Google Australia Is Not A Regulator And It Should Stop Trying To Be One

Google Australia Is Not A Regulator And It Should Stop Trying To Be One

In this guest post, Digital360 copywriter, Hugh Steele, argues Google Australia’s attempts to regulate the sort of ads it features is wrong and not part of its remit…

For the most part, Google does a good job of moderating its AdWords platform. However, some of its policies enter the realm of trying to regulate Australian industries. The two most glaring examples of this are their policies concerning payday loans and brothels.

AAEAAQAAAAAAAAzzAAAAJDYxYjA0NTUyLTI2NmItNDc5Ni1hYmI4LWY1ZTcxMWViNTYxYw

Google’s recent ban on ads for payday loans is equal parts moralistic and ineffective. It was announced in May 2016 and came into effect in July of that year.

The ban was widely praised in the digital marketing industry and the media. However, it was quickly circumvented by some Australian payday lenders who changed their policies.

Google’s ban only covers loans which require repayment within 60 days. Several lenders have increased their minimum loan terms to 61 or 62 days so that they can continue to advertise on Google.

Google essentially made a policy decision for Australian businesses – loans longer than 60 days are acceptable, shorter loans are not. Even though longer loan terms will mean customers pay more in fees.

In response to this, Philips Johns, chief executive of the National Credit Providers Association, described Google as a “pseudo-regulator” and the ban as a “feel-good stunt”, the Sydney Morning Herald reported.

Despite the Google ban, both loans longer and shorter than 60 days are legal and regulated in Australia as Small Amount Credit Contracts (SACC). Any lender offering these loans must be licensed and adhere to strict lending criteria, including a warning to consumers about borrowing in the application process.

But Google has decided to give an advantage to lenders who only offer “longer” short-term loans, even though they are regulated by the same legislation as shorter loans in Australia.

When it comes to the adult entertainment industry, the advertising restrictions are rightly intended to prevent ads for adult content from appearing for people who are not seeking that type of content.

However, Google has a blanket ban on ads which “promote escort services or other services that may be interpreted as providing sexual acts in exchange for compensation” which puts ads for legal brothels in the same category as ads which “promote content with underage or non-consensual sexual themes”.

There is a clear legal and moral distinction between Australian brothels and anything which promotes “underage or non-consensual” content. Google’s policy is clearly ridiculous in this case, and they need to respect Australia’s legal sex industry.

For the most part, Google’s AdWords policies are designed to protect users from counterfeit products, dangerous products, dishonest behaviour, and inappropriate or offensive content.

The Australian government already regulates short-term loans and consumers are already being protected from businesses operating illegally within those industries.

According to IAB Australia, $1.88 billion was spent on online advertising in the quarter ending 30 September 2016. The two biggest recipients of that spend are Google and Facebook.

The size of the Google AdWords platform means that its policies have significant impacts on Australian businesses and industries. Google’s attempts at holding a regulatory role are inappropriate and ineffective.




Please login with linkedin to comment

Designworks Digital360 Hugh Steele

Latest News

‘Those In the Know DFO’: DFO Launch Brand Refresh With Creative Agency Taboo
  • Advertising

‘Those In the Know DFO’: DFO Launch Brand Refresh With Creative Agency Taboo

DFO takes on brand refresh with creative campaign in partnership with Melbourne-based creative agency Taboo. Premium outlet shopping centre DFO has released a new creative campaign in collaboration with creative agency Taboo, ‘Those In The Know DFO’, encouraging buyers to purchase luxury products for a discounted price. In response to the growing demand for face-to-face […]

One Man’s Waste Is A Major PR Win For The Bravery
  • Advertising

One Man’s Waste Is A Major PR Win For The Bravery

Independent purpose PR, Communications, and Social Media agency, The Bravery, has strengthened its commitment to enhancing behavioural change in waste after being appointed by Dulverton Waste Management in North West Tasmania. Lead image: The Bravery Team The Bravery has been appointed as the lead communications, community engagement and PR partner after a competitive tender process. […]

Broadsheet Promotes Claire Booth To National Sales & Partnerships Director Role
  • Media

Broadsheet Promotes Claire Booth To National Sales & Partnerships Director Role

Broadsheet has promoted Claire Booth to the national sales and partnerships director role. Since its launch in 2009, Broadsheet has published news, features, and events coverage across the Australian cities of Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Adelaide, Perth, Tasmania, and New Zealand. Claire Booth was acquired by the Broadsheet team in 2019 from The Story Lab and […]

Yahoo Academy Invites Applications From Future Industry Leaders For 2024 Program
  • Marketing

Yahoo Academy Invites Applications From Future Industry Leaders For 2024 Program

Nominations are now open for Yahoo Academy 2024, an immersive talent building program which helps 30 rising media agency and marketing superstars across Australia and Singapore develop the skills needed to lead and thrive in the workplace of the future. Taking place over two days in Sydney, Yahoo Academy 2024 will engage participants with in-depth […]

Taboola Appoints Experienced APAC Advertising Exec To Manage New Zealand Sales
  • Marketing

Taboola Appoints Experienced APAC Advertising Exec To Manage New Zealand Sales

Taboola, has announced the appointment of former Taboola APAC director and skilled digital strategist Joe France (lead image) as its New Zealand sales lead, as it continues to expand its presence in the ANZ market. Under his new remit, France will be responsible for cultivating key partnerships and delivering innovative solutions to meet evolving New […]

Activation Union Hires Bree Mankin As Managing Partner
  • Media

Activation Union Hires Bree Mankin As Managing Partner

Activation Union is thrilled to announce the appointment of Bree Mankin as Managing Partner. In this pivotal role, Bree will spearhead the agency’s growth initiatives and client strategy, leveraging her extensive experience and innovative approach in delivering exceptional results for her clients. With over two decades of experience in marketing and communications, Bree is a […]

Toyota Launches Integrated Electric Vehicle Campaign Via HERO
  • Campaigns

Toyota Launches Integrated Electric Vehicle Campaign Via HERO

Toyota Australia has launched its highly anticipated new all-electric vehicle, the bZ4X, on Australian shores through a nationwide integrated campaign. Spearheaded by a big spot, the campaign was created by independent creative agency HERO, which sees a typical EV sceptic named Barry behind the wheel of an all-new Toyota bZ4X much to the surprise of […]

Canva Launches First Ever Podcast: Design Surfaces
  • Media

Canva Launches First Ever Podcast: Design Surfaces

Canva has announced its very first podcast: Design Surfaces. Covering all areas of design, from brand campaigns to UX flows, the podcast digs deep into the intricate parts of designers’ brains to unearth valuable insights, unique perspectives, and what makes them tick. The Design specialty at Canva is made up of some of the most […]

SBS Launches Development Fund To Find Australia’s Next Top Documentaries
  • Media

SBS Launches Development Fund To Find Australia’s Next Top Documentaries

SBS is searching for its most daring, unflinchingly fearless and boundary-smashing factual format yet, issuing a call out for impactful ideas for new documentary series unlike anything seen on Australian screens before, with up to $50,000 in development funding on offer. Announced this morning at the Australian International Documentary Conference (AIDC) in Melbourne, SBS is […]

Resolution Nabs Sarah Truong From PHD
  • Advertising

Resolution Nabs Sarah Truong From PHD

Full-service media agency Resolution has appointed Sarah Truong as head of investment to lead the agency’s investment product. Sarah joins from PHD where she was Group Investment Director for half a decade. With 14 years’ experience in the media industry including seven years at media agency, Carat, Sarah a proven track record for delivering results-driven […]