Why We Should Embrace Twitter’s Experiments Instead Of Shooting Them Down

Why We Should Embrace Twitter’s Experiments Instead Of Shooting Them Down
SHARE
THIS



Edge’s Richard Parker says Twitter is going to change the way it delivers its timeline whether users like it or not so we may as well concede the tech platform has a point.

Apparently, Twitter’s chief financial officer (CFO) Anthony Noto, has been running his mouth off at the Citi Global Technology Conference in New York, about Twitter’s imminent timeline rejig. He was quoted as saying, somewhat undramatically, that the reverse chronological order of content that Twitter is known for “isn’t the most relevant experience for a user”.

Apparently Twitter tested the idea of surfacing content that people you follow have favourited in your timeline back in August – and it didn’t go down to well amongst Twitter users who didn’t take kindly to what they saw as Twitter forcing content on them that they hadn’t asked for.

So what exactly did Noto say? Well, according to the Washington Post:

It’s important to understand what Noto did and didn’t say. He pointed to the problem of important content disappearing quickly and said that Twitter might resurface tweets from people who the user already follows if the company deems those tweets important. How that would work is anybody’s guess. But Noto did not suggest that Twitter would start filtering or curating timelines (my emphasis). If all Twitter does is resurface a tweet from someone that a user follows, they’re not distorting what the user sees. That user already follows the person whose tweet they’re now seeing. They would have already seen the tweet if not for the fact that they were away from their timeline.

Hmm. Noto’s clearly got a point about content disappearing quickly on the newsfeed. It’s problematic in a number of ways.

Firstly, there’s a threshold – a function of the number of people a user follows and the frequency at which those users post – after which without being logged in all the time, users will miss a lot of posts. The user has a choice here – accept missing the posts, or follow less users.

And obviously, from a broadcast viewpoint – whether you’re a brand or an individual – it’s difficult to get content out to your entire follower base without tweeting the same content numerous times, which could alienate users who spend a lot of time on Facebook.

These are issues. But is resurfacing favourites-of-friends the answer? I’m not so sure about that.

For one thing, just because I follow someone doesn’t mean that I care what they favourite. I might, for example, follow a politician for their views on government – I don’t care that they favourite a brand or a musician or a place, and yet if they do, the content from that user will be surfaced to me. No thanks. It also affects my behaviour as a user. Am I more, or less likely to favourite something knowing that it might then show up in my friends’ feeds?

For another thing, not all of the people I follow are equal in terms of their influence on me – or to put it more succinctly, I give more of a shit about some users’ opinions than others. Twitter would need to do some serious work to make sure that they only resurface content from favourites of friends whose opinions I respect. And even then, they can only go on observed behaviour, and what I click on or favourite depends on what I see on my timeline at any given moment – which is a random, time-based sample of the users I follow, and not necessarily reflective of my rational preferences.

I wonder whether Twitter could take this opportunity to do something more interesting. It would be a shame to see them reduce the amount of content that users see, as Facebook has done, based on a bunch of assumptions. Rather than ape the algorithmic tinkering of Facebook, Twitter could allow their medium to become truly user-controlled by allowing people to prioritise the users they follow – a simple preferential indicator like ’ Trusted’ or ‘Respected’. Giving users this power would also be interesting from a brand viewpoint: only brands that consumers really want to hear from would get any kind of cut through.

This approach COULD help to negate the filter bubble effect, too. Sometimes our actual behaviour is different to the way we think we want to behave (that old thinking fast and slow thing), so an algorithm that shows us content based on observed behaviour could be reducing the breadth of opinions that our evolved brains want to see. But it would also reduce Twitter’s opportunities to eventually ape Facebook in gradually reducing organic exposure for brands, and helping to position Twitter as a paid platform.

Whatever happens, something is sure to change, whether users want it or not – and experience tells us that any tinkering with timelines and news feeds is greeted with initial uproar, gradual acceptance, and eventual amnesia that it was ever different.

Richard Parker is the joint managing partner of Edge.  

Please login with linkedin to comment

ABC Flavour Favour Social Media The Smith Family

Latest News

me&u Appoints Clementine Churchill To Head Of Marketing
  • Marketing

me&u Appoints Clementine Churchill To Head Of Marketing

me&u, Australia’s first and leading mobile ordering and payment platform, has appointed Clementine Churchill as Head of Marketing as they continue to drive rapid growth and expansion in Australia and new international markets. A highly experienced marketing leader and recognised industry thought leader, Churchill joins me&u from My Muscle Chef, one of Australia’s top rated […]

MILO Asks Fans To Compete To Win #TheMILOCup In New Campaign Via Ogilvy
  • Marketing

MILO Asks Fans To Compete To Win #TheMILOCup In New Campaign Via Ogilvy

MILO is on the search for Australia’s best made MILO, calling on fans to share their creations for the chance to win #TheMILOCup, via Ogilvy Sydney. This integrated campaign follows on from the success of last year’s ‘Hot v Cold’ campaign, which encouraged Aussies to settle the debate on whether MILO is best enjoyed hot […]

New ANZ Research Shows That LGBTQ+ Visual Representation Relies On Stereotypes
  • Advertising
  • Marketing

New ANZ Research Shows That LGBTQ+ Visual Representation Relies On Stereotypes

New research from Getty Images, a world leader in visual communications, has found that LGBTQ+ representation in ANZ remains low and stereotypical. It’s 2021 – this needs to change – especially in marketing and advertising. In partnership with GLAAD, the LGBTQ+ media advocacy organisation, Getty Images has launched a full-spectrum Guidebook in direct response to […]

Dir David Attenborough’s Life Stories Launches On LiSTNR
  • Media

Dir David Attenborough’s Life Stories Launches On LiSTNR

Natural historian Sir David Attenborough is one of the most commanding and respected storytellers in the world and now the iconic series, David Attenborough Life Stories, is available on LiSTNR as part of SCA’s recently announced partnership with the BBC. David Attenborough Life Stories is a series of talks on the natural histories of creatures and […]

Menulog Makes Key Marketing Promotions
  • Media

Menulog Makes Key Marketing Promotions

Menulog has doubled down on its marketing support for restaurant partners, with the promotion of Senior Marketing Manager, Rami Tamer, to a newly created role of ‘Head of Partner Marketing’, as well as the promotion of former-Blue 449 Performance Manager, Jaryd Buggins. In the new Head of Partner Marketing role, Rami will lead a team […]

Barry Drinkwater Leaves ARN Brisbane After 28 Years, Will Hand Over Reins To Alisson Longhurst
  • Media

Barry Drinkwater Leaves ARN Brisbane After 28 Years, Will Hand Over Reins To Alisson Longhurst

ARN has announced Barry Drinkwater will be handing over his content director reins at 97.3FM and 4KQ to respected radio executive, Alisson Longhurst. Drinkwater has had a stellar career in radio spanning more than four decades, and was acknowledged as one of Australia’s Top 20 Content Directors by Radio Today in 2020. He began his radio career […]

Australian Radio Industry Joins Global Working Group On Android Automotive
  • Media

Australian Radio Industry Joins Global Working Group On Android Automotive

The Australian commercial radio industry has joined a global working group of broadcasters, carmakers and tech experts collaborating on the innovation of radio in Android Automotive. Android Automotive is Google’s infotainment operating system which is being built into new connected cars. Industry body Commercial Radio Australia is part of the working group, led by the […]

Triple M’s No Talk Day Returns To Inspire Conversation Around Men’s Mental Health
  • Media

Triple M’s No Talk Day Returns To Inspire Conversation Around Men’s Mental Health

For the third consecutive year, Triple M’s No Talk Day will return on Thursday July 1 to raise awareness around men’s mental health and encourage courageous conversations on Triple M’s 45 stations across the country with support from partner Beyond Blue.  From 6:00am – 6:00pm on July 1, Triple M is encouraging listeners to clear […]

Thrive PR Wins SodaStream Account
  • Marketing

Thrive PR Wins SodaStream Account

The farting in the Thrive PR office rises expodentially after the agency snares the SodaStream business.

Businessman using tablet payments online shopping with speed icons customer and data network connection on virtual screen.
  • Marketing

62% Of Shoppers Doing Most Of Their Purchases Online: BigCommerce And PayPal Report

Consumer shifts in how and where people buy products evolved significantly during the COVID-19 pandemic, creating new opportunities for retailers to use new channels, fulfilment strategies and payment options, according to the results of a new survey out today from BigCommerce and PayPal. While a majority of the 3,000 consumers surveyed from the United States, United Kingdom […]

New Talent Agency, Liquorice Plants Roots In NZ
  • Marketing
  • Media

New Talent Agency, Liquorice Plants Roots In NZ

The brainchild of co-founders Gina Williams-Folau (main photo) and Greer Bland, the talent agency Liquorice was born out of a desire to make things easier for brand managers. Liquorice offers social talent for brands wanting to hit the sweet spot with Kiwi audiences. Launching with a roster of big names on board including Millie Elder-Holmes, Athena […]