Ladders, Black Cats And How Marketers Fall Prey To Superstitions & Assumptions

Ladders, Black Cats And How Marketers Fall Prey To Superstitions & Assumptions

B&T’s favourite Millennial marketers are back with a brand new piece. Today, Brian Mitchell PhD and Evan Mitchell, co-founders of Gen Y brand strategy specialists HOW&Y (howandy.net), take a look at how spooked marketers are letting superstitions hold them back…

What’s black and tan and looks good on a lawyer? A Doberman.

Don’t you just love dog jokes? (Actually, let’s be honest, that was a lawyer joke – and there’s deservedly more where that came from.) But here’s a funny dog story that isn’t a joke. In NZ the SPCA has taught dogs to drive a car. The evidence is on YouTube – it’s a hoot.

This Kiwi dog-driving achievement is an example of operant conditioning, a form of learning that’s been recognised for more than a hundred years. Researched into prominence mid last century by the psychologist B F Skinner, it involves the techniques of reinforcement and punishment – each of which can be positive (adding a stimulus to a situation) or negative (removing a stimulus). When combined with other principles, such as schedules of reinforcement, these four tools control much of our behaviour.

One of the interesting consequences of operant conditioning, is that random behaviours can become associated with positive or negative outcomes, in a way that seems causal. Such believable but imaginary connections between an action and an outcome can lead to superstitious behaviour – where a particular action will be avoided or another carried out, in the hope of escaping something negative or securing something positive. The cognitive label for these events is magical thinking. Many examples have passed into folklore – not walking under a ladder, avoiding black cats, crossing fingers, blowing out all the candles… But circumstances can result in the creation of our own superstitious behaviours.

That’s a slimmed down account of the phenomenon, but it will serve our purposes.

We’ve all witnessed superstitious behaviour, in ourselves or in others. And up to a point it’s harmless fun – that point being where it veers towards the slippery slope of delusion. Our interest lies in if and how superstitious behaviour can affect commercial decision-making. The behavioural mechanisms are in place, but is it possible or likely that decisions would actually be made superstitiously, given the obvious downside?

Take the field of marketing, where costly decisions occur regularly and judgments are often laden with subjectivity. There are numerous variables at play in a marketing campaign and most of those decisions will be significantly influenced by the knowledge-based expectations of the decision-maker/s. That’s as we’d expect.

But how significant is that influence? Here, psychological research takes us in an unexpected direction. It turns out that the influence of knowledge-based expectations over the decision-making process can extend to blocking out relevant information where this contradicts the expectation.

Consciously or unconsciously, expectations based on prior experience assume a dominance based on their familiarity alone, even in the face of contrary evidence. Just another form of superstitious behaviour – automatic belief in a course of action, on the assumption it’s right. We love to find patterns in our world that we can believe in. Which plays to this kind of illusion. And ominously, the culprit here is something we’ve been taught to respect – experience.

When there are multiple variables in play, as in our campaign example – choosing the brand, target market/s, the idea, the theme, the media, and so on – what are the odds on one or more of these mutually dependent decisions being based on biased and erroneous assumptions arising from past experience? And with what impact on the outcome?

So, back to our question (now a no-brainer). Is it possible that superstitious behaviour occurs in commercial decision-making?

More than possible, it’s certain and inevitable. And undoubtedly, given our human failings, it’s also widespread. We can’t eliminate subjectivity from marketing decisions, nor should we want to. But we can and should question marketing assumptions based on faith.

In a previous article on Millennial consumers for B&T we had this to say “What if the successes marketers enjoy with this demographic are a matter of chance, of hitting Gen Y values they weren’t even targeting? What if the subsequent repeat of their ‘successful’ approaches is akin to what psychologists would deem ‘superstitious behaviour’?”

This probability will remain as long as marketers ignore this generation’s distinctive differences, and attempt to engage Millennials via techniques and messages that worked with other generations.

Gen Y are not like Gen X and Boomers – and for the most part never will be.




Latest News

Dwyane Wade “Toasts” To The Finals In New 2024 NBA Finals Campaign
  • Campaigns

Dwyane Wade “Toasts” To The Finals In New 2024 NBA Finals Campaign

NBA Legend and three-time NBA Champion Dwyane Wade gathers a cast of former champions and famous NBA fans to celebrate the pinnacle of the NBA season with a toast “to the Finals” in the 2024 NBA Finals campaign “The Toast”. Ray Allen, Mike Breen, Ken Jeong, Magic Johnson, Jimmy Kimmel, Isiah Thomas, Queen Latifah and […]

Year13 Launches Virtual Work Experience Program
  • Marketing

Year13 Launches Virtual Work Experience Program

Thousands of school students have engaged with Youth Engagement Platform Year13’s recently launched Virtual Work Experience during National Careers Week, May 13-19, 2024. Year13’s Virtual Work Experience platform seeks to solve the problem of school students struggling to find placements by moving employer branded Work Experiences online for students to participate in. Year13’s After The […]

Taskmaster’s Tom Cashman Reveals Why He Is More Relaxed This Season
  • TV Ratings

Taskmaster’s Tom Cashman Reveals Why He Is More Relaxed This Season

Network 10’s hit improv comedy show Taskmaster Australia returned last night for a second season. Joining Tom Gleeson and his sidekick Tom Cashman were a slew of new comedic talent including Josh Thomas, Jenny Tian, Lloyd Langford, Anne Edmonds and Wil Anderson. The unscripted comedy show in which comedians are tasked with a random task […]

QMS Put Brands Up In Lights For Vivid Sydney 2024
  • Advertising

QMS Put Brands Up In Lights For Vivid Sydney 2024

As Vivid Sydney 2024 kicks off, QMS is embracing the celebration of creativity, innovation and technology with a powerful collection of advertisers for the annual festival of lights. QMS’ world-leading City of Sydney digital street furniture network will proudly showcase campaigns from brands including Kia Australia, Visit Victoria, Foxtel Hubbl, Kayo, Universal Pictures, Chemist Warehouse, […]

A Current Affair EP Fiona Dear Appointed Nine Director Of News & Current Affairs
  • Media

A Current Affair EP Fiona Dear Appointed Nine Director Of News & Current Affairs

Nine has announced the appointment of Fiona Dear, currently EP of A Current Affair, as the new director of news and current affairs. This appointment comes at a time of rapid change in our news division as Nine continues to rise to the challenges of an ever faster, more dense media environment and an audience […]

Cashrewards: A Decade Strong!
  • Partner Content

Cashrewards: A Decade Strong!

This month, Cashrewards celebrates its 10th birthday. In this op-ed, Anthony Seymour-Walsh, CEO, reflects on the journey of this inspiring Aussie business, which has evolved from humble beginnings to become Australia’s leading cashback ecosystem and a key strategic partner for clients.   Lead image: Anthony Seymour-Walsh – CEO, Cashrewards.   I am excited about the next chapter as […]

Partner Content

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Gold Artifacts Give Clues To Apple Music’s 100 Best Albums
  • Campaigns

Gold Artifacts Give Clues To Apple Music’s 100 Best Albums

Apple Music has unveiled its complete 100 Best Albums list, celebrating the greatest records ever made. Crafted by Apple Music’s team of experts and artists the lists includes Maren Morris, Pharrell Williams, J Balvin, Charli XCX, Mark Hoppus, and serves as a love letter to the records that have shaped, inspired, and fundamentally changed music. […]

Chook & HOYTS Celebrate Webby Honouree Recognition At The Australian Web Awards
  • Advertising

Chook & HOYTS Celebrate Webby Honouree Recognition At The Australian Web Awards

Chook, a strategy, design and development agency that specialises in bespoke digital experiences, has received international acclaim at the 28th Annual Webby Awards and clinched the Best in Show in the SEO effectiveness category at the Australian Web Awards for the HOYTS’ Australia and New Zealand websites. Lead image: Adam Dipper and James Hartcher, Chook […]

Salesforce’s Bobby Jania: AI Has Flipped Marketing Campaigns On Their Head
  • Technology

Salesforce’s Bobby Jania: AI Has Flipped Marketing Campaigns On Their Head

Bobby Jania, CMO of Salesforce’s Marketing Cloud has said that AI has flipped the traditional marketing campaign on its head, with customers — instead of brands — being in the driving seat. Speaking to a panel of journalists at Salesforce’s Connections event in Chicago, Jania told B&T that the attention economy and AI will force […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Network 10 Axes Gladiators
  • Media

Network 10 Axes Gladiators

the network has dropped its third tentpole show in recent months after cancelling The Bachelor and The Masked Singer. First airing in January this year and hosted by Beau Ryan and Liz Ellis, the reboot features contenders from all walks of life in the ultimate test of speed, strength, stamina, agility and power. It is […]