Nine And News Corp Lose Defamation Case Over Facebook Comments
Nine and News Corp will both be held legally responsible for defamatory comments made on their social media pages, the NSW Supreme Court has ruled.
The case involves a series of 2016 articles published on The Australian, The Centralian Advocate, Sky News Australia’s The Bolt Report, and The Sydney Morning Herald (then owned by Fairfax), concerning former Northern Territory youth detainee Dylan Voller.
Voller has now won the first round of the defamation case, with his claims against the media companies set to continue.
The actual articles were not ruled defamatory, rather comments made by the public on various Facebook posts published by the outlets sharing the story.
“Each defendant was not merely a conduit of the comment,” said Supreme Court Justice Stephen Rothman in his judgment.
“[They] provided the forum for its publication and encouraged, for its own commercial purposes, the publication of comments.”
“A defendant cannot escape the likely consequences of its action by turning a blind eye to it.”
Rothman ruled the media outlets were the publishers of the comments as social media pages are used with the primary objective to “optimise readership of the newspaper (whether hard copy or digital) or broadcast and to optimise advertising revenue”.
The decision largely rested on a report by social media expert and founder of Pepper IT Ryan Shelley, which declared the occasional monitoring of comments by such media companies as insufficient, “particularly for media outlets of significant size and with significant available resources”.
“Strategies could have been put in place to allow for a more robust and deliberate attempt at monitoring comments.”
News Corp said the decision shows “how far out of step” Australia’s defamation laws are with the rest of the English-speaking world.
“It defies belief that media organisations are held responsible for comments made by other people on social media pages,” the media giant said in a statement.
“It is ridiculous that the media company is held responsible while Facebook, which gives us no ability to turn off comments on its platform, bears no responsibility at all.”
News Corp has also announced it is “reviewing the judgment with a view to an appeal”.
Latest News
DrinkWise Launches Bounce Back Podcast
DrinkWise has launched a new podcast series named Bounce Back featuring prominent Australians talking about how they overcame adversity. The series launched yesterday with Australian Test Cricket Captain Tim Paine speaking candidly about how seeking professional support helped him beat his mental demons and save his cricket career.
Parkinson’s NSW Launches ‘No Escape Room’ To Raise Awareness Via Wunderman Thompson
B&T's not published any Wunderman Thompson news for some time. Although we do stress, that's our laziness & not theirs.
Bras N Things Launches New Brand Position: ‘I Am Many Things’ Via TBWA\Sydney
Yes, lingerie campaigns can ruffle a few readers' feathers. But then we could all do with a good ruffling, couldn't we?
“Couldn’t Be Bothered To Hire A Black Photographer”: Vogue Under Fire For Latest Simone Biles Cover
Anna Wintour longing for a simpler time when all a magazine needed was 30-grand handbags & models with eating disorders.
The Monkeys Win Open Colleges’ Creative, Shows Off First Work
Has CV-19 led you to re-evaluate life? You could consider an Open Colleges course or continue with your Netflix bender.
News Corp To Launch 50 New Titles As Part Of Online-Only Shift
Football team get flogged over the weekend? Well, avoid the sports pages today by reading this good news story instead.
Thinkerbell Snares CHEP’s Ben Shepherd As It Ramps Up Media Offering
Thinkerbell walks through a valley of darkness as it snares Ben Shepherd to strike down with vengeance & furious anger.
Facebook Weighs Up Political Ad Ban
Despite the gold embroided satin sheets & pillows filled with dodo down, apparently Mr Zuckerberg is not sleeing well.
Sunday TV Wrap: Seven’s Investigation Into The Peter Falconio Murder Proves A Hit
Peter Falconio is either dead OR wins world's best-ever hide-and-seek champion alongside Elvis and Jim Morrison.
“It’s An Insult To Satan!” People Are Calling This The Best Press Photo Of Trump Ever!
Stunning press image gives Trump unintended horns, as Lucifer's PR agent forced to issue statement denying similarities.
Nike Launches New Shoe With AR-Powered Colouring Book Via AKQA
Everytime you buy sports shoes are you left with that niggling feeling "I should've got the Adidias"? This won't help.
Women In Media’s Sandra Wee: “To Bring About Change in Our Industry, Being Courageous Is Necessary”
B&T has a delightful chat with Trade Desk’s Sandra Wee. Sandra was delightful, we were a bit brusque, to be honest.
Data Proves Key To Marketers For Managing Change & Disruption
Here's a guest post from Gumtree's Daniel Kuziow who could also get you a top deal on a chaise lounge & matching pouffe.
Seven Musters Sponsors For Launch Of ‘Farmer Wants A Wife’
Does your Tinder profile list "interests" as driving combine harvesters & manure spreading? Get excited on this TV news.
How LegalVision Is Disrupting Law With Digital
Here at B&T we're big supporters of media law. Our defamation lawyer's brand new Mercedes testament to our commitment.
Former Politician Scott Emerson To Host 4BC’s New Drive Program
Scott Emerson to host Brisbane 4BC’s drive show. B&T can't confirm if Pauline's already been banned or will shortly.
Woolworths & News Corp Partner To Aid Local Food Charities During CV-19
Woolies & News partner on top initiative amid reports Rupert was spotted nicking grapes in the fruit and veg.
“A Home To Advertise To Youth”: Everything You Need To Know About 10’s New Channel 10 Shake
Father Time now considering extended the average day from 24 to 32 hours to cater for yet more TV channels in our lives.
Change Your Plans. Your Audience Already Did
Here's a top piece from Pinterest's Andréa Mallard. With B&T even managing to get the squiggly thing on the 'e' right.
Weber Shandwick Chairman Ian Rumsby To Depart After 19 Years
Weber Shandwick's Ian Rumsby to quit, with silver goblets in a velvet-lined presentation box touted as farewell present.
Report: Social Media To Reignite Chinese Tourism To Australia
In exciting news for the sale of fake didgeridoos & chocolate-covered macadamias, social media to revive China tourism.
Nine CFO Paul Paul Koppelman Departs After 10 Months Citing Family Reasons
Nine's CFO departs, although not linked to Karl trying to get his Willougby Hotel beer receipts through on expenses.
Thursday TV Wrap: SBS Closes In On 10, Yet Seven Wins Night On Back Of Cats-Lions Game
AFL proves Thursday's TV highlight. Yet, with everyone in Melbourne stuck at home, it could've done better than it did.
Meet The Women Leading Tech: Blackmores Marketing Manager Integrated Communications Rachelle McDermott
Not only is Blackmores' Rachelle McDermott leading tech, she also knows what saw palmetto and Coenzyme Q10 even are.
Coming Soon: Facebook Messenger And WhatsApp Integration
Facebook Messenger & WhatsApp set to merge in what no one's describing as the "pineapple on pizza" of the tech industry.
Amy Schumer Partners With Tampax To Teach Women How To Use Tampons & It’s Bloody Hilarious (And Helpful)
Only Amy Schumer could make a Tampax ad funny. That said, we're sure Rebel Wilson or even Sacha Baron Cohen could too.
Reports: Private Equity Eyeing Distressed Media Assets, With Seven, oOh!media & SCA All Possible Targets
James Warbuton bakes a delightful sponge & gives the offices a Glen 20 with news private equity could soon be knocking.
“Nan Will Love It!” VB Unveils “Limited Edition” Christmas In July Sweaters
The advantage of any VB Christmas jumper is, if you drank too many VBs and threw-up all over it no one would even know.
“The Most Effective Political Ad Ever!” A Ronald Reagan Speech From 1980 Tears Trump To Shreds In Brutal Campaign
Most political ads don't aim much higher than "dull, tedious & vanilla". Hence what makes this anti-Trump ad so good.
McDonald’s Unveils Swimwear Range Made From Its Recycled Plastic Straws
McDonald's unveils a new swimwear range featuring models that, it's abundantly clear, never eat at McDonald's.
