Political Leadership Poll: Women Are More Believable Than Men

Political Leadership Poll: Women Are More Believable Than Men
SHARE
THIS



Australians see more leadership strength and believability in Penny Wong, Julie Bishop and Tanya Plibersek compared to the Prime Minister, Scott Morrison or Opposition Leader, Bill Shorten, according to a new study released today.

The 1,400-person survey run over March and April also revealed that not only did Australians rate non-party leaders as being more believable and stronger leaders.

New Zealand’s Jacinda Ardern scored higher than any Australian politician.

The study was commissioned by communications agency, opr as part of a wider report into overall leadership believability.

In the era of fake news, click bait and institutional scandal, the study sought to understand whether believability was the new critical factor in peoples’ decisions to support leaders and organisations.

The results demonstrated that Australians are left wanting when it comes to political leaders based on their ability to be inspiring, to represent us well on the global stage and to be leaders really worth getting behind.

The findings also revealed what it takes for leaders to win not just the minds – but the hearts – of those they serve; what it takes to go from being someone who is not just trusted, but believed, and believed in.

The nationally representative findings have been published as a new ‘Believability Index’ which uncovers the six key dimensions Australians are looking for when it comes to leadership strength – Relevance, Integrity, Commitment, Shared Values, Affinity and Follow Through – and ranks aspiring political candidates and business leaders in an index according to these.

The Believability Index scores for the political party candidates included in the survey are:

  • Jacinda Ardern, Prime Minister, New Zealand (77)
  • Penny Wong, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate, Labor (53)
  • Julie Bishop, Liberal (52)
  • Tanya Plibersek, Deputy Labor Leader (50)
  • Anthony Albanese, Labor (46)
  • Richard Di Natale, Greens leader (45)
  • Pauline Hanson, Pauline Hanson’s One Nation Party (44)
  • Scott Morrison, Prime Minister (43)
  • Bill Shorten, Labor Opposition Leader (42)
  • Tony Abbott, Liberal (36)
  • Peter Dutton, Minister for Home Affairs, Liberal (34)
  • Clive Palmer, United Australia Party Leader (30)

opr chief strategy officer, Kaz Scott said: “When it comes to capturing the hearts and minds of the people they lead, it’s no longer enough to just focus on trust – that’s merely a starting point and a rational place to play.

“More important is the ability for leaders to transcend the rational and build an emotional connection.

“That takes them from being not just trusted or believed, but believed in.

“Believability is important because when we believe in an individual or an organisation, we are more likely to listen, engage, be loyal, defend and act on their behalf.”

Scott continued: “This new study shows Australians are crying out for leaders they can get behind.

“They do not perceive our political leaders to be believable and are instead looking to other examples emerging from places like New Zealand and outside politics to find new benchmarks.

“The perceived disconnection between what politicians say and what they do creates a believability gap, which can impact all aspects of their leadership and purpose.” 

Corporate leaders ranked amongst the top of the Index scores

Respondents were also asked to rate their perceptions of the leadership qualities of well-known corporate individuals, with three out of four of those polled ranking in the top third of the overall Index.

The Believability Index scores for the corporate leaders included in the survey are:

  • Ita Buttrose, Chair, Australian Broadcasting Corporation (64)
  • Andrew Forrest, Chairman, Fortescue Metals Group (53)
  • Alan Joyce, Chief Executive Officer, Qantas (48)
  • Gina Rinehart, Chairman, Hancock Prospecting (40)

Scott added: “When it comes to leadership in business, Australian shareholders, employees and customers are looking for the same things that they are looking for in their politicians: shared values and connections, strong platforms and bravery to stand up for the things they believe in and that matter to the people they represent.”

Please login with linkedin to comment

Auspol Kaz Scott opr

Latest News

Spikes Asia Portraits
  • Marketing

Spikes Asia Appoints Jenny Lau As Events Director

Spikes Asia has announced the appointment of Jenny Lau as events director. Based in Singapore, Lau will take overall responsibility for Spikes Asia.  Lau (pictured) has worked within the Asia-Pacific advertising industry for more than 20 years and brings a deep understanding of the trends and issues affecting the regional advertising and marketing industry. Lau […]

ANZ Brands Top Pattern’s Best Practice Ranking Of Brands On Amazon.com.au
  • Media

ANZ Brands Top Pattern’s Best Practice Ranking Of Brands On Amazon.com.au

Global ecommerce and marketplace specialist Pattern has ranked a group of 50 brands selling on Amazon.com.au based on a set of best practice criteria it has developed. Pet brand Zenify topped the ranking in Pattern’s Amazon Australia Benchmarking Report, scoring 82 per cent of the possible marks against a set of criteria designed to measure […]

Fifth Dimension Expands Executive Leadership Team
  • Marketing

Fifth Dimension Expands Executive Leadership Team

Fifth Dimension Consulting has announced the expansion of its executive leadership team in response to the organisation’s significant growth over the last 18 months. Lyndall Spooner has moved from the position of managing director to the role of chief executive officer (CEO).  As CEO, she will lead Fifth Dimensions’ innovation arm, as well as the […]

GoDaddy Australia Launches GoDaddy Studios To Support Creative Content By Small Business
  • Marketing
  • Technology

GoDaddy Australia Launches GoDaddy Studios To Support Creative Content By Small Business

GoDaddy Inc. has today announced the Australian launch of GoDaddy Studio, a new content creation tool designed for small and medium businesses to create beautiful visual content for their business for all platforms. Compatible on both iOS and Android mobile apps and desktop, GoDaddy Studio includes thousands of customisable templates and easy-to-use tools, providing small […]

Seismic Announces New Zealand Partnerships To Empower Businesses And Workers
  • Technology

Seismic Announces New Zealand Partnerships To Empower Businesses And Workers

Seismic has announced an expanded New Zealand (NZ) presence to support the transformation of sales and marketing teams, and enable the nation’s employers to focus on upskilling their workforces to overcome a digital skills shortage. The company has also signed NZ-based specialist consultancies, Fresh Perspective Sales (FPS) and Jumping Fox Interactive, as its first two […]

Booktopia’s Alex Huntley On Partnering With SaaS Platform Freshworks And Tackling The Pandemic
  • Marketing

Booktopia’s Alex Huntley On Partnering With SaaS Platform Freshworks And Tackling The Pandemic

Alex Huntley, Booktopia’s head of customer experience, recently appeared at software company Freshworks’ recent digital CX summit RE:SOLVE. During the summit, Huntley shared his thoughts on future-proofing customer service architecture.Huntley sat down with B&T to discuss Booktopia’s partnership with Freshworks and how it has helped their platform develop. B&T: Why did Booktopia first decide to partner […]

Nestlé Oceania Adds The Edison Agency To Strategic Design Roster
  • Marketing

Nestlé Oceania Adds The Edison Agency To Strategic Design Roster

The Edison Agency has made four new appointments in its Sydney office to service the continued growth across key account The Arnott’s Group and the recent appointment to Nestlé Oceania’s strategic packaging design roster. Over the past 12 months, the culmination of strategic and creative work across the Uncle Toby’s brand and continued growth of […]

SCA Launches Smart Speaker Experience Tom & Olly’s Guide To Lockdown
  • Media

SCA Launches Smart Speaker Experience Tom & Olly’s Guide To Lockdown

SCA has announced a new smart speaker experience for the Hit Network, with Tom and Olly’s Guide to Lockdown. A voice-activated way to get inspiration and information on fun activities that can be done at home, the guide is curated to appeal to a wide audience. Smart speaker users will find a range of ideas […]