Media Agencies Slam Transparency Report Claiming Widespread Rebates

Media Agencies Slam Transparency Report Claiming Widespread Rebates
SHARE
THIS



A report coming from the States claiming media rebates and non-transparent practices are widespread among the US media buying landscape has ruffled a large amount of feathers among media agencies.

A number of media agencies have come out swinging at the report, claiming it’s “insubstantive” and was based on “subjective methodologies”.

A number of big brands have also released their own statements, citing concern of the findings, as have industry bodies.

The study released by the National Association of Advertisers (ANA), the US industry body, claims there’s a number of non-transparent practices going down in Adland in the form of media rebates.

The study cited a number of instances of non-transparent practices and pressure on senior agency execs from higher up.

Below are the statements we have so far, some sourced from AdAge and Business InsiderB&T has contacted a number of media agencies in the Australian landscape for their take on the report. We’ll update this story as we hear back.

Dentsu Aegis Network

From Jerry Buhlmann, global CEO

Today’s ANA Report (June 7th) is an insubstantive report with subjective methodologies and anonymous input. The business practices referenced in this report do not exist within our US business. Our media buying process is robust and transparent for our clients, is subject to rigorous compliance processes and all our clients have the ability to audit us. Furthermore, we pride ourselves on our focused and extensive efforts on compliance policies, practices and controls.

GroupM

From David Grabert, director of global communications

The ANA report and the objectivity of its authors and advisors needs to be examined carefully. The report should not be allowed to tarnish the entire industry, nor every company in it.  As we stated from the outset of the ANA’s exploration, GroupM does not seek, nor accept rebates or hidden revenues in any form from media partners in the U.S.; nor do we accept service fees from vendors that are not disclosed to clients.  GroupM is straightforward with clients concerning our proprietary media products and the value they provide; clients always exercise an informed opt-in to participate. As we’ve already indicated, we insist that the ANA share any specifics relating to our group with us so that we can ensure continuing contract compliance.  If clients have any questions, they should contact us.

Omnicom

We have not yet had a chance to fully review the ANA study, however based on the overview provided in the press release we believe that the key findings — neither quantified nor qualified, and based on a small sampling of unnamed sources — do not accurately portray how Omnicom’s agencies work on behalf of our clients; in so doing, it does not serve the best interests of the clients that the ANA purports to represent.

As we have said since the ANA first launched its study last year, we believe that trust and disclosure are the cornerstone of every client relationship. This means that all of our U.S. media agency clients receive all value negotiated on their behalf in the form it is received. Compliance with each individual client contract has always been central to that trust at Omnicom – as is transparency in the structure and execution of each contract.

Publicis

Had the ANA been willing to have an open dialogue with our industry, we would have been immediately ready to cooperate, as we did last year, and that is reflected in our engagement with the 4A’s. By refusing such a dialogue and choosing a sensational approach, it seems clear that the ANA is not trying to find a solution to the alleged problems, and instead is acting with other goals in mind.

The ANA has failed its members, advertisers, agencies and the entire industry by releasing a report that relies on allegations about situations involving unnamed companies and individuals to make broad, unsubstantiated and unverifiable assertions.

Australian Association of National Advertisers (AANA)

From Sunita Gloster, CEO

Any best practice guidelines or initiatives that emerge are likely to have universal application, so we will aim to share them with our members here. Every advertiser’s contractual relationship with its media partner is unique and commercially and competitively sensitive. Individual advertisers therefore have the primary responsibility to ask the right questions of their agency partners so that they can be reassured that there is transparency. The role the AANA can play is to help equip members with the basic framework that is a prerequisite to obtaining transparency.

Whilst the US report reminds advertisers to remain vigilant, it is important that we remember these principles of transparency, disclosure and fairness are central to the reputations of all parties involved. Equally importantly, adherence to these principles is crucial to achieving our common goal which is to show the link between advertising and business growth. Businesses need to have confidence in the integrity of their media spend allocations.

From Matt Tapper, chair

Advertisers are ultimately responsible for ensuring they are appropriately equipped to put in place agreements and processes that deliver fair value to all parties involved. The need for transparency in media buying is not a new issue. It is a perennial challenge, one that will only get more complex. New media platforms and technology developments mean new trading arrangements are springing up all the time. This US report is a timely reminder that advertisers cannot be complacent about these conversations.

World Federation of Advertisers

From CEO Stephan Loerke

Transparency has long been considered a critical issue by WFA and remains a priority for its members. We welcome the findings from the ANA and will continue to address the challenge globally, not least in emerging markets where transparency problems can be more acute.

Advertisers should take the lead in addressing the challenge but WFA also believes in, and calls for, global cross-industry collaboration to find answers. That’s why we have been conducting systematic dialogues between media agencies and clients around the world to better understand the issues and ultimately try and engender greater trust in the marketplace.

Unilever

From Luis Di-como, senior vice president of global media

Trust and transparency are critical to any relationship, so we take the ANA’s findings very seriously. We support its work to ensure that as the media industry evolves these values remain a top priority.

At Unilever, we are actively engaged with our agencies and the industry at large to exert greater control and responsibility around media transparency. We go to great lengths to make certain that our proprietary procedures and policies maximise our investments and fulfil our contracts, in both the letter and spirit. We’re confident the right steps will be taken to strengthen our industry.

Proctor & Gamble

We appreciate the ANA’s diligence to study media transparency practices, particularly as technology is bringing a significant transformation in the industry. As a result of the study, it’s important that advertisers and agencies work together appropriately to deal with the changing media ecosystem.

At P&G, we want and expect strong agency partnerships based on mutual trust, transparency and teamwork. We have a “trust but verify” approach that includes having clear and thorough stipulations in our contracts, regular audits on performance, and third party verification that ensures transparency. If we find irregularities, we will take remedial action.

 

 

Please login with linkedin to comment

100th employee Advertising Standards Bureau ana ana report Is He Asahi media rebates

Latest News

Asics Australia Launches First Women’s Cricket Shoe
  • Marketing

Asics Australia Launches First Women’s Cricket Shoe

ASICS Australia has released the world’s first cricket shoe, specifically designed for females – developed locally in conjunction with Cricket Australia’s (CA) Women’s Team Physiotherapists and Athletes. In recognition of the incredible growth of women’s cricket in Australia, ASICS has launched the 350 NOT OUT FF to the market alongside a fresh ‘Made For Me’ […]

Tourism Tropical North Queensland Appoints Marketing Manager
  • Marketing

Tourism Tropical North Queensland Appoints Marketing Manager

Tourism Tropical North Queensland has appointed Marketing Manager Lani Strathearn to spearhead the rollout of the Cairns & Great Barrier Reef brand. TTNQ Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Mark Olsen said Ms Strathearn had a solid career in tourism marketing having worked in agencies in Melbourne and Adelaide for the past four years with clients including […]

Omnicom’s Resolution Digital Named As Google Honours Agency Of The Quarter
  • Advertising

Omnicom’s Resolution Digital Named As Google Honours Agency Of The Quarter

Resolution Digital has been awarded the Australia’s Agency of the Quarter award in the prestigious Google Honours program. The Honours program for 2020 recognises the achievements of the very best performance marketing agencies and providers across Australia and New Zealand. The program consists of 3 quarters, 43 agencies and over 500 individuals; measured on account […]

SCA Launches New Media Research & Insights Division
  • Media

SCA Launches New Media Research & Insights Division

SCA today announced that its award-winning Research & Insights and Strategy & Insights divisions have come together to form SCA iQ, one of Australia’s largest media research and insights offerings.   SCA iQ fuses the research, insights and strategy functions together, to better power insightful solutions for SCA’s Sales and Content teams and advertising partners and is underpinned […]

Audi Pulls Ad, Apologises For Dangerous, “Phallic” Campaign
  • Campaigns

Audi Pulls Ad, Apologises For Dangerous, “Phallic” Campaign

German carmaker Audi has been forced to pull its latest campaign and issue the usual round of apologies after a rather tone-deaf launch over the weekend. On Saturday, the carmaker shared an ad for its snazzy looking Audi RS4 with the caption “Lets your heart beat faster – in every aspect”. The ad featured a […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Audiences Are Coming Back, Says Global Out Of Home Industry Leaders
  • Advertising

Audiences Are Coming Back, Says Global Out Of Home Industry Leaders

World Out of Home industry leaders from Australia, the UK, US and Germany have revealed that audiences are returning to public spaces despite ongoing challenges from COVID-19, and that they anticipate improved market fundamentals in coming months. In an interview for a podcast being released today, leaders including oOh!media CEO Brendon Cook, President of the […]

Perth Agency Firefly Adds Six New Accounts & Launches New Media Arm
  • Advertising

Perth Agency Firefly Adds Six New Accounts & Launches New Media Arm

Firefly has brought on six major new clients as it continues to expand, adding new media planning and buying arm to its business. Managing Director Andrew Mathwin (pictured) said the independent agency, known for clients such as Air New Zealand, Buy West Eat Best, West Coast Eagles and Mrs Mac’s Pies, had a strong year […]

Media33 Announces Two Senior Promotions
  • Advertising

Media33 Announces Two Senior Promotions

Boutique communications agency, Media33, have made two senior appointments with Ashlee Crawford appointed to General Manager and Mick Bradley appointed to Agency Director. Both Ashlee & Mick have been part of the management team at Media33 since it was launched in early 2013 and have played a key role in the agencies ongoing cultural strength […]

Independent Brewer Wingman Cancels All Sales For A Month In Support Of Dry July
  • Marketing

Independent Brewer Wingman Cancels All Sales For A Month In Support Of Dry July

In possibly a first for the category, independent brewer Wingman decided to cancel all sales of Wingman beer during the month of July, in support of Dry July. This bold initiative went live at midnight June 30 and ran throughout July. Wingman Beer’s general manager Will Chambers explained: “We have noticed a dramatic spike in […]

AAP Sale Formalised, Confirms Name To Be Retained
  • Media

AAP Sale Formalised, Confirms Name To Be Retained

The sale of Australian Associated Press (AAP) to a consortium of impact investors and philanthropists has been formally completed, ending 85 years of ownership by Australia’s major publishing groups. The national news agency will continue to provide a trusted breaking news service with a team of journalists and photographers, most of whom have joined the […]

Aussie Success Story Afterpay Unveils New Brand Identity
  • Marketing

Aussie Success Story Afterpay Unveils New Brand Identity

Aussie retail payments platform Afterpay has launched a new global look, feel and positioning with a fresh brand identity. Founded out of Bondi, Sydney, Australia five years ago, Afterpay has skyrocketed to infinite heights, with almost 10 million customers and 55,000-plus merchants now using the platform globally across Australia, US, UK (where it is called […]

Women in Media’s Doris Li: “Listen To Your Heart And Go For It, Then Settle For Extraordinary”
  • Media

Women in Media’s Doris Li: “Listen To Your Heart And Go For It, Then Settle For Extraordinary”

How Communications’ China marketing director, Doris Li, believes ad-land professionals must be courageous enough “to be abnormal”, and listen to their hearts, to be fearless in times of change. During this year’s B&T Women in Media Awards, presented by Bauer Media, we’ll be recognising exceptional people who have achieved success in their professional arenas, celebrating […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Study: New Business Wins Still Resilient, But Creative Finding It Tougher Going Than Media
  • Advertising
  • Media

Study: New Business Wins Still Resilient, But Creative Finding It Tougher Going Than Media

The holding companies might be losing as much as 23 per cent of their revenue year-on-year, but new business has remained relatively resilient through 2020, the lastest research from R3 has revealed. In the first half of 2020 total new business revenue decreased 10 per cent globally – but creative agencies are having to find […]

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
I’m Not Loving ‘Karens’, For What They Highlight About Our Society
  • Opinion

I’m Not Loving ‘Karens’, For What They Highlight About Our Society

In this guest post, the CEO of PR/comms agency Extollo, Katy Denis, examines the social phenomenon of our time – the entitled ‘Karens’ amongst us & why they can be such a danger… Until last week, I had no idea who or what a “Karen” is. Thanks to (and I use that term very lightly, […]

Opinion

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
The Mint Partners Wins Pernod Ricard, Cemoy & Little National
  • Advertising

The Mint Partners Wins Pernod Ricard, Cemoy & Little National

Independent communications consultancy The Mint Partners has bolstered its integrated client roster and signed a number of premium lifestyle brands to kick start the new financial year. With an array of new products, services, and a focus on insight-led and creative integrated communications, MINT has enjoyed recent success with an expanded portfolio across new categories including fintech, […]

opr Adds DocuSign To Client Roster
  • Media

opr Adds DocuSign To Client Roster

Sure, it might not be a Coke or a Qantas, but opr think this win significant enough to send well-meaning press release.

Stan Acquires Heckler Co-Produced Biopic On F1 champion Sir Jack Brabham
  • Media

Stan Acquires Heckler Co-Produced Biopic On F1 champion Sir Jack Brabham

A feature length documentary on the extraordinary racing career of Australia’s first Formula 1 champion, Sir Jack Brabham, co-produced by design, animation and visual effects house Heckler, will be available on Stan exclusively from this Friday – 7 August. Directed by Ákos Armont (Aurora Films) in association with Heckler, whose co-founder Will Alexander served as […]