion piece, digital content writer for Optus Lucy Soares-Smith tells us how she really feels about the proposal.
In the famous words of Bert Lance, “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” That’s the sentiment echoed by two of Instagram’s darlings, Kendall and Kylie Jenner, after the photo-sharing app announced it was to begin rolling out a new algorithmic feed.
Instead of photos appearing in a chronological order, Instagram would push the posts it thinks you want to see most to the top of your feed, based on what you’ve liked or commented on in the past.
Last week, the social network was forced to backtrack after receiving considerable backlash and published a tweet saying they wouldn’t be rolling out any changes just yet. If you ask me, that’s a smart move because the algorithm would suck and this is why.
My old boss is terrified that robots are going to take over the world and kill us all. Should he be worried? Maybe. Robots and computers have learnt how to walk, talk and even speak like humans but the simple fact remains, they cannot *think* like humans (yet).
With this in mind, how can an app truly tell what I want to see on my Instagram feed based just on past photos I’ve liked or commented on? I follow plenty of people whose photos I enjoy looking at but rarely double tap or leave a comment. Does that mean I don’t want to see them? No.
Likewise, there are the cringe-worthy couply photos my friends put up that I feel I have to like, for fear of looking mean or unsupportive. Do I want to see a post-coital bedroom selfie from my mate? Umm not really. Have I liked this type of photo in the past? Yes.
So riddle me this Instagram, how can you really tell what photos I want to see at the top of my feed? You can’t – because you’re an app.
On the date the algorithm was supposed to drop, my Insta feed was a flurry with anxious pleas from celebs, brands and bloggers begging followers to turn on their notifications in order to continue seeing their content.
People were worried that Instagram would become like Facebook, where organic reach is nil and the only way your content will be seen is if you pay for it to be.
I guess enforcing an algorithm is Instagram’s way of monetising the platform and ensuring big brands now pay for the free marketing they’ve been enjoying up until now. All this does however, is force out mid-level content creators like bloggers, vloggers and photographers who create beautiful content but can’t afford to pay for it to be seen.
Facebook has proved that monetising social media doesn’t make for better content and that algorithms just don’t work.
By enforcing a similar system, Instagram would completely lose its “insta” appeal and go the way of the dinosaur (that’s Facebook FYI); filled with annoying, irrelevant ads and posts from people I was “friends” with in middle school and whose status I maybe liked once (when drunk) but now they keep appearing in my feed.
Finally, there’s simply no need for an algorithm on Instagram because the follow button already allows me to choose what I want to see. If I like an account, I follow it. If I decide later on that I’m not that interested in their content any more, I unfollow.
I don’t need to turn on a hundred push notifications because I’ve already chosen what content I want to see by following that person’s account. And while we’re on the subject of push notifications – I don’t even have them on for my own photos, let alone turning them on for every Tom, Dick and Harry Styles I follow.
For now it seems Instagram is listening to the masses so we’re not going to see that algorithmic feed just yet. I’m hopeful they understand that chronology is the last cornerstone of the little guy but I won’t hold my breath and believe things will stay that way forever.
Lucy Soares-Smith (@lucy_vss) is a self-confessed Instagram addict and digital content writer at @Optus.
Please login with linkedin to comment
algorithm einsights Gameshow media agency Online ads prince charles SensoryLab The Smith FamilyLatest News
Today’s The Day! Announcing The Winners From The 2021 Snapchat Young Lions Competition
Here we have it: all the winners for this year’s 2021 Snapchat Young Lions Competition. The Misfits Media Company, proud official representatives of the Cannes Lions Festival in Australia, is delighted to share the winners for this prestigious award. After presenting their second-round pitches, all the shortlisted candidates were evaluated by 50 esteemed industry judges. […]
IAB’s MeasureUp To Return In 2021
IAB Australia has announced that the MeasureUp conference will return for its fifth year on 27th October and is seeking submissions for smart and engaging speakers, sessions or workshops from Australia’s media and marketing industry. As investment in digital advertising continues to outpace the rest of the media sector representing two-thirds of the paid advertising market, […]
iProspect Revamps Sydney Leadership Team
Oliver Rapson, CEO iProspect Australia, announces today the appointment of three new executives and a promotion from within.
Google Maps Out Return To Office
It appears free breakfast, lunch & dinner, slippery dips, bean bags & escape pods not enough to lure Google staff back.
All The Goss On ARN And SCA’s Quarterly Results
B&T's industry leading financial reporter has downloaded ARN's & SCA's numbers off the ASX & cut n pasted them here.
Go Transit Expands In Sydney As OOH Demand Increases
Judging by Gladys' press conference this morning, news that Sydney OOH demand is on the rise may be a tad premature.
Admix In-Play Advertising To Be Verified For The First Time By IAS
In-Play advertising platform Admix has announced a new partnership with Integral Ad Science (IAS). This integration with IAS makes Admix the only In-Play advertising company to offer ad inventory that is measured and verified by a trusted, independent partner. This ground-breaking news means that the quality of Admix’ In-Play advertising is independently assessed and verified […]
For Mother’s Day, NIVEA And Publicis Celebrate The Mums Who Welcomed Their Kids Back Home
Nothing says "Mum, those crow's feet desperately need working on" quite like a gift from the Nivea moisturiser range.
How to Operate at Scale – Without Missing the Human Touch
This columnist says you need to stand out where ever you show up. High vis or poor personal hygiene not among ideas.
ADMA Launches Cookie Masterclass
ADMA has launched a cookie masterclass that B&T understands isn't modelled on Sydney Fish Markets Cooking School.
Tourism Australia Urges Aussies To Take An Epic Holiday In New $9m Campaign Via M&C Saatchi
Tourism Australia urges Aussies to take an epic holiday. So that apparently rules out Adelaide and Launceston.
Tinder Launches Season Two Of Branded Content Series ‘Love Songs’
On the downside, COVID's put the kybosh on Tinder dates. That's also an upside if you've ever been on a Tinder date.
“Mr Trump Created An Environment Where A Serious Risk Of Violence Was Possible”: Facebook Upholds Donald Trump Ban
In bad news for the sale of tear gas, water canons & truncheons, Facebook's blocked the former leader of the free world.
Jockey Announces Ambassadors For Australian Olympic And Paralympic Games
Want to spend a motza on a brand sponsorship no one even gets to see? Feel sorry for this underpants CMO.
Men’s Health Organisation Movember Encourages Men To Catch-Up In MAYEIGHT Campaign
Movember encouraging blokes to reconnect on May the 8th. Just lay off the gin and wondering where your life went.
Fashion Photographer Scott Ehler Collaborates With The Children’s Tumour Foundation Australia In New Campaign
The Children’s Tumour Foundation (CTF) has teamed up with international fashion photographer and industry veteran Scott Ehler, to develop a striking campaign that aims to shine a light on a lifelong, genetic condition called Neurofibromatosis (NF). Progressive and unpredictable, NF causes tumours to form on nerves in the body, including the brain and spine. In […]
Wallabies Find A New Sponsor In The Form Of eToro
Wallabies unveils new sponsor, as both Kev's Mower Repairs at Greenacre and Miranda's Erotic Massage pull the pin.
Dairy Australia Partners With Airbnb In First initiative From Newly Appointed PR, Haystac dentsu
Dairy Australia announces partnership with Airbnb in worrying news for lactose intolerant holidaymakers.
Kathmandu Relaunches Brand For First Time In 30 Years Via Special Group
If you'd seen the hill B&T has to climb to our local, it's very surprising we don't wear more Kathmandu.
Sitecore Acquires Moosend
Sitecore has acquired Moosend. B&T unsure who ended up with the front part.
George Clooney Shows The Love For Brad Pitt In Wonderfully Whacky Ad For Charity Organisation
This ad will be the best four-minutes of your day. Unless you got sex this morning, that will be the best four minutes.
Wednesday TV Wrap: Nine News And Seven News In Ratings Stand-Off
COVID outbreaks continuing to prove a boon for nightly news programs. Less so for packed trains and swingers parties.
electriclimefilms And Riot Games Launch League of Legends: Wild Rift With New Campaign
The lively spot takes its inspiration from the neighbourhood streets of the Middle East and asks the audience: “who would you call when challenged to a Wild Rift tournament?”
WPP & Microsoft Partner With Cloud Platform That Allows Content To Be Made Anywhere In The World
Software lets creative teams make content from anywhere! So expect the next Coles "prices are down" ad to be in Hindi.
Ita Buttrose Raises Concerns Over ABC Board Selection
If there are two people you don't want to f@ck off in this industry it's Ita and Ita's nephew.
Francis Coady Named Havas’ Group CMO
Francis Coady named Havas' Group CMO. Allegedly softening his stance surrounding the whole "Frank in the office" thing.
Ads Going Unnoticed: 82% Of Australian Shoppers Ignore Targeted Ads
Study finds 82% of Aussie shoppers ignore targeted ads. On the upside, some 18% are buying extra shit they didn't need.
Why Prioritising Mail Is Key To Reaching Your Customers
There are few thrills quite like getting a crisp 50 in a birthday card in the mail. The gas bill less thrilling.
Menulog Transforms Cadillac Lowrider Into The Ultimate Macca’s Delivery Whip
Nothing says stinging hangover on Sunday morning like Menulog, Macca's & not giving a stuff about the $20 delivery fee.
Adland Veteran Vijay Solanki Launches Parenting App ParentalEQ
Here's a great initiative from a good friend of B&T's, Vijay Solanki. Who did pull a few favours to get this up.
