The Advertising Standards Board (ASB) has ruled in favour of several complaints against Ultra Tune Australia’s adverts “avoid unexpected situations” for its sexist depiction of women and for trivialising car safety.
Check out the 30 second and 15 second ads and see what you think:
Some of the complaints included:
- In the unexpected ad, two women are portrayed in a stereotyped “bimbo” manner, driving and pouting their enhanced lips….Level crossing accidents claim lives and this trivialises the risk.
- I am offended that in 2016 it is still deemed appropriate to try and sell something using suggestively or scantily clad, artificially big busted women.
- Completely inappropriate for daytime TV due to the explicit content of seeing two women apparently being killed in an accident when a train crashes into them and then walking away from the crash.
- I feel the ad is derogatory towards woman – portraying females as stupid and only good for one thing.
- It is making light of a very serious and real situation where people have lost their lives. Although at the end of the advertisement the women survive, the reality of the situation is that this is an unlikely outcome if it were to actually happen.
An Ultra Tune representative commented on the complaints:
“The actors are fully clothed wearing evening street clothing that is common in today’s society. The whole advertisement is depicted at dusk and night / evening time, when it is common for women to be in such attire.
“We note a number of complaints have referred to the actors in a derogative way, based upon their appearance which is a personal bias. In other environments (such as a workplace or school yard), such derogative comments based upon appearance could be considered harassment and bullying.
“The final scene was designed to emphasise the female empowerment with them confidently walking away from the vehicle without harm.”
The ASB ruled that the ads violated section 2.1 of the Advertiser Code of Ethics- Discrimination or Vilification Gender. “The Board considered that the women are depicted as unintelligent in the way in which they sit passively, with blank faces, in the car on the train tracks and also in the way they appear to not notice the oncoming train.
“This behaviour, in the Board’s view, makes the women appear unintelligent and presents them in a stereotypical helpless female situation. In the Board’s view, the depiction of the women’s reaction to their situation is a negative depiction of women and does amount to vilification of women.”
In response Ultra Tune Australia discontinued the ad but it intends to seek an independent review of the Board’s decision: “We advise for the record that our client views the Board’s decision that the Advertisement provides “a negative depiction of women and does amount to vilification of women” as without foundation and intends to vigorously dispute these findings”.
Please login with linkedin to commentclash magazine
Spikes Asia today announces that the 2021 awards will take place in February, bringing them forward to the first quarter of the year. Judging for the Spikes Asia Awards, the region’s most prestigious creative branded communications accolade, as well as the Tangrams Awards and Young Spikes competitions will all take place in February 2021. In […]
Following a rigorous round of online judging by 133 industry experts, The Communications Council today announced that 88 finalists from 24 agencies on behalf of 36 clients have made it into Round Two of the Australian Effie Awards. Finalists will now compete for Effies, Australia’s only awards based on proven advertising effectiveness – across 26 […]
Integral Ad Science (IAS) today announced the launch of “Channel Science”, an industry-leading partnership between Channel Factory and IAS. The Channel Science solution helps advertisers to leverage both companies’ technologies through a single product to ensure their YouTube campaigns are brand-safe, brand-suitable, and performance-optimized. More than ever before, advertisers are searching for ways to streamline their media buying and improve […]
WPP AUNZ has launched its inaugural podcast series, led by WPP AUNZ Chief Strategy Officer, Rose Herceg (pictured). The podcast series will focus on the company’s recent thought leadership study: Secrets & Lies Chapter 4, Humanity & the Machine. Aired over the next few weeks, each discussion will take a deep dive into exploring the role […]
Westpac Group today announced it has partnered with Verizon Media’s Omnichannel DSP across its entire brand portfolio including Westpac Bank, St George Bank, Bank of Melbourne and Bank of South Australia. The new partnership gives Westpac Group access to Verizon Media’s end-to-end strategic marketing and planning capabilities including: first-party data based audience insights; full-service omnichannel […]
Network 10 is set to undergo a massive restructure, leaving a number of high-profile journalists out of a job, including Kerri-Anne Kennerley, Natarsha Belling and Tim Bailey, B&T understands. As first reported on The Sydney Morning Herald, the restructure was announced to staff on Tuesday. As part of the restructuring, the presentation of the weekday […]