Should hashtags be banned from TV ads?

Should hashtags be banned from TV ads?
SHARE
THIS



Hashtags have been creeping in local TV ads lately. As I sit through these ads, I often find myself asking: “What do they expect me to do here? Jump on Twitter and spread the word on their brand new product? Why would I or anyone?”

The sudden appearance of hashtags in TV ads has been awkward at the best of times.  This made me wonder: were hashtags ever meant to be used in TV ads? And if they were, when do they work best?

American developer and UX designer Chris Messina is credited for the (brilliant) invention of the hashtag. His original intent was (in his own words) to improve “contextualization, content filtering and exploratory serendipity within Twitter”.

In other words, Messina wanted to make it easy for Tweeters to find, join or simply “eavesdrop” on social conversations. There is no evidence that his bigger plan at the time was for the pound sign to spill offline onto other media.

Yet, if you occasionally watch TV like me, you may have noticed that hashtags have started creeping in TV ads. And perhaps like me also, each time one shows up, you may wonder why anyone would want to start or join a conversation around the ad, or the product it promotes, using that particular hashtag.

More often than not, hashtags in local TV ads look like they were slapped on as an after-thought, with no to little context to what they mean or what their purpose is.

Brands and agencies are visibly hoping that viewers simply thrilled by what they have just seen will drop whatever they are doing at the time, and in a flash take to Twitter or Facebook to banter about it.

The most likely behavior however – as most instinctive and prevalent – is that they will take to Google to search for the brand or product name they have just seen – that is if they are interested and want to find out more about it. For most viewers however, a hashtag with no context or incentive will trigger little if any response at all.

A recent example of an ill-thought-out campaign hashtag is the one seen a few weeks ago in the TV ads for the launch of Magnum 5 Kisses, Unilever’s new Limited Edition ice cream. The various TV edits mention the #Magnum5kisses hashtag.

Twitter and Facebook are the natural destinations for social TV banter. With this in mind, I searched both networks for #Magnum5Kisses to see whether the campaign hashtag had caught on at all.

Results were underwhelming to say the least and, probably fair to say, not what Unilever had hoped for.

Twitter returned just under 20 tweets and not all tweets were from consumers… Facebook returned no results due the lack of recent posts… In a final attempt to uncover some campaign-related buzz, I took to Instagram. There I found a total of 686 posts mentioning the hashtag, not all from Australian users and some visibly the result of a hashtag hijacking by a self-loving attention-seeking user.

Why did the #Magnum5kisses hashtag fail to catch on during the campaign?

Critically, this ad was never designed with the intent to trigger a social conversation and engage the audience in the first place.

As it happens, the hashtag seen in the Australian versions of the ad was most likely introduced in post-production locally. You can check the original TVC produced by Spanish agency Lola below– no hashtag in sight.

The ad is also not word-of-mouth worthy – a new ice cream range is hardly riveting stuff or breaking new grounds; the ad doesn’t feature anyone famous and isn’t funny. All in all, it isn’t designed to be viral (unlike the excellent 2013 #DancePonyDance ad for UK mobile network Three).

Simply, unless you give your audience a compelling reason to participate in your hashtag conversation, they just won’t.

For recent best-in class examples, I settled on this year’s Super Bowl TV ads. The clear winner this year was Esurance with its #EsuranceSave30 campaign.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NWAzi8w1HD0&feature=youtu.be

The insurer prides itself in being “built to save”. True to its brand mission, it went on to save US$1.5M (i.e. 30%) by strategically booking the first TV spot after the end of the game. Naturally, it wanted all Americans to know about it and made sure of it by offering to give it all back to one lucky winner through a contest on Twitter. Entering the mega prize competition was as simple as posting a tweet (any tweet) with the campaign hashtag to be eligible. Not surprisingly, it became the most talked about brand of the game with 200, 000 entries in the first minute of the ad going on air and the hashtag trending as #1 worldwide shortly after.

Critical to the success of this campaign was the prize give-away – and what a prize that was – but most importantly the fact that the ad gave the audience a simple yet robust reason to participate.

With all of this in mind – should hashtags be banned from TV ads?

Clearly not. As seen with Esurance and other successful case studies, they can be one of the key enablers of a campaign success.

Also, with social TV participation on the rise in Australia, this represents a great opportunity for brands to engage with their audience in new and interesting ways, and generate much-needed brand love – that is as long as it is done effectively.

Perhaps, instead, TV networks could help champion best practice by rejecting TV ads every time they fail to use hashtags correctly. Just a thought.

Cecile Ferre is a digital marketing consultant. Passionate about digital marketing, she writes about its development and future direction. You can follow her via email at http://www.digitalfabriq.com or on Twitter at @digitalfabriq .

Please login with linkedin to comment

News of the World Tablets The Smith Family

Latest News

Nike And Uber Compromised In Hack As Twitter Disables Verified Accounts
  • Technology

Nike And Uber Compromised In Hack As Twitter Disables Verified Accounts

Twitter was forced to make the unprecedented decision to disable the ability of verified accounts to send tweets following a major hack. The hack saw Barack Obama, Joe Biden, Bill Gates, Elon Musk, Kanye West and Michael Bloomberg attempting to fool their millions of followers with a Bitcoin scam. As well as these major political […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Studio microphone for recording podcasts over blue background
  • Media

Acast Marketplace Adds Virtual Storefront

Acast Marketplace now has a virtual storefront. Advertisers can browse Acast’s global inventory of thousands of monetizable podcasts, and use search criteria to filter a list of shows that best fit their brief and budget. Filters include audience demographics such as age, gender and language, podcast subject categories, and more — and, once selected, the […]

Princess Polly Appoints Jaywing To Drive Global Expansion With SEO Account Win
  • Marketing

Princess Polly Appoints Jaywing To Drive Global Expansion With SEO Account Win

Data science led marketing agency, Jaywing, has won the SEO account for online fashion retailer, Princess Polly, in both Australia and the United States, adding to its ever-growing eCommerce portfolio. The Sydney based agency will be managing the retailer’s search engine optimisation, with the aim of facilitating the brands growth in Australia and the US, […]

Connect Agency Launches Micro Influencer Booking Agency
  • Advertising

Connect Agency Launches Micro Influencer Booking Agency

The Connect Agency has just announced the launch of their micro influencer booking agency, Connect Engage. The division will represent digital content creators in the kids and family; interiors; and health and wellness spaces to drive brand engagement and reach further. Connect Engage will work alongside the public relations, creative, and talent representation arms of […]

Processed with VSCO with  preset
  • Marketing

Bernard Wilson To Lead Cashrewards

Cashrewards, today announced the appointment of experienced loyalty, data, digital marketing and ecommerce executive Bernard Wilson as its Chief Executive Officer. Wilson previously ran loyalty, data, media and marketplace for Myer and was a senior executive in loyalty and data at WooliesX. He joins from data science and artificial intelligence leader Quantium, where he was […]

Network 10’s Moira Hogan To Lead Australia BritBox, Richard Hill To Lead Marketing & PR
  • Media

Network 10’s Moira Hogan To Lead Australia BritBox, Richard Hill To Lead Marketing & PR

As BritBox escalates its plans to launch in Australia later this year, joint venture partners BBC Studios and ITV announce the appointment of Moira Hogan as Country Manager. Tasked with leading the BritBox Australia strategy and team, Moira joins from Network 10, where she was Head of Content and Commercial Partnerships for Digital Media.  She […]

Bean Body Launches ‘Be Any Body’ Campaign
  • Campaigns

Bean Body Launches ‘Be Any Body’ Campaign

Australian Energetic Beauty brand, Bean Body today launches its new campaign #BEANYBODY that breaks convention by featuring every bodies. Captured by Steven Chee and styled by Marina Didovich, with hair by Anthony Nader and makeup by Max May, the campaign features the completely unretouched new faces of Bean Body – 12 inspiring everyday women who […]

Media Platform Cannabiz Launches For The Burgeoning Legal Cannabis Market
  • Media

Media Platform Cannabiz Launches For The Burgeoning Legal Cannabis Market

A new media platform servicing Australia’s burgeoning legal cannabis industry launches today. Cannabiz is the brainchild of Mumbrella co-founder and former CEO Martin Lane and KlickX founder Kim McKay. It will inform, educate and connect Australia’s legal cannabis sector through its website weekly newsletter, podcast, market intelligence, industry reports, networking events and business consulting services. As […]

Courier holding package and tablet while male customer is signing receipt for his home delivery parcel.
  • Technology

Medallia Partners With Adobe To Deliver Complete View Of Customer Experience Journey

Medallia today announced an integration between Medallia Experience Cloud and Adobe Experience Platform (AEP) that gives brands comprehensive insights into the complete customer journey to deliver highly personalised real-time experiences that increase purchase frequency. Customer feedback from Medallia Experience Cloud seamlessly integrates with behavioral data in Adobe Experience Cloud to deliver a single view of […]

How Marketers Can Avoid ‘Overcooking’ The Storytelling Process
  • Media

How Marketers Can Avoid ‘Overcooking’ The Storytelling Process

“As marketers, we tend to overcook the storytelling process.” That was the message from Carlton and United Breweries head of creative and production Jonathon Bernard, during a special B&T Webinar on Storytelling at Scale, presented in partnership with Shutterstock. “Successful storytelling is the ability for a story to resonate and connect with its audience. As […]

New Leader Boosts oOh!’s Queensland Sales Team
  • Media

New Leader Boosts oOh!’s Queensland Sales Team

oOh!media’s Queensland market position is set to be bolstered with the appointment of former ARN Sales Director Jamie Wood as the new leader of its Queensland sales team. An experienced and respected industry figure, Wood will enhance the capabilities of the local sales team while delivering strategic leadership and building customer relationships across the portfolio. […]

New Research Shows Echo Chambers Present An Opporunity For Brands To Escape The Sea Of Sameness
  • Media

New Research Shows Echo Chambers Present An Opporunity For Brands To Escape The Sea Of Sameness

New research has examined the role of echo chambers in Australia and their impact on society, media and brands, offering guidance to marketers on how to escape the sea of sameness surrounding their industry. The independent study conducted by the human and cultural strategy team of FiftyFive5 and Nine’s marketing solutions division, Powered, examined the […]