Disruptor Branding: How To Take On A Titan And Win

Disruptor Branding: How To Take On A Titan And Win

In the latest opinion from Men At Work Communications, Youth Strategy Director Nick Donovan (pictured below) explores the world of disruptor branding, and how businesses can take on established market leaders and win.

The Internet and, more recently, smartphones have overturned almost every industry imaginable. In fact, well-established giants in most categories – from hospitality and transport to energy and media – are struggling to remain relevant in the midst of unprecedented competition from brands that have entered the market and seriously upset the applecart. Innovate or perish, they say. But in this environment, being innovative isn’t enough – not even close.


What you really want is to be known as a disruptor.

Think of brands like Uber, AirBNB and now, Vampr – they have seriously upset the status quo by taking on the accepted norm, turning it on its head, and recreating it in their own image.

These brands empower consumers through the use of innovation and technology; through personalisation, self-service and peer-to-peer sharing  – using the ways, means and methods that appeal to younger generations who will take up these new platforms and then push them to critical mass. They have ingrained themselves within the youth market, in particular, those tastemakers who determine what is ‘cool’ or ‘now’ and ultimately lead to mainstream acceptance.

Most importantly, the fact that these brands are seen as rebellious and that they are perceived as taking on an industry is a big part of their success. In fact, while many ‘disruptor’ brands are merely an evolution of a pre-existing product or service rather than a true disruption, their ability to brand themselves as disruptors in the eyes of consumers has enabled them to successfully stand up against giants of industry and win.

Everyone loves a rebel

Uber took on the taxi industry and Airbnb faced off against accommodation. Now Vampr is trying to take out the middlemen within the music industry, by connecting musicians directly and helping to ensure the razor-thin profits for up-and-coming musos aren’t shaved down further by ‘management’.

Clearly, Vampyr are trying to position themselves as a musician-cultivating Robin Hood, and to their credit, it’s working – everyone loves a rebel brand.

Consider Uber and Airbnb and the legal trouble they faced when getting started.

While there was nothing cool about Uber founder Travis Kalanick resigning due to a sexual harassment scandal, the fact Uber was illegal in Australian states for a number of years adds a certain edge and credibility to the company.

That the government eventually rolled over and allowed the ride-sharing company to go about its business only adds to a story that young people love – Uber stuck to their guns and came out on top.

Airbnb have walked a similar path, facing regulatory issue after regulatory issue, and while they continue to fight the good fight in a number of markets across the world, the simple fact they are projected to top $3 billion in revenue by 2020 suggests they’re confident of keeping on.

Empowering the consumer

Of course, taking on the establishment and winning is the holy grail from a marketing perspective, but it won’t necessarily see you become a multi-billion dollar company.

No, that happens when the product or service you are offering offers serious cut-through – and that’s exactly what the most successful disruptors have done. It’s not rocket science – they have simply offered a far superior product.

Uber, AirBNB and Vampr are on an upward trajectory because they saw a gap in their relevant market and a convenient way to fill it – by using the gadget in people’s pockets that consumers touch (on average) more than 2000 times per day.

These companies are seeing success by giving the consumer unparalleled control. Successful ‘disruption’ – it’s really as simple as empowering the consumer, although that’s one of the simple lessons established businesses seem to forget.

And that’s where the question of whether these companies are actually disrupting anything comes up.

You don’t need to disrupt to succeed – just be better

Any up-and-coming business could do a lot worse than look to Uber when they are starting out.

But if you are using the San Francisco company for inspiration and a roadmap to success, you should be aware of the fact Uber did not disrupt the market, at least not in the true sense of the word disruption.

Instead, they did what successful businesses have been doing since time immemorial: took someone else’s model and improved it.

Few in the world would argue the taxi industry needed to be shaken up, which is exactly what ride-sharing has done, but they’ve done so by simply offering a better service.

Think about it: what does Uber do that taxis don’t? Your driver offering you a bottle of water and lollies is nice, as is the fact the cars are clean and generally odour-free – and of course there is an undeniable convenience in being able to track your ride in real time, and the ability to book and pay through the app.

None of these aspects could be considered a disruption to what a taxi can provide now though – they’re just improvements.

But so what? Recognising a substandard business and offering an improved model has been a roaring success for Uber and countless businesses before them for the simple reason that it works.

Is disruption simply a matter of branding?

The concept of disruptive innovation was brought to the fore by the Harvard Business Review in 1995, in an article entitled ‘Disruptive technologies: Catching the wave’.

Some 20 years later, that same publication published a piece in which authors Clayton M. Christensen, Michael E. Raynor and Rory McDonald argued that the term is being misused, holding up Uber as the prime case of a ‘disruptive’ business that doesn’t actually fulfil the definition. True disruption is more likely to come in the form of the driverless car or teleportation rather than a new (and admittedly roaringly successful) business model which dominates the competition by simply being better.

However, while the fellows who coined the notion of disruptive innovation might be able to show that Uber isn’t disruptive, perception is reality, and most people don’t read, nor care about, the Harvard Business Review.

And you better believe Uber aren’t about to post a blog about how this perception is incorrect. They have cleverly and successfully positioned themselves as disruptors because that perception has fuelled their rise. They are the disruptors who took on an industry and won.

This is not just a lofty perspective that only applies to tech giants. It is applicable at a far more micro level, for any business in any industry. A chicken shop might incorporate digital self-service kiosks or customer loyalty technology to dominate the tired, old-hat, well-established competitors in a local market – if they the position themselves as disruptors taking on on the establishment, you’d better believe they will come out on top, provided their product is top quality as well.

If well-established players are cornering a market, find a way to brand yourself as a disruptor. Of course, once you then become the dominant player, there will likely be another disruptor nipping at your heels.

Please login with linkedin to comment

Disruption Men at Work

Latest News

Hands using mobile payments, Digital marketing. Banking network. Online shopping and icon customer networking connection on virtual screen, Business technology concept
  • Media

IAS Report: Australian Digital Advertisers Experience Higher Brand Risks Across All Buying

Today, Integral Ad Science (IAS), a global leader in digital ad verification, released its Media Quality Report (MQR) for H2 2020, providing transparency into the performance and quality of Australian digital media, alongside global comparisons. Integral Ad Science’s H2 2020 MQR highlights brand safety, ad fraud, and viewability trends across display, video, mobile web, and […]

Quintis Appoints Illuminate As Global PR Partner
  • Media

Quintis Appoints Illuminate As Global PR Partner

Quintis Sandalwood has appointed Illuminate as its global PR partner following a competitive pitch process. Proudly Australian, Quintis produces and markets Indian Sandalwood oil, logs, chips and powder products across the world to major companies in industries such as fragrance, aromatherapy, cosmetics, handicrafts and Traditional Chinese Medicine industries. Illuminate will be responsible for a global communications […]

Image lead story Even More Pics From The 30 Under 30 Awards!
  • Media

Even More Pics From The 30 Under 30 Awards!

Hopefully the weekend has given everyone enough time to recover from B&T’s 30 Under 30 awards and prepare themselves for our official photo dump! We shared some of the highlights last week, and now you can peruse all of the pictures taken on the night. Thank you to everyone for attending this year’s awards, and […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Kinderling Kids Streams Ahead With Direct-To-Consumer Offering
  • Marketing

Kinderling Kids Streams Ahead With Direct-To-Consumer Offering

Kinderling Kids Radio (Kinderling) has announced the completion of its move from DAB+, where it launched six years ago, to a direct-to-consumer streaming model, accessible online or through the Kinderling Kids iOS and Android app. The Parent Brand, the parent company of Kinderling Kids and Babyology, made the decision to shift as streaming and on-demand […]

RUN Take On The Flu
  • Advertising
  • Campaigns

RUN Take On The Flu

Globally award-winning, indie agency RUN, have launched the New Zealand National Influenza Immunization Campaign, running over the next 8 weeks across TV, digital, social, print and press.

Audika Says Stop Ignoring The ‘Whats’ And Get A Hearing Test, Via Ward6
  • Campaigns

Audika Says Stop Ignoring The ‘Whats’ And Get A Hearing Test, Via Ward6

Most people over 60 stay on top of their health with regular check-ups. Whether it’s eyes, prostate or breasts, they realise at their age it’s important. But one that gets ignored is hearing. They’d rather live with gradual hearing loss, and continually ask what, huh, pardon or sorry until it seriously impacts their life and […]

Connecting Plots To Handle [yellow tail] Social Media Following Account Win
  • Media
  • Technology

Connecting Plots To Handle [yellow tail] Social Media Following Account Win

Creative communications agency Connecting Plots has been appointed by Casella Family Brands to handle the social media accounts for [yellow tail] wine in Australia. The win follows an audit of the Casella Family Brands social activities, which led to [yellow tail] rethinking its approach to social media and how it aligns with its overall marketing […]

HERO’s B.B.E Wins v2food Account
  • Media

HERO’s B.B.E Wins v2food Account

v2food, has appointed HERO’s B.B.E as the lead strategic and creative agency for the brand following a competitive pitch process. v2food is an Australian pioneering food technology business with a global vision to feed the planet sustainably. After launching nationally in 2019, v2food has been on a mission to offer Australians an easy alternative to meat […]

Rows of coins isolated on white background. Finance and banking concept.
  • Media

Magnite And Adform See Monetisation Uplift Using First-Party Identifiers

Magnite (Nasdaq: MGNI), the largest independent sell-side advertising platform, today announced it has been working with Adform, the only independent global ad management platform covering all aspects of the digital campaign lifecycle, to scale first party identifiers in privacy-safe ways. With the pending elimination of third-party cookies, the industry must establish future-proof identity solutions for publishers and buyers.

Martin Box Named Co-Chair Of Commercial Producers Council
  • Media

Martin Box Named Co-Chair Of Commercial Producers Council

The Commercial Producers Council is delighted to announce the appointment of Martin Box (pictured) as its new Co-Chair, effective immediately. Box, Head of Production at Airbag, joins Co-Chair Pip Smart, and fills the vacancy left by Lucas Jenner who steps aside from the Co-Chair role after four years of service, in accordance with the CPC’s […]