Why Are Aussie Indies Doing So Well?

In this guest post, Chris Walton, managing director of indie media agency Nunn Media, explains why he thinks local indies are punching well above their weight at the moment…
There has been extensive coverage both in Australia and abroad about how well independent agencies are currently doing compared to their multinational/Holdco counterparts. Whilst accounting for a 10 per cent market share globally, some reports suggest indie media agencies won a third of all new business last year.
But why? In an age when you could argue that indie agencies should really struggle to survive, they thrive.
Having been on both sides of the media agency ownership fence I think there are several practical reasons why this is happening.
Holdcos Are Profit Extraction Businesses
One of the most telling descriptors of Holdco media agencies I have read was ‘Profit Extraction Businesses’. Nail hit on head. Sure, every business sets out to make a profit, but too much focus on this is detrimental to investment. Try naming a single piece of market-changing IP developed in-house by a Holdco that has significantly changed the industry. The same goes for acquisition. For example, if holdcos were serious about developing their data credentials, one of them would have bought Quantium (where I also used to work). Too much focus on short-term profit means they lack the ability to invest. Net outcome? A democratisation of the industry lowering barriers to entry.
Short-term results have evolved from being the output of delivering great service to being the key driver of behaviour. A ‘do whatever it takes to achieve the numbers’ culture rules which is detrimental to client outcomes.
The Peril of Beryls
There is a lady in Singapore called Beryl who unwittingly became the straw that broke the camel’s back when it came to me staying at a Holdco. I’ve got no reason to suspect that Beryl is malicious person. So what did she do? Beryl’s role at my old Holdco was to review business plans and revenue forecasts for the ‘Analytics’ divisions in Asia-Pacific. Beryl had never worked in Australia and she wasn’t a data analyst. Yet she repeatedly refused to accept my business plan for the discipline due to it not satisfying certain ratios. To compound the situation – I was paying Beryl to tell me this. Holdco agencies are taxed anywhere between five per cent and 15 per cent of their revenue to fund the non-revenue generating aspects of regional and global structures – including the Beryls of the world. Her role was to kick me up the arse to do better against targets (targets which ironically I would have reached if I wasn’t paying for her in the first place…)
This approach has another big knock-on effect operationally. If you were expected to deliver a 20 per cent margin, you actually had to deliver up to a 35 per cent margin due to paying for Beryl. At the same time, these agencies are somehow meant to compete against indies where there isn’t a Beryl in sight.
Show Me The Money
A big, big, issue Holdco agencies face is that many of their clients simply do not understand their business model. Yup – clients don’t know how their agency makes money. This is ridiculous. Clients should know both how and how much money their agency makes.
The seeds of this situation were sown 25 years ago when media agencies were spun out of full-service agencies. The initial driving force was efficiency and the tool was scale. Scale is important for several reasons, but only to a point, and holdcos have gone way beyond this. All significant efficiency gains have been realised long ago, so revenue and margin is being searched for elsewhere. Clients can smell an alternative agenda (and nefarious behaviour) a mile off, which leads to trust in their agency relationship being significantly undermined.
Lack of Local Logic
I sympathise with local Holdco agency management as the commercial pressure they are put under lacks local logic. What do I mean? It is common for holdcos to publish market reports outlining how much global ad markets will grow by. Forecasts for Australian growth in 2023 range from GroupM’s estimate of just 0.2 per cent, to Dentsu’s 3.2 per cent, up to glass-half-full Magna with four per cent. But do you think the management of any of these agencies have local growth targets of less than 10 per cent? Yeah right.
Of course, every agency wants to grow more than the market, but these three groups account for 50 per cent of the entire market. So where is this growth meant to come from? Local logic doesn’t exist in setting local agency business targets. And let’s be clear – aggressive targets have no more a bearing on aggressive growth than my underpants do.
…cos Shit Happens
There are reams of column inches on work-life balance within indies and the importance of workplace flexibility which I’m not going to regurgitate. However, a key test of how truly flexible an organisation is occurs when bad things happen. The child of a pitch-lead gets sick or has an accident the day before a big pitch? What happens? If an agency has its balance right, it will have a stable team that is resourced appropriately. This means a rare, unfortunate incident like this does not de-rail either the pitch or the affected family as there isn’t a last-minute sprint to get good work done. Balance and stability are the foundations of flexibility, and indies have done a very good job here. This means the shit doesn’t hit the fan when…um… the shit hits the fan.
Partnership and collaboration are two of the most over-used terms by agencies because they are important to the success of a service business. But true partnership and great collaboration involve grey areas of operation, blurred lines of scope and different operating speeds from project to project. In wanky terms – it is a fragile ecosystem.
Such fragility breaks down if there is not unity of purpose – a shared vision for success. However, the above points combine to wreak havoc on this system. This ultimately fuels an openness in clients to consider a different type of agency.
Internally many talented people at holdcos feel the same things which only compounds the situation. Clients want to work with skilled and experienced people in stable teams motivated by a desire to solve their business challenges. Many of these types of people have been seeking out independent agencies for years and this has powered their rise. Any Holdco agency that is still doing a good job (and there are some) is doing so despite how they are structured rather than because of it, and this is why indies are having a good time of it at the moment.
Latest News

The Works Distills “Question Everything” For Archie Rose Distilling Co.
The Works has announced the launch of ‘Question Everything’ a new brand platform and campaign for their newest client, Archie Rose. As a nine-year-old independently owned and operated Australian multi-spirit distillery, Archie Rose has garnered a devoted following among existing customers, with a reputation primarily built on white spirits – particularly gin. However in line […]

farsiight Unveils New Market Positioning Putting Growth for Good Over Growth At All Costs
Brisbane performance agency farsiight has announced the launch of its new market positioning, Growth for Good, in response to a changing business landscape, marking a departure from a “growth at all costs” mentality that has defined the industry in recent years. Agency founders and brother duo, Josh and Ben Somerville, envision Growth for Good as […]

By Land Or By Sea: GoTransit Offers Options Galore For Transit Advertisers In Newcastle
Australia’s largest privately owned transit media supplier, GoTransit Media Group, now offers unprecedented options for transit advertising in Newcastle – on both land and sea following their successful tender to supply interior advertising inside the popular Stockton Ferries. The national transit media company is already well acquainted with the thriving NSW market, having successfully operated […]

‘People First Bank’ Heritage & People’s Choice Bank Unified
Heritage and People’s Choice have launched People First Bank, the new name for positive change in banking Australia’s largest customer-owned bank has unveiled its new brand, announcing that Heritage and People’s Choice will be unified under the new name of People First Bank. Chairman Michael Cameron said the highly anticipated new brand offered a compelling […]

“Cozzie Livs” Announced Macquarie Dictionary 2023 Word Of The Year
We're not sure how many logophiles read B&T, but this one's for you. That's a lover of words, not a lover of logging.

🏆 Hear From The B&T Awards Winners! 🏆
It's the B&T Award winners all in video form! We're putting the slurring down to their excitedness.

Today The Brave’s Hannah Lawson & Kate Idle On What’s Hot & What’s Not In 2024
Planning your own what's hot/what's not for 2024 list? There's some good ones here if plagiarism is on your what's hot.

Cultural Shift For Australians With ‘The Great Slow Down’
Don't ever really go beyond what's asked? Loathed by colleagues? Bone idle, in fact? The 'great slow down' is calling.

L’Oréal Aus & NZ Partner With Great Barrier Reef Foundation, Announcing Large Investments
L’Oréal Groupe Australia and New Zealand have announced one of the largest investments to the Great Barrier Reef Foundation to pioneer new coral restoration efforts in the region. L’Oréal Groupe Australia and New Zealand have announced today a new partnership with the Great Barrier Reef Foundation (GBRF), to help coral reefs withstand the devastating impacts […]

Fast 10: B&T Chats Marketing & The Future With The Marketing Academy’s Sherilyn Shackell
It's B&T's quick 10 with marketing guru Sherilyn Shackell. And, believe it or not, AI not mentioned once.

Hardhat Nabs Magdalina Triantafyllidis From whiteGREY
whiteGREY's Magdalina Triantafyllidis jumps ship to rival Hardhat. Fear not, B&T double checked the spelling.

Media.Monks Names Matthew Godfrey EVP, Head Of Content In APAC
Effective immediately, S4Capital’s operating brand Media.Monks, a digital-first marketing and advertising services company, has appointed Matthew Godfrey to lead its APAC Content practice. With over 15 years of experience leading innovative businesses in the Asia-Pacific region, Godfrey will support a best-in-class senior leadership team across the region as EVP, head of content, APAC. He joins […]

“This Full Moon, It Messes With People” – Kyle Sandilands Storms Off-Air After Clash With Jackie ‘O’ Henderson
Despite a new $200 million contract extension, Kyle still getting away with behaviour that would get anyone else sacked.

Squealing Pig Launches Summer Of Love Campaign At Opening Of New NPL Indoor Pickeball Facility
Still hold on to a perverse dream of sport mega stardom? Perhaps the National Pickleball League could be your ticket?

From Matildas Fever To An Ice-Cold English Cricket Team: These Are B&T’s Biggest Sporting Moments Of 2023
It's B&T's top sporting moments of 2023. Also read - the sporting moments that Australia appeared to do well in.

Monday TV Ratings: Disaster Hits On Semi-Final Of Dessert Masters
Who hasn't suffered their very own dessert disaster? Although it is typically reborn as a tasty trifle.

“A Parody Of A Tone-Deaf Wealthy Person!” Gwyneth Paltrow Slammed For $22,700 Vibrator Stunt
Is Gwyneth mad or just a genius self-promoter? Find out here with this latest bit of genius self-promotion.

How AI Is Empowering Small Businesses With Creative Collaboration
Chandra Sinnathamby, Adobe’s director, digital media B2B strategy & GTM, Asia-Pacific, explains how the tech firm is empowering its small business customers with new AI tools, including its Adobe Firefly tools. In today’s fast-paced digital landscape, small businesses face numerous challenges when it comes to creating captivating content that resonates with their audience. Despite the […]

Chemist Warehouse And Menulog Become Sponsors Of Seven’s Summer Cricket Coverage
Seven unveils its summer cricket line-up. Seemingly far less concerned the Tests won't run the five days.

Cash At First Sight! MAFS Stars Cash In On Sponsorship
They're typically hideous people you'd avoid at all costs, but it appears it's not stopped MAFS contestants cashing in.

Study: Aussie Teens Are Not Actually Selfie-Obsessed
Study finds teens less selfie-obsessed than we thought. Still refusing to eat anything that's not grammable, however.

OMD Crowned Top Global Media Agency By COMvergence
Work for OMD? You can feel suitably chuffed on these numbers. If not, don't rage too hard or you'll get a peptic ulcer.

New Balance Signs Extensive Agreement With Australian Open & United Cup
We're fast approaching tennis season in Australia, but will it be sullied by a dearth of bratty mens players?

Clem’s Hall & Partners Snares Fiftyfive5’s Elodie Myers For National MD Role
Fiftyfive5’s Elodie Myers jumps ship to rival. The sling back recliner and window seat said to have sealed the deal.

Candace Warner, Tom Tilly & Harley Breen Kick Off Summer On Triple M
Summer mornings are heating up with Triple M again in 2023, thanks to the star-studded line-up of Harley Breen, Candice Warner and Tom Tilley, who are joining forces each weekday morning from 6-9 am for Triple M’s Summer Breakfast show. Airing from 4 to 15 December in Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Adelaide and streamed live on […]

Disinformation Regulation Called For After X Kicked Out Of Social Self-Reg Code Following Voice Referendum
Elon counting his blessings for Bud Light that's clearly saved him from the number one spot on 2023's biggest f#ck-ups.

Jimmy & Nath, Hamish & Andy And Seany B Light Up Christmas At Hit Network
The Hit Network has announced its summer line-up for 2023, kicking off on Monday, 4 December, featuring The Jimmy & Nath Show, Hamish & Andy podcast, Nights with Seany B and special return celebrations for Christmas Day and New Year’s Eve. Hit’s cheeky radio duo Jimmy Smith and Nath Roye of The Jimmy & Nath […]

Women’s Weekly Annual Christmas Special To Air On 10, With A Host Of Sponsors In Tow
Is your Christmas a case of VB, a bottle of port & four kilos of king prawns? Take 2023 up a notch with the Weekly.

AFFINITY Launches Worley Rebrand As A Force In Sustainability
Full-service CX, media and advertising agency AFFINITY has completed an 18-month-long global rebranding for ASX-listed engineering powerhouse Worley. The rebrand reflects Worley’s commitment towards being a leading force in sustainable change. Worley, a global provider of professional services in the energy, chemicals and resources sectors working across six continents, has set out on a significant […]

Val Morgan Cinema Surfs To Victory At UnLtd: Big Kahuna
Think there's lots of sharks working in adland? Thankfully, that wasn't the case at the UnLtd: Big Kahuna surfing comp.

Study: 77% Of Aussie Respondents Want To Remove Anonymous Commentary From Industry Sites
Sure, B&T's far from blameless, but we think we all know who the finger of blame's being pointed at here, don't we?

JOLT & Transport For NSW Partner To Introduce Free EV Charging Stations With Digital Advertising Screens
With just eight per cent of cars in Australia electric, these EV charger ads certainly aren't for everyone.

Tourism Tasmania & ARN Invite Aussies To “Come Down For Air” With New Podcast Partnership, Via Starcom
Tourism Tasmania continuing with its "Come Down For Air" campaign. Which is better than "Come Down For Apples".

R.M Williams Unveils “The Mark Of An Icon” Installation To Celebrate Opening Of New George St Store
Highlighting its craft and a world-class shopping experience, Australia’s favourite heritage brand R.M.Williams has announced a consumer competition to celebrate the opening of its new national flagship store at 345 George St. Sydney. Launching on 1 December in line with the new store opening, ‘If The Boot Fits’ invites brand lovers and new customers alike […]

Congratulations To Our Quiz Winner: Sparro & Jack Nimble’s Jake Spaccavento
This $100 BWS voucher giveaway is exactly what ad agency staffers need in the run up to Christmas - more free drinks.

MFA Commits To Expanding E-Learning Program & Launch “Industry Psychosocial Safety Action Plan” At AGM
Miss the MFA's recent AGM? Here's all the highlights sans the cheap red and the slightly cold mini quiches.