IAB Mobile Numbers Are Wrong: Amobee Boss – UPDATED WITH PWC RESPONSE

IAB Mobile Numbers Are Wrong: Amobee Boss – UPDATED WITH PWC RESPONSE
SHARE
THIS



Liam Walsh, B&T editorial board member and MD ANZ of Amobee, has called into question the estimated numbers of mobile ad spend in Australia proffered by IAB as wildly wrong.

Speaking on a panel at Rubicon Project’s Australia Market Summit, Walsh (pictured right above) took issue with the numbers being bandied around at the conference for mobile ad spend, which the IAB put at $1.5 billion in calendar year 2015.

“$1.55 billion for mobile? . . . I don’t think it’s right. If you make an assumption about how much money Facebook is getting on mobile – let’s say it’s $300 million excluding small business, I just don’t see where the other $1.2 billion in mobile is,” he said.

“Even though I respect the IAB enormously, I just don’t think that number is right,” he added.

Walsh’s opinion carries some weight, having worked at Facebook in various agency facing roles from May 2011 through to March 2014, before a brief stint at Kenshoo and then his current role at Amobee.

The amount of money media agencies are allocating to mobile excluding Facebook is around 2-4 per cent of the total ad expenditure in Australia,” he said. “So it’s low by definition; there is not enough money going into mobile.”

Walsh admitted there were “a whole bunch” of reasons why ad expenditure was low.

“The formats suck, they’re in annoying places … measurement sucks because you can’t track some conversions. There’s a whole bunch of things that the IAB and Nielson and all of these people are doing to make stuff better.

“But it feels exactly the same as 1999: digital, back of the PowerPoint deck. Then Facebook in, say 2011, back of the PowerPoint deck. [Facebook] is the most pervasive platform that has ever existed and it was in 2011, but it still had customers not spending much money on it.

“It was the same stuff, the ads are too little: an investment director sat in front of our global something or other and said he would spend more money, but the ads are too small. Our response was, ‘How big would you like it to be?’ Because it was ridiculous, right?

“I am very confident the issue wasn’t any of those things . . . it’s just fear and change management. People don’t know how to do mobile very well.

Walsh argued that problems arose because internally, at a client a business case, it has to get signed off.

“You’ve got to ask for money. And a GM is going to ask, ‘What do I get for all these little mobile ads?’ The answer is they’re not really sure. We haven’t got muscle memory in how to do this well.”

Walsh went on to say that when you solve all of these individual problems and you go back to the customer and say, ‘We’ve solved all of those problems’ and they still don’t sign off.

“Why is that? Because they don’t know what to expect from mobile. It’s the third evolution of the same problem: it happened in digital, it happened in social and it’s happening now.

“Mobile will be huge, but it won’t be for many years and it will be in a different shape. I can’t think of any single thing that social did that made it a dominant force it is today.”

In response to Walsh’s comments, PwC’s Megan Brownlow has sent B&T the following statement:

PwC Executive Director Megan Brownlow would like to clarify that the estimates for mobile advertising expenditure include both search and display advertising, as outlined in the Online Advertising Expenditure Reports (OAER):

“Mobile advertising comprises General Display and Search expenditures and also includes mobile video expenditure.  Total advertising revenue is reported on a gross basis. The figures are based on participants’ data, industry estimates for Google’s mobile display and search revenues, Twitter’s mobile display revenues and Facebook’s mobile display revenues.” (OAER March 2016 p14)

Mobile search represents a significant proportion of mobile advertising expenditure, at 43% for calendar 2015 according to our model, she says. Additionally mobile  grew to represent 40% of general display advertising in Australia in 2015. Some industry players experience lower proportions of expenditure directed to mobile but given that Facebook reports 80% of its global revenues are from mobile (Facebook 4th Quarter and Full Year 2015 Results) it seems plausible that Australian industry players achieve a 40% average, equivalent to $1,550m in calendar 2015.”

Please login with linkedin to comment

Advertising Standards Bureau Digital Advertising Liam Walsh Mobile Shopping

Latest News

Are Australian Brands Missing A Subscription Opportunity?
  • Media

Are Australian Brands Missing A Subscription Opportunity?

US retailer Walmart surprised many when it launched Walmart Plus last month, a premium subscription service that gives members access to unlimited delivery and special deals. The move puts Walmart directly against Amazon, which has enjoyed enormous success through its Amazon Prime initiative in recent years. And while the US retail subscription market might be […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Mindshare Boss Nick Emery “Filmed Himself With His Bottom Out” Prior To Sacking
  • Media

Mindshare Boss Nick Emery “Filmed Himself With His Bottom Out” Prior To Sacking

Nick Emery’s misdemeanour that led to his abrupt sacking can finally be revealed. The London-based Mindshare global CEO was given his marching orders last Thursday after an incident that WPP described as “inappropriate and offensive” and “a clear breach of the company’s code of conduct”.   And it appears the UK’s venerable The Sun newspaper has […]

HT&E Appoints Angela Ewers As New Chief People Officer
  • Media

HT&E Appoints Angela Ewers As New Chief People Officer

HT&E today announces Angela  Ewers has been appointed to the newly created position of Chief People Officer. Ewers will commence her new role in November, based in Sydney, where she will lead both HT&E and ARN’s People & Culture function to support growth and ensure ARN is not just Australia’s number one radio and digital audio business, but also […]

Is Christmas Cancelled? Research Reveals Aussies Plan To Spend Less This Festive Season
  • Marketing

Is Christmas Cancelled? Research Reveals Aussies Plan To Spend Less This Festive Season

New research has revealed a major cut-back in Christmas spending, with Australians planning to spend less on gifts, food, and social events this season. The research out of market research firm Toluna also reveals 23 per cent of Australians are worried about being able to afford the Christmas season altogether. Australians are feeling the pinch, […]

Pause Fest To Return In 2021 As Online Event
  • Media

Pause Fest To Return In 2021 As Online Event

Festival for business and creativity, Pause Fest, has confirmed the event will run in 2021 – and will be its biggest to date. The 11th Pause Fest – named Changes – will migrate from its Melbourne home to the online world for the first time, running 1-12 March 2021. “Pause Fest has always been at […]

Nine Director Of News Darren Wick Charged With Drink-Driving, Blowing Over Four Times The Legal Limit
  • Media

Nine Director Of News Darren Wick Charged With Drink-Driving, Blowing Over Four Times The Legal Limit

Nine director of news and current affairs Darren Wick has been charged with drink-driving after he was caught driving over four times the legal alcohol limit following a work function Friday evening. As first reported on the SMH, Wick’s blood alcohol reading was more than .2. The legal limit is 0.05. Following the incident, Wick sent […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Shutterstock Adds Editorial Video Service
  • Media

Shutterstock Adds Editorial Video Service

Shutterstock today announced the highly anticipated addition of Editorial Video, a new premium, full-service editorial video offering that is now available for license. Critical Past, Celebrity Footage and Viral Hog are just a few of the new partners who will distribute their engaging video content worldwide through Shutterstock’s Editorial Video. In addition, current partners’ epa […]

Adobe Unveils A Host Of New Innovations As Part Of Adobe Max 2020
  • Technology

Adobe Unveils A Host Of New Innovations As Part Of Adobe Max 2020

Today at Adobe MAX, Adobe unveiled significant innovation across its Creative Cloud applications and services. In addition to ground-breaking new features like Neural Filters in Photoshop, the company released major updates to its flagship applications including Lightroom, Premiere Pro and Illustrator. Adobe also underscored its commitment to accelerating the development of mobile and multi-surface apps, with […]

The Data-Driven Revolution: Data Is The Key to Marketers’ Integral Role In Driving Business Growth
  • Partner Content

The Data-Driven Revolution: Data Is The Key to Marketers’ Integral Role In Driving Business Growth

The role a marketer plays in the success or failure of a brand has never been disputed. However, modern marketers are now taking on their biggest role yet – tasked with not only driving exceptional customer experiences but also business growth. In fact, a new report surveying more than 1,000 marketers across APAC from Salesforce […]

Partner Content

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Cate Blanchett & Aussie Celebs Back DrinkWise’s You Got This Campaign For Year 12s Via  89 Degrees East
  • Campaigns

Cate Blanchett & Aussie Celebs Back DrinkWise’s You Got This Campaign For Year 12s Via 89 Degrees East

DrinkWise and Communications Agency 89 Degrees East has launched a new campaign called You Got This – an initiative designed to support Year 12s as they head into their final exams. The campaign involves well-known Australians offering short video messages of support for Year 12 students, including superstar Cate Blanchett, Australian Test Cricket Captain Tim […]

Timboon Fine Ice Cream Celebrates 21 Wears With Rebrand Via Squad Ink
  • Campaigns

Timboon Fine Ice Cream Celebrates 21 Wears With Rebrand Via Squad Ink

To mark a twenty-one year milestone the iconic Victorian ice cream brand, Timboon Fine Ice Cream, has revealed a modernised new look for their take home tubs.  Tim Marwood, third generation farmer and founder of Timboon Fine Ice Cream, explains why the anniversary provoked the upgrade.  “There’s not too many small family rural based ice […]

Study: 51% Of Aussie Professionals Don’t Feel Safe Returning To The Office
  • Uncategorised

Study: 51% Of Aussie Professionals Don’t Feel Safe Returning To The Office

Just over half (51 per cent) of professionals who have been working remotely do not yet feel safe and happy to return to their co-located workplace, according to a survey of more than 3,000 working professionals by recruiting experts Hays.  Of these, Western Australians are the most confident, with 73 per cent of those who […]

Bendigo TAFE And Kangan Institute Launch Latest Advertising Campaign – Our Heroes
  • Campaigns

Bendigo TAFE And Kangan Institute Launch Latest Advertising Campaign – Our Heroes

Bendigo TAFE and Kangan Institute have launched their latest advertising campaign titled, Our Heroes, which is a celebration of the role their students play in the community. “Within a few short years, our students are building our houses, nursing our sick, fixing our cars, caring for our children and pets, designing our clothes – all […]