“Data Isn’t Killing Creativity, It’s Killing The Creative Ego”

  • 20160609_190059_resized
  • 20160609_191817_resized
  • 20160609_190054_resized
  • 20160609_190035_resized
  • 20160609_190044_resized
  • 20160609_184557_resized
  • 20160609_184039_resized
  • 20160609_181534_resized
  • 20160609_180253_resized
  • 20160609_174546_resized
  • 20160609_173133_resized
  • 20160609_171922_resized
1 / 12
SHARE
THIS



It’s Adland’s ego that is bearing the brunt of the influx of data, not the actual creativity itself. At least, that was the gist of the creativity versus data debate at last night’s Vivid Festival in Sydney.

Posed with the question of whether data is killing creativity, three creatives fought tirelessly against three data gurus to prove creativity was being smothered by data. But alas, when it came to voting it turned out the data geniuses were more persuasive and won over the audience.

The data argument that numbers weren’t killing creativity earned a 64 per cent share of the audience vote. Only 36 per cent of the audience thought it was pounding down creativity.

Earning a huge amount of applause, Jenny Williams, CMO of The Hospitals Contribution Fund (HCF), ended the debate with: “Data isn’t killing creativity. But data is threatening to kill the creative ego.”

However, creative ad man Luke Chess, who was arguing on the side that data IS killing creativity, said brands are like the creepy guys at parties that are looking for the one on one conversation. And that the persona has been exacerbated by data, given marketers are constantly trying to personalise messaging.

And insights and ideas don’t come from data, he said, they come from human creativity and just bloody good ideas. However, Holly Joshi, senior manager of optimisation and analytics at SapientNitro and fellow data panellist, refuted this, saying ideas can only come from insight.

“Data is human,” she said. “And it’s proven to drive creativity.” But the term ‘big data’ has been bandied around for too long, and it’s this outdated view that hinders data. Instead, Joshi said it’s the little bits of data that help shape an overall insight – which then leads to a creative idea.

Still, futurologist Oliver Freeman, on the creative side, said data is too often used to determine trends. For him, trends are a way of looking back at what’s happened, not a way of looking forward.

Echoing this, Chess said: “Data determines what was. Creativity determines what could be.”

The speakers for the creative side:

  • Olivier Freeman – director and co-founder, The Neville Freeman Agency
  • Fiona Kerr – systems and neural complexity specialist, Adelaide University
  • Luke Chess – creative partner at Mammal

The speakers for the data side

  • Jenny Williams – chief marketing officer, HCF
  • Holly Joshi – senior manager optimisation & analytics APAC, SapientNitro
  • Dr Chelsea Wise – founder, head of behavioural science at Pureprofile

Moderator

Jane Caro – lecturer, The School of Communication Arts at UWS

Please login with linkedin to comment

Advertising Standards Bureau data debate Doug Campbell einsights vivid ideas

Latest News

Wild Turkey And Matthew McConaughey Recognise Aussie Local Legends
  • Media

Wild Turkey And Matthew McConaughey Recognise Aussie Local Legends

Wild Turkey and Creative Director Matthew McConaughey, in partnership with Eleven, unveil a new Wild Turkey With Thanks initiative. The integrated campaign is shining a light on Australian Local Legends who have stood with conviction supporting their environment and communities throughout the crises of 2020. Wild Turkey’s With Thanks is a global, annual platform, wherein […]

Australian Rules football on grass
  • Uncategorised

AIA Australia Partners With Yet Another AFL Team

AIA Australia has announced that it is now the official life, health and wellbeing partner to the AFL’s St Kilda Football Club. According to the company, the new partnership will provide club members with learnings, tools, and strategies that they can use to lead healthier lifestyles. Members will at the same time receive access to […]

Apple Ads Spark $16M Lawsuit
  • Technology

Apple Ads Spark $16M Lawsuit

Apple has been fined $16 million for misleading ads. Tim Cook pays it with loose change from behind the couch.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
AppsVillage Partners With TikTok To Allow SMBs To Advertise To TikTok’s Aussie Users
  • Technology

AppsVillage Partners With TikTok To Allow SMBs To Advertise To TikTok’s Aussie Users

Small to medium sized businesses will now be able to advertise on TikTok through SaaS solutions provider AppsVillage (ASX:APV). APV will allow SMBs to create and manage campaigns on TikTok in under three minutes using its AI software and advertising management platform JARVIS. The partnership makes the most of TikTok’s self-service advertising offering which launched […]

DOUBLESTAR CO Turns Technology Stunning With New Brand Livery For Australia’s Own Advanced Navigation
  • Advertising

DOUBLESTAR CO Turns Technology Stunning With New Brand Livery For Australia’s Own Advanced Navigation

To keep pace with their transformative technology, Advanced Navigation turned to DOUBLESTAR CO for art direction, 3D modelling and design help that would capture the value proposition and offering of Advanced Navigation: AIR, LAND, SEA & SUB-SEA for their upcoming campaign “Accurate positioning in the most demanding conditions”. Advanced Navigation’s Head of Marketing Romain Pare […]

Tom Pitney Promoted To Strategy Director At Junkee Studio
  • Media

Tom Pitney Promoted To Strategy Director At Junkee Studio

Junkee Studio, oOh!media’s creative and social agency division, is capitalising on another successful year by announcing the promotion of Tom Pitney to Strategy Director. Pitney will now drive the direction of Junkee’s in-house creative and strategy team, which produces bespoke content solutions for brands to help them tell and share their stories across their owned […]

Cricket Australia Boss Slams Seven For Talking “Our Wonderful Game Down”
  • Media

Cricket Australia Boss Slams Seven For Talking “Our Wonderful Game Down”

Cricket Australia’s (CA) interim CEO Nick Hockley (main photo) has slammed broadcaster Seven for talking “our wonderful game down”. In a blistering attack on its broadcast partner, Cricket Australia lashed Seven for its ongoing legal stoush as it attempted to exit its four-year deal with the sport. As reported on B&T today, Seven West Media […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
TAC’s Christmas Campaign Via TABOO Urges Victorians To ‘Spend It Wisely’
  • Campaigns

TAC’s Christmas Campaign Via TABOO Urges Victorians To ‘Spend It Wisely’

Road safety meets a time-honoured Christmas tradition with the launch today of the Transport Accident Commission’s ‘Spend it Wisely’ advent calendar initiative, developed in close partnership with Melbourne-based creative agency TABOO. The digital advent calendar provides 25 days of road safety tips, plus offers and discounts to businesses throughout the holiday season, to help Victorians […]

Fort Wayne, Indiana - Circa April 2017: Pepsi and PepsiCo Vending Machines Awaiting Repair. Pepsi is one of the largest beverage producers in the world IV
  • Marketing

PepsiCo ANZ Appoints New CMO For Snacks & Beverages

PepsiCo Australia and New Zealand has announced the appointment of Vandita Pandey to the newly created role of Chief Marketing Officer for both snacks and beverages. Pandey comes from Frito-Lay (a PepsiCo company) in the United States where she has spent the last 11 years in roles that span across marketing, corporate strategy, insights and […]