Quotas Should Be Used On The Hiring Panel, Not In The Agency
It’s a debate rolling around the industry as to whether agencies should have quotas to fill to ensure diversity.
While some argue the concept of setting quotas shows measurability and is more likely to be accomplished, there’s the argument companies could start hiring to fill a quota, rather than who is best for the job.
“It can incent the wrong behaviours and choices,” Caroline Turner wrote for The Huffington Post. “It enables men to charge reverse discrimination. It can invite cynicism and backlash.”
When asking a table full of senior women at ad retargeting company AdRoll a yay or nay on quotas, Stacey Manes, vice president of human resources and recruiting, said it’s about having diversity on the hiring panel itself.
“A certain amount of a panel had to be a female. At the end of the day you pick the best candidate, but it ensured you had a more diverse panel of candidates.”
The move for AdRoll’s diverse recruitment panels was spearheaded by Michelle Filo, human resources director.
“In the Sydney office we’re very much looking at that diverse mix of recruitment interviewers,” she explained. “We have a large range of people from different disciplines that sit on the panel.
“It’s to ensure that whilst you can’t dictate how someone may operate, it’s about building an awareness around our bias. Once we’re aware of it we can make a more educated decision
“When we do interview, we ensure we have a variety of demographics that includes gender.”
In early 2015, creative Vicki Maguire at Grey Group in London, said she doesn’t mind quotas – but hates the thought agencies put in “orders” for people.
“‘Can we have two birds, a couple of ethnics; not Swedes, we’ve got them… Have you got any disabled?’” she quipped for British trade magazine Campaign Live.
Still, agencies should be looking at the remit and questioning their own diversity management.
“All clients should be asking questions when the same white besuited posh boys and professional northerners rock up to meeting after meeting talking about changing the cultural landscape,” added Maguire. “Come on. Anyone can see your agency is dying on its arse.
“If you can’t see that coming, you’re fucked.”
Please login with linkedin to comment
adland quota Advertising Standards Bureau digital customer quotasLatest News
Former Agency Execs Launch Car Service Summon
Former agency executives Tim O’Neill and Tim Fouhy have launched the auto technology startup Summon. Australia’s first full e-commerce service for prestige cars. O’Neill and Fouhy both worked together at Accenture Interactive, before co-founding Reactive a digital agency bought by Accenture in 2016, now they’ve combined their knowledge and expertise to create Summon. Summon offers […]
Hootsuite Shares The Top Social Media Trends Of The Tokyo 2020 Paralympic Games
To honour the fantastic feats of the Australian Paralympians, Hootsuite has revealed the top trending hashtags and social media data of the Paralympics. The top trending hashtag during the Paralympics period, #tokyo2020, received over 38,000 tweets and retweets, amounting to 1.7M+ impressions, while other popular hashtags included #paralympics, #readysettokyo and #paraswimming. According to Hootsuite’s research, […]
Coco-Cola Australia Unveils New Recipe & New Look
Coke rolls out latest new look & new recipe. Despite having a checkered history of rolling out new looks & new recipes.
So Media Group Acquires Social Media Company Carma The Social Chameleon
Perth-based digital media publisher So Media Group has completed the acquisition of fellow Perth-based social media marketing ag
SCA Appoints ABC Executive Melanie Withnall To Head Of News & Information
SCA snares ABC radio veteran Melanie Withnall who brings with her 18 years' experience & an "I Love Ita" coffee mug.
VCCP Business Acquires Sling & Stone To Create $50m Global PR And Communications Group
B&T tried to get "David & Goliath battle" into this Sling & Stone headline; however, it proved not possible in the end.
CHE Proximity, DDB Sydney, TBWA Melbourne And Thinkerbell Melbourne Battle It Out In YouTube Skippys Competition
Some serious agency heavy hitters vying for YouTube's Skippys competition. Hopefully none will be gracious in defeat.
Aussies Can Now Stream The iHeartRadio Music Festival Live
Aussies can now stream the iHeartRadio Music Festival live. Not that it's stopping anyone on a temporary visa either.
We Are Social Launches Insta-Based Cultural Insights Publication, The Feed
Global socially-led creative agency We Are Social has launched The Feed, an editorial Instagram publication tracking digital culture and trends on a global scale.
SOON, Think Tank Giving Insights Into Future Trends, Officially Launches
SOON, a futures think tank focused on human insights, has launched today tracking trends, developments and disruptions across people, products and the planet. Led by internationally renowned futurist, social scientist and trend forecaster Sarah Owen (pictured centre) in partnership with TABOO directors Andrew Mackinnon (right) and James Mackinnon (left), the independently Australian-owned futurist company uncovers […]
Melbourne’s Non-Alcoholic Wine Brand NON SeesInternational Growth Spurt In Just 3 Months
NON is pioneering a whole new category of sommelier-standard 0.0% ABV wine alternatives, manufactured in a completely new way. Despite the lockdown, in 3 months NON has tripled their overseas distribution and begun work on a new NONLab production facility 6 times larger than their current space.
Nina Tsalapatanis And Vince Prochilo Join Orchard In Business Director Roles
B&T asks, is the tedious marketing trope "low-hanging fruit" banned in the Orchard offices?
Deloitte Digital Creative Snares Colenso BBDO’s Dan Wright As Sydney Chief Creative Officer
Deloitte continuing to fish in adland's pool. B&T assumes it's not using worms for bait but rather large pay cheques.
TIME Magazine Reveals 100 Most Influential List, As Harry & Meghan’s “Creepy” Cover Cops A Roasting
TIME unveils its 100 most influential list & mercifully sans any real estate agents, influencers, WAGS or anti-vaxxers.
Experiential Agency GPJ A/NZ Farewells MD Caleb Bush
GPJ MD Caleb Bush announces move to Europe. Has a low-mile 1998 Suzuki Swift on Gumtree if anyone's interested.
New LinkedIn Research Shows Aussies Are Less Hygienic & Have Forgotten How To Banter Due To Working From Home
One notable impact of lockdown has been B&T's desire to cook and then consume an entire roast dinner at 10am.
Aussie TikTok Star & Lockdown Protestor Hospitalised With COVID-19
B&T has gone for "Aussie TikTok star" in this headline. That could've been easily supplanted by "dickhead" or "f@ckwit".
iHeartPodcast Network Australia Launches SAS Australia Debrief Podcast
ARN’s iHeartPodcast Network Australia has announced a new podcast, SAS Australia Debrief hosted by 2020 recruits Merrick Watts and Sabrina Frederick. The podcast is made for anyone that can’t get enough of Aussie celebs putting themselves through the toughest test of their lives on the Seven Network’s hit show SAS Australia. Or anyone that wishes […]
“The Roar Of The Crowd!” How Twitter Is Keeping Sports Fans Close To The Action In 2021
Footy team flop again this season? Well, Twitter now proving the platform for all coach & underperforming player abuse.
Nine’s Upfronts: Here’s What Agency Bosses Had To Say
Sadly, no news of an Ossie Ostrich return, but Nine's annual Upfronts were definitely less bum-numbing than years past.
Wednesday TV Wrap: 10’s Making It Australia Premieres To 474,000 Viewers
B&T enjoyed the Making It Australia premiere last night. Admittedly, we had no compulsion to want to make anything.
Rakuten Advertising Shares Blueprint For Affiliate Marketing
Rakuten Advertising has launched ‘A 5-Stage Blueprint for High-Performance Affiliate Marketing’, designed to educate and inform both advertisers and publishers about the strategic role that the affiliate channel is now playing in marketing strategies. The blueprint is based on input from members of the Rakuten Advertising International Collective (RAIC), comprising affiliate marketing specialists from leading advertisers […]
Study: 42% Of Aussies Say They Don’t Feel Represented By Advertising
Some 42% of Aussies say they don't feel represented by advertising. It was zero per cent for Coles Big Red Hand.
Are Media Highlights The Changing Face Of Beauty In Latest TRENDtalks Series
Are Media research highlights latest beauty trends. Yet no news of the return of the Boy George blush or the fake mole.
Nature Launches New Parental Leave Scheme
Nature unveils impressive parental leave scheme; however, it does carry the caveat of being impregnated first.
EngageTV Launches Metro Connected TV Campaign In Sydney And Melbourne
EngageTV, Australia’s most sophisticated CTV & BVOD service partner, has today launched a Sydney and Melbourne metro Connected TV campaign to help business owners and marketers better understand what can be achieved with CTV.
Buzzfeed Australia Launches Bloom, A Womxn-Focused Vertical
Bloom to cover topics such as sexuality, mental health & relationships. Bad news if you're looking for a sponge recipe.
ARIA Awards Axe Gendered Categories In An Inclusive Move
ARIA Awards announces the end of gendered categories. Which thankfully should shorten the event by a good 40 minutes.
Adland State Of Originality To Return For Nine’s 2022 Origin Series
Nine has announced the return of State of Originality, Australia’s biggest advertising prize, with $1 million again up for grabs to the brand and agency that creates the most original ad in the 2022 State of Origin Series. This year Nine launched State of Originality, challenging Australia’s marketers to help make State of Origin not […]
Nine Uses Upfronts To Reveal Content Slate For 2022
It's all your Nine Upfront news which sadly didn't include an impromptu version of 'New York, New York' by Mike Sneesby.
