“Choice Is Driven By Context” Says Ogilvy Vice Chair Rory Sutherland

“Choice Is Driven By Context” Says Ogilvy Vice Chair Rory Sutherland
SHARE
THIS



It was standing room only yesterday as Ogilvy’s vice chair Rory Sutherland delivered a fascinating keynote at the Cannes Lions Festival of Creativity. One key takeaway was the importance of context in relation to consumer decision making.

A lot of things that economists think are true, are hugely context dependent.

Generally, paying people for services is good. But if you pay your wife for sex, it doesn’t really act as an incentive.

Giving people gifts is good. Returning a gift isn’t an act of generosity, it’s an insult.

In human behaviour, lots and lots of things have a context dependent meaning which trumps their economic significance.

Simply observe the world and observe it’s anomalies. Find out the strange things that people do. 

Advertising and consumer marketing is the Galapagos Islands for understanding consumer behaviour and understanding consumer weirdness.

We noticed something very strange which is that nearly everybody at restaurants ends up drinking wine. And the standard explanation is because it is what people want to drink.

I’m one of the minority people who think wine is a load of bollocks. We have beer and gin and whisky – why would we drink some bottled grape crap?

The strange thing was that I realised that restaurants do everything they can to make you order wine because the mark-up is much higher. You can buy totally crap wine and charge 40 euros for it.

When you go into a restaurant, there are already wine glasses there. Then they bring you a drinks list which isn’t called the drinks list, it’s called the wine list.

The wine list has five pages of wine and only one page of beer and spirits.

And then there’s the even more ingenious nudge which is that they only bring you one wine list. That means that since there’s only one alcoholic drink that you can all share, the person with the wine list ends up turning to the table and going “red or white”?

Once you’ve said “red or white”, it’s game-over for the gin drinkers.

The point is that choice is driven by the context in which we choose. It’s not driven by preference as economists believe, it’s driven by meaning.

Every single pizza company in the world assumes that everybody wants their pizza as soon as possible.

One thing about big data that you have to be really careful of is that all big data comes from the same place: the past.

Everything you know can be rendered complete bollocks by one small change.

One of the problems with big data is that I think it might give people a false sense of certainty. As had happened in the pizza industry because 97 per cent of people asked for their pizza as soon as possible.

I said, “why don’t you try changing the context in which people choose?

“At the moment, you go to the app, what’s the default? ASAP. You go to the website, what’s the default? ASAP. If you ring up, they don’t say, ‘when would you like your pizza?’ They just assume you want it as soon as possible.”

I said “what happens if you change that? And what happens if you call it not ‘duration’, but a ‘time of day’. So the default on the app is 8:45?”

If you can get 45 minutes to an hour to a pizza being ordered and a pizza being delivered, you can put more than one delivery on a bike. You can deliver to three places before a bike returns to base, rather than just one.

This means you reduce carbon emissions and make a stack of money, depending on how right-wing or left-wing the audience is I’m talking to.

What we found was that if we changed the default to a particular time of day, if the person on the phone said, “Is 9:30 ok or would you like it earlier?” nearly everybody was totally happy to order a pizza with as much as an hour’s wait.

Weirder still, we measured customer satisfaction, expecting it to fall a bit. It went up by 50 per cent!

I don’t really know why. One possibility is that waiting for an ASAP pizza is kind of ‘stressy’. You’re spending all your time on tenter hooks.

Whereas if you know your pizza is arriving at 8:45, you can go and have a shower, get ready, relax until about five minutes before it is due to arrive. And then when it arrives two minutes early you’re really impressed.

Context is really important and human evolution has not given us sensory mechanisms which cause us to see the world objectively.

Price all depends on context.

If you had to buy Nespresso coffee in a jar, a large jar would cost about $40 or $50 for the equivalent dosage of caffeine compared to Nescafe or Maxwell House. You probably couldn’t bring yourself to buy that jar: that’s bat shit crazy.

But you don’t know what an individual Nescafe costs so when you put the 49 cent pod in the Nespresso machine, your frame of reference isn’t Nescafe, it’s Starbucks.

You think to yourself, “it’s 49 cents, that would have cost me £2.40 at Starbucks, this machine is basically making me money!”

That’s precisely why Maserati stopped exhibiting their cars at car shows, because they got really expensive. They started exhibiting their cars at yacht and plane shows instead.

At a car show, a 300,000 euro car is expensive. At a plane show, it’s an impulse buy.

What something is depends on how we perceive it because evolution has calibrated our sensory mechanisms to deliver relevant, important meaning, not to deliver an accurate picture of reality.

Please login with linkedin to comment

2019 cannes lions Cannes Lions Cannes Lions 2019 Ogilvy Rory Sutherland

Latest News

TripleLift Expands Into APAC, Naming The Trade Desk’s Henry Shelley As Managing Director
  • Technology

TripleLift Expands Into APAC, Naming The Trade Desk’s Henry Shelley As Managing Director

TripleLift has today announced an expansion in their Asia Pacific (APAC) operations, with Henry Shelley [featured image] appointed as Managing Director, based in Singapore. Fueling TripleLift‘s expansion in APAC is its success in Australia, where the company works with 70 per cent of the top 50 comScore publishers. “As the home to several of the worlds’ […]

Rob Highett-Smith Joins Fiftyfive5 In Newly Created Role
  • Media

Rob Highett-Smith Joins Fiftyfive5 In Newly Created Role

Rob Highett-Smith joins Fiftyfive5 in the newly created role of head of performance measurement. Performance measurement represents one of the three core offer areas at Fiftyfive5 with tracking programs running across 40 countries; representing our fastest growing capability pillar.  Rob joins to lead this capability, which encompasses brand and comms tracking, multi market monitoring, CX and customer satisfaction, as well as other longitudinal programmatic work.   

Customer Messaging Platform Podium Launches In Australia
  • Technology

Customer Messaging Platform Podium Launches In Australia

Podium has continued its international expansion today announcing its launch in Australia. Podium serves more than 90,000 local businesses in the United States, Canada and Australia, and has seen its customer base in Australia almost quadruple to over 3,000 local businesses since the start of the pandemic. Through its SMS-based platform, Podium helps local businesses receive […]

The Misfits Partners With Business Leadership & Culture Experts To Expand Agency Offering
  • Advertising
  • Marketing
  • Media

The Misfits Partners With Business Leadership & Culture Experts To Expand Agency Offering

Independent experience agency The Misfits has recently announced a strategic partnership with cultural change and leadership experts Nancy Hromin and Kate Chaffer. While the company has for a long time operated in the space of creative services, digital and content marketing, film production and events, The Misfits is now broadening this offering to include business […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
THE EDGE Welcomes New General Manager Emily Copeland
  • Media

THE EDGE Welcomes New General Manager Emily Copeland

Commercial DAB+ hip hop and RnB station, THE EDGE has appointed Emily Copeland, to the newly created role of General Manager. Copeland brings an awesome mix of skills and experience to THE EDGE, including cross-platform media content experience, partnerships and events (including music festivals – remember those?). Copeland also has a stack of achievements to […]

Sustainability 101 With Brianne West, CEO Of Plastic-Free, Eco-Focused Beauty Brand Ethique
  • Marketing

Sustainability 101 With Brianne West, CEO Of Plastic-Free, Eco-Focused Beauty Brand Ethique

Brianne West is the founder and CEO of Ethique, a New Zealand-based sustainable, plastic free and cruelty free skin and hair care range. West sat down with B&T to explore what genuine environmental sustainability looks like, and how brands can better respond to eco-conscious consumers. B&T: Why are we seeing a rise in eco-conscious consumption?    BW: […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Cities connected with lines on a blue globe.
  • Technology

Blis Unveils New Interactive Dashboard That Tracks Consumer Movement In Australia

Blis has today revealed its new Consumer Confidence Pulse — the most comprehensive tracker of its kind — this interactive dashboard builds on its existing trend data around consumer mood to analyse behaviour during the COVID pandemic. The dashboard also now tracks consumer movement over a rolling 13-month period, across 18 retail and lifestyle sectors […]

Australian Seniors Releases ‘Dare To Date’, Second Series Of ‘Life’s Booming’ Podcast
  • Media

Australian Seniors Releases ‘Dare To Date’, Second Series Of ‘Life’s Booming’ Podcast

Following the success of Series One: Grey Nomads, Australian Seniors has launched the second series of the Life’s Booming podcast – Dare to Date.  Hosted by James Valentine (pictured with guests Liz and Barry), Life’s Booming explores the incredible stories and addresses topics important to Australians over 50. Series two titled Dare to Date is a six-part series that covers real-life love, […]

VERSA Announces Two Senior Appointments As Demand For Conversational AI Gains Further Traction
  • Marketing

VERSA Announces Two Senior Appointments As Demand For Conversational AI Gains Further Traction

World-leading conversational agency VERSA has bolstered its team with two senior appointments in response to growing uptake in conversational AI technology across various sectors. Vanessa Tout has been appointed global head of client partnerships and growth, while Michael Oso-Hughes comes on board as design director. Tout joins VERSA CEO Kath Blackham and managing director Michael […]

Patrick Rutkowski Joins Banter
  • Marketing

Patrick Rutkowski Joins Banter

Engagement marketing agency, Banter, has hired Patrick Rutkowski as Creative Technologist, to further bolster the digital and innovation side of the business. Rutkowski joins Banter after having spent the last five and a half years at independent creative agency, The Hallway where he was most recently creative technologist working with the likes of Rheem, Tourism […]

person using mobile application on smartphone, abstract close up of hands
  • Technology

Mobile Advertising Company Kargo Announces New Hires Following H1 Growth In APAC

Kargo has today announced several major growth milestones across the APAC region for the first half of 2021, more than doubling H1 revenue year-over-year with 115 per cent growth. Kargo also ran 41 per cent more campaigns in the region than in H1 2020 and the average campaign size increased by 32 per cent over […]