It’s Adland’s ego that is bearing the brunt of the influx of data, not the actual creativity itself. At least, that was the gist of the creativity versus data debate at last night’s Vivid Festival in Sydney.
Posed with the question of whether data is killing creativity, three creatives fought tirelessly against three data gurus to prove creativity was being smothered by data. But alas, when it came to voting it turned out the data geniuses were more persuasive and won over the audience.
The data argument that numbers weren’t killing creativity earned a 64 per cent share of the audience vote. Only 36 per cent of the audience thought it was pounding down creativity.
— Adobe Australia (@Adobe_aus) June 9, 2016
Earning a huge amount of applause, Jenny Williams, CMO of The Hospitals Contribution Fund (HCF), ended the debate with: “Data isn’t killing creativity. But data is threatening to kill the creative ego.”
However, creative ad man Luke Chess, who was arguing on the side that data IS killing creativity, said brands are like the creepy guys at parties that are looking for the one on one conversation. And that the persona has been exacerbated by data, given marketers are constantly trying to personalise messaging.
And insights and ideas don’t come from data, he said, they come from human creativity and just bloody good ideas. However, Holly Joshi, senior manager of optimisation and analytics at SapientNitro and fellow data panellist, refuted this, saying ideas can only come from insight.
“Data is human,” she said. “And it’s proven to drive creativity.” But the term ‘big data’ has been bandied around for too long, and it’s this outdated view that hinders data. Instead, Joshi said it’s the little bits of data that help shape an overall insight – which then leads to a creative idea.
Still, futurologist Oliver Freeman, on the creative side, said data is too often used to determine trends. For him, trends are a way of looking back at what’s happened, not a way of looking forward.
Echoing this, Chess said: “Data determines what was. Creativity determines what could be.”
The speakers for the creative side:
- Olivier Freeman – director and co-founder, The Neville Freeman Agency
- Fiona Kerr – systems and neural complexity specialist, Adelaide University
- Luke Chess – creative partner at Mammal
The speakers for the data side
- Jenny Williams – chief marketing officer, HCF
- Holly Joshi – senior manager optimisation & analytics APAC, SapientNitro
- Dr Chelsea Wise – founder, head of behavioural science at Pureprofile
Jane Caro – lecturer, The School of Communication Arts at UWS
The latest NGINX campaign is live as The Misfits Media Company, and NGINX creates parodic ‘investigative reporter’ content with Dan Ilic on the streets of Sydney. The Misfits recently partnered with the APAC marketing team at NGINX to take an investigative deep dive into the world of mobile apps as the good, bad and (even) […]
Trade publisher AMT Pty Ltd has announced the acquisition of Radio Today, the Australian media and marketing sector’s go-to source for radio news, analysis, ratings and jobs. AMT currently publishes Radioinfo in Australia & New Zealand, Asia and Africa, and was a key partner in bringing the annual Radiodays conference to Asia. Radio Today will continue to […]
Mediahub Australia has made its most significant restructuring to date, as it positions itself to professionally manage the changing world of broadcast technology and consumer viewing habits. The most significant new appointment, and one of many, is Scott Jolly being promoted to the role of chief operating officer. As COO, Jolly now has full responsibility for the […]
For Melbourne, the past 18 months have been largely dictated by the COVID-19 pandemic and lockdowns. Despite this, The Trade Desk has managed to establish one of its most successful offices. Here, The Trade Desk lead director, client strategy, Kali Guillas [pictured], explains how the Melbourne office has managed to thrive. We are in a […]
Australian Comedian Hannah Gadsby has slammed Netflix executive, Ted Sarandos after he used Gadsby’s presence on the platform to defend Dave Chappelle’s new comedy special on Netflix. Chappelle’s recent comedy special, The Closer, which debuted on Netflix last week, has been met with backlash, after Chappelle used his special to discuss transgender and gay people, […]
Acast has announced its partnership with Samsung Electronics Australia to produce and distribute the company’s first branded podcast within the Australian market. The Rule Benders podcast will feature conversations with extraordinary Australians who have bent the rules, defied convention, and redefined what is possible. Rule Benders is a six-week branded podcast campaign, with a new […]
DocuSign Australia this week unveils its first work with independent creative agency, Hardhat, encouraging people to ‘Next time, DocuSign’. Spearheading the campaign is an influencer series featuring entrepreneurial business leaders Janine Allis, Jules Jund and Emma Isaacs sharing stories of oversights and slip ups during important business deals. The three ‘That time I screwed up’ […]
Global experience design agency Imagination, has expanded its Sydney team, with the appointment of two new key hires. Ashley Diamond (pictured below), with over 18 years experience across large scale events and broadcast quality content production, joins as project director to continue driving the growth of Imaginations’ largest clients. “The people, the work and the […]
Switch, an award-winning digital agency has announced the appointment of Matt Watson as its technical director. Watson joins Switch at an exciting time as the business focuses on its growth strategy and bringing the best talent in the market to deliver exceptional outcomes for customers. Watson is the most recent talent appointment by Switch, after […]
Rolling Stone Australia publisher The Brag Media has announced that the Sailor Jerry Rolling Stone Australia Awards will be back for a second year in 2022, with a star-studded party to reunite the music industry following extended lockdowns. For the first time, a free live event series will spearhead the return of live music in […]
Hayley Fisher [pictured] is the AUNZ Country Manager at Adyen. In this op-ed, she discusses the upcoming holidays sales season and explains marketers can help drive sales. Over the 18-months the pace of ecommerce has accelerated to new heights. According to latest figures from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), a record $44.2 billion was […]