Isentia Slams Meltwater For “Very Misleading” Statement Around Court Ruling

Isentia Slams Meltwater For “Very Misleading” Statement Around Court Ruling
SHARE
THIS



Media intelligence provider Isentia has fired back at Meltwater over a statement it made about their current court battle, saying the orders for injunctions against the SaaS provider remain in place.

Isentia announced on Friday that it had gained a court order restraining Meltwater from supplying its customers with content such as TV clips and press clippings from Isentia.

This came after Isentia made an application to the Federal Court seeking urgent injunctions to restrain Meltwater from using its content alleging that Meltwater’s managing director and his wife had breached contracts with Isentia for media intelligence services.

However, a statement by Meltwater on Friday indicated that Isentia had lost its injunction application against its rival.

Isentia has responded to Meltwater’s statement with one of its own, claiming that the orders for injunctions remain in place, and that its attempt to reframe this one ruling as an overall success in the interlocutory application is “very misleading”.

Here’s the statement in full:

The orders for injunctions that prevent Meltwater’s ongoing “free ride” on Isentia’s systems and supplied content, and to which Meltwater submitted, remain in place.

Therefore, Isentia was successful in its interlocutory application for those orders and in seeking an order that all evidence be preserved and not destroyed by Meltwater pending a final hearing of the claims. Any suggestion by Meltwater to the contrary is deliberately misleading.

In the hearing on Friday 24 June, Justice Jagot ordered Meltwater to file a defence within 28 days and that the matter be relisted for directions after that time. Justice Jagot declined to make a further order that would require Meltwater to put on an affidavit detailing, amongst other things, all Isentia accounts used by Meltwater and material supplied to its clients.

Isentia had sought this information now as it would have assisted in Isentia’s understanding of the full extent of Meltwater’s conduct. Meltwater argued that this order would require Meltwater to file an affidavit “confessing to its alleged wrongdoing”, and it was premature as this material would need to be produced through discovery in due course.

Her Honour decided against making the order on the understanding that Meltwater would not resist production of the information sought about Isentia’s accounts through discovery. As the order for affidavits was not made, her Honour awarded the costs of that day’s short hearing (only) to Meltwater.

To try to reframe this one ruling as an overall success in the interlocutory application is very misleading. It is also incorrect for Meltwater to suggest that her Honour ordered Isentia to pay Meltwater’s costs in defending the injunction, an injunction to which Meltwater actually submitted. Meltwater’s readiness to consent to the injunction speaks volumes.

The fact remains Meltwater is presently restrained by orders from misusing Isentia’s accounts to supply content to its own clients, and is also under orders from the court to preserve all evidence of its wrongdoing.

Prior to the hearing, the third respondent, Ms Singh filed an affidavit explaining she had no knowledge of the Isentia account in her name, or of any activity on that account. Her husband, who identifies himself as the managing director of Meltwater News, did not file an affidavit explaining why a false account had been set up in his wife’s name or identify the person/s responsible for using this account for Meltwater’s clients. On the basis that Ms Singh has given sworn evidence she was not involved, Isentia will consider discontinuing the claims against her.

 

Please login with linkedin to comment

A&E Advertising Standards Bureau Fox International Channels

Latest News

Former Agency Execs Launch Car Service Summon
  • Marketing
  • Media

Former Agency Execs Launch Car Service Summon

Former agency executives Tim O’Neill and Tim Fouhy have launched the auto technology startup Summon. Australia’s first full e-commerce service for prestige cars. O’Neill and Fouhy both worked together at Accenture Interactive, before co-founding Reactive a digital agency bought by Accenture in 2016, now they’ve combined their knowledge and expertise to create Summon. Summon offers […]

Hootsuite Shares The Top Social Media Trends Of The Tokyo 2020 Paralympic Games
  • Media

Hootsuite Shares The Top Social Media Trends Of The Tokyo 2020 Paralympic Games

To honour the fantastic feats of the Australian Paralympians, Hootsuite has revealed the top trending hashtags and social media data of the Paralympics. The top trending hashtag during the Paralympics period, #tokyo2020, received over 38,000 tweets and retweets, amounting to 1.7M+ impressions, while other popular hashtags included #paralympics, #readysettokyo and #paraswimming. According to Hootsuite’s research, […]

SOON, Think Tank Giving Insights Into Future Trends, Officially Launches
  • Advertising

SOON, Think Tank Giving Insights Into Future Trends, Officially Launches

SOON, a futures think tank focused on human insights, has launched today tracking trends, developments and disruptions across people, products and the planet. Led by internationally renowned futurist, social scientist and trend forecaster Sarah Owen (pictured centre) in partnership with TABOO directors Andrew Mackinnon (right) and James Mackinnon (left), the independently Australian-owned futurist company uncovers […]

iHeartPodcast Network Australia Launches SAS Australia Debrief Podcast
  • Media

iHeartPodcast Network Australia Launches SAS Australia Debrief Podcast

ARN’s iHeartPodcast Network Australia has announced a new podcast, SAS Australia Debrief hosted by 2020 recruits Merrick Watts and Sabrina Frederick. The podcast is made for anyone that can’t get enough of Aussie celebs putting themselves through the toughest test of their lives on the Seven Network’s hit show SAS Australia. Or anyone that wishes […]

Rakuten Advertising Shares Blueprint For Affiliate Marketing
  • Technology

Rakuten Advertising Shares Blueprint For Affiliate Marketing

Rakuten Advertising has launched ‘A 5-Stage Blueprint for High-Performance Affiliate Marketing’, designed to educate and inform both advertisers and publishers about the strategic role that the affiliate channel is now playing in marketing strategies. The blueprint is based on input from members of the Rakuten Advertising International Collective (RAIC), comprising affiliate marketing specialists from leading advertisers […]

EngageTV Launches Metro Connected TV Campaign In Sydney And Melbourne
  • Media

EngageTV Launches Metro Connected TV Campaign In Sydney And Melbourne

EngageTV, Australia’s most sophisticated CTV & BVOD service partner, has today launched a Sydney and Melbourne metro Connected TV campaign to help business owners and marketers better understand what can be achieved with CTV.

by B&T Magazine

B&T Magazine
Adland State Of Originality To Return For Nine’s 2022 Origin Series
  • Media

Adland State Of Originality To Return For Nine’s 2022 Origin Series

Nine has announced the return of State of Originality, Australia’s biggest advertising prize, with $1 million again up for grabs to the brand and agency that creates the most original ad in the 2022 State of Origin Series. This year Nine launched State of Originality, challenging Australia’s marketers to help make State of Origin not […]