Dr Elaine Stead Wins $280k Damages In Defamation Suit Against The AFR’s Joe Aston

Dr Elaine Stead Wins $280k Damages In Defamation Suit Against The AFR’s Joe Aston

Venture capitalist Dr Elaine Stead sued the Australian Financial Review and their columnist Joe Aston for defamatory statements, which included calling her a “feminist cretin”.

The Sydney Federal Court has ruled that Dr Stead must receive $280, 000 in aggravated and ordinary damages based on comments Aston made in in 2019. Defamatory remarks were found in two of Aston’s Rear Window columns and in one tweet.

Dr Stead was previously a venture capitalist at Blue Sky Alternative Investments. Among his criticisms, Aston said she “made stupid investments” and “set fire to other people’s money”.

The defence pleaded “honest opinion”, with Aston arguing that the comments reflected his actual opinion at the time. He cited tweets that Dr Stead made during Blue Sky’s suspension from trading in 2019.

In his ruling, Justice Michael Lee asserted that, “the targeted campaign of offensive mockery of Dr Stead was unjustified and improper”.

He also said that while “what occurred at Blue Sky was a legitimate (indeed, one might think important) matter of public interested – especially for a newspaper life AFR”, an opinion “needs to be properly based on facts stated in what is written or be otherwise evident”.

Dr Stead’s barrister, Sue Chrysanthou, SC, said in her opening statement that, “there aren’t many high-profile female venture capitalists”. She argued that “Mr Aston targeted my client because she is a woman” and that the purpose of the columns was to humiliate Dr Stead. Chrysanthou is one of Sydney’s most well-known defamation lawyers, having previously won a defamation case for actor Geoffrey Rush.

In his judgement, Justice Lee acknowledged that Joe Aston is a “talented and oftentimes highly entertaining wordsmith”. Aston is well-known for his colourful attacks on businesspeople, politicians and celebrities.

In 2015, he described Darren Davidson, media editor of The Australian as “staggeringly incompetent” and a “village idiot”. In 2018, Liberal MP Julie Bishop was described as a “pioneer of fashion diplomacy, now beyond reproach, her popularity absolution for her vacuity.”

In one of his columns, Aston likened Dr Stead to Brick Tamland, a character from the film Anchorman described as having “an IQ of 48”.

Justice Lee concluded that Dr Stead “was being seriously mocked by Australia’s leading financial daily” and that she experienced a “high degree of subjective harm”.

Originally Dr Stead, was seeking $421, 000 in damages. A spokesperson for AFR said in a statement that the legal fees were more than $2 million on both sides.

AFR continues to defend Aston and stated that “expensive and disproportionate defamation cases like this have a chilling effect on freedom of speech”. They also cited the proposed reforms to the Defamation Act to defend public interest journalism as hopefully “[going] some way to correcting the imbalance”.




Please login with linkedin to comment

AFR joe aston

Latest News

Beacon Lighting Extends Carat’s Contract For Three More Years
  • Media

Beacon Lighting Extends Carat’s Contract For Three More Years

Dentsu’s media agency Carat Victoria has extended its six-year relationship with Beacon Lighting for another three years in a closed review. The agency, which is responsible for all paid media strategy, planning and buying including brand, performance and programmatic, first won the Beacon Lighting account in 2018. In 2021, it extended the contract for a […]

Former EssenceMediacom CEO Pat Crowley Calls On Adland To Back Rare Cancer Drug
  • Advertising

Former EssenceMediacom CEO Pat Crowley Calls On Adland To Back Rare Cancer Drug

Pat Crowley, former CEO of EssenceMediacom has called on adland to get behind a petition to add cancer drug Belzutifan to the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme, in the hopes it could save his son’s life. Last year, Crowley had a spate of terrible luck. In September, his 17-year-old son Fletcher suffered a severe spinal cord injury […]

University Of Sydney Appoints CHEP For Australia & APAC Media Account
  • Advertising

University Of Sydney Appoints CHEP For Australia & APAC Media Account

The University of Sydney has appointed CHEP Media to provide media planning and buying services for Australia and key markets across the Asia-Pacific region, following a competitive pitch. CHEP Media will support one of the world’s top 20 universities with an integrated, whole-of-university media strategy, to further elevate its brand profile and driving recruitment for […]

The Case For Nature: Let The Media & Advertising Industries Tell A Story & Tell It Well
  • Advertising

The Case For Nature: Let The Media & Advertising Industries Tell A Story & Tell It Well

Last year, Siddarth Shrikanth published The Case for Nature: Pioneering Solutions for the Other Planetary Crisis. Catherine de Clare caught up with him at the Jaipur Literary Festival in India this year. Shrikanth currently works as a director on the Investment team at Just Climate, a sustainability-focused investment fund chaired by former US vice president Al […]